A Rhetorical Perspective On The Issue Of Wiki Leaks

1715 words - 7 pages

Menace or Assurance? :
A Rhetorical Perspective on the Issue of WikiLeaks
Founded in 2006 by Australian journalist Julian Assange, the website WikiLeaks had quickly risen in infamy over the past few years (Majerol 19). The controversial website had posted hundreds of thousands of classified documents about the Iraq and Afghanistan war, revealing government cover-ups, a secret assassination unit and the killing of civilians among many things. The release of these confidential documents has produced two opposing views on whether or not WikiLeaks is a good thing (Pilger 18).
In an article highlighting the benefits of WikiLeaks, Steven Greenhut explains that Julian Assange and his website have “done our nation a service”. Greenhut asserts that by distributing the details on how U.S. government runs its foreign affairs, WikiLeaks is embodying the true spirit of a transparent government, one that is of the people, by the people, and for the people. A truly open government, he says, is the “cornerstone of a free society”. The government, he says, will always pull out the “’endangering lives’ or ‘protecting security’” card in order to protect its own interests and conceal its past transgressions. He insists that there is no proof that any information released by the website will endanger anyone. The only people who will be negatively affected, Greenhut says, would be the government officials whose “hypocrisy and corruption” would be shamefully exposed (Greenhut 1.)
In the opposite side of the argument stands S.E. Cupp. In an article, she says that WikiLeaks and its proponents are jeopardizing innocent life by recklessly releasing unfiltered information for the entire world to access. She argues that by irresponsibly posting classified information, WikiLeaks is putting the safety of individuals and nations at risk. She calls the website “information terrorism”, which, according to her, is holding sensitive information for ransom. She also questions the legitimacy of the documents posted by WikiLeaks. Since the information was essentially stolen, she says, who can truly verify the truth behind the documents? Furthermore, Cupp strongly rejects the idea of WikiLeaks being a journalistic service because the best journalists, she says, always consider the consequences of the information they release, something WikiLeaks is “all too willing to compromise” (Cupp 1).
This paper will not align itself behind a certain view in an attempt to twist the reader’s arm into believing one side is better than the other. It will provide no opinion whatsoever as to which side you should belong to; it will leave the qualities and failings of the argument itself alone.
Rather, this paper will outline the rhetoric behind each op-ed. It will analyze each op-ed for strengths and weaknesses in its use of logic (logos), ethics (ethos) and appeal to the reader (pathos). It will evaluate how the evidence is presented, answering whether the evidence is enough, whether it is...

Find Another Essay On A Rhetorical Perspective on the Issue of WikiLeaks

The Audacity of Hope: A Rhetorical Analysis

2079 words - 8 pages understand "the power of the African-American religious tradition to spur social change." With this in mind, I believe chapters 6 and 7 are perfect examples of ethos in this novel, describing racial heritage, racial equality, and faith. In chapter 6, Obama attacks the issue of religious faith, mainly focusing on roots and influence of the Democrats growing uneasiness with the displays of religious faith. Because this is such a controversial topic, I

A Rhetorical Analysis of Richard Lindzen’s The World Should Not Waste Resources on Fighting Global Warming

1231 words - 5 pages In his piece on climate change, Richard Lindzen addresses his stance on the heated debate of global warming. He claims that there is, in fact, no ongoing catastrophic temperature increase. Lindzen, a Professor of Meteorology at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and a recipient of the Jule Charney award from the American Meteorological Society (Richard Lindzen), believes that the earth goes through natural phases of warming and cooling

A Rhetorical Analysis of "On Liberty" by John Stuart Mill

1642 words - 7 pages A Rhetorical Analysis of "On Liberty"John Stuart Mill, an English philosopher and a political economist, had an important part in forming liberal thought in the 19th century. Mill published his best-known work, On Liberty, in 1859. This foundational book discusses the concept of liberty. It talks about the nature and the limits of the power performed by society over an individual. The book also deals with the freedom of people to engage in

On the Issue of Hate Speech

1527 words - 7 pages endanger the right of free speech for those who use it responsibly. One of the many problems that restrictions on hate speech would create is the issue of how a line, which would separate appropriate and hate speech, should be drawn. Ultimately, the line would distinguish between acceptable and unacceptable use of First Amendment rights. In the article of Jonathan Rauch, the writer of Kindly Inquisitors: The New Attacks on Free Thought, questions are

Essay on the Issue of Aids

2066 words - 8 pages learn more they are then introduced to the dissidents' side of AIDS, that is that HIV does not cause AIDS. This controversy makes it hard for people to fully understand HIV and AIDS, and makes wearing a condom a thought many put on the back burner. This is a very dangerous thing as AIDS is spreading more throughout our earth people need to be informed that HIV does exist and is a deathly virus, HIV does cause AIDS, and that ATZ do not cause

Analysis of a Television Advertisement Aimed at Raising Awareness on the Issue of Road Safety

1305 words - 5 pages Analysis of a Television Advertisement Aimed at Raising Awareness on the Issue of Road Safety In order to analyse the advertisement, it is necessary to look at the different techniques used throughout. The advertisement has been created in order to promote road safety, and is from a series of advertisements called ‘THINK!’ The specific advert I am to analyse is called ‘Backwards’, and deals with the decision of whether or

A Feminist Perspective of On the Road and The First Third

644 words - 3 pages Much has been written about the Beat generation, especially about the hold its radical freedom has exerted on the American imagination. The Beats who stand out in most of our minds are men and the freedom they enjoyed--a freedom of movement, of creativity, of sexuality--is coded as a particularly male kind of freedom. My paper will suggest that in their autobiographical texts On the Road and The First Third Jack Kerouac and Neal Cassady

The issue of race as a concept

1242 words - 5 pages different groups based on the thinking of the times. Even during the times of Homer, the Iliad and Odyssey acknowledged variability. The texts referred to Aethiopians, the people at the eastern and western edges of the known world, and to cubit-men, presumably referring to African pygmies.A race is a division of mankind, the members of which, though individually varying, are characterized as a group by a certain combination of features which has been

The Cycle of Creativity: A Psychoanalytic Perspective on Samuel T. Coleridge’s Kubla Khan

2357 words - 9 pages place where refinement and logic of the surrounding environment does not hold sway, and thus is untamed and dangerous (Lawall 813-815). Outside of the chasm there is “a woman wailing for her demon lover”, and if one views this from a Jungian perspective it provides insight into the meaning of this otherwise perplexing symbol. Jung posited archetypes within every mind that act as somewhat independent semi-unconscious components of the unified

A "Brave New World"-perspective analysis on the subject of Hedonism.

959 words - 4 pages Imagine Brenda, a woman who will not under any circumstances trade her life in order to be conditioned, and then live as a Beta in the Brave New World (BNW), universe. If this is the case, then Brenda could not consistently accept Hedonism. This is due to the definition of Hedonism, the amount and intensity of bodily pleasure in Brave New World (BNW), and the amount and intensity of bodily pleasure here in real life.The definition of Hedonism

A broadening perspective of the hero's journey

807 words - 4 pages use of the hero's journey in their writing but from a different perspective. Christopher Marlowe's 16th century work, Doctor Faustus, follows another form of the hero's journey, the flip side of Beowulf, as one sells his soul to the devil and pursues more evil desires. While both protagonists are entirely different they both remarkably follow the same journey of showing a great division over time in what one might consider to be a hero. The

Similar Essays

The Issue Of Female Circumcision From A Medical Anthropology Perspective

1106 words - 5 pages practice is done in a variety of cultural and ethnic groups (Toubia 1994,712). In order for change to occur, the practice must be understood from the culture it happens in. Once the problem is understood from that perspective, then the most appropriate and effective solutions can be suggested. The age at which a circumcision is preformed on a female varies. Female Circumcisions are normally preformed on girls between the ages of 4 and 10 years of age

Narrative Perspective In A Dance Scene Of Pride And Prejudice. Comment On The Dance Scene Using A Rhetorical Analysis. What Does The Narrator With Her Moving Perspective Bring You To Understand About...

593 words - 2 pages In-class Essay March 3, 2010 Comment on the dance scene using a rhetorical analysis. What does the narrator with her moving perspective bring you to understand about society, Lizzy, about pride and prejudice? How? One of the most unique techniques used by Jane Austen, in Pride and Prejudice, is her moving narrative perspective. In several parts of the novel, the narrator changes its "position", so that the reader finds her closer to the

The Perspective Of A Heterosexual Teenager On Same Sex Marriage

1462 words - 6 pages legitimate one. Newborns have never crawled out of their mothers' wombs predetermined as homosexuals. Several scientists have researched on this issue, and they have not proved that humans can not be inherently homosexual, since the attraction for the same gender does not normally cross the mind of a human and there is an insufficient amount of genetic evidence to prove it. The cause of their sex preference must be some mental disorder because

A Philosophical Perspective On The Regulation Of Business

3022 words - 12 pages A Philosophical Perspective on the Regulation of Business ABSTRACT: The paper compares the Anglo-American and continental legal systems in parallel with a comparison of the philosophical foundations for each. The defining philosophical distinction between the two legal traditions (viz., the Anglo-American system is predicated on idealism and the continental system on materialism) is shown to influence the way in which criminal justice is