A Study About Information Technology Systems

1792 words - 7 pages

Introduction and Purpose of the Study
Information technology (IT) systems play a key role in the success of most of today’s organizations (Jabbari Sabegh & Motlagh, 2012, p. 16). According to Tan, Cater-Steel, and Toleman (2009, p. 1) IT functions are being driven to become more service-oriented and there is increasing pressure for an organization’s IT to become more cost effective. Further, they state in in their exploratory case study, that many organizations are using the IT Infrastructure Library (ITIL) framework to accomplish both of those requirements.
The purpose of Tan’s et al. (2009, p. 3) study was to answer the research question “What factors influence the success of implementing IT service management.” Specifically, the authors sought to highlight the challenges and breakthroughs experienced by Queensland Health, a large Australian government operated medical organization, as it implemented the ITIL service framework. Further, the study was conducted to confirm and expand upon earlier research that had identified how five IT project Critical Success Factors (CSF), “key areas where things must go right in order to successfully achieve objectives and goals” (Bullen & Rockart, 1981, p. 7) led to Queensland’s successful ITIL implementation.
This assessment will present two weak areas in Tan’s et al (2009) study. Those areas, which may have had the potential to affect the case’s validity and reliability, associated with the authors’ research design and data collection methods.
The reader will find this paper laid out as follows: first, there is a methods section to identify the potential weaknesses identified in Tan’s et al. (2009) article, followed by a discussion section containing implications of weaknesses to the study results. The paper will conclude with a closing section to provide an overall assessment of the analysis.
Two areas call into question the validity and reliability of the Tan’s et al. (2009) results. First, there are concerns with the consistency of the research design relating to the research question, that which is being measured, and the study’s conclusion. Second, there are potential issues associated with the validity of the data collected including the sample size for the in-depth interviews and the bias of those responsible for the project.
Research Design
There is an inconsistency between the research question and the research design. Tan et al. sought to answer the question, “What factors influence the success of implementing IT service management?” (2009, p. 3). The authors recognized four types of factor criticalities: First, there are factors that have causal links to success; second, factors that are necessary and sufficient for success; third, those that are necessary for success; and lastly factors only associated with success (p. 2). Of those four, the authors claimed to consider the factors only associated with success. Their methodology used attributes mapped to each of the...

Find Another Essay On A Study about Information Technology Systems

A Present Career in Information Technology

2563 words - 10 pages of study for jobs in the field include the design, development, installation, and implementation of information systems. Technical components include acquiring technical skills for integrating systems and the information technology standards for rules that are used to implement the logical architecture of computers and networks. Staff members in the information technology industry are accountable for keeping the computer systems and networks

Reward Systems - A TopTek Case Study

1337 words - 5 pages The Harding (2004) case study brings to light a range of different problems faced by the TopTek organisation, most of which stem from unsuccessful or nonexistent reward systems. TopTek faces human resource management (HRM) issues common to many organisations in the areas of recruitment, retention and organisational culture. As these issues can all be linked to the organisation's reward system, an analysis and reform of this system may provide

A case study about Microsoft

3349 words - 13 pages 1. INTRODUCTIONToday, business and management continue to be transformed by high technology. An interesting description of the modern era is the Information Age The Information Age implies a time for a revolution in the information environment for business and management. The changes that are taking place may be more significant to management than the Industrial Revolution.If organizations are to remain competitive, they must learn to adapt the

The Development of a Code of Ethics in Information Technology

1861 words - 7 pages decisions are embedded into the operation of Information Technology systems and consequently, they often become an afterthought. For example, a good case of subsumption is duplicating copyrighted compact disk and then reselling duplicate copies. This has been a highly debated topic. Does the ethical infraction lie with the person duplicating the copyrighted material, the software company that writes the code to clone the material, the hardware

A Fictional Case Study in Systems and Operations Management

3106 words - 12 pages Customer service Custom print Range of products Warehousing Technology and IT Purchasing and supplies The 4v's topologyLow volume highHigh variety lowHigh variation on demand lowHigh visibility lowExplanations of the topologies and structureFor good management of systems and operations, there is the creation of a goal where in the case study; the goal is to sell different types of office supplies and also stationery to organisations

A Forensics Memory Study of Malware in Android Operating Systems

2744 words - 11 pages I. INTRODUCTION A ndroid operated devices are one of the most competitive technology devices in the market, with the fastest growing market share within the mobile industry [1]. Technology experts predict that it will dominate the mobile market in the coming decade. Additionally, recent research shows a huge year over year increase in the number of Android specific malware attacks [1,3]. It is relatively straightforward to investigate such

Economic Research about Ministry of Communication and information technology In Egypt

2084 words - 8 pages participation in its development.Effective 3 Jun 1999, MINCOM was expanded and renamed Ministry of Communications & Information Technology (MCIT). With the expansion, MCIT has taken over National Computer Board (NCB) from the Trade and Industry Ministry.Egypt has seen huge growth in the ICT (information and communication technology) sector in the last years; this was the beginning of a larger change in the country. The last seven years have

Examine the strategic value of information systems in a Collection organisation.

646 words - 3 pages write-offs.5. A pool of supporting staff to deal with daily administrative services.Structural Alignment between Information Systems and the Collection UnitAn online accounts receivable system called ARS (Accounts Receivable System) is modified. The ARS system improves unit's ability to manage and recover its receivables by providing a consolidated tool that will serve the needs of its clients. ARS is housed in the Ontario Information Technology

Using Information systems development methodologies and knowledge management ideas to create a University e-learning infrastructure

5384 words - 22 pages information to support decision making and control in an organisation. In addition to supporting decision making, coordination, and control, information systems may also help users analyse problems, visualise complex subjects, and create new products (Laudon & Laudon 2000). There are a number of different types of Information Systems.2.1.2 Types of Information SystemsFig 1 below shows the types of Information Systems that are in existence.Fig 1

Should a company select proprietary, open source, or free software for it’s most important information systems?

1434 words - 6 pages software so you can change it to meet all of your most valuable needs. It is constantly evolving keeping the companies technology up to date. Open source software does not require a new upgrade for features. Simply expansion on what you already have. While companies may use any combination of proprietary, open source, and free software, the most important business information systems should be a form of open source software. Open source

A case study of background of technology project

1349 words - 5 pages Background of Technology ProjectThe Project to be studied is an implementation of a work assignment and tracking system in an IT department in a medium sized company. The IT Department before the project was started, had undergone a management change and a reorganization due to corporate cost cutting and restructuring. The previous structure of the IT organization was teams of people that support specific applications in the system, and the

Similar Essays

Information Technology Shop Systems. Essay

784 words - 3 pages Information technology - Shop systems. Specification Background to the topic: I visited my local video and music store and after an interview with the manager I suggested there might be a better and more efficient way to manage their records. The better way would be to be to use a computerized system through the use of excel. My main task would be to create a new system which would be much better than their current system at

Comair Information Systems And Technology Essay

1075 words - 4 pages was a problem with the airline’s system which resulted in all flights being cancelled. All the passengers who were flying out for the vacations were stuck at the airport.INFORMATION SYSTEMSManagement Information Systems (MIS) are a set in computers which have been integrated to help the organization operate efficiently and effectively. With the help of these systems the employees can perform their daily tasks quickly. They can process any

About Information Technology Infrastructure Library Essay

2811 words - 11 pages standards for Information Technology (IT) service management. The United Kingdom's Central Computer and Telecommunications Agency (CCTA) created ITIL in response to the growing dependence on Information Technology to meet business needs and goals. ITIL provides businesses with a customizable framework of best practices to achieve quality service and overcome difficulties associated with the growth of IT systems.3.1 ITIL Framework (Wikipedia.org

Study Notes From Information Technology In The It Environments Section

3369 words - 13 pages must provide a service to a client or customer. It will list the tasks you complete as a part of your job and how you are to complete those tasks when you provide a service.Most IT departments have a service level agreement for all information technology positions.ContractsA contract is a legal document that outlines you job responsibilities. Most contracts go into a lot of detail about their requirements of the job, your probation (or trial