This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Myth That Shaped Reality: The Native Americans And Discrimination

1279 words - 6 pages

Most Americans in the nineteenth century did not appreciate or understand their Indian neighbors. The Native American lifestyle seemed foreign and uncivilized compared with American society, which was experiencing unprecedented revolutions in technology and engineering. For this reason, a myth began to develop in the minds of the American people that the Indian presence in the West was unacceptable and that the American government needed to take action to solve the problem of the “uncivilized” Indians. Over time, two conflicting opinions developed concerning the form that the proposed government intervention should take. Some thought that the Native Americans were pitiful, uncultured people ...view middle of the document...

For example, near the bottom edge of the painting, an Indian kneels by an animal burrow, waiting with his bow poised to shoot the creature when it emerges. Not only do the Indians seem to be primitive in their technology, Bierstadt also portrays them as detached from the Western world that was becoming increasingly dependent on international influence and trade. Bierstadt included images such as the dead antelope and the hunting Indian to remind his viewers that the Indians relied on the land, not other countries, for survival.
Many Americans understood the connection between the Indians and animals such as the bison and the deer (The Humanities pg 1055). Most people also knew that American expansion was placing a tremendous strain on the herds of bison, reducing the populations of these animals to a fraction of what they had been before the American settlers arrived. For this reason, some well-meaning government officials theorized that the Indians would be better able to survive in a changing world if they became “civilized” (The Humanities pg 1048). As a result, the government implemented programs in an attempt to incorporate the Indians into society (The Humanities pg 1050). While these programs did assimilate many Indians into American culture and enterprise, not all of the Indians accepted these policies. Indians who rejected government policies often found themselves at odds with the military, and unfortunately several of the tribes who did participate in the government programs were still sometimes subjected to relocations because of greedy government leaders (The Humanities pg 1051). Thus, even though some Americans had good intentions, efforts to integrate the Indians into society were often unsuccessful.
A painter named John Vanderlyn went to the other mythical extreme in his painting The Murder of Jane McCrea. The painting shows two Native Americans holding a young woman by her arm and her hair while one of the Indians raises a tomahawk to scalp her. Most of the light in the painting is centered on the three figures, which makes the surrounding forest appear dark and sinister. The girl wears a look of terror on her face, pleading for her life with her eyes, but the Indians only look at her with grim, blank expressions. They appear as if they are either not intelligent enough to understand what they are doing or that they are so hardened that they do not care that they are about to commit murder.
Vanderlyn’s painting reflects the widely held view of the time that the Native Americans were horrifying brutes who killed every American in sight. While the death of Jane McCrea was a historical event, the details of her death remain a mystery to this day. There are many theories as to how she died, but Vanderlyn chose to depict one of the more sinister speculations, and he did this without...

Find Another Essay On A Myth that Shaped Reality: The Native Americans and Discrimination

The Southeast Native Americans: Cherokees and Creeks

934 words - 4 pages The Native Americans of the southeast live in a variety of environments. The environments range from the southern Appalachian Mountains, to the Mississippi River valley, to the Louisiana and Alabama swamps, and the Florida wetlands. These environments were bountiful with various species of plant and animal life, enabling the Native American peoples to flourish. “Most of the Native Americans adopted large-scale agriculture after 900 A.D, and some

Native Americans And Treaties with the Government

3983 words - 16 pages before on how Sherman went about Total Warfare. I used this to explain what Total Warfare is and how the same tactic was used on the bison. Huey, Aaron. "http://www.ted.com/talks/aaron_huey.html." TED. Video file, 15:25. November 2010. Accessed December 19, 2013. http://www.ted.com/talks/aaron_huey.html. This is a video with a native american bias going over all the wrong doings that happened to the native americans since 1824. I used this

Teenagers Myth and Reality

1019 words - 4 pages research shows that many parents never encounter serious conflicts with their adolescent children. Studies show that parents can live peacefully with their teens by keeping communication open and positive and by encouraging their teens to become independent while maintaining reasonable rules. Growing a "thick skin" for the duration can certainly help too."Teenager" is a loaded word and adolescents are victims of that label. Adolescents are not a

Native Americans and Alcoholism

1940 words - 8 pages . Native Americans have ever since been tagged and stigmatized as alcoholics. To an extent they have both received the degrading title as a whole as a result of the reality that the disease is very present in the population. Furthermore, the stigma may act as a precedent to the trend of growing alcoholism. It can be speculated that the negative stereotype has unfortunately harmed, if not promoted, the disease among the population. "Indian drinking

Italian-Americans and Discrimination

967 words - 4 pages Discrimination in America has mainly publicized certain races, such as African Americans, Native Americans, Hispanics, Middle Eastern, and even Asians. One race that is rarely publicized for its discrimination in America is the Italian Americans. Many are unaware of the discrimination that Italian Immigrants had to face during their first wave to America, and even today. During their earliest times in America, labor struggles were forced upon

A Large Flaw in Human Nature (Essay comparing/contrasting treatment of Native Americans and African Americans by the white people)

804 words - 3 pages almost every hour of every day. And yet, these advertisements are what keep business flowing, because they influence people to buy whatever product is being sold. If a man from a wealthy, well-known family walks into a high-class restaurant and orders a table, is it not predictable that he will most likely be seated and probably even served before the regular Joe-schmo that walks in off the street? Or if an entire nation supported a policy and

Convicts and The writing of History: Reality or Myth?

2580 words - 10 pages Historiography, or the methodology used for historical study and writing, helps demonstrate that the present is not divorced from the past; rather that history is a continuous dialogue with it. There are many contentious issues in writing history, depending on the agenda behind the accounts. This is shown clearly through attitudes to the Australian convicts. This essay will examine the historiography of writing Australian history, through

Ploitical, and Social Effents that Shaped the 60's Generation

3247 words - 13 pages , single mothers were forced into the labor market, and with these jobs came independence. The 50's and all its political, and social change, was only the breeding ground for the free thinking generation that was to follow.In America, a group of militant blacks called the 'Black Panther Party' had been dubbed 'American's Vietcong.' They were tired with the roadblocks and discrimination that were plaguing the civil rights leaders, like Dr. Martin Luther

Native Americans, Bradbury and the Scorn of the FBI

1869 words - 8 pages expansionism. Serving more as warning than a plot point, Spender’s discrediting furthers Bradbury’s points against “typical” American culture. Moreover, Spender alludes that as a settler, he has become one of the savages, saying that he is free of “ethics and customs,” meaning that he has free reign to kill in the name of Mars, and the other astronauts feel free to party and vomit on priceless artifacts. The Native Americans of the New World often

Alcohol Abuse and Native Americans

1746 words - 7 pages Americans. The Native American Culture and Alcohol Prevalence Native Americans refer to a Nation of related tribes that form the indigenous peoples of the North American Continent. They form one percent of the United States population where 500 tribes are now recognized by the government (Substance Abuse Policy Research Program, n.d.) The history of the Native Americans stretches beyond the European settlements and is characterized today by long

US Government and Native Americans

4066 words - 16 pages then the white people, they did not have enough power to fight against them. Andrew Jackson made them aware of their future, when he said "The tract you have ceded will soon be surveyed and sold, and immediately afterwards will be occupied by a white population. You will soon be in a state of starvation. You will commit depredations upon the property of our citizens."(The Native Truth) The Native Americans were also threatened that if they

Similar Essays

Discrimination Against Native Americans Essay

777 words - 3 pages some Alaska Natives and Hawaiians, the “Digital Divide” is a great handicap in their ability to gain jobs and to get a better education, since they do not have the technological skill or recourses required by many jobs (Native Americans). Also, over 317 of their reservations are full of environmental dangers. There may not be that much actual racism going on, but the aftermath of previous discrimination is still in effect. Although many

" Propaganda Vs. Reality" This Essay Is About Political Factor That Is Going On Between United States And Iraq. Our Reality Between Americans, And Other Reality Between Strangers

1254 words - 5 pages Kathy Brandon English 28 Staci Ranger Argumentative Analysis 08-21-01 Propaganda vs. Reality For the last couple of years, the United States and Iraq have been unfriendly to each other. It's been difficult to determine who was stating factual evidence, and who was ludicrously attacking to start a war. Its been known that the best and the worst way to get someone's attention, is to manipulate and mislead their views. The precise definition of

Finding A Balance Between Reality And Myth

961 words - 4 pages . It’s like an onion, once you peel off each layer symbolizing a mythical idea, what’s left in the core is the truth, what one can take with them to create their own mythical reality. Something that started out as a myth takes flight and people really live with the ideas that come from these mythical stories to create a stronger reality for themselves. For instance, in The Company of Wolves, Angela Carter was dissatisfied with the traditional

The Relationship Between Oklahomans And Native Americans

4507 words - 18 pages The Relationship Between Oklahomans and Native Americans I. Introduction When the name Oklahoma is mentioned, there are certain things that come to the minds of many people and one of those things are Native Americans. Native Americans and Oklahoma share a special bond that neither one of them ever thought would come into fruition. This special bond between Native Americans and Oklahoma is something that started with great