A Review Of American Negro Slavery By Ulrich B. Phillips

1299 words - 5 pages

A Review of American Negro Slavery by Ulrich B. Phillips

Phillips' book is an attempt to provide an overview of the practice and institutions of slavery in the Americas from its beginnings to the 19th century. Writing in 1918, Phillips hoped to provide an account of slavery based upon historical evidence and modern methods of research, rather than ideological motivations. He drew his evidence from the plantation records and letters of slave owners; contemporary travel accounts; court records and legal documents; newspaper articles; and in some instances, the recordings of slaves themselves, rather than what he viewed as more biased sources such as abolitionist writings. While this approach was not systematic and led him to base many of his conclusions upon subjective evidence and an over reliance upon particular chroniclers of the South, the bulk of his findings are supported by subsequent scholarship.
The book opens up with Genovese's Forward, stating that since WWII many historian have been reading Phillips with "hostility, suspicion, and even contempt" and even worse because they "have not been encouraging their students to read him at all." Phillips begins the book by discussing the beginnings of the use of slaves in the West Indies sugar plantations, and slowly makes his way towards America. The author explains each type of plantation and its cash crop and discusses the areas where slavery was well received or rejected.
In the descriptive portions of his book, Phillips was generally on target but lacked depth. Historians would later take exception to his findings, as they are based more upon his personal beliefs concerning race, rather than documented evidence. The author is mainly concerned with the economic and political aspects of slavery and as such the bulk of the book is therefore devoted to an examination of how westward expansion coincided with economic development that resulted in the creation of legal institutions protecting slavery in those regions where a shortage of labor and an excess of arable land combined to make it a feasible method of production. Phillips found that most slaves were well provided for materially and treated with less than brutality by their masters, who for both economic and moral reasons had an interest in the happiness and well-being of their property. He does not deny that slaves were whipped, performed dangerous or tedious tasks, or were separated from their families, but points out that such occurrences were the exception rather than the rule. He does not find that slaves were particularly susceptible to laziness or criminality, or that the threat of slave uprisings was as great as contemporary whites assumed, but rather finds that the racial characteristics of slaves included loyalty, geniality, and a predisposition to manual rather than intellectual labor.
The author also explores the profitability of slavery as an institution, as while the tendency of slave owners to keep their...

Find Another Essay On A Review of American Negro Slavery by Ulrich B. Phillips

Analysis of White Over Black: American Attitudes Toward the Negro by Winthrop D. Jordan

1181 words - 5 pages Analysis of White Over Black: American Attitudes Toward the Negro by Winthrop D. Jordan Winthrop D. Jordan author of White Over Black: American Attitudes Toward the Negro 1550-1812, expresses two main arguments in explaining why Slavery became an institution. He also focuses attention on the initial discovery of Africans by English. How theories on why Africans had darker complexions and on the peculiarly savage behavior they exhibited

Attend a concert and write a review. "Duo" in B-flat major by Mozart and "Terzetto" in C by Dvorak.

851 words - 3 pages the fleeting, blithe, and spirited nature of his works. This is what I expect to hear too, in Mozart's Duo in B-flat major, and it shows in the concert that it is a typical Mozartiana work. Famous for symphonies, miniature compositions for solo instruments or group instruments (not duo) and operas, instrumental duets are very rare in Mozart's compositions. The duo for violin and viola in B flat was composed in 1783, during which Mozart had already

Review of Chapter 4 of "American Holocaust" by David Stannard

1130 words - 5 pages "American Holocaust" by David E Stannard was first published and distributed in 1992, the same year that celebrated the quincentenary of the discovery of America by Christopher Columbus. The release date would not have been decided upon by happenchance, but would have been part of a well thought out marketing strategy to take best advantage of the five hundredth anniversary of American 'civilisation'. The book is highly controversial in its

Review of John Blassingame's "The Slave Community". Rather specialized, I'm afraid. Review of a book on slavery in the South.

610 words - 2 pages : Plantation Life in the Antebellum South (1972). Blassingame was also the editor of the Papers of Frederick Douglass in the mid-1970's. He has a Bachelor's Degree from Fort Valley State College, a Master's Degree from Howard University, and a Ph.D. from Yale. He passed away in February 2000, and is survived by his father, Grady Blassingame, his wife Teasie, and his two children, Tia and John.In The Slave Community, Blassingame argues that despite their

Letter to negro parents chosing to go to trade school for the time of slavery instead of college.

1747 words - 7 pages becoming the first African American to major out of Harvard he became well known and respected. People of our race began to listen to what he had to say. Both men have achieved great goals in their lives and still prosper today. But in reality, I myself cannot achieve my goal of becoming more respected in the community by following both men's lifestyles, which is why I must chose the path I want to follow in my life.After weighing both my options, I

Was Colonial Culture Uniquely American? Refers to a section in the book "Taking sides" by Gary B. Nash

857 words - 3 pages the effect the Native Americans had on the building of a new American culture. He says that the ones who were not killed by either disease, murder, or sold into slavery, were enveloped into the European society. As a result, we can assume that some Native Americans had to have taken part in the mixing of the Native American and European races. I believe this to be the first time that two major cultures had ever actually combined, either by

Review of American Beauty

536 words - 2 pages Review of American Beauty The 1999 Academy Award winning movie American Beauty has many major plots and shows the reality of American life. This movie uses symbolism to get ideas across in many different situations and it shows the actuality of life, it is not always what it looks like on the outside. Lester and Carolyn Burnham seem like they have a perfect marriage and a perfect family life while in turn they are having a lot of

Comparison of Roman and American slavery

768 words - 3 pages , on the other hand, the slaves mostly just cooked the meals and worked in the fields. However, the similarity between the two society's includes the abuse felt by the slaves. In the movie, Sparticus was constantly hit with the wooden paddle and made to fight as a gladiator, just as the American slaves were whipped and hung by their white masters. The movie, "Sparticus", is an excellent example of the treatment and views of slavery in Roman

Phenomenon of Slavery In American And Abolitionist

1747 words - 7 pages After years of campaign by some sections of British society, the Anti-Slavery Abolition Act was finally passed by the Prime-Minister Earl Grey's Whig government in 1833. This was a great result for the many slave trade demonstrators, such as William Wilberforce and Thomas Clarkson, who had been part of the Anti-Slavery Society from 1923 and who had been fighting for this result throughout the previous decades. However, slavery had been a fashion

The American history of slavery has been conveniently shrouded by a comfortable state of "national amnesia". By what means and how far successful is Morrison in addressing this issue in Beloved.

641 words - 3 pages Toni Morrison contends that American history of slavery has been conveniently shrouded by a comfortable state of "national amnesia" However, this has brought about destructive effects which are highlighted through the symbolism and character developments. By not "passing the story on", there is no healing process and the community is missing out vital gaps which are required for lessons to be learnt and an identity to be built.Toni Morrison uses

A Changing View of Slavery

1318 words - 5 pages The institution of slavery in the seventeenth-century had evolved into a whole new attitude by the nineteenth-century. A time where one's economic standing marked their place in society had long since been forgotten as the nineteenth-century began to give a new meaning to slave ideology. Racism became more of a determining factor in a slaves life as the nineteenth-century progressed and slaves were treated more unfairly in all aspects of life

Similar Essays

Frederick Douglas And John Brown History Of The American Negro Slavery

718 words - 3 pages Frederick Douglas and John Brown discuss methods of abolishing American Negro slavery. Brown was an antislavery leader while Douglas was an ex-slave and he internationally recognized antislavery teaching himself to read and write. Even though they differed on tactics to be used, they were together in leading American Negro slaves to freedom. Although Douglas became very impressed with John Brown with his radical Abolitionist, to end

American Slavery Book Review

968 words - 4 pages "American Slavery" Book Review This book achieved its goal by reflecting the past and history of American Slavery. We can see through much detail what America was and has become throughout the era of slavery. It was the Colonial era that America began to see what true slavery would soon become. The author, Peter Kolchin, tried to interpret the true history of slavery. He wants the readers to understand the depth to

Peter Kolchin : American Slavery Review

1741 words - 7 pages , Ulrich B. Phillips states "the planters had a saying... that a negro was what a white man made him."(134) The slaves rebelled against what the white man perceived them to be. Kolchin then points out there eagerness for society, music, and the need to be seen and heard. He then provides research by acclaimed scholar Herman G. Gutman which provides a vast amount of knowledge on slave families.After a chapter which tells the economical and

"In The Name Of War" Written By Jill Lepore: King Phillips War And The Origins Of American Identity.

1079 words - 4 pages and outrages on both sides were too horrific to deserve the name of a fully declared war, but more on the lines of mutual racial terrorism. How did such a division occur? The conflict between the two groups began when Metacom, significantly called 'Phillip' by the Anglo people of the land, who was the leader of the Wampanoag Indians, led attacks against English towns in the colony of Plymouth. Yet the reasons for this attack to this day remain