A Progressive Movement Essay

1574 words - 6 pages

A Progressive Movement

Much of a historian’s job is to read what their colleagues have written on their subject of interest at the moment. Often, they then go on to write their own opinions on the subject, thereby influencing the historians of the future. The famed historian and teacher Richard Hofstadter wrote The Age of Reform in 1955 about the late 19th century and early 20th century movement of Progressivism. In turn, other historians that include Paula Baker, Richard McCormick, and Peter Filene have written their opinion on what the movement we call Progressivism really was, and what its real significance is, or even if it really existed as a movement in its own right.

Richard Hofstadter’s book The Age of Reform was written in 1955 and influenced future historians in their studies on the progressive movement. Hofstadter argues that the progressive movement was due to the loss of status of the professional and gentry classes to the “new money,” for example, the Vanderbilts. “Progressivism resulted from attempts by the old urban middle class, whose status was threatened by the plutocrats above them and the workers and immigrants below, to restore their social position and to cure the injustices in American society” (Hofstadter 135-66). Hofstadter also attempted to explain the progressive movement by delving into the populist movement of the 1800s, which occurred mostly in rural areas where the farmer was beginning to lose status and money. He traces the origin of progressivism to the loss of status, or as he calls it, a “status revolution.”

Peter Filene’s paper, “An Obituary for the Progressive Movement,” contains a thesis very different from the other three works that address Progressivism. He argues that Progressivism as a movement never truly existed. He acknowledges the fierce debate that has existed among historians like Hofstadter, Baker, and McCormick for much of the 20th century about Progressivism’s meaning and results, however, he is adamant that it did not exist as a movement as it is commonly defined (Filene 20). Filene defines a movement as a “collectivity acting with some continuity to promote or resist a change in the society…one can then analyze its internal characteristics along four dimensions: program, the values which underlie this program, membership and supporters” (20-21). Filene finds the program of a social movement the most important part, for without a program the movement will be unable to sustain itself. His most convincing point is that on so many issues, the Progressives, supposedly a defined and cohesive movement, had numerous splits within their group. For example, “The Federal Reserve Act of 1913 created, according to Arthur Link, a conflict between ‘uncompromising’ and ‘middle-of-the-road’ progressives.” The most convincing example concerns women’s suffrage, “a cause that has generally been attributed to the progressive movement.” However, as Filene points out, progressive...

Find Another Essay On A Progressive Movement

The Progressive Movement Essay

535 words - 2 pages Progressive Movement EssayBetween 1890 and 1919, a new era of reforms began. These reforms were put forth by people who called themselves Progressives. The progressives wanted to confront the problems brought on by America's industrialization. For example, Progressives wanted to improve poor working conditions, reform the corrupt systems of political machines, and regulate big business. This progressive movement was successful in carrying out

Progressive Movement Essay

648 words - 3 pages Although the Progressive Era managed to solve much of the backwater left over from Industrialization, it failed in regards to discrimination. America would have to wait decades later for the issue of civil equality to truly be addressed. Due to the apathy of the politicians during that time, the desperate need for a scapegoat, and the hypocrisy people displayed when confronted with the topic, the movement that was intended to achieve “progress

The Progressive Movement

578 words - 2 pages The progressive movement consisted of a diverse group of middle and upper-class Americans engaging in the social reform. Their general purpose was to make society a better world to be in. Whether it concerned women suffrage, political corruption or the conservation of natural resources, these activists fought to make society recognize these concepts as being national priorities. This unification of mostly democrats and republicans started an

Disappointment in the Progressive Movement

622 words - 3 pages The Progressive Movement was a welcoming concept to many Americans. As America continued to advance the people needed a government that also changed, so “As Americans ushered in a new century they began to demand change, equality and reform and the progressive era was born.” (The Progressive Era, n.d.) The current president’s first campaign slogan sounded incredibly familiar to the Progressive Movement. As in the late nineteenth century

The Progressive Movement in America

1040 words - 4 pages , religious leaders, and politicians joined in, these grass-roots efforts morphed into a national movement. This movement of reform was called the progressive movement. The progressive movement included, among others, four areas of reform: social, economic, moral, and efficiency. In the area of social reform, the main problems that were put at task were poverty, education, living conditions and women’s rights. To help solve these problems

Affects of American Progressive Movement

849 words - 3 pages The progressive movement sought a series of reforms to address specific social, economic, and political problems. The movement attempted to bring the government into a state where it served all people. Though the amount of reform wanted often varied between the individuals of the progressive movement, some disturbing ingredients that led to its creation remained the same in many. These ingredients, that all too readily could turn repressive and

The Progressive Movement... everything about the progressive historians

6426 words - 26 pages era.John Fiske wrote a two-volume treatment of the American Revolution in 1891. To be sure, this was at the earliest stages of the Progressive movement in the United States, but it falls well within the boundaries. In that context, one can evaluate the contents of Fiske's book, and in one other also: which occurred in various places in Turner's writings.Fiske writes much in the second volume of his history of "drums and trumpets." However, there are

“The Progressive Era and the Occupy Movement”

1777 words - 7 pages Progressive Movement” (Sachs). With the public returning to familiar senses of accusations and criticism towards capitalist “tyrants”, a strong resemblance to the past Progressive Era of the early 1900’s cannot be overlooked. Although differences do exist between the two influential movements (most notably the roles held by both advanced technology and the federal government), the many similarities – the push for reform and the presence of economic

The Effects of the Progressive Movement

884 words - 4 pages Progressive Movement The Progressive Movement was initiated to fix many of the United States problems surrounding its industrial growth of the nineteenth century. The ultimate goal of Progressivism was to clear up corruption in all phases of the economy and the government. Both President Theodore Roosevelt and President Woodrow Wilson wanted to give the working man a better chance to achieve success (ushistory.org, 2008). By the time of the

The Progressive movement of the 1900’s

874 words - 4 pages The Progressive movement of the 1900’s was the most important event to occur in the United States during the twentieth century. Progressives at first concentrated on improving the lives of those living in slums and in getting rid of corruption in government. The goal was to make working conditions better for the workers. True reform needed to happen. The workers of America believed this to be the best nation with opportunities for all people

Main Goals of The Progressive Movement

2519 words - 10 pages In the late nineteenth century to early twentieth century the Progressive Era was moving to reshape America. Progressivism was a political movement that encouraged the exposure of corruption in America in order to reshape it for the better. This time period became known for the social and political changes that took place as a result of the progressives. Progressivism ruled the country, changing the way Americans lived and the way politics

Similar Essays

The Progressive Movement Was A Liberal Triumph

927 words - 4 pages Progressive Movement:"The Progressive movement of 1900 to 1917 was a triumph of conservatism rather than a victory for liberalism." I disagree with this statement. The basic philosophy of "conservatism" is that change is bad. The basic "historian" definition of progressivism is: a movement for social change and improvement. For this reason, it is accurate to say that this era was a triumph of liberalism. The Progressive movement was a time of

Progressive Movement Essay

571 words - 2 pages The Progress of the ProgressivesThe beginning of the twentieth century would not be a continuation of the 19th century; new issues were to dominate the 1900's. America was experiencing a call for social, economic and political reform. The instrument of this reform would be both local and federal government. And the people who would write the symphonies of change were part of the Progressive Movement. The Conductor would Theodore Roosevelt

The Progressive Movement Essay

2412 words - 10 pages The Progressive Movement The progressive movement of the early 20th century has proved to be an intricately confounded conundrum for American historians. Who participated in this movement? What did it accomplish, or fail to accomplish? Was it a movement at all? These are all significant questions that historians have been grappling with for the last 60 years, thus creating a historical dialogue where in their different interpretations

The Progressive Movement Essay

889 words - 4 pages then to elucidate historical distortions, most notably between the New Deal and Progressivism. The progressive movement brought to the place of entirely during the moment of sustained and prosperity. The reading brought views and thoughts of why did the concerns of the leaders for progression. The leaders contributed the movements for a political and intellectual stand for finance to formulate ideas. I agree with Richard Hofstadter that with a