A Vindication Of The Rights Of Woman And An Ode Popular Superstitions Of Highlands Of Scotland

2673 words - 11 pages

Comparing Unification in A Vindication of the Rights of Woman and An Ode on the Popular Superstitions of the Highlands of Scotland     

 
In A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, Mary Wollstonecraft seeks to abolish repressive, orthodox conventions. She endeavors to abate manners that lacerate our society, that elevate man above woman, that prohibit equal exchange between the sexes. This unequal system of gender roles forms the basis of her argument. Wollstonecraft claims that civilization will not progress while half its population is subjugated. Arguing that progress in sexual commerce will balance the scales, she seeks simplicity in society through equality between man and woman. Through equal education, rejection of traditional expectations, but most importantly a dismissal of complex, debilitating emotions like love and passion, the sexes will overlap, becoming one, becoming unisexual. This simplification, this unisexuality, will clear the smoke between men and women, allowing them to return to a basis of reason upon which to build a better society. Wollstonecraft sees this unisexuality as the savior of human kind.

In An Ode on the Popular Superstitions of the Highlands of Scotland, Considered as the Subject of Poetry, William Collins seeks to abolish cultural stereotypes rending Scottish and English societies. Collins realizes that if unabated, the rising 18th century commercial torrent will consume Scotland. This flood will leave the north hopelessly backward, unable to unite with the southern commonwealth. The growing cultural and economic gap between north and south will leave England ripe for conflict. Collins also realizes that the British Empire can never be a great power unless these two warring factions unite. And so, Collins strips away modern differences between these two nations in order to unify them. Collins uses the spiritual traits of the ancient Celts, from which the Scottish and English both descend, as common ground upon which to build this reconciliation. Once bridged, these two separate cultures will form one solid society, simpler because of its unity, simpler because elements that once kept them apart now bring them together under one banner, a unicultural banner. Collins sees exchange of intellect, and a blending of Scotch and British literature as England's only salvation. He considers the raw energy of Scottish ballads, tempered by reason, as the basis of cultural commerce from which both parties can profit.

Collins is arguing for a uniculture just as Wollstonecraft is arguing for unisexuality. Both seek unification through simplicity. Wollstonecraft and Collins seek to harmonize society: an integration of sexes, an integration of cultures. They seek to tear down irrational, complex boundaries to begin commerce on simpler terms. Wollstonecraft argues for progress through sexual commerce and reason, Collins argues for progress through primitivism, using reason to tender solidarity. He sees a...

Find Another Essay On A Vindication of the Rights of Woman and An Ode Popular Superstitions of Highlands of Scotland

A short response to Mary Wollstonecraft's "A Vindication of the Rights of Woman"

678 words - 3 pages spoken to. I find it interesting that she chooses the words 'rational creatures' to describe women. The term has a connotation of being asexual, and it gives a notion of an equality between men and women as both being creatures.Also, Wollstonecraft appears to be fighting for an equal education for both men and women alike. She repeats the idea of education throughout the essay. "By individual education...for the sense of the word is not precisely

On Mary Wollstonecraft 'A Vindication of the Rights of Woman' (1792)

1817 words - 7 pages The object of this essay is to discuss two passages from 'A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792) , and to identify in what ways, and to what extent this text is 'modern'. To achieve this, an analysis of the main ideas and arguments of the text will be conducted, together with an attempt to identify ways in which the text responds to the ideas, social circumstances and cultural preoccupations of its own time as well as the ways in which it

A Vindication of the Right of Women and Woman in the Nineteenth Century

1384 words - 6 pages Education of Women in A Vindication of the Right of Women and Woman in the Nineteenth Century        In two centuries where women have very little or no rights at all, Mary Wollstonecraft and Margaret Fuller appear as claiming voices, as two followers of feminism. Two women separated by a century but united by the same ideals. In these male- dominated societies, these two educated women tried to vindicate their rights through one of the

Mary Wollstoncraft's, The Vindication of the Rights of Women

1167 words - 5 pages Mary Wollstoncraft's, The Vindication of the Rights of Women Mary Wollstoncraft's book, "The Vindication of the Rights of Women," is an incredibly insightful look into the life of women in the early portion of this century. It is a philosophical examination of the condition of women, in relationship to some very basic rights, and is also a very enlightening look at how short a distance we really have come, as a society, in relationship to

The Clans of Scotland

642 words - 3 pages around Lake Mentieth in Scotland. Officially known as Clann Greumach, the Grahams were a clan with lands in the highlands and the lowlands. This finding encouraged me to study into the dozens of other clans present in Scotland. Q2. What questions did you ask as you learned about your topic? A2. Researching any topic will induce many questions upon research, many of which can not be given a clear cut answer. The biggest question I wondered about

Women’s Inequality in Wollstonecraft’s A Vindication of the Rights of Women & Rousseau’s On the Origin of Inequality

1174 words - 5 pages Both Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Mary Wollstonecraft agree that in society women and men are not equals. Rousseau’s idea that socialization brings inequality in his Discourse On the Origin of Inequality is manipulated by Wollstonecraft in her A Vindication of the Rights of Women. She uses his arguments to prove that the inequality between men and women is not natural, but it comes from Rousseau’s idea of socialized inequality. The inequality

History of Woman's Rights rooted in Mary Wolfstonecraft's Publication Vindication of the Rigts of Women

1704 words - 7 pages struggled through this classic example of social injustice involving the rights of women, our world was forever changed. Not only has our personal view of women changed; from that of stay-at-home mommy who does not have any concept of what the real world is like to that of influential women in business and board rooms across the world. Society as a whole realizes that women are an integral part of all aspects of life and gender basis is an unjust

Vindication of Women

1374 words - 5 pages , inferior to the male." This shows that women are inferior to men in physicality, and a number of areas throughout the essay, yet through it all she voices her concerns for the rights of women and how well deserved they are. [1: Wollstonecraft, Mary. A Vindication of the Rights of Woman. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1992, 10]Throughout mankind's history there has been an obvious bias towards men. Men have always been deemed superior to women, whether it

Equal Rights of Woman

645 words - 3 pages rights to liberty and pursuit of happiness. This made Wollstonecraft very unhappy that the “Enlightenment” male thinkers promised to only to degrade women as a person and continue to oppress them as members of society. The exclusion of women from reason and right provided the platform for Wollstonecraft Vindication of Rights of Woman (1792) (Clark and Poortenga 2003). Vindication was the most prominent early warning that there was something

Analysis of Vindication of the Rights for Women by Mary Wollstonecraft

991 words - 4 pages man’s ego. And she did all of this because she was passionate about Vindication for Women’s rights. Many thought she was crazy, and were opposed to her and women having an education. They believe that women do not need education, or to be free. So there were some confliction between Wollstonecraft and the people. When you have a passion for something, for change, the only way you can see if your passion actually made a change is if it indeed

A review of the book, Andrew Jackson and the Search for Vindication by James Curtis

923 words - 4 pages character and I would not recommend it. It seemed to me, Curtis represented him as an American hero more than a dynamic political figure. Andrew Jackson was the result of the troubled lives Americans lived during the Revolutionary period. The emotions of those people were the catalyst in Andrew Jackson's search for vindication.

Similar Essays

An Essay On A Vindication Of The Rights Of Woman

1084 words - 5 pages After reading from the excerpts of A Vindication of the Rights of Woman I have concluded that the situations of women, as far as rights are concerned, have indeed improved vastly. However, even though their situation has been amended and they are now afforded the same equal rights as men, not all women take advantage of these rights. A fraction of women still care more about their own physical beauty, appearance, and the prospect of finding a

Life Of A Sensuous Woman And A Vindication Of The Rights Of Woman

1842 words - 7 pages Ihara Saikaku’s Life of a Sensuous Woman written in the 17th century and Mary Woolstonecraft’s A Vindication of the Rights of Woman written in the 18th century are powerful literary works that advocated feminism during the time when women were oppressed members of our societies. These two works have a century old age difference and the authors of both works have made a distinctive attempt to shed a light towards the issues that nobody considered

A Vindication Of The Rights Of Woman Book Report

1330 words - 6 pages When I hear the word feminism, I automatically think of theories that want to place woman in a superior position to man. This is what most people think. When I was reading A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, I questioned if Mary Wollstonecraft was truly a feminist. So I looked up the definition of feminism and discovered that it is not an issue of one sex being superior. It is an issue of equality. In light of the definition, Wollstonecraft is

The Influence Of The History Of Rasselas On A Vindication Of The Rights Of Woman

2196 words - 9 pages The Influence of The History of Rasselas on A Vindication of the Rights of Woman         A surprising commonality found between Johnson's The History of Rasselas, Prince of Abissinia and Wollstonecraft's A Vindication of the Rights of Woman is their shared views on women's issues. This commonality is surprising since the two authors had different political viewpoints. While Johnson was a conservative Tory, Wollstonecraft was a social