A New Birth Of Freedom: Human Rights, Named And Unnamed

1924 words - 8 pages

In A New Birth of Freedom, Charles L. Black, Jr., attempts to stem the tide of judicial conservatism that has dominated American constitutional law in the 1980’s and 1990’s. Black’s credentials are most impressive. A professor emeritus at Yale Law School and part-time instructor at Columbia Law School, he was part of the team of attorneys that successfully overcame legally mandated school segregation in the case of Brown v. Board of Education (1954), which remains a groundbreaking example of judicial activism, an approach to constitutional law that encourages sweeping judicial initiatives consistent with the text of the Constitution. Black has also been well-published in the fields of constitutional law and civil liberties, previously authoring books such as Structure and Relationship in Constitutional Law (1969), Capital Punishment: The Inevitability of Caprice and Mistake (1980), and Decision According to Law (1981). He has published numerous scholarly articles and spoken publicly to a variety of audiences on these and related topics.
The title of Black’s book comes from the Gettysburg address by Abraham Lincoln, to whom the book is dedicated. According to Black, Lincoln’s promise of “a new birth of freedom” was meant to be taken seriously and was not just a rhetorical convenience of the moment. Lincoln’s promise, however, has not been fully realized because of the failure of Americans to understand the true expanse of rights offered by the U.S. Constitution. This, in turn, is linked to three mistakes of constitutional interpretation: failure to realize the quasi-legal status of rights outlined in the Declaration of Independence, failure to utilize the Ninth Amendment to the Constitution (which strongly suggests the existence of rights not enumerated in the Constitution), and failure to properly implement the “citizenship” and “privileges and immunities” clauses of section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment. In concert, these mistakes have led to an overall approach to civil liberties and civil rights that systematically deprives Americans of freedoms they should and could be enjoying under the protection of constitutional law.
All three of these alleged mistakes of interpretation are controversial and, therefore, need explanation, which Black supplies in enough detail to make his arguments compelling but not so much as to make his book esoteric or conspicuously academic.
With regard to the Declaration of Independence, Black argues that the nation’s founders had the “inalienable rights” mentioned in that document’s second paragraph well in mind when they authored the Constitution and, even more particularly, when they added and ratified the Bill of Rights (the first ten amendments to the Constitution). Black reminds readers of the close proximity in time between the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, which are separated by only about a dozen years, and asserts that the Declaration of Independence had, at the very least, quasi-legal...

Find Another Essay On A New Birth of Freedom: Human Rights, Named and Unnamed

Child Labor - A Violation of Human Rights

847 words - 3 pages In the late 1700's and early 1800's, most of the world had gradually evolved from a rural economy to an urban economy. Power-driven machines replaced hand labor in the making of most manufactured products for the first time. Factories began to open everywhere, first in England and then in the United States, then nearly the rest of the world. The owners of these factories found a new source of labour to run their machines - children. Operating

Child Labor: A Violation of Human Rights

847 words - 3 pages In the late 1700's and early 1800's, most of the world had gradually evolved from a rural economy to an urban economy. Power-driven machines replaced hand labor in the making of most manufactured products for the first time. Factories began to open everywhere, first in England and then in the United States, then nearly the rest of the world. The owners of these factories found a new source of labour to run their machines - children. Operating

Haitian Government and Violation of Human Rights

1621 words - 6 pages the government wanted you dead you would die they had hitmans and everything they are unstoppable to the Haiti citzens. According to The Front Line in Haiti speaking out to the government and defending human rights is asking for death. So that is another human rights violation right there freedom of speech. To no be harmed by the government you had to be on perfect behavior. According to Human rights violations on the increase a Haitian government

Violation of Human Rights: Homosexuality and Military

2741 words - 11 pages heterosexuals allowed to serve their country? Yes, they are. It is simple as that, that homosexuals should have their right to serve their country too. That is why I think the Don't Ask Don't Tell policy was a violation of fundamental human rights. Eventhough, homosexuals were allowed to serve their country under specific circumstances, these circumstances were clearly violating their rights in terms of freedom of speech and equality of all people

Human Rights and Human Rights Organisations

2596 words - 10 pages much more subjective and inconsistent across an entire society and are not as discoverable or wide spread as customary rights or legal rights.b) various types of individual and collective human rightsRights can be divided into individual rights, those that are held by citizens as individuals (or corporations) are recognised by the legal system, and collective rights, held by an ensemble of citizens or a subgroup of citizens who have a certain

The Vietnam War: A Fight for Human Liberty and Freedom

2121 words - 8 pages at the same time fighting for freedom, democracy, and human rights? The war in Vietnam was fought over citizens’ chance to choose their own type of government. The United States was justified in all its involvement during the Vietnam conflict. Although the United States did not achieve all of its objectives, our country did achieve its primary objective, which was to stop the spread of Communism throughout Southeast Asia

Have the courts struck a balance between the protection of individual rights under The Human Rights Act and Parliamentary sovereignty?

2052 words - 8 pages The traditional Diceyan view was that the role of the judges is to protect civil liberties and human rights through the common law, and by judicial interpretation. Dicey placed great emphasis on the fact that there was no need for a formal document laying down the rights of the individual, as the remedies of private law provided adequate protection. His view was backed up by the classic decision in Entick v Carrington, where the courts

Christianity and Human Rights

1508 words - 7 pages Human Rights has evolve ever time to a more complex concept; at the same time Christianity as one of the major religions has as well grown, expand and become more complex. Originally the concept of human right aboard the ideas of life, liberty, security, freedom of religion, opinion and the right to assembly; and from here it was grown. A fundamental issue regarding human rights and religion is whether the disclose of human rights is

Controversies and Human Rights

1733 words - 7 pages Human rights are those rights that has “recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world, Whereas it is essential, if man is not to be compelled to have recourse, as a last resort, to rebellion against tyranny and oppression, that human rights should be protected by the rule of law, Whereas it is essential to promote the

Human Rights and Reconciliation

2475 words - 10 pages , services, and venues such as clubs. Other initiatives taken to protect such rights include changes made to the level of accessibility for the disabled in the design of public buildings and transport. A concern still exists, however, it is the plight of the mentally disabled, who are over represented in Australia's prison system.Responses of Other nations:New Zealand New Zealand meets international human rights standards in many respects, and often

France and Human Rights

2489 words - 10 pages case law a Grand Chamber of 17 judges is used (Merrills, 2014). In 2012, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Belarus produced a publication of certain country’s violations of human rights. According to the publication, France is accused of violating 14 articles such as, “Right to Peaceful Assembly, Freedom of Expression, and Torture”. In November 2012, over 1000 people gathered to protest the legalization of same-sex marriages in

Similar Essays

To What Extent Did The Spread Of Christianity Violate Human Rights And Freedom In Africa? By Walubo Jude Tadeo

1919 words - 8 pages subjugation of Africans, Coloureds and Indians for the sake of South Africa. Christian Missionaries based their principles and programmes on doctrines of racial superiority, relegated Africans to a second race, denying then the human respect.Christian missionaries never at one time had any respect for the religious freedom of Africans who practiced Traditional religion. They regarded Christianity and Traditional African religions as an equal and

Birth Of A New Era Essay

1977 words - 8 pages Birth of a New Era Despite the problems of the fourteenth century, it marked the beginnings of extraordinary changes in numerous facets of fifteenth century society. This astonishing revolution was coined the Renaissance, which meant “rebirth.” The Renaissance led to such literary pioneers as Niccolò Machiavelli. His work, The Prince, gave detailed instructions as to what qualities a perfect leader must possess and how to use these

The Birth Of A New Mother

1588 words - 7 pages the father of these two girls my wife naturally was their mother of course. I focused on bringing in the income and paying for everything, while my wife stayed home and watched our girls. I was a happy father and husband. I spent seven years watching my wife run after them day and night. She would make them dinner, bathe them, shop for them, and everything a mother does. By the seventh year of my second child’s birth I surprised my wife with a

Birth Of A New Kind Of Music: Kwaito

1601 words - 6 pages , Kwaito is also seen to be related to American styles of music through the kinds of messages they promote and convey. A strong name in the Kwaito genre is Arthur Mafokate who is considered one of the founding fathers of this new and upbeat style of music. Basically a type of dance music, most Kwaito songs are composed of slowed down House tracks and repetitive lyrics. This genre relates well to the youth of South Africa due to its appealing lines