A Textual Analysis Of A Scene From Now Voyager And Its Effects On Male And Female Spectators

2433 words - 10 pages

As Laura Mulvey states in her article "Visual Pleasure and the Narrative Cinema", the cinema operates as an "advanced representation system" that offers pleasure in the act of looking, what she classifies as scopophilia or voyeurism (Mulvey 484). Through the cinematic experience, one may sit in a dark theatre and derive pleasure from looking without being seen. As E. Ann Kaplan describes in the introduction to her book Women and Film, within this act of gazing there are three looks: "(i) within the film text itself, men gaze at women, who become objects of the gaze; (ii) the spectator, in turn is made to identify with this male gaze, and to objectify the women on screen; and (iii) the camera's original 'gaze' comes into play in the very act of filming" (Kaplan 15). The gaze is associated with subjectivity and control and as Kaplan later suggests in the chapter "Is the Gaze Male?", "to own and activate the gaze...is to be in the masculine position" (Kaplan 30). Therefore the visual pleasure in cinema is mainly geared towards a male spectator who maintains subjectivity and a sense of voyeurism, while his female counterpart must be both subject and object, she must see herself being seen.

At first glance, women's films or family melodramas such as Now Voyager seem to reverse such spectator roles as one is made to identify with a female protagonist. Yet as E. Ann Kaplan suggests, by using psychoanalysis one can deconstruct these films in order to show how they only work to reinstate the dominant patriarchal order of man as subject and woman as object. She suggests that "the family melodrama, as a genre geared specifically to women, functions both to expose the constraints and limitations that the capitalist nuclear family imposes on women and, at the same time, to 'educate' women to accept those constraints as 'natural', inevitable - as 'given' (Kaplan 25). The female spectator identifies with the ideal mirror image of the self on screen, one who acknowledges the pleasures and concerns of a woman living under the capitalist nuclear family while remaining desirable and maintaining the dominant order.

In the 1942 film Now Voyager, one sees these roles being played out. Yet the film does something quite different in its beginning and calls into question some problems with the pleasures of viewing. What happens when the object on screen is neither desirable for the male spectator, nor the ideal mirror image of the female self? What happens when there is nothing to 'fetishize' and the object of the gaze returns the gaze? The result is that of a suggested disturbing cinema where the male gaze is threatened, suggesting that pleasure has been denied for both male and (seemingly) female spectators. The early part of Now Voyager suggests how a cinematic world that disrupts scopophilia is coded as disturbing, one where the characters are deemed ill. Although the film temporarily disrupts this pleasure, the film ultimately maintains the notion that...

Find Another Essay On A Textual Analysis of a Scene from Now Voyager and its Effects on Male and Female Spectators

A media analysis of the film 'Psycho' by Alfred Hitchcock. Looking specifically at voyeurism, third person narrative and the roles of both male and female characters.

974 words - 4 pages makes Normanappear nervous and edgy and creates suspense because the audience wonderwhy this scene is portrayed in this particular way. We discover the answersto all of these things as the film progresses.The next crucial scene is where Norman and Marian are having aconversation in his house. Here, for part of the time the camera is situated ata low angle showing Norman and a stuffed Eagle on the wall behind himwith its wings outspread. This is

Male and Female Issues Essay

3177 words - 13 pages accomplish all that they are able. Textbooks and Testing There has to be more equal treatment given to males and females, not only by the teacher but also by the textbooks and standardized tests. Textbooks tend to favor men. There is a greater focus on male achievements over female achievements. Women are neglected, especially when pertaining to pictures of scientists and mathematicians (Hamner 1996.) It is also seen that some

Male and Female Stereotyping

1432 words - 6 pages beliefs are what cause unrealistic expectations which leads to problems with one another. What’s “appropriate”, causes kids to double think before doing something different, For example a little boy playing with a Barbie doll. The things children sees and hears creates a very big impact on the thinking of that child as they grow older. A male can alter into a judgmental, narrow minded and emotional detached by viewing media, (etfo, paragraph 5

Male and Female Ways of Thinking

1018 words - 4 pages Male and Female Ways of Thinking It has long been thought that men and women have fundamental difference in the way they think, but this was always considered to be down to the hormones. Recently it has been discovered that although the hormones do play a role in the behaviour and views of the different sexes, the brain also plays a key role. It has been found that there are many ways which the male brain varies from

A Leader's Role and its Effects on Everyone

643 words - 3 pages While studying on a full scholarship at the Draver School in London, I organized a Business Development Club to investigate opportunities in the flourishing British economy. I quickly discovered the challenges required to motivate, attract, and change the mindset of others.After taking language and cultural awareness classes at school, I realized there were significant economic opportunities outside the campus walls. People from all over the

Determinants of Philippine Trade: A Regression Analysis of Trade and its Factors from 1980

1686 words - 7 pages significant enough to determine Philippine Trade. Statement of the Problem As shown from the acquired data from the World Bank from years 1980 to 1981, the researcher would like to determine whether these promising factors identified such as Gross Domestic Product per Capita expressed in percentage annually, Exchange rate, and Inflation rate contain significance in the determining the effects on Philippine Trade Objectives of the Study The

Male Depression: A position paper analyzing the symptoms of male depression and detailling how it can be worse than female depression by society's standards.

1319 words - 5 pages supplemental chart developed by Jed Diamond, MSW and a forty-year psychotherapist, detailing the symptoms of male depression and female depression. As the chart shows, men who are depressed exhibit traits that are typical of the lazy short-tempered male archetype.On a general level, depressed women tend to internalize their feelings, and are not hesitant about expressing them and talking to others about them. This is in sharp contrast with how men

Loss of a Family Member, and Its Effects on the Family

1940 words - 8 pages also refer to an emotional or physical distance put between two people. In “The Shawl” by Louise Erdrich, there is an example of a physical loss and its effects on the family, while in “Bone Black” by Bell Hooks the loss shown is of the emotional kind. It is interesting to view these stories side by side, as they showcase how both types of loss effect the family. In both of the stories, the relationship effected most is that between a parent and

A brief field study of the Vancouver(Canada) Landfill and its effects on the environment

661 words - 3 pages IntroductionThe amount of damage done to the environment by the Vancouver Landfill is a lot lower than it was ten years ago. An emphasis has been put on reducing the harming effects on the environment that the landfill produces. Leachate and landfill gases are taken care of properly as approximately 475,000 tonnes of municipal solid waste are put in the landfill every year. The Vancouver Landfill is 635 hectares; 235 hectares take up the

Examine Act 3 Scene 5 of 'Romeo and Juliet' closely, how does Shakespeare ensure that the scene is one of dramatic interest and how could a production enhance its effects?

1518 words - 6 pages Examine Act 3 Scene 5 of 'Romeo and Juliet' closely, how does Shakespeare ensure that the scene is one of dramatic interest and how could a production enhance its effects?The tragedy of 'Romeo and Juliet' is one of Shakespeare's most famous plays. It was written in the late 16th century. The contemporary society is reflected throughout the text; one in which men rule and women are viewed as possessions. In comparison to its predecessor, Scene 5

The Male and Female Role

604 words - 2 pages the family. Providing for the family may be something that she isn't used to but it something that she has to achieve to take care of her family. While in homes where there is simply a male present he has to be the provider and give emotional support. Emotional support is harder for a male to give than a female because males have been taught from a young age that it's not alright to show their emotions and to express their feelings. Males are

Similar Essays

Capitalism And Its Effects On A Nation.

1132 words - 5 pages overly motivated, he/she runs the risk of risking too much and losing everything. With no restraints on personal spending from the government of a capitalistic economic system, it could be often difficult to use one's money and capital in a responsible manner. For this reason, capitalism can be considered a 'gamblers economy.' If the citizens in this system are unable or unwilling to accept the fact that they may come out worse than where they started

Observation And Analysis Of A Cultural Scene

1366 words - 5 pages . Although they had a more relaxed appearance, their typical style of clothes did not look comfortable at all. Keeping in mind that the temperature was close to 85 degrees, a few of the female seniors were wearing long sleeves, pants and light sweaters. Also, their vehicles looked to be in immaculate condition. I am not sure of the reasons for all of their particular behaviors, but I would assume their calm/relaxed nature may stem from being retired

Testing A Hypothesis About Male And Female Drivers

1385 words - 6 pages comes up must be rounded to the nearest whole number this number is then used to pick the relevant number from the sheet. Once 30 pieces of data had been collected for the males and I had not yet got 30 for the females, I continued using my calculator until I got a number that corresponds with a female piece of data on the sheet. Once I had 30 for each I started to refine the data. I started by taking the 30 male pieces

A Conflict Between Male Authority And Female Resistance.

793 words - 3 pages The Religious Beliefs of Others"The Lottery"In Shirley Jackson's "The Lottery," there is a conflict between male authority and female resistance. "The Lottery" attempts to explain an obscured way of controlling female sexuality. In this short story the women are not allowed to take part in the drawing. This is significant because their exclusion from the lottery leaves their fate to be decided by the males in the society. The society in this