A Review Of The Court Of Appeal Decision In St Albans City And District Council V International Computers Limited

1990 words - 8 pages

A Review of the Court of Appeal Decision in St AlbansCity and District Council v International Computers LimitedAbstractLast year, the Court of Appeal [1996 All ER 481] upheld an earlier decision St Albans City and District Council v International Computers Ltd. [Queen's Bench Division 1995] in which substantial damages were awarded in respect of a supply of software which proved unsuitable for the customer's intended use. This article provides a detailed examination of the implications of this decision; in particular, the interpretation of exclusion clauses and the vexed question of the legal status of software.Keywords: Liability for Defective Software, Exclusion Clauses, Unfair Contract Terms Act1. IntroductionIt would be all too easy to discuss St Albans City and District Council v International Computers Limited(1995, 1996) in the context of well-worn clichés - shock waves running through the industry, computer suppliers running to their lawyers for advice - but that would be to negate the undoubted importance of this case not just for software suppliers but as further evidence of the swing in legal policy from caveat emptor to caveat vendor.The doctrine of caveat emptor - let the buyer beware - arose in English law from judicial reluctance to intervene in contractual disputes: in particular their unwillingness to imply terms into contracts where there were no express terms. The effect of this doctrine was that the buyer was naturally disadvantaged by a lack of knowledge or expertise about what he was buying. Over time judicial policy changed and judges became more willing to imply terms into certain contracts. Sale of goods is the classic example where judicial policy on implying terms into such contracts became so well established that the law was codified in the Sale of Goods Act 1893 ('the 1893 Act').1893 Act may be viewed as the first consumer protection legislation, however, the last thirty years have seen a dramatic explosion in consumer protection. From the Misrepresentation Act 1967 to the amendments to the Sale of Goods Act in 1994 and the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contract Regulations 1994, the doctrine of caveat emptor has gradually been weakened and, as far as consumers are concerned, replaced with caveat venditor. As Atiyah has noted "it is now unrealistic to treat the basic principle of law as caveat emptor rather than caveat venditor." (Atiyah PS et al;1995, p111)Moreover, the European Union has consistently taken a pro-consumer stance and more legislation in this vein is planned. The Times has reported that a Directive on the Sale of Consumer Goods and Associated Guarantees, which would require a standard two year guarantee for all consumer products, is being considered. (Wednesday 5 February 1997)Although the position as regards sale of goods is relatively settled, the position as regards other types of contract is not so clear. Judges are still reluctant to interfere unless they are satisfied that to imply the term...

Find Another Essay On A Review of the Court of Appeal Decision in St Albans City and District Council v International Computers Limited

Identify the contractual principles which emerged from the decision of the court in Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company (1893) and explain why lawy

2980 words - 12 pages Case in hand: Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company [1893] 1 QB 256; Court of Appeal, 1892 Dec. 6,7, LINDLEY, BOWEN and A. L. SMITH, L.JJ. The ‘Carbolic Smoke Ball’ company was selling self-proclaimed health enhancing and disease curing ‘Smoke Balls’ during and throughout the 1890’s. Whilst advertising the product, they professed that absolutely nobody who used their product in their recommended usage pattern would contract a list of diseases

Murphy V. Brentwood District Council 1991 Ac 398

1380 words - 6 pages some time the plaintiff noticed cracks, and the defect which caused the settlement was discovered. He could not afford the money needed to repair the same, so he sold the house suffering a loss of 35,000 ponds than the proper market price to a builder. The court of appeal held that the local authority, treated as responsible for the negligence of the engineers to whom they entrusted the vetting of plans, must pay the diminution in the value

How issues such as immigration, abortion, specifically the Supreme Court decision of Roe v. Wade, and flag burning have divided American society and how decisions or comprimises have been reached

682 words - 3 pages In recent years, there have been many issues that have divided American society. Opposing sides have presented strong arguments to support what they believe in, and attempts have been made to come to a solution or compromise for the decision. Such issues include immigration, abortion, specifically the Supreme Court decision of Roe v. Wade, and flag burning.From 1967-1990, American immigration underwent dramatic changes. The Immigration Act of

Community Analysis: North County Branch - St. Charles City-County Library District

2663 words - 11 pages of town in a former one-room schoolhouse (St. Charles City-County Library District, 2010). (figure 1) Portage des Sioux was once a typical, small, Midwestern town, encompassing several more blocks than today remain (Mincke, 2004, pp. 106-107). At present, the town boasts two marinas, a handful of restaurants, an auto repair shop, a general store, one church and a bar. Most residents of the town leave the area to seek work in either St. Louis

In the Court of Appeal of the State of Oregon

1285 words - 5 pages A person has a constitutional right to be free from unreasonable search and seizure. This argument was used in the Oregon court of appeals when George Daniel Snow filed an appeal using the malicious prosecution tort, similar to abuse of process, as his defense. Summited to the Jackson County Court of Appeals of Oregon on May 25, 2011 and filed December 29, 2011, Mr. Snow argued that his arrest for possession of methamphetamine, ORS 475.894

Report of Downing Court (local, civil and district courts) and the Roles and Responsibilities in the Court System

2098 words - 8 pages 1. On arrival at the downing courts on Liverpool St, the court officer Richard took the commerce II students on a tour. The students were provided with a brief history on the building before they were taken to courtroom 2 on level one. Here Richard explained the role and jurisdiction of both the local and district courts as well as the layout of the court room. He also explained that the Australian court system is arranged in a hierarchy.The

Commissioners, City Council Members and The Value of Forensic Evidence

841 words - 4 pages welfare programs, and consumer protection. Other duties that the commissioner may also oversee are; assemble property and sales taxes, guarantee water quality, gather and regulate trash, issuance of bonds, oversee courts and jails, handling the pensions for county employees, and operating county parks (Kelly, John, 2013). City council is a customary model of the local government in the United States. A city council is voted in as a legislative

A) Explain how lay magistrates and district judges (magistrate's court) are selected and appointed. b) Identify and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the use of lay magistrates

2315 words - 9 pages 1a) Explain how lay magistrates and district judges (magistrate's court) are selected and appointed.Lay Magistrates can also be referred to as 'justices of the peace'. The Lord Chancellor appoints JP's. This is formally done under a document called 'commission of the peace'. This is carried out in two ways. Either in respect of counties, where it is under the recommendation of the lord lieutenant of the county and assisted by the advisory

District of Columbia v. Heller: The Use and Permit of Handguns

1955 words - 8 pages in place is violated the individual rights that granted and protected by the United States Constitution. They believe that the rigorous system will prevent people from defending themselves and could be a violation of their privacy. Regardless of which side is right, if we want to understand more about our current conflict, we have to look back on how this hold debate started. The District of Columbia v. Heller, the Supreme Court case in 2008

The Freedom of Speech in the Tinker V. Des Moines Independent Community School District

916 words - 4 pages ://americanhistory.about.com/od/supremecourtcases/p/tinker-v-des-moines.htm>. Tedford, Thomas L., and Dale A. Herbeck. Freedom of Speech in the United States. State College, PA: Strata Publishing, Inc., 2009. Tinker V. Des Moines Independent Community School District. Web. 28 Oct. 2013. . "Tinker V. Des Moines Independent Community School District." Supreme Court Cases: The Dynamic Court (1930-1999) (1999

How does fashion matter to the Garment District and the economic development of New York City?

2841 words - 12 pages produced and marketed at an affordable cost. The Garment District also helps support young designers in a way that no other major fashion hub can. There is nowhere else in the world that is easier to start a fashion line than here in New York City. The City’s Economic Development Corporation has launched several programs to help emerging students and designers acquire financing. They also strive to “improve the business skills of designers, market New

Similar Essays

Un Security Council And The International Court Of Justice

1396 words - 6 pages among the Countries. It is no doubt true to say that one of the issues that has most troubled the world this century is the task of finding appropriate international institutions that can guarantee peace and security among nations . Since their establishment, a passive conflict has always been a part of tussle between the Security Council and the International Court of Justice. As a result a number of times the International Court of Justice in

Hiibel V. Sixth Judicial District Court Of Nevada, Humboldt County

1188 words - 5 pages Hiibel V. Sixth Judicial District Court Of Nevada, Humboldt County Citation: 542 U.S. 177 (2004) Case Facts: The sheriff’s department in Humboldt County, Nevada, responded to a 911 call that reported an assault. The 911 caller reported witnessing a man assaulting a woman while driving a GMC truck on a local road. The sheriff’s department responded by sending Deputy Sheriff Lee Dove to investigate. The deputy arrived to the reported area and

Equality In Education: A Review Of Grove City College V. Bell And Title Ix

1317 words - 6 pages discrimination as a prerequisite for federal funding did not infringe on Grove City College’s first amendment rights (“Grove”). The court also allowed Grove City to freely end its participation in the BEOG program to maintain its autonomy (“Grove”). The ruling of Grove City College v Bell caused turmoil in the education system for the next three years. It impeded the further growth of Title IX and made it difficult for people who suffered from

The Court Case Of Clinton V. The City Of New York

1072 words - 5 pages thousands of bills in which he would have to sign and pass or veto altogether. In the final decision made by the Supreme Court in the case of Clinton v. The City of New York was that is was unconstitutional. The majority received a six-to-three vote in the court. This then made it clear that it was unconstitutional of the President Clinton to exhibit the Line Item Veto in 1997-1998. Though something very interesting happened that I think is very