A Pluralistic Balance Essay

1784 words - 7 pages

In the last decade, Canadian courts have increasingly recognized gay marriages. This recognition has been long overdue as the Canadian gay community was routinely oppressed prior to this string of court rulings. This was a definite victory for Canadian democracy, seeing that a minority group has had its rights protected. Paul Martin, after having presented the Civil Marriage Act, described it "as a natural and necessary evolution of minority-rights protection under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms." (Den Tant, 2005) However, there are certain inconsistencies with this seemingly pluralistic approach that have become more apparent in recent years. Canadian democracy may be defined as "majority rule, minority rights," and with these decisions we can safely assume that the majority of Canadians are tolerant of gay marriages. It therefore follows that those against gay marriages are also a minority. As a result of this recent change in the political climate, the power scheme has shifted from those who oppose same-sex marriage to the gay community. This is evidenced in the many incarcerations of religious figures who peacefully protest outside of parliament hill and were consequently charged with hate crimes1. This is clearly not the epitome of democracy and the best possible solution would be to restore the power balance between these groups so that each has as much power as the other with compromises on various issues.

Pluralism may be defined as the pursuit of individuals in utilizing various political tools available to them, with the freedom to find and cooperate with those who are like minded. If this group is formed but is ignored by the government of Canada and the majority in general, the group can mobilize its resources and act in various ways to change their status in the face of the public. This is the most common approach in Canadian democracy and is the ideal described herein. (Dyck, 2004) It is necessary to take note of this because those who would justify the incarcerations, penalties and to some extent oppression of religious and other figures against gay marriage may state that Canada is a secular nation and human rights take precedence over religious beliefs. This is correct in essence but also contradicts itself in this context; religious figures have been much oppressed as a result of this power shift and therefore also qualify for protection under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. This will become more evident with relevant examples.

In May of 2002, Marc Hall, a gay student in an Oshawa catholic school was not permitted by school officials to take his boyfriend to the graduation prom. A court case was launched and the judge ruled in favour of Hall. The school officials said that they were not against Hall's homosexuality but did not wish to send an image of public homosexual acceptance as it goes against the teachings of the church. Hall had the right to switch to a public school but he refused. (CBC, 2002)...

Find Another Essay On A Pluralistic Balance

The English School: A Via Media

999 words - 4 pages School by combining the Hobbesian/Realist element of international system, with the Grotian/Rationalist element of a socially constructed order” (Buzan, 2001, p476). Advantages One of the advantages of the English School is “ the role of balance of power, diplomacy and international law” (Devlen, James and Ozdamar 2005) that are essential to maintain Wight’s idea. He insisted that a common culture is necessary to talk seriously about an

Benefits of the Federal System Essay

1952 words - 8 pages Although the power has shifted back and forth from stronger decentralized government to a dominant centralized government, the balance between the two has yet to fall completely. Thanks to the limitations the Founders installed into our Constitution, there has yet a time where the states or national government has the total power to control the nation as a whole. We call this type of government system as the federal system. In a federal system

The Bi-Polar World Order

2134 words - 9 pages ), the period of thaw within the Cold War time span, allowed a shift in the geopolitical code of the bi-polar world – from a blanket containment code to a more pluralistic balance of powers model. Consequently, countries like Japan, China and Europe (meaning the European Community), caused disturbances in the duopoly. The recessive tendencies of US economy in the late 1960s and 70s, and the withdrawal of the dollar as a reserve currency, thus

Colonialism and Morality in The Moonstone and The Man Who Would Be King

1403 words - 6 pages divest himself of the burden of taking an ethical standpoint. Moral balance becomes the responsibility of the native culture and people, this in turn is objectified in the Moonstone itself. Collins presents us with a for the want of a better term; discerning curse, a moral arbiter. At an extreme the cursed jewel can be seen as a universalist device dispensing sub-Christian morality. Virtuous characters pass on the jewel unharmed, Franklin Blake

In what ways has Channel 4 altered the landscape of British television broadcasting for its competitors?

2180 words - 9 pages The main characteristic of Channel 4's broadcasting life is, as John Ellis highlights, a marked shift from offer-led to demand-led television. Channel 4 can without question be seen as crucial in 'breaking open the habits of the era of scarcity, in leading the development away from concepts of balance and towards that of diversity of view'. This policy, despite the channel's difficulties, has proved successful, and has moved the goalposts of

The American Religious Experience

1209 words - 5 pages and secondary curricula as opportunities for teaching about religions. Such study serves the academic goals of educating students about history and cultures as well as about the traditions of particular religions in a pluralistic society.When should teaching about religious holidays take place?On the elementary level, natural opportunities arise for discussion of religious holidays while studying different cultures and communities. In the

Value Pluralism and Absolute Moral Judgments

1735 words - 7 pages Widespread and deep moral disagreements are persistently resistant to rational solutions and thus allow for continuing debate over the validity of moral judgments. This paper will discuss prominent positions regarding whether moral judgments may be true and false in an absolute sense or a relative sense, in light of the diverse and intense disagreement in moral judgment. This paper will defend the pluralistic conclusion that if there are not

What are the advantages of Parliamentarism

2412 words - 10 pages Parliamentarism is that the executives are generally collective (Heywood 2013, p. 310). These features of Parliamentarism, argued by Linz (1989), create and foster a flexible political environment conducive for the main political actors to ‘get things done’ (Heywood 2013, p. 310). It also creates, Linz (1998) argues, a more pluralistic atmosphere facilitating the necessary incubation conditions required to foster burgeoning political ideals and government

The pros and cons of capital punishment from all angles.

2374 words - 9 pages equal citizens devoted to a balance between individual self- fulfillment and the advancement of the common good. Communal life would be based on mutual love in which equality of giving and receiving was the norm of social practice. Everyone would contribute to the best of ability and each would receive in accordance with legitimate claims to available resources. What would a community based on this kind of love do with those who committed brutal acts


6913 words - 28 pages factors, it would be far more useful to adopt a more multi- dimensional, pluralistic approach. This will prevent an over-simplification of the complexities involved in understanding globalisation, while permitting a flexible definition of contemporary globalisation. It is stating the obvious to declare that globalisation has not suddenly ap- peared out of the blue. An understanding of the type of factors and events that shaped globalisation will enable

Capital punishment

2508 words - 10 pages SPIRITUAL COMMUNITYChristian love, is unconditional. It does not depend on the worthiness or merit of those to whom it is directed. It is persistent in seeking the good of others regardless of whether they return the favor or even deserve to be treated well on the basis of their own incessant wrongdoing. An ideal community would be made up of free and equal citizens devoted to a balance between individual self-fulfillment and the advancement of the

Similar Essays

Social Responsibility Theory (Srt) Of The Press

628 words - 3 pages ideas because an unregulated media would serve the interest of the socially dominant groups while small, weak, pluralistic groups would either be neglected or denigrated.- The Chicago School also felt that a "benevolent elite" could use media to gain personal power and to transmit hate & fear propaganda. Hitler's use of the media to sow hatred of the Jews was seen as an example.- The Chicago School (which comprises a group of social researchers

Check And Balance Essay

1402 words - 6 pages four principles are the check and balance and the separations of power, federalism, limited government and judicial review. Check and balance became one of the principle of structuring the government in America, because in the big and large country as America the distribute of power is a big deal, the distribute power in america became one of the first priority, because the people of American believe in equality and balancing power.The American

Educating Our Youth Toward Responsible Citizenry.

973 words - 4 pages each lesson." In the Multicultural education process the classroom should become models of democracy and equity. Multicultural education must be integrated throughout the curriculum at all levels". (Gollnick, Donna M. and Philip C. Chinn, Multicultural Education: History in a Pluralistic Society, pp. 224-227, )In order to teach multicultural principles we must first establish a set of core bilingual curriculum standards that incorporate cultural

Social Ethics Essay

999 words - 4 pages Social responsibility begins centuries ago when people realized that living in a community and that is why their decisions affect others. We have considered a pluralistic society is one that accepts, recognizes and tolerates the existence of different positions or thoughts and that is why we must always look for a common welfare laws governing society to find a balance that benefits all its members. However throughout history we can find