A Philosophical Perspective On The Regulation Of Business

3022 words - 12 pages

A Philosophical Perspective on the Regulation of Business

ABSTRACT: The paper compares the Anglo-American and continental legal systems in parallel with a comparison of the philosophical foundations for each. The defining philosophical distinction between the two legal traditions (viz., the Anglo-American system is predicated on idealism and the continental system on materialism) is shown to influence the way in which criminal justice is handled by the two systems as applied to citizens, and how this influence is carried across to the regulation of business as applied to corporations. The idealistic (possibly theological) worldview inherent in the Anglo-American legal system explains its moral presumptions regarding human freedom, dignity, and responsibility, while the materialist worldview inherent in the continental legal systems explains its amoral assumptions about human motivations and behavior. I suggest that while the Anglo-American legal system may be justified in its moral philosophical presumptions as applied to citizens, the continental legal system, with its amoral assumptions, more accurately reflects corporations than citizens. Understanding how the philosophy behind the two legal systems influences the application of law in modern society can lead to improvements in public policy.

There is an effort underway in the automotive sector of the ever-expanding global economy to harmonize motor vehicle regulations world-wide. This micro-experiment in world democracy (along with others like it in different economic sectors) differs from more prominent examples of negotiating international law in that it deals with the amoral realm of business, rather than the moral/immoral realm of international conflict and criminal justice, and in that it deals with regulations, rather than laws. Because regulations govern very technical aspects of business activity, they are even further immersed in the amoral aspects of society, namely the activities that constitute science, technology, and commerce. Nevertheless, because the regulation of business is patterned after, and administered by, legal authorities established to maintain social order, the regulation of business reflects regionally the legal traditions under which it was established.

As might be expected, this regulatory harmonization effort is taking place under the auspices of the United Nations (specifically, Working Party 29). It has as its ultimate goal the development of a global automotive regulatory system in which motor vehicles are tested once according to universal standards, and are accepted everywhere, as opposed to the current situation in which differing regulations require unique vehicle configurations, and differing certification requirements require that a vehicle be tested according to multiple test procedures and standards, even where the vehicle configuration is the same. The U.S. Department of Commerce (DOC), the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and the...

Find Another Essay On A Philosophical Perspective on the Regulation of Business

Regulation Of The Internet Essay

5981 words - 24 pages customised. It can be tailored to suit the organisations needs via the incorporation of old and new systems.Reducing risks: We are dealing with a government agency, which cannot be subjected to failure as it the most critical establishment on which people?s lives depend. SSADM reduces risk of project failure. It is the most complete analysis and design method on the market that uses tried and tested techniques to define your business needs.Conforming

Role of the US Constitution and Legal System in Business Regulation

1090 words - 4 pages Role of the US Constitution and Legal System in Business RegulationThe Constitution of the United States and their legal system have an impact on the guidance and operation of companies in any industry. In case a person breaks a law, for example, he or she may be obliged to pay a fine or even imprisoned in the US. It works the same way with companies: if a business is found responsible for allowing its employees to violate regulations this

The Significance of Philosophical Scepticism

1828 words - 7 pages this. Its essential element is a general view about human knowledge. In the broadest terms, philosophical scepticism holds, or at least finds irrefutable, the view that knowledge is impossible. There are two features of philosophical scepticism which differentiate it from everyday 'sceptical' outlooks. The first has to do with its strength. The more challenging sceptical arguments do not depend on imposing high standards for knowledge or

The Philosophical Question of Suicide

2592 words - 10 pages matter every second that one is breathing but can be all can be ended with one act. So if life is the beginning of all the problems, then suicide is the ending to every problem. With such a serious question many will have very enlighten and fictitious answers on the philosophical problem of suicide. The philosophical problem of suicide will have supporters and opponents and those people have adequate supportive arguments for both sides of the

The Problems of Philosophical Anarchy

1082 words - 4 pages The oxford dictionary defines anarchism as “belief in the abolition of all government and the organization of society on a voluntary, cooperative basis without recourse to force or compulsion.” Therefore, philosophical anarchism is a form of political philosophy which rejects all types of hierarchy and authority not just states or governments. However, there are a number of problems with philosophical anarchism. Firstly, the most prominent

The Value of Philosophical Thinking

1353 words - 5 pages The study of Philosophy is often under serious suspicions from society of being somewhat useless. It provides no immediate answers or results, leaves one with uncertainty and unanswerable questions, and also a complicated view of the life in this world. This is to say the value of philosophizing is not obvious and not easily attained. As it has been pointed out, the pursuit of philosophical knowledge does not often bring wealth or concrete

The Philosophical Teachings of Supernatural

1691 words - 7 pages done by finding the value of the consequences of following a particular rule. The rule the following of which has the best overall consequences is the best rule” (Mautner, ed.). This is unlike the Act Utilitarians, who must make decisions based on every individual consequence. In “Bloodlust,” Gordon Walker is introduced as a hunter who has seemingly no conscience when it comes to killing monsters. He has generalized throughout the experiences of

A Feminist Perspective of On the Road and The First Third

644 words - 3 pages Much has been written about the Beat generation, especially about the hold its radical freedom has exerted on the American imagination. The Beats who stand out in most of our minds are men and the freedom they enjoyed--a freedom of movement, of creativity, of sexuality--is coded as a particularly male kind of freedom. My paper will suggest that in their autobiographical texts On the Road and The First Third Jack Kerouac and Neal Cassady

The Cycle of Creativity: A Psychoanalytic Perspective on Samuel T. Coleridge’s Kubla Khan

2357 words - 9 pages place where refinement and logic of the surrounding environment does not hold sway, and thus is untamed and dangerous (Lawall 813-815). Outside of the chasm there is “a woman wailing for her demon lover”, and if one views this from a Jungian perspective it provides insight into the meaning of this otherwise perplexing symbol. Jung posited archetypes within every mind that act as somewhat independent semi-unconscious components of the unified

A discussion on the principle ways in which heat is gained and lost by the body, explaining the various mechanisms involved in the regulation of body temperature

1574 words - 6 pages Since evolution began Man has spread to all areas of the globe, his ability to regulate his body temperature independently of his external surroundings contributes significantly to this success. This assignment will discuss the methods by which heat is exchanged, the effect of this exchange on the body and how it is utilised in thermoregulatory mechanisms. The importance of these regulatory measures will be demonstrated by a brief description of

My Philosophical Views on the Colorado Shootings

1324 words - 6 pages There are many disastrous events in the world that have happened, that make many people reflect on things like their beliefs, the actual occurrence of the event itself, what caused one, or a group of people to do such a thing, the credibility of the media they got such information from, the responsibility of those involved or not involved in any way, their own religion, the probability of death all around them, and even the safety of those they

Similar Essays

Role Of The United States Constitution And Business Regulation

736 words - 3 pages University of PhoenixThe role of the United States Constitution in business falls under Article I, Clause 3, Commerce Power, Power to Regulate Commerce. The role will be discussed in this paper along with a current example from today's world. The example will show how Constitutional rights can affect business and how our legal system will be used to protect those rights.The Commerce ClauseCongress has the sole power to govern commerce or

The Perspective Of A Heterosexual Teenager On Same Sex Marriage

1462 words - 6 pages matrimony is a very sacred commitment between heterosexuals because God accepts their special intimate emotions that they share, but homosexual marriages are clearly unaccepted in God's perspective regardless of how deep their feelings are for each other.In addition, the bishop has emphasized two points. Firstly, he stressed that homosexuals should greatly reconsider their sex preference, for the reason that the bible has never stated or implied

A Rhetorical Perspective On The Issue Of Wiki Leaks

1715 words - 7 pages Menace or Assurance? : A Rhetorical Perspective on the Issue of WikiLeaks Founded in 2006 by Australian journalist Julian Assange, the website WikiLeaks had quickly risen in infamy over the past few years (Majerol 19). The controversial website had posted hundreds of thousands of classified documents about the Iraq and Afghanistan war, revealing government cover-ups, a secret assassination unit and the killing of civilians among many things

A Philosophical View On 'the Great Gatsby' By Fitzgerald

623 words - 2 pages a philosophical view on 'The Great Gatsby'--using time as a key dimension to ones life theme.The Great Gatsby - EssayTopic: Time as a key dimension to one's life's theme.Time is an idea described in different periods and aspects, for example philosophical,psychological, physical and biological. This time flows evenly but is broken into the past, presentand future. Since we only live in the present forever planning for our futures and dreams