This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Marxist Reading Of Shakespeare's Coriolanus

2309 words - 9 pages

A Marxist Reading of Coriolanus

 
    One popular dissecting instrument of any Shakespearean character is the modern tool of psychoanalysis. Many of Shakespeare's great tragic heroes-Macbeth, Hamlet, King Lear, and Othello, to name a few-have all been understood by this method of plying back and interpreting the layers of motivation and desire that constitute every individual. Add to this list Shakespeare's Roman warrior Coriolanus. His strong maternal ties coupled with his aggressive and intractable nature have been ideal fodder for modern psychoanalytic interpretation. This interpretation, however, falls within a larger, political context. For despite the fact that Coriolanus is a tragedy largely because of the foibles of its title character, its first and most lasting impression is that it is a political play. Indeed, the opening scene presents the audience with a rebellious throng of plebeians hungry for grain that is being hoarded by the patricians. When Menenius, a patrician mouthpiece, enters the scene a dialectic is immediately established, and the members of the audience inexorably find themselves on one side or the other of this dialectic, depending, most likely, on their particular station in life.

 

The English nobility that viewed this play in Shakespeare's time undoubtedly found Menenius' fable of the belly compelling, in which the belly-representing the patricians-is said to be a distribution centre that may initially receive all the flour (nourishment), but parcels it out evenly to the various limbs, and organs-representing all other classes of the republic-leaving itself only the bran. I doubt the audience in the pit found this body trope very persuasive, especially since this play was initially performed at a similar time of corn shortages and insurrection in England. Their allegiance most probably was with the plebeians in the play, and their arguments against the patricians' attitudes likely resembled and anticipated Marxist theory.

 

Marxism, essentially, is a theory of the proletarian liberation movement. This theory is dialectic in that society is seen as a composition of contraries (e.g., rich vs. poor), and that what makes humanity evolve is the struggle between these contraries. The triumph of one over the other produces change. Change, however, is resisted by the ruling class because most, if not all, of the wealth is concentrated in their hands; they in turn control the means of production, allowing them to exploit the workers for their own ends and widen the gap between the rich and poor even more in the process. This situation produces alienation in the worker; it deprives him of something, and this is not only degrading but depersonalizing as well (Appignanesi, 79).

 

From this perspective, Menenius' fable of the belly is clearly fallacious and intended to instill a false state of consciousness in his listeners. The tale deflects the cause of the plebeians hunger from the patricians...

Find Another Essay On A Marxist Reading of Shakespeare's Coriolanus

Absolulely Absolutism - Analysis of Political Structure in Shakespeare's Coriolanus

1648 words - 7 pages evidence from Cicero and Machiavelli, one may conclude that Shakespeare favours absolutism over republicanism. Particularly: the commoners are characterized as fickle, selfish, and uneducated, suggesting that power to the people will lead to corruption; Shakespeare's main historical source, Plutarch's Life of Coriolanus, is a veneration of Coriolanus; and Shakespeare gives the protagonist, Coriolanus, a moral temperament, implying that an

marxist reading of william blake - university - essay

2282 words - 10 pages Word Count - 2132 Blake: Labour, Religion, and the State If one is to examine William Blake's Songs of Innocence and Experience using a Marxist critique, it is imperative to note their similarities through their critcisms of social structures and organised religion. I will be investigating these similarities through Marxist writings and applying Blake's Songs hold sympathy for the working classes and their impoverished struggle against the

A Marxist Interpretation of Bram Stoker's "Dracula"

816 words - 3 pages A Marxist reading is one which interprets history as a series of class struggles. Marxists believe that, within a society, people think and behave according to basic economic factors. These factors are derived from the dominant class imposing their beliefs on the lower classes in order to make them conform to the standards and beliefs of the dominant class.Bram Stoker's novel, 'Dracula' represents a class struggle not between the bourgeois

A Marxist Critique of the Occupy Movement

1450 words - 6 pages Journal and The New York Times compare the occupy movement to the Soviet communist uprising. William F. Jasper a writer for The New American, states, “The leading activists openly display their communist, Marxist, socialist, anarchist affiliations and orientations. One would have to be totally blind and totally dishonest not to notice this. The purpose of Mr. Jasper’s article was to show the contrast between the tea party who “paid for permits

“Acceptance to the Cruel Reality: A Marxist Reading on William Blake”

1271 words - 5 pages compares dissimilar objects in a way to turn the stomachs of the reader and to leave an impression on the importance of his subject matter. “The Chimney Sweeper” lends itself to a Marxist reading as Blake cynically and sarcastically depicts the young and perhaps voiceless victims and their unfortunate acceptance to the social and economic arrangements in the late eighteenth and nineteenth century. The direct and simple form of the work presents a

The Marxist Interpretation of A Doll’s House by Henrik Ibsen

635 words - 3 pages “A principal tenet of Marxist criticism is that human consciousness is a product of social conditions and that human relationships are often subverted by and through economic considerations.”(Witham and Lutterbie) A Doll’s House, by Henrik Ibsen, can be interpreted and critiqued in many different ways. One of these ways is the Marxist approach. This way of thinking can basically be summed up by saying this: Money changes people’s thinking and

A Comparison of the Functionalist View with the Marxist View

867 words - 3 pages A Comparison of the Functionalist View with the Marxist View Sociologists may disagree in their interpretation of how society works. Some have focused on what keeps society together; others have focused on what divides society. Over the years the two major paradigms have dominated sociology these are functionalism and the conflict theory better know as Marxism. Both the Marxism view and the functionalist view have their

A Jungian Reading of Beowulf

1617 words - 6 pages A Jungian Reading of Beowulf     This essay will propose an alternative means by which to examine the distinctive fusion of historical, mythological, and poetic elements that make up the whole of Beowulf.  Jeffrey Helterman, in a 1968 essay, “Beowulf: The Archetype Enters History,” first recognized Grendel as a representation of the Shadow archetype and identified Grendel’s mother as an archetypal Anima image; I wish to extend the scope of

A Feminist Reading of Othello

1151 words - 5 pages Question: Why is Othello relevant today?Othello is relevant today because of its ability to be interpreted from different perspectives and have different readings applied to it. One such reading is the Feminist reading.The opening scenes of Othello establish firm Gender identities, and a patriarchal context for the play. The Gender identities are established in the way Othello's speaks about of his wooing of Desdemona, where he says,"...her

Shakespeare's Definition Of A Ghost

1165 words - 5 pages Shakespeare's Definition of a GhostThe American Heritage Dictionary, published in 1973, defines a ghost as, 'the spirit or shade of a dead person, supposed to haunt living persons or former habitats.' Unfortunately, this simple definition does not explain where a ghost comes from or why it haunts. When used in the context of Shakespeare's Hamlet, this definition seems to suggest that the ghost who visits Hamlet truly is his dead father seeking

Argumentative, the joy of reading a novel

1155 words - 5 pages As soon as a novel must be read or becomes part of a literary course, the joy of reading it is immediately lost due to the fact that the particular novel may not be interest to the student, the student may hurry to finish the novel and by the extent to which the novel is studied.The joy of reading a novel is lost when a novel is not of interest to the reader because the reader would not be able to relate to any of the characters, and would

Similar Essays

A Marxist Reading Of Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet

1078 words - 4 pages is constantly fighting darkness, he searches for people to create love and warmth in his life, and eventually finds Juliet. However her warmth does not keep him alive for long and the brooding, angry Verona and its families result in the darkness of death. Part B Marxist literary criticism finds its roots in Marxist theory. It pays particular attention to notions of ideology and hegemony, the idea that the ruling classes or those in a position

What Is Your Response To The Marxist Reading Of Shakespeare's King Lear?

1307 words - 5 pages -divided the kingdom up, saving a "third more opulent" for his last daughter. The Marxist reading appears to portray the characters as driven only by their greed for power.There are many parts of the play which exhibit Marxist beliefs, for example, Gloucester's speech when he gives Poor Tom his purse displays socialist thinking. He comments that we should limit our desires, as everything is superfluous. He preaches that people should share if they

A Marxist Reading Of Native Son

4888 words - 20 pages A Marxist Reading of Native Son In the Communist Manifesto Karl Marx states clearly that history is a series of class struggles over the means of production. Whoever controls the means of production also controls society and is able to force their set of ideas and beliefs onto the lower class. The present dominant class ideology is, as it has been since the writing of the United States Constitution, the ideology of the upper-class

A Marxist Philosophy Of Life Reading Mao’s Three Essays

879 words - 4 pages the orthodox Marxist principle of dialectic materialism, which asserts that everything in the world is constantly changing and interconnected; therefore, practice is the only way to discover the truth in life, which is a claim in line with pragmatism doctrines. Altruism, on the other hand, also complies with the notion of world revolution and the union of the world’s proletarians in Marxist teachings. However, when we evaluate the value of