An Opinion Piece On California's Three Strikes Law.

897 words - 4 pages

In 1994, California passed its infamous Three Strikes law after a twice-convicted kidnapper on parole kidnapped and murdered a 12 year old girl. The law has been under scrutiny ever since. Essentially, the law states that any person convicted of the same felony three times will automatically receive a 25 year to life prison term. Obviously, this can cause a lot of debate - With kidnapping and murder, of course it should apply, but in one man's case, after stealing $153.54 worth of videos, he was sentenced to 25 years or more in prison. So is it constitutional? You be the judge.Leandro Andrade, a 37 year old man from San Bernadino County, was convicted of possession of marijuana and a few petty thefts in 1983. Then, in 1995, he was convicted twice of shoplifting, usually a misdemeanor offence. Prosecutors cited his prior offences, and got his two most recent shoplifting counts bumped up to felonies, which then counted as his third and fourth strikes. He was sentenced to 25 years to life, and appealed his sentence. In April 2002, the law was taken in front of the supreme court, who over turned his sentence, deeming it to be cruel and unusual punishment for such a crime.They ruled that the severity of the crime didn't merit the tough and severe punishment. This sparked the Supreme Court to analyze the law itself. The court may remove California's use of minor theft or drug possession as a felony and thus as one strike. Two times in the past few months, cases involving the three strikes law have made it to the Supreme Court, and have been overruled.The major debate of this law is over the 8th amendment - Cruel and Unusual punishment. Everyone involved with cases of this magnitude is forced to, at some point or another, ask themselves this question: Does the crime merit the punishment? Especially in the case of Mr. Andrade, people have been questioning the ferocity of the punishment. Life in prison for three charges of auto theft or even shoplifting? It doesn't seem like the question alone makes sense. How can one knowingly give the same charge to a murderer that they give to a shoplifter?In most other states, shop lifting is a misdemeanor, which calls for a fine or a small amount of prison time, no more than 6 months. Unfortunately, due to this law, many prosecutors in California have tried successfully to turn drug possession and shop lifting into full felonies, so that they count as strikes. The problem with all of this is that now, more so than ever, there are...

Find Another Essay On An opinion piece on California's Three Strikes law.

Three Branches: The Impact on Law Enforcement

1250 words - 5 pages influence law enforcement. Similar to the discussion question presented this week, the question, “What branch of government has the most impact on law enforcement?” originally presented itself with a deceivingly obvious answer. As stated in this paper’s thesis, and later individually addressed, there are two branches that influence law enforcement; the Legislative and Executive Branches of government. However, upon further research, it became

Romeo and Juliet: Comparing Banishment to Death An opinion piece stating that banishment would be a preferable fate to death.

624 words - 2 pages situation.Death has no real advantages over banishment, as death includes nearly every consequence associated with banishment. Dead people have absolutely no contact with those who are alive, contrary to the superstitious opinion that a surprising number of people possess. And although the concept of an afterlife is widely accepted, there is no way to conclusively prove its existence, or, assuming an afterlife does exist, to determine what sort of

Equality in New Zealand. In short, this is a factually based opinion piece on race relations in New Zealand

1419 words - 6 pages advance their own agenda. In the context of New Zealand, Maori predicate ‘cultural sensitivity’ and are effectively creating a wall of silence that no debate on major issues can stem from. A fig to Political Correctness! I am unwilling to become the white equivalent of an oppressed burka-clad Muslim woman just yet. And as the moral platitudes of democracy dictate, I am allowed to voice my opinion, even if the local iwi disagree with it

Forming an Opinion of Others based on Wealth

595 words - 2 pages personality. Typically, 2 people will form an opinion of others within the first 3 seconds of meeting one another. The way these opinions are formed so quickly is, generally speaking, solely because of physical appearance. All too often, in our society today, people are criticized for what material possessions they have and how much money said people have to spend on things that they do not need, but instead just want. It does not matter where you go

an opinion paper on whether or not we should return to the moon

673 words - 3 pages Opinion paper on returning to the moonOver the last three decades one of the most talked over and questioned subjects has been whether or not to return to the moon. Many people have the view of "been there, done that" when it comes to the moon, and believe that we should look ahead, not behind. However I think that returning to the moon still has many advantages to offer us.For example, it has now been discovered that there is a possibility of

Summary and opinion on George Orwells "Shooting of an Elphant" good paper many qoutes and examples.

839 words - 3 pages of the piece; but in reality I was only an absurd puppet pushed to and fro by the will of those yellow faces behind" (573). Everyone has been in a situation in which he or she has been expected to be a leader. For different reasons people are looked to as leaders, sometimes because of their race, ethnicity, or heritage. In this case, Orwell was pictured as a leader because he was British and he worked for the British Empire.Readers are able to

This is an essay on how to improve education in my opinion.

1245 words - 5 pages reduce in size, the emphasis on standardized testing must be lowered, and traditional teaching strategies must change.Currently, students are not receiving the optimum education they need to succeed in life. With this lack of proper education, students are growing up without the fundamental knowledge to be able to strive for success. An abundance of students are failing in school and are not equal with their peers due to traditional teaching

It's an essay on Traditional Policing within Law Enforement

561 words - 2 pages -toss-the-key" approach to law enforcement.Traditional policing tends to appeal to conservatives who believe that a police force should solve crimes on their own, using tough strategies to deter other criminals, a relationship that scientific data tend to find doubtful. Community policing involves multiple actors who are not ordinarily involved in crime. It is more effective, more informative, generates more leads and uses resources not available

A Piece for the Fire: Review of the film "American Beauty" with an emphasis on family and morals.

1122 words - 4 pages . By viewing the movie in such a manner, the audience must become desensitized to the violence which saturates the story, which, in turn, could have a similar effect on society by becoming accustomed to witnessing violence among friends and family. This cannot be stood for!The sexual content of this film is another reason to raise an eyebrow. It is hard to find a movie today that does not have some form of sexuality, so of course, on viewing

An essay disagreeing on John Ruskin's piece about giving precedence to a soldier rather than a merchant

651 words - 3 pages In society, a soldier is very much respected and is only reasonable to view him superior to a person such as a merchant. Philosophers on the other hand, contradict this statement and write that a merchant who is a harmonious man should be held in a much higher position than a soldier whose only objective includes killing. John Ruskin, the English critic of art and society, argues that a soldier should be given precedence rather than a merchant

Ride On (an Imaginative Piece)

945 words - 4 pages "You're lying! That's not funny, Mum!" I screamed and ran straight up the stairs, heading for my bedroom. Once there, I slammed the door hard behind me and fell on to my bed in a sobbing heap. It's not true! It can't be true! Karly loved her life, and me, she would never do anything like that. She always said she never wanted to die, so why would she do it on purpose? I rolled on to my side and picked up a photo of Karly and I, which had been

Similar Essays

Three Strikes Law Essay

1794 words - 7 pages felonies are resolved in state courts and less than two percent in federal courts” (p.8). Kovandzic et al. (2002), Marvel and Moody (2001) published two studies examining the impact of the Three Strikes Law on state crime rates and city homicide rates (Kovandzic, et al., 2004). Both studies showed the impact of the Three Strikes Law on crime “generally concluded that the law either had minimal impact on crime or may “backfire” and cause an

Three Strikes And Youre Out Law

1534 words - 6 pages keep it simple because they knew people would not vote for something they could not understand. There is a lot of talk about serious and violent felonies in the law and there are certain offenses that must be met in order to qualify as a serious or violent felony. The felonies that would fall under both categories would be those that are beyond misdemeanors and/or carry an extensive sentence. With the passage of "Three strikes

The Three Strikes Law Is Lost In A Dessert         The

683 words - 3 pages many non-violent three strikers. Letting out more serious and violent offenders for non-violent offenders increases the cost to society, since they are more likely to commit more violent and serious felonies than the non-violent three strikers. Thus, the law is inappropriate by engendering an influx of prisoners to an already overflowing prison system and an unbearable financial burden. The 'three strikes' law requires millions from

Please Describe The Current Three (3) Strikes Law In California. Also, Give Any Solutions You Feel Would Correct The Problems That Are Now Occuring. Please Attach A Bibliography.

2133 words - 9 pages crimes in jail for an extended amount of time costs the state an overwhelming amount of money.Fiscally, California's Three Strikes Law is irresponsible, and places stress on California's budget. It costs $31,000 per inmate, per year to keep criminals jailed (Ehlers). This amount is negligible when the criminals being locked up for over 25 years warrant their sentence. When the crime is simple drug possession or unarmed robbery, $31,000 a year for