A Text Based Study Of Gender In Hamlet English Essay

1509 words - 7 pages

J.P. Mortenson
English 12
Damon Van Leewen
Don’t Discount Gertrude       
“Frailty, thy name is woman!”(I.ii.146) Indeed, one common analysis of female characters in Hamlet is that they are frail pawns stuck in the middle of the male characters’ schemes. Feminist critic Elaine Showalter bases her analysis on her belief that the women in William Shakespeare’s play Hamlet are passive vessels. Showalter argues that women in Hamlet are not full characters but instead are empty vessels or essentially blank slates from which modern viewers can draw conclusions about representations of women. She discusses this representation of women in the context of “English and French painting, photography, psychiatry, and literature, as well as in theatrical production” (Page 3), and argues that each time period and location’s interpretation of Shakespeare’s characters reveals something about that specific locus. She also stretches this argument to include Ophelia’s creator and discuss his era’s view on women. She focuses her analysis largely on Ophelia, drawing from both modern feminist critique and the contemporary views of women from the era in which her sources were created. Showalter argues that all the women in Hamlet are like Ophelia, but this theory does not apply to every female character in the play. The character Gertrude reveals that Shakespeare did not write all his female characters as passive. Shakespeare’s writing reveals the tension of women trying to navigate sexuality, motherhood, political power, and gender expectations of the time. This throws a wrench into the argument as a whole.
       Showalter’s premise that Ophelia is a passive character is certainly true. “We can imagine Hamlet's story without Ophelia, but Ophelia literally has no story without Hamlet” (Page 2), feminist expert Lee Edwards argues. Hamlet’s story has many other aspects to it besides being in love with Ophelia, such as his thirst for revenge or his problems with his mother, but the same can not be said about Ophelia’s story as she does not contribute to the plot on her own. Showalter uses this quote to show that Ophelia is a completely passive character created only to define her male love interest. Ophelia willingly becomes a pawn in the plots schemed by the people around her. For instance, Claudius, Polonius, and Gertrude use her as a pawn when they to try and discover the root of Hamlet’s insanity. She is unable to form her own thoughts or opinions, and always gives into the will of others. This is evidenced with Ophelia’s love interests. Laertes and Polonius, her brother and father, tell her not to respond to Hamlet’s affection. Ophelia's family members believe that she should “keep in the rear of [her] affection”(I.iii.24) and not give into Hamlet’s advances. They believe this because Hamlet’s “choice depends the safety and health of this whole state,”(I.iii.20) and “the main voice of Denmark goes withal,”(I.iii.28) that Hamlet’s first priority will always be...

Find Another Essay On A text based study of gender in Hamlet - English - Essay

A Gender Expectation - English 1A - Essay

779 words - 4 pages expectations of a female. While men do wear makeup in movies and sometimes have a passion for cosmetics, almost every woman can be expected to wear make-up for a particular occasion. Throughout the world, gender expectations can be found virtually anywhere, and the act of wearing make-up is seen, but also expected for females in casual, professional and formal environments. First, the casual act of being in public influences a woman’s reason to

What are the effects of gender based violence in south Africa? - Sociology - Essay

281 words - 2 pages SRE 315: Contemporary Sport and Recreation Management Homework Assignment · National Sport and Recreation Strategic plan The vision and mission statements Vision: An active and winning sport nation. Mission: To transform the delivery of sport and recreation by ensuring equitable access, development and excellence at all levels of participation and to harness the socio-economic contributions that can create a batter for all South Africans

Gender differences in text messaging

908 words - 4 pages In the book by Hilary Lips (2008), she examined and showed the differences in every aspect of life with genders. Being it charcteristics, biology perspective, or simple as using toys or playing with it. Therefore, there will be difference among genders within text messaging. One gender is going to used it more, text different or even rely on it more often than other. The purpose of this study is to determine the differences with genders in text

Gender Roles in Hamlet

1872 words - 7 pages In Hamlet, gender plays a huge role in the assumed capability of people. Queen Gertrude had to remarry instead of rule the kingdom by herself. If she wouldn’t have gotten remarried, it would have been likely that her kingdom would have been usurped by a chauvinist male ruler; who felt that women couldn’t rule a kingdom. The only other female in the play is Ophelia, and she isn’t allowed to see Hamlet because her dad said so, but her brother

Gender in the Gilbert Text

1573 words - 7 pages The gender binary portrayed in “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman assesses society’s lack of respect for women with mental illness and their subsequent isolation, concluding that the binary hinders a woman’s recovery. In the story, Perkins creates a situation where in order for Jane, a woman with post-partum depression, to overcome her illness she must first utilize her insanity to eradicate the restrictive, inhibitive social

Critical Study of a Novel Animal Farm - English - Essay

1347 words - 6 pages the Russian Revolution of which it was based on. The way in which this is presented by Orwell, who uses an easily understandable style, acts as a universal and timeless warning of what can happen, which is without a doubt still relevant today with the current global political circumstances. In doing this, it is made clear that a texts literary value is decided on its capability to deliver a strong message that is both universal and relevant all

“Rape Fantasies”: A Text Worthy of Study in the Eleventh Grade Curriculum

3028 words - 12 pages situation that women live in due to the gender power disparity in our society. Though this short story was set in the 1970s, rape remains a prominent problem today (Pearson 47). Through the discussion of this text, negative attitudes that many students harbor about rape and its victims could likely be corrected as well as diminish general rape acceptance. Furthermore, this story also reveals the power imbalance between men and women that allows rape

Hamlet essay, got a 95 just need to fix a couple of things for a 100 - English III - Essay

938 words - 4 pages dark and destructive life of Hamlet. For example, the text, “How now, a rat? Dead for a ducat, dead… A bloody deed - almost as bad, good mother, As kill a king and marry with his brother”, shows a new temperament and emphasizes the murderous rage of Prince Hamlet (III.iv. 29, 34-35). This exemplifies that by pretending to be insane, one can legitimately lose their sense of reality. I believe this is still a relevant concept in the world today

the role of women in the tragedy of hamlet - english - essay

1373 words - 6 pages The Role of Women in the Tragedy of Hamlet Though both female characters seem to play a key role in the plot of the Shakespearean play entitled Hamlet, they are generally portrayed as powerless and compliant individuals that are used by essentially all the male characters, thus driving their mental state into complete insanity. The following essay will go into depth with the mistreatment of the women in Hamlet, in specific, how both Gertrude and

The opening of a text should contain all the important features to be investigated within its later structure. - English - Essay

769 words - 4 pages Tsotsi Essay 1 Statement #2: The opening of a text should contain all the important features to be investigated within its later structure. Often the most important part of any film is the opening, it contains all important features that can be investigated within its later structure. What is shown in that opening will be what drives and setup the rest of the film. This is especially the case in director Gavin Hood’s film “Tsosti” where

Why is Hamlet A Tragic Hero - Grade 11 English - Essay

1283 words - 6 pages love of general gender bear him”. The public’s love towards Hamlet is so great that if the King were to publicly take action against him he would be dethroned and there would be riots. Clearly Hamlet has something that the general public values and this is the reason as to why they hold him to such a high regard. Due to this high regard and common interest they are able to respect him so well. If the public can see something in Hamlet and because

Similar Essays

Close Reading Paper Of Winter's Tale And Hamlet And The Involvement Of Love After Death In The Text. University Of Illinois/ English 218 Essay

1689 words - 7 pages Jordan Roberts English 218 Close Reading Paper #2 November 12, 2017 Love after Death A recurring theme of loving your partner after their death has been common in our readings throughout the plays we have been analyzing in class. In The Winter’s Tale and Hamlet I saw a lot of men mistreating their women or not really showing them love until their death. In the case of the male this occurred for them to get their way. In the case of the females

An Author Study Essay Of Biographical Information And Analyzing Text Frost English Expository Essay

1085 words - 5 pages 1 Ellis Miss Ellis Ms. Balduff/ Ms. Ellis Author Study Essay 23, March 2018 The Literary Works of William Shakespeare William Shakespeare is arguably one of the greatest writers in literary History. With over a 150 Sonnets and 39 plays, Shakespeare provided readers with stories of vengeance, unconditional love, and conflicting relationships. He brought us infamous characters such as Macbeth, Hamlet, and Romeo that gave readers astute insight

Gender Stereotypes In A Midsummer Night’s Dream English Essay

962 words - 4 pages Midsummer Night’s Dream William Shakespeare portrays female characters to be equal or stronger to the male. The play reflects these qualities through bravery, determination, gender role reversal and how it creates a crack in stereotypes set up by humankind. The first reason why women are seen equivalent to the male is because they prove themselves as strong to authoritative figures. At the start of the play, Hermia proves her boldness when she

A Study Of Lexical Changes Of Modern English Based On Barney Stinson

3233 words - 13 pages A Study of Lexical Changes of Modern English Based on Barney Stinson's The Bro Code崔佳灿(河北师范大学外国语学院 石家庄 050024)[Abstract] Lexical change is an inseparable part of language study. With the development of science and technology, many words are created or shifted from its original meaning. By selecting the