This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Case Of Religious Freedom : Multani V. Commission Scolaire. Examines The Two Principle Reasons For The Ruling In Favour Of Multani.

1595 words - 6 pages

SEQ CHAPTER \h \r 1 In November 2001, a boy who followed the Sikh faith dropped his ceremonial kirpan dagger in a Montreal school yard. The school board was contacted about the incident and proceeded to impose a board-wide ban on the kirpan. The school board ban was overturned by the Quebec Superior Court, but then upheld by the Quebec Court of Appeal. The case was appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) which held that the ban was in violation of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The SCC determined that in the case of Multani v. Commision Scolaire Marguerite -Bourgouys, the ban on the kirpan, as a symbol of religious expression, was not found to be reasonable or justifiable as required by Section 1 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, but primarily because the school board ban on kirpans violated the individuals right to freedom of Religion under Section 2 of the Charter.Firstly, the Supreme Court of Canada, in their ruling on the case of Multani v. Commision Scolaire Marguerite -Bourgouys, found that the school-board imposed ban on kirpans , was not reasonable or justifiable as required by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Marguerite -Bourgouys School Board failed to establish that kirpans were a dangerous weapon or that they posed a threat to other students and the S.C.C. also decided that the ban was not reasonable because it was possible to accommodate the kirpan easily without a ban. At trial, the School Board first attempted to prove that school safety concerns outweighed the violation of religious freedom [the kirpan ban].The school board argued that allowing the kirpan in school would "lead to a proliferation of weapons" in school, and have a "negative impact" on the school environement. The SCC did recognize that it was possible to use the kirpan as a weapon, however they concluded that in a classroom setting, other items, such as scissors and baseball bats, were more readily available for use as a weapon than a sheathed kirpan would be. According to Justice Louise Charron ,who supported the majority decision , there are "objects that are much more easily obtained than a kirpan"to commit violent acts in schools. This furthers the position that both the ban and the argument that the kirpan is a dangerous weapon, are unreasonable.Aditionally, the principles of the Sikh faith were taken into consideration by the S.C.C., as the Sikh faith does not allow the kirpan to be used as a weapon, as doing so will cause ostracism from the Sikh community. In the ruling on Peel Board of Education v. Singh , the Ontario Inquiry Board found that the kirpan was a "spiritual symbol of justice, morality and order" , which affirms that a kirpan is not a weapon. The religious purpose of the kirpan is non-violent which further illustrates that the ban is unreasonable . Furthermore, there are no reports of a violent kirpan incident ever occurring in a Canadian school despite the fact the kirpans have been worn in...

Find Another Essay On A Case of Religious Freedom : Multani v. Commission Scolaire. Examines the two principle reasons for the ruling in favour of Multani.

Two Forms of the Generalized Uncertainty Principle

1937 words - 8 pages Various theories of quantum gravity predict the existence of a minimum length scale, which leads to the modification of the standard uncertainty principle to the Generalized Uncertainty Principle (GUP). In this paper, we study two forms of the GUP and calculate their implications on the energy of the harmonic oscillator and the Hydrogen atom more accurately than previous studies. In addition, we show how the GUP modifies the Lorentz force law

Religious Freedom in a World of Religious Restrictions

3617 words - 14 pages party partisans can help a religious group increase its religious freedoms. The international pressure on China to exhibit more religious freedom is an example of third party partisans helping the religious groups in China increase their religious freedoms. Third party partisans can also limit religious freedom. In the case of the proposed ban on religious symbols in Quebec the majority of the population were for the ban, working as a third

Iphigenia, examines the relationship of religion in the classic tradgedy Iphigenia, and also includes modern day examples of religious corruption

708 words - 3 pages cases of religious corruption. For more examples of religious corruption, look to more modern times. The roman catholic religion has always played an important role in controlling the European countries. This role has just recently changed. Not everyone follows exactly what the church wants. Still, Iphigenia clearly shows that this is not a new thing.The gods in Iphigenia clearly play many important roles. They allow Agamemnon to control the army

Control Of The Ruling Class

1142 words - 5 pages As Gore Vidal once said: “The genius of our ruling class is that it has kept a majority of the people from questioning the inequity of a system where most people drudge along, paying heavy taxes for which they get nothing in return” (Vidal, N/A). In our society, the ruling ideas are easily believed and taken as “true.” Advertisements sell ideas and lifestyles rather than objects; people consent to the ruling ideas which in turn make them less of

The Ruling Leaders of Syria

871 words - 4 pages vThe desire to rule a country, set up a powerful kingdom that could run for a longer time, and names markup the history is almost every human’s wish. Lives, money and so many other precious things have been put into use to save kingdoms. One such example of ruling the kingdom is in that of Syria. The Asad family is running the kingdom since decades, four decades indeed. The king runs a rule of law, modified by him for him, and his powerful

Freedom of Expression? R v. Zundel - In Depth Case Analysis

1881 words - 8 pages was coerced.JudgmentsThe case comes to this Court after two trials, each of which resulted in a conviction. Although the first conviction was overturned, the Ontario Court of Appeal rejected the appellant's submission that s. 181 violated the Charter and sent the matter back for a new trial. This appeal is brought from the conviction on the second trial. Leave to appeal to this Court was granted on the general Charter issue only -- the

Case Study of The Public Service Commission of Canada

2295 words - 9 pages essence concluded the regions had to use the resources of the DSDT, for which the regions would be charged.•After failing to agree on standard charges, the Management Committee imposed the DSDT program demands on the Regional Operations Directorates.•The subsequent fiscal budgets projected the regional operations directorate accruing a substantial loss and a substantial profit for the DSDT.Assumption: from the facts present in the case the

Two main themes in The Freedom of a Christian by Martin Luther - Essay

893 words - 4 pages Martin Luther. The Freedom of a Christian, 1520: The Annotated Luther, Study Edition. In this book, Martin Luther addresses two main themes: “The Christian individual is a completely free lord of all, subject to none” and “dutiful servant of all, subject to all” (488). He is able to reconcile these seemingly contradictory statements by claiming that one is justified by faith alone, and faith is active in love. For him, the Christian can do

Implications of the Peel Commission

2519 words - 11 pages . In this movie, they place God on trial, and after much discussion, come to the conclusion, that God’s plans for them, need not be questioned, for they are Gods children, and must therefore obey any task that God has placed in front of them, whether it is life or death. meant to be a solution, but it was deemed unfit3, for the area that is was trying to partition. The Commission was seen as a precursor to the partition plans that were implemented

The Search for Truth in A Tale of Two Cities

2888 words - 12 pages The Search for Truth in A Tale of Two Cities           "Since before the ancient Greeks, mankind has striven to discern and define truth, a noble if somewhat arduous task"( Swisher 118). Even modern society, despite losing so many of the old, "prudish" morals of preceding generations, still holds truth as one of the greatest virtues and to find truth in life, one of the greatest accomplishments. Authors such as Charles Dickens

The Case for Principle-Based Accounting

1011 words - 4 pages a company. Rules-based and principle-based accounting standards both have advantages and disadvantages. Advantages of rule-based accounting standards include clarity in application, reduction of risks when the rules are followed to the letter and the ease of comparing companies with the same industry using the same rules. Disadvantages of rule-based accounting standard include rigidity since a transaction must be accounted for under specified

Similar Essays

In R. V. Malmo Levine; R. V. Caine, The Court Held That The Harm Principle Is Not A Principle Of Fundamental Justice For The Purposes Of Section 7 Of The Charter

2454 words - 10 pages In R. v. Malmo-Levine; R. v. Caine, the court held that the harm principle is not a principle of fundamental justice for the purposes of Section 7 of the Charter. Explain the harm principle and the court's reasons for rejecting it. Did the court reach the right decision in holding that the authority of the Canadian state is not limited by the harm principle? Why or why not?In his essay "On Liberty", John Stuart Mill explains the importance of

Outline The Arguments In Favour Of Abortion

545 words - 2 pages Religious Studies - website)They also believe that if the pregnancy is a result of a rape, then abortion is the lesser of two evils, also if the mother's life is at risk, then abortion should be permitted."It is argued that in these tragic cases the great value of the mental health of a woman who becomes pregnant as a result of rape or incest can best be safe-guarded by abortion." (Christian answers.net)These are only a few of the arguments for abortion, there are many more.

How Might A Liberal Philosopher Argue In Favour Of The 1976 Motor Cycle Crash Helmets (Religious Exemption) Act? How Might A Liberal Philosopher A

949 words - 4 pages be placed on the universally common features of our humanity. They argue that cultural, religious, and racial and gender differences are private and not the concern of public institutions. From a Difference-Blind Liberal perspective the 1976 Religious Exemption was unjust. Those in favour of rule and exemption approach argued that Difference-Blind Liberalism is itself flawed as it can create inequality in its application and may hinder the

The Search For Religious Freedom In America

2160 words - 9 pages July 1591 to the Reverend Francis Marbury and Bridget Dryden. She was married to William Hutchinson and was a mother of 15 children. Hutchinson was chosen for her brave stance on religious freedom in a time when women were not welcome to a public opinion on any matter, much less one that defied the Puritan faith. While the Puritans believed salvation was the result of God’s grace, they also stressed works as a requirement of salvation, although