This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Matter Of Honor Case Study

3022 words - 12 pages

Summary of the Case
The case under review occurred in the city of Newton against a backdrop of economic decline, political disenchantment, and a widening racial divide. A Newton High School senior,Sheila Allison, is accused by her teacher of plagiarizing a book review. Mrs. Durnitz, the teacher, reported to the school principal that Sheila admitted to taking material from the web but claimed she did not know that doing so constituted plagiarism. The district’s policy states that students found guilty of plagiarism must receive a failing grade and repeat the course. Mrs. Durnitz feels that Sheila, having a copy of the student handbook in which plagiarism is discussed, should have known that what she did violated the policy. The teacher also believes that the policy, drafted by the teachers who teach honors classes and approved by the administration, must be followed to the letter despite any extenuating circumstances.
Sheila, a good student who is popular and athletic, received a congressional appointment to a national military academy. She is the first African American at Newton High School to receive such an honor. The town has publicized this fact widely throughout the community. Should Sheila receive a failing grade in her honors English class, she may lose this prestigious appointment. The ramifications for the district—should this occur—will most likely be both political and legal.
The superintendent and principal are stymied in their efforts to reach a compromise as Mrs. Durnitz refuses to change her position that the policy must be followed to the letter. She appealed to the teachers’ association for support when it appeared that the administration and board might not uphold her position. The local newspaper picked up the story and, in the article that was written, Sheila’s parents indicated their belief that their daughter did not knowingly commit plagiarism. They placed the burden on the school, commenting that the school should have done a better job of educating students about what this meant. With the scrutiny of the press as an added pressure, the superintendent asked the principal to make a quick determination that would avert the looming crisis.
The Problem
In the case study under review, there are many contributing factors or causes that can be identified in relation to the problem. Kowalski (2012) found that “administrators often confuse causes and problems. Problems are products and causes are variables responsible for the product” (p. 6). The problem itself lies in the inadequacy of the district’s plagiarism policy. The policy is flawed in that it precludes school administrators from using their professional judgment to make determinations that are both ethical and fair. A zero tolerance policy does not allow extenuating circumstances to be taken into account, and thus is not the type of policy called for in regards to an issue that is as complicated and often ill defined as in the case of plagiarism.

Find Another Essay On A Matter of Honor Case Study

A Matter of Safety Essay

965 words - 4 pages highly unlikely to act out against someone in a classroom just because of a contrasting opinion on an academic subject, especially to the extent of taking a person’s life. The article “The Case for More Guns (and Gun Control)” states that research shows “permit holders in the U.S. commit crimes at a rate lower than that of the general population,” proof that gun-carrying students would respect the weapons they hold and are not likely to lose

A Matter of Understanding Essay

1405 words - 6 pages of knowledge of the persona. In a time where it may be deadly for one to speak out so openly, it is not impossible to say that the persona may have been indirectly forced into this state of ignorance. Putting aside all the distractions however, is it even possible for a person to fully understand a particular object - or in this case a particular place? When it comes to understanding a certain place, it simply isn't. Along with the flow of time

A Matter of Differences

1418 words - 6 pages as being extremely crowded. All of these factors help to disorient the man and obscure his perception of the time that has passed, or in his case has not passed as he may be just daydreaming. The older man in “Willow Waist” has a much clearer view and is much more in touch with reality. After he has met with this woman of interest and begins to leave, he then makes an apology to the cab driver on how much time he has taken after promising to

Case Study of a Business

2542 words - 10 pages Case Study of a Business Rexam PLC is a Consumer Packaging company. Consumer Packaging is the packaging that reaches the consumer, e.g. Bottles and cans etc. Rexam PLC is the parent company of Rexam Glass LTD among other companies, and it is based in Britain. Rexam PLC has multiple business activities. One of their activities is the production of beverage cans and bottles, and almost 80% of Rexam PLC's sales come

Reality: A Matter of Perception

3743 words - 15 pages asked to intercede in the proffering of a demonstrable miracle. The accompanying miracle testifies to the sanctity of the intercessor and provides a clear sign of God's intercession (“RECENT ARTICLES”). If that and a second miracle can be ascribed to the person in question, the pope can canonize them as a saint. Being named a saint establishes to the Church’s satisfaction that the person is holy, is in heaven, and is due the honor and respect of

Constructivism: A Matter of Interpretation

1924 words - 8 pages Constructivism: A Matter of Interpretation The theory of constructivism rests on the notion that there is an innate human drive to make sense of the world. Instead of absorbing or passively receiving objective knowledge that is "out there," learners actively construct knowledge by integrating new information and experiences into what they have previously come to understand, revising and reinterpreting old knowledge in order to reconcile it

A Matter of The Heart

1524 words - 6 pages stated may prove a difficult task.” (Georgieva 52) In The Scarlet Letter, the reader sees the characters develop and Hawthorne’s belief that when sin is hidden it will destroy the person. “This secrecy generates a series of double-binds where Hawthome's characters have to choose between two unsatisfactory alternatives. On the one hand, they can accept to share the secret and reveal the truth in an attempt to expiate the sin. In that case

Anthem: A Matter of Indivduality

1073 words - 5 pages goes to study that belonged to the Unmentionable times and he alone learned many new things. "...In these two years we have learned more than we had learned in the ten years of the Home of Students (Rand 36). From the book, one learns that this is a great sin—to have one's own ideas because all the "brothers" are equal and should have equal thoughts. In reality, this is not true for the place is ruled by Council. For light in his cave he steals

Rehabilitation Case Study of a Hamstring Tear

2031 words - 9 pages Rehabilitation – Case Study Introduction This case study is based on a twenty four year old Rugby Union winger. The injury the client has is a grade two hamstring tear in the left leg which also happens to be the dominate leg, this was caused by deceleration from a sprint and change of direction. Specifically it is the bicep femoris that is ruptured and is also the first time he has received this particular injury. The incident occurred four

A Case Study of Kenterrius Emcii Harris

917 words - 4 pages The unit of work is broken down into four general stages: assessing what is (diagnosis), making the choice as to what to attend to, how to move on choice, and closure. This case study involves Kenterrius “Emciii” Harris, an AA artist/lyricist, and I, co-founder of AA. Above AveRich Productions (AA) aims to produce a sound that is a stewpot of rich and meaningful lyrics. We also encourage affiliated artists to be confident and act on creative

Skills Approach: Assessment of a Case Study

904 words - 4 pages Northouse’s (2013) book, Leadership: Theory and Practice, presents a case study of an Italian restaurant successfully operating in the Midwest for 25 years. The purpose of this paper is to analyze the restaurant’s various levels of leadership using the Skills Approach. First, the restaurant’s success will be described through the owner’s general leadership. Second, the managers’ leadership skills will be described and improvement identified

Similar Essays

A Study Of Temporary Matter Essay

1089 words - 5 pages with her husband and disorganized life style, suggest that she has lost hope and faith in her past life and on the verge of creating a new life. Another issue that contributes to her decision of moving out is the haunting memories of that house which play a great role in the case of trauma. For Shobha her bedroom is the place which haunted her the most with its beautiful moments and sweet memories. The pictures of ducks they have drawn on the

Honor Of A Hero Essay

750 words - 3 pages journey is a move from dependence to self-responsibility. There is no way that a person can have self-responsibility and be a liar. Sir Gawain also showed throughout the story that he was brave.During the journey that Sir Gawain went on he faced a lot of challenges and remained brave no matter what was ahead. "Many times he found himself beset by many enemies- dragons, wild men, wolves, bulls and boars and great shaggy bears, and even giants. With

A True Coach Of Honor Essay

1035 words - 5 pages a lot better than being 2-10. I’m happy with it…(but) I’ve been there and done that” (“2011 SN College Football Awards”). This is a great example of how a coach should act when he is doing well, but he makes you realize that no matter how well the team is this year, it could all change like. For example, on one Saturday, one of the other teams’ players got hurt. The following day, Snyder wrote him a letter stating, “Hope you weren’t hurt

A Matter Of Fate Essay

2224 words - 9 pages despite Baba’s successes, people were always doubting him. They told Baba that running a business wasn’t in his blood and he should study law like his father. So Baba proved them all wrong by not only running his own business but becoming one of the richest merchants in Kabul (Hosseini, 16). When the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan, Baba left the country through a people smuggler along with his son to Pakistan then America. Once in America, Baba