This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Perplexing Sense Of Justice Essay

1371 words - 6 pages

Driven by a complicated sense of justice, Captain Vere believed it was possible that even justice can cause the innocent to suffer. While Vere had compassion for Billy, he felt that he was bound by a strict loyalty to his duties. Because the law is clear in this matter of striking an officer, Captain Vere was serving justice based solely on Billy’s immediate actions. In defense of Captain Vere, it is necessary to take a closer look at what conventions he was acting on. Vere’s actions were based on four weighty and controversial principles: upholding communal justice over individual justice, maintaining discipline on the ship, the letter of the law in a wartime setting, and an obsession with his oath of service to the King. All of these reasons provide significant testimony and justification for Captain Vere’s intentions.
Captain Vere, in the interest of maintaining order and discipline on his ship, immediately activated a drumhead court in order to convict Billy Budd. His decision, although harsh and unsavory, was necessary; such sacrifices are required in order to ensure that society, although imperfect in nature, is functioning in a reasonably harmonious matter. In the case of the captain, it was important to ensure unquestioned order on his ship, especially in an unsteady, precarious time of war. There are compromises made when an individual trades, whether willingly or not, their natural liberty in order to gain the order and protection promised by government. Vere was representing a general public order that opposed Billy’s individualism. Even though the other officers on board the ship asked Captian Vere to push Billy’s trial to a later date, he denied their request because he realized that waiting would show weakness. Vere knew that the consequences of displaying weakness would not be pretty.
Captain Vere had many reasons for his decision to continue with the execution of Billy Budd. One of these was his need to maintain order and discipline on the ship. In a time of severe dissatisfaction among the majority of the sailors due to impressment laws, Vere deeply understood the risk of showing any weakness to his sailors. Amidst the climate of dissatisfaction, the Captain was preventing a potential full-scale mutiny. If executing Billy for a crime he clearly committed prevented mutiny, then Captain Vere’s actions were protecting the greater good. Billy’s actions, if left alone, outwardly showed the other sailors that they could express their dissatisfaction of authority through physical means. This could escalate quickly and put many more lives at risk than just Billy’s. Captain Vere’s decision not only upheld the law, but it protected the ship, and potentially the British navy.
"Struck dead by an angel of God! Yet the angel must hang." These words were exclaimed by Vere shortly after Billy ended the life of Claggart. They suggest that Billy, although thought of as an angel, would still have to abide...

Find Another Essay On A Perplexing Sense of Justice

A Defense of Justice Essay

1256 words - 6 pages Have you ever thought about if the person next to you is a killer or a rapist? If so, what would you want from the government if the person had killed someone you know? Should they receive the death penalty? Murderers and rapists should be punished for the crimes they commit and should pay the price for their wrongdoing. Having the death penalty in our society is humane; it helps the overcrowding problem and gives relief to the families of the

A Statement Of Justice Essay

2102 words - 8 pages A Statement of Justice "I'm innocent I tell you! I'm innocent!" The door slammed shut with a bang. "Yeah, yeah tell it to the judge!", declared the guard. "I've been telling them I'm innocent from the day I got put in here." Leroy looked in the corner of the room and saw Paul sitting on the cold wet ground. "But I am innocent!" shouted Leroy. "Relax will ya! I don't want those guards

Critical Comparison of the Content and Literary Devices Used in Bon Voyage, Mr. President by Gabriel Garcia Marquez and The Perplexing Simplicity of a

1468 words - 6 pages Critical Comparison of the Content and Literary Devices Used in Bon Voyage, Mr. President by Gabriel Garcia Marquez and The Perplexing Simplicity of a Lack of Nothing Bon Voyage, Mr President is a short story written by Gabriel Garcia Marquez. This is a tale of a South American President in exile. Nearing the end of his days, we are given an insight into the life of a man with injured pride, reminiscing the days that went

A Sense of Place in Maupassant's Vendetta

2272 words - 9 pages Schoolteacher’s Guest”, it was definitely not justice. “The owner… fired a blast from his rifle meaning to scare the boy away but drilling a black hole in the middle of his forehead through which his life rapidly escaped.” The schoolteacher’s son died as a result of an accident, while the man died in cold blood. It was “an eye for an eye” in the sense that two lives were exchanged or were extinguished as a result, but

Symbols in "A Sense of Shelter"

799 words - 3 pages In “A Sense of Shelter” by John Updike, various symbols are used to emphasize the overall theme of comfort and express the gradually depressing mood. The author uses bad weather, a familiar desk, and a familiar school as symbolic objects within the story to display these ideas. Updike strategically places these symbols throughout the story, emphasizing the importance of these elements.Weather is one of the accounts used to set the mood

A Sense of Desperation in Atonement

908 words - 4 pages How does McEwan capture a sense of desperation in Part 2 of Atonement? The title ‘Atonement’ hints at a dark secret, a need for retribution and weighty themes, which McEwan duly delivers. The desperation in the narrative format of Robbie the soldier is paralleled by Briony’s increasing desperation to obtain penance for her crime. It is a desire further complicated by her omnipotent narrative role; McEwan steps in and out of his

The Automobile: A False Sense of Freedom

2503 words - 10 pages . Homemakers and stay at home moms have quickly become soccer moms, always on the go; brining the kids wherever they need to go. This is a false sense of freedom from enslavement, “Liberation is word commonly used to describe how the auto has released women from social control”, (Kay, 1998). It isn’t really liberation, but a change of scenery. The car also changes feelings of enslavement for the teen girls of San Jose; Amy Best describes how the teen

Smart Phones and a Sense of Belonging

1544 words - 7 pages their conversation and felt I was invisibly being excluded in the group. I started to doubt self-position and value in the friendship. In order to seek for a sense of belonging in peer group, a contradiction between family education and peer influence was being shaped gradually. Brown et.al (1986) observe that the importance of group affiliation was related more clearly to the self-perceived centrality of one's position in peer groups. This

Chivalry, Politically Incorrect? <Tab/>Who would have thought that chivalry, a sense of justice, and honor above all else would be accosted by a modern society and the legal system?

782 words - 3 pages Chivalry, Politically Incorrect?Who would have thought that chivalry, the idealization of virtue, military courtesy, a sense of justice, unconditional devotion, and honor above all else would be accosted by a modern society and the legal system? Who would accuse the medieval King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table principles as unjust or thought of as an object of scorn? Present day American society, that's who would dare to attack such a

A sense of belonging requires an understanding of one's past

1051 words - 5 pages 'Put oneself in else's shoes', expecting that everyone have heard of this quote as it floats around the world and has been translated in almost every language, and it works! In this essay about belonging we are going discuss about how an understanding of one's past develop a sense of belonging. Without understanding what a person have gone through, either adaptation or fighting for acceptance we will never be able to understand how one can or

The Function of Consumerism in Creating a Sense of Self

2582 words - 11 pages the human race. The question at hand, however, is what drives or motivates us towards this consumerist culture? What are we hoping to achieve at the end of it all? In our postmodern or contemporary society consumerism has taken up a very big role in our lives and few things play such an influential role in our lives. Sociological analyses and studies have shown that consumerism is very intimately tied to the creation of a sense of self.For the

Similar Essays

A Sense Of Humor Essay

1603 words - 6 pages that works, like King and Compton, often illustrate social issues regarding gender, oppression and multiculturalism. We normally sense the of rage and empathy that the author tries to convey but I find that humor can portray these themes in a way that can easily interest the reader. In literary works like Thomas King’s short story “Borders” and Wayde Compton’s poem “Where Heaven Lies”, these works prove that humour can project these social

Character Sketch Of Atticus Finch From "To Kill A Mockingbird" By Harper Lee. Discusses His Morals And Sense Of Justice

907 words - 4 pages personal one for Atticus. Throughout the novel he fights to keep on the right track en route to the stars. What appealed to myself as a reader was his undetoured course in reaching his person ideals and set of morals: his resolute refusal to yield to social pressure, his ardent sense of racial equality, and his ability to risk great sacrifice to remain true to what he believes in.Atticus has an amazing adherence to his morals; even when surrounded by

A Mortals Sense Of Immortality Essay

1784 words - 7 pages A Mortal&#8217;s Sense of Immortality To fear death is to fear life itself. An overbearing concern for the end of life not only leads to much apprehension of the final moment but also allows that fear to occupy one&#8217;s whole life. The only answer that can possibly provide relief in the shadow of the awaited final absolution lies in another kind of absolution, one that brings a person to terms with their irrevocable mortality and

Gaining A Sense Of Peace Essay

810 words - 4 pages Gaining a Sense of Peace In the novel Dreaming in Cuban by Cristina Garcia, Cuba had an impact on each character especially to Pilar. Pilar moved to New York when she was just a little girl. She felt like she was unfamiliar with her heritage, which sparked the idea to move back to her homeland. Pilar’s grandmother, Celia and her mother, Lourdes were Pilar’s only connections to Cuba. Throughout the book, Pilar has expressed several changes