A Matter Of Honor Case Study

3022 words - 12 pages

Summary of the Case
The case under review occurred in the city of Newton against a backdrop of economic decline, political disenchantment, and a widening racial divide. A Newton High School senior,Sheila Allison, is accused by her teacher of plagiarizing a book review. Mrs. Durnitz, the teacher, reported to the school principal that Sheila admitted to taking material from the web but claimed she did not know that doing so constituted plagiarism. The district’s policy states that students found guilty of plagiarism must receive a failing grade and repeat the course. Mrs. Durnitz feels that Sheila, having a copy of the student handbook in which plagiarism is discussed, should have known that what she did violated the policy. The teacher also believes that the policy, drafted by the teachers who teach honors classes and approved by the administration, must be followed to the letter despite any extenuating circumstances.
Sheila, a good student who is popular and athletic, received a congressional appointment to a national military academy. She is the first African American at Newton High School to receive such an honor. The town has publicized this fact widely throughout the community. Should Sheila receive a failing grade in her honors English class, she may lose this prestigious appointment. The ramifications for the district—should this occur—will most likely be both political and legal.
The superintendent and principal are stymied in their efforts to reach a compromise as Mrs. Durnitz refuses to change her position that the policy must be followed to the letter. She appealed to the teachers’ association for support when it appeared that the administration and board might not uphold her position. The local newspaper picked up the story and, in the article that was written, Sheila’s parents indicated their belief that their daughter did not knowingly commit plagiarism. They placed the burden on the school, commenting that the school should have done a better job of educating students about what this meant. With the scrutiny of the press as an added pressure, the superintendent asked the principal to make a quick determination that would avert the looming crisis.
The Problem
In the case study under review, there are many contributing factors or causes that can be identified in relation to the problem. Kowalski (2012) found that “administrators often confuse causes and problems. Problems are products and causes are variables responsible for the product” (p. 6). The problem itself lies in the inadequacy of the district’s plagiarism policy. The policy is flawed in that it precludes school administrators from using their professional judgment to make determinations that are both ethical and fair. A zero tolerance policy does not allow extenuating circumstances to be taken into account, and thus is not the type of policy called for in regards to an issue that is as complicated and often ill defined as in the case of plagiarism.

Find Another Essay On A Matter of Honor Case Study

Constructivism: A Matter of Interpretation Essay

1924 words - 8 pages Constructivism: A Matter of Interpretation The theory of constructivism rests on the notion that there is an innate human drive to make sense of the world. Instead of absorbing or passively receiving objective knowledge that is "out there," learners actively construct knowledge by integrating new information and experiences into what they have previously come to understand, revising and reinterpreting old knowledge in order to reconcile it

A Matter of The Heart Essay

1524 words - 6 pages stated may prove a difficult task.” (Georgieva 52) In The Scarlet Letter, the reader sees the characters develop and Hawthorne’s belief that when sin is hidden it will destroy the person. “This secrecy generates a series of double-binds where Hawthome's characters have to choose between two unsatisfactory alternatives. On the one hand, they can accept to share the secret and reveal the truth in an attempt to expiate the sin. In that case

Prada: A Case Study

3344 words - 13 pages major luxury brands has LVHM and Kering “and is arguably seen as more exclusive than either Louis Vuitton or Gucci (Kering’s flagship brand).” (Prada Case Study, 2012). A key source of Prada’s strategic positioning to its competitors has been its ability to differentiate itself from these other brands. “in an era in which mass produced handbags and clothes are made stylish and affordable by high street retailers, Prada has had to emphasize what

Depression: A Case Study

2122 words - 8 pages Case Study # 1 A hospital was encouraged strongly by a husband that his wife mental status warren assessment. Therefore, the woman was hospitalized voluntarily for depression. The husband provided information to the hospital on the women’s current state because the woman has failed to display coherent behavior and effectively communicate with personnel at the time of admission. At the onset of assessment by a staff-counseling

its a case study

1630 words - 7 pages Case History Case History History of Zong Introduction Paktel PT Pasifiktel Indotama, ("PAKTEL"), was introduced in the Republic of Indonesia in 1995. PAKTEL provides corporate telecommunication network services pages, to see the broad scope of our solutions for your communication needs. PAKTEL shareholders and staff provide a strong foundation with extensive

Case Study - Let it Pour. A case study of an article assigned in MGT 350

1767 words - 7 pages University of Phoenix and Pat's direct input, Chris should find the resolution of these major issues to provide a vastly rewarding business experience.ReferencesUniversity of Phoenix course material (n.d.) Case Study: Let it Pour - My FirstAssignment as Executive Assistant. p. 2, (para. 5)

A Case Study of a Student with Special Needs

1478 words - 6 pages Case Summary Background It was observed a 5th grade elementary student, that for privacy we will name him J during this case study. He arrived to the school in the second semester of Fourth grade and he has being diagnose under the umbrella of the Autism spectrum from the previous school documentation. J was served by the Especial Education content Mastery (“as known Especial Ed. Classroom”) in period of times during the day, but he was place

Summary of Case study

723 words - 3 pages In the case study Chrysler and Gao Feng: Corporate Responsibility for Religious and Political Freedom in China by Michael Santoro, he states that multinational corporation doing business internationally faces complex ethical issues. The ethical dilemma Chrysler encounters is the corporate responsibility for religious freedom in China. In May 1994, Gao Feng a Christian was arrested in Beijing for planning a private worship service to remember the

Case Study of Hypertension

3470 words - 14 pages Case Study of Hypertension During my experience in volunteering, I chose a patient for the case study assignment. The subject I chose was identified as GKM. The patient’s chief complaint upon her visit to the clinic was for a follow-up on her hypertension and for more medication for this disease. GKM is a 56-year-old Caucasian female with the date of birth on 12-14-43. Her past medical and surgical history consisted of childhood

Case Study of Dell

4056 words - 16 pages the following showing how the concepts related to OPP could be applied. [Use Dell and other case studies or companies to illustrate your answer]: Organising for High Performance Supply Chains Creating an environment for Innovation Motivation and Reward Career management and developmentMotivation and reward2.0 IntroductionMotivating employees to excel in any business is a topic of great practical concern to employers

Analysis of The Types of Law in a Case Study

2204 words - 9 pages defendants were liable due to the production of a faulty garment containing excess sulphite, which led to the claimant contracting dermatitis; which led to the claimant spending a long period of time in hospital. This case relates to Slump Ltd as due to the negligence shown Big Deal Ltd, 'five of the company's best customers have now transferred their business to Slump Lt's main competitor, Keynes Ltd'.The second scenario involves Big Deal Ltd and

Similar Essays

Honor Of A Hero Essay

750 words - 3 pages journey is a move from dependence to self-responsibility. There is no way that a person can have self-responsibility and be a liar. Sir Gawain also showed throughout the story that he was brave.During the journey that Sir Gawain went on he faced a lot of challenges and remained brave no matter what was ahead. "Many times he found himself beset by many enemies- dragons, wild men, wolves, bulls and boars and great shaggy bears, and even giants. With

Case Study Of A Business

2542 words - 10 pages Case Study of a Business Rexam PLC is a Consumer Packaging company. Consumer Packaging is the packaging that reaches the consumer, e.g. Bottles and cans etc. Rexam PLC is the parent company of Rexam Glass LTD among other companies, and it is based in Britain. Rexam PLC has multiple business activities. One of their activities is the production of beverage cans and bottles, and almost 80% of Rexam PLC's sales come

A Matter Of Fate Essay

2224 words - 9 pages despite Baba’s successes, people were always doubting him. They told Baba that running a business wasn’t in his blood and he should study law like his father. So Baba proved them all wrong by not only running his own business but becoming one of the richest merchants in Kabul (Hosseini, 16). When the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan, Baba left the country through a people smuggler along with his son to Pakistan then America. Once in America, Baba

A Matter Of Differences Essay

1418 words - 6 pages as being extremely crowded. All of these factors help to disorient the man and obscure his perception of the time that has passed, or in his case has not passed as he may be just daydreaming. The older man in “Willow Waist” has a much clearer view and is much more in touch with reality. After he has met with this woman of interest and begins to leave, he then makes an apology to the cab driver on how much time he has taken after promising to