This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Rational Look At The Abortion Controversy

3845 words - 15 pages

A Rational Look at the Abortion Controversy

One of the most hotly contested issues inside and outside of biomedical ethics today is abortion. The discussion received a new impetus at the release of the controversial abortion drug RU-486, "a pill to increase access to abortions and let women get them privately from their own doctor instead of facing shouting protesters at clinics."2 As is the case with all controversial issues, there are very passionate people on both sides of the fence. Unfortunately, a heated discussion on abortion can easily and quickly turn into a battle of rhetoric rather than a dialectic of reason. But the guiding light in such a discussion must always be reason, not rhetoric or other fallacies, for only reason can solve this issue and judge which side is correct.

In this brief essay, I shall attempt to clear away some of the confusion present in typical abortion debates by cooling the rhetoric with reason enlightened by scientific facts. Specifically, I will examine two common pro-abortion arguments made by Mary Anne Warren and Judith Jarvis Thomson and demonstrate that they cannot stand up to rational scrutiny and therefore fail to justify abortion. I shall also use a
"quadrilemma" argument similar to that of Peter Kreeft's to show that, aside from all specific argumentation, abortion cannot be morally justified.

Before even beginning to discuss the issue of abortion, it is imperative to agree upon a starting point from which to reason. The fact that some people differ even about this very point tends to render the pro-abortion and the anti-abortion paradigms somewhat "incommensurable," and this is probably one major reason why people are tempted to arrive at different conclusions about this topic. It seems to me, however, that to start with the definition of abortion and an examination of the beings involved would be a fair move.

Abortion is the unnatural termination of a pregnancy by killing (at least) one human fetus. This definition is not contested, and I think it seems clear that it is correct. Science confirms that life begins at conception,3 and that this life is human is a-scientific as well as logical-necessity, because it is the product of two humans, and humans can only produce humans. Ergo, the fetus involved is human. Secondly, the fetus is, at least scientifically speaking, a singular and individual organism, as evidenced by his own unique genetic make-up, which he shares with no other human being on earth (unless he have an identical twin). There is thus an essential difference between a human fetus and, say, a tumor or similar parasite. Finally, that the fetus is alive is confirmed through empirical observation, and hence forcing that life to come to an end involves at least some sort of killing. Therefore, the unavoidable conclusion is that abortion deliberately and forcibly puts to death a human being. Again, this definition is uncontested and thus I shall not dwell on it any further....

Find Another Essay On A Rational Look at the Abortion Controversy

A Look At the Past Essay

1437 words - 6 pages Wow, how the times have changed. Just imagine this scenario. A group of friends go out to eat at a restaurant. They walk in the establishment and a man stops them. “You all are black. You can’t be in here!”, the man says. The group of friends must leave because of the color of their skin. No one really thinks about events like this anymore because everyone today is allowed to socialize together. Authors Kate Chopin and Alice Walker were probably

The Rational Woman's Right to Abortion

2108 words - 8 pages themselves and pursue serious aspirations. Unplanned pregnancies due to small lapses in judgment do not fit into the equation for certain women, whether or not they are in a stable relationship. A cost-benefit analysis of abortion versus raising a child will provide a utilitarian ethical argument for the right to abortion. On the other hand, Kantian philosophy will determine that today’s woman is genuinely autonomous and rational and therefore has a

A Look at the Strenghts Perspective

1439 words - 6 pages not understand."Most Individual problems are social problems caused by social and/or economic injustice"The first thing a social worker needs to do when dealing with a client is to identify their needs. The social worker should look at the environment the client has been exposed to as a key to understanding him or her. The focus when working with the client should be on his or her individual strengths rather than pathology. The social worker should

A Look at the Nursing Profession

2931 words - 12 pages , doing the job a lot of people don’t wish to do. It’s about self-fulfillment” (Jones). Carmen Jones really helped me understand the profession of nursing. Barbara Sopoaga is the Director of Payroll at the Community Hospital of Monterey Peninsula. She handles paychecks and schedules, and also has the power to qualify someone for a job at the hospital. When asking Mrs. Sopoaga what she looks for in a potential employee, she stated, “I first look

A Critical look at the Foster

4801 words - 19 pages A Critical Look At The Foster Care System THE GROUP HOMES OVERVIEW Children entering the shadowy world of foster care are often assigned labels arbitrarily and on a bed-available basis. They may end up spending some time in conventional foster homes, only to find themselves shuffled through group homes, residential treatment facilities, mental hospitals and prisons. Scant attention is given to the needs of these children, and the conditions they

A Look at Terrorism: The New War

1549 words - 6 pages Terrorism is the issue on everyone's mind these days. It is a global disorder that we have been fighting, and probably will be fighting for many years to come. What is terrorism? There is no exact definition for the word. The word means different things to different people at different times in history. Violent activity at one point in time may be called terrorism, while the same action may be deemed war, liberation, or crime at another time in

A look at the NHL lockout

2563 words - 10 pages advertising, 13 percent relates to merchandise, 13 percent pertains to spectator spending, 12 percent is attributable to operating expenses, and 10 percent is tacked on to gambling, with the remainder spread out across many small areas and trickle down industries. With such a large aggregate product for the industry, the fifth largest player on a continent should consider themselves in good shape. At the time of the NHL lockout, the league was in

A Look Back at the Crusades

935 words - 4 pages HolyLand (Oakes 53). I had met several knights that had made the trip to Jerusalem. I hopedthat one day I may be able to visit the city. Most of the knights that had visit Jerusalemhad a great hatred for the Moslems (Johnson). It was as if seeing Jerusalem underMoslem control enhanced the anger that was already stirring in the knights (Johnson).Knights that were once clam and level-headed would strike out at the Moslems and killthe harmless Moslem

Taking a Look at the Influential Fifties

1529 words - 7 pages The Influential Fifties Jeremy Cai Honors US History 11 Ms. Byars 2 April 2014 Jeremy Cai Honors US History 11 Byars (2) 2 April 2014 The Influential Fifties The half century from 1900 to 1959 was very eventful for the history of the United States of America. It began with the introduction of contemporary life itself, followed closely by the beginning of the First World War. World War I ended in 1918, and with its end came a great

A Look at the Rwandan Genocide

1442 words - 6 pages up at helped the victims of this horrible crime. Rwanda used to be a peaceful country until the Civil war started. Belgium then took over Rwanda and put the Tutsis in charge of the government because they had more European characteristics like the Belgium population (Anderson 1). This upset the Hutus, so the Hutus then blamed the Tutsis for the president’s assassination. The Rwandan genocide then started on April 6, 1994. It lasted for 100

Abortion a Controversy of All Time

861 words - 4 pages Abortion has been one of the biggest controversies of all time. Many people believe it is immoral and even consider it to be murder. The definition of abortion is; “The termination of pregnancy by the removal or expulsion from the uterus of a fetus or embryo prior to being capable of normal growth.” 1 These pro-life believers do not support the idea of induced abortion and believe it should be illegal. Many of these supporters do not know that

Similar Essays

Rational Versus Non Rational: A Look At Kepler

2221 words - 9 pages . Others, however, look at Kepler?s extensive and successful use of mathematics as proof that he was indeed a rational man. After taking both side of the argument into consideration, I come to the belief that this was a complex man who, though was rational in most respects, also had a healthy dose of non-rationality mixed in his persona that influenced how he looked at the universe.Mathematics is a field that is rational by its very nature, and for

The Abortion Controversy Essay

1426 words - 6 pages abortions, women aren’t allowed to practice their freedom of privacy. In a way, women are being denied their constitutional rights. Many pro-choice activists also state that abortion is justifiable, because at the time of fertilization the ensuing embryo is not yet a human being. It is not a human being, but a potential one. Therefore, its death does not constitute a murder. Pro-choice activists’ beliefs, that the economics of a family necessitates

The Abortion Controversy Essay

1881 words - 8 pages -life and 42% were pro-choice. Even within these groups, it can be broken down further still. A proponent may be someone who believes that abortion should be used as a last resort or that there should be unrestricted access to women. An opponent may state that, under no circumstance should abortion be allowed, or that it will be accepted for cases of rape, incest, and when the woman’s life is at risk. The most common procedure is a surgical abortion

A Look At The Ileostomy Essay

613 words - 2 pages the stool via catheter throughout the day. With this ileostomy a stoma cover is needed to collect any mucous discharge at the stoma site. The third type is a Ileoanal Reservoir. The surgeon creates a pocket within the pelvic cavity by making a pouch from the ileum and rectum and connecting it to the anus. This functions when there is an urge to defecate the stool is passed through the anus and out of the body. Stool excretion With a standard