This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Well Regulated Militia: The Founding Fathers And The Origins Of Gun Control In America

1323 words - 6 pages

The second issue in this paper is about rebellions throughout American history. There were several rebellions, but Shays’ Rebellion, the Whiskey Rebellion, and Fries’s Rebellion were an important part of the militia debate. “Shays’s Rebellion was the largest violent uprising in the new nation’s history, would become the first test of the radical potential of the militia and the right to bear arms in post-Revolutionary America”(Cornell, 31). Shays’s Rebellion revealed a tension in American constitutional theory if the militia was an agent of government authority or a popular system serving as a check on government. The notion that the militia refused to enforce an unjust law or took up arms against the government became the most important ideas in mental political confusion of the Revolutionary era. The consequence of the rebellion had influenced the content of the Constitution. Although the rebellion collapsed so quickly, it had an important effect on American constitutional development that motivated to reform the Articles of Confederation. (p.33-36) Following in the tradition of Shays, the Whiskey Rebellion in which farmers took up arms against the whiskey excise tax in western Pennsylvania believe that the people might bear arms to defend liberty. The tax protest had become an armed rebellion and Washington had to lead federal and state militia to put down. It appropriated the rituals and rhetoric of the militia muster and used the language of civic obligation and republican liberty. However, their idea that assembling in arms for liberty was rejected because Republicans believed that bearing arms was only for a well-regulated militia under state authority. The rebellion easily fell apart due to government forces (Cornell, 76-84). Fries’s Rebellion happened in southeastern Pennsylvania because of the tax on houses, land, and slaves. The state militia then was called out to put down the rebellion, so the rebellion fell apart quickly. The prosecution in Fries’s case was as same model set out in the trial as the Whiskey Rebellion that prevented the populist vision of the militia. From this rebellion, the notion that state might use their militias against the federal government gained more support when Republicans had to face another constitutional crisis. The crisis, apparently, forced Americans to consider both the militia’s role
Another noticeable issue in the the book is how slavery affected the debate over militias in the South. Abolitionists developed a new theory of the Second Amendment that provided the constitutional foundation for an individual right of revolution. They supported for an immediate end to slavery. From that event, a new revolutionary theory of the Second Amendment about an individual right of armed resistance became a cornerstone of abolitionist ideology. In addition, abolitionist Joel Tiffany stated that the right to bear arms also implied the right to use them in self-defense; Spooner thought that bearing arms for...

Find Another Essay On A Well Regulated Militia: The Founding Fathers and the Origins of Gun Control in America

Gun Control in America Essay

1071 words - 4 pages , Original Intent) Hopefully in asking this question and considering if gun control is successful, what causes gun violence, and what are the real solutions, a new perspective can be gained.Gun control successfulIn a deeply moving testimony given by Mark Matiolli, the father of six year old James Mattiolli killed in the Sandy Hook massacre, Matiolli stated that in researching gun laws he was startled to find that there are already many gun laws in place

Gun Control in America Essay

2429 words - 10 pages . The first and simplest way to show that gun control will not work is to look to the past. Usually, people learn from their past mistakes and from other’s past mistakes in history. Sadly, American society has clearly shown a lack of development in this topic. If we travel back roughly ten years from now, we will have entered a time of gun control that our current government is pushing to achieve once again. According to, The

Gun Control in America

829 words - 4 pages adults” (Dreier, 92). Others say that four handguns were found on or around his body and were the main weapons used in the assault. It is still unclear as to which weapon(s) he used to carry out his crime. This is the type of misinformation that has put semi-automatic firearms on the main stage. The AR-15 rifle has been the center of attention in many debates concerning gun control. The annual U.S. firearm fatality statistics are a main concern

Gun Control in America

1301 words - 5 pages protect themselves and their families without the firearms? Improper use of firearms is another very big reason for the restrictions as well as the violent shootings that have happened in the past few years. Many of those against gun control will point to the old saying that “guns don’t kill people, people kill people”. This would partially prove that what we need to focus on taking away the weapons from all the people who don’t need them instead of

Gun Control in America - 1398 words

1398 words - 6 pages federal “assault weapon” ban was banished in 2004, murder rates fell by 10%. Studies for Congress, the Congressional Research Service, the Library for Congress, the National Institutes of Justice, the National Academy of Sciences, and the Center for Disease Control and Prevention have not found evidence that gun control laws reduce crime (Ownership at All Time High, 1). In Florida, over a 15-year period with concealed weapon laws, homicide rates fell

Gun Control in America: The Problem Lies in Enforcement

1410 words - 6 pages Ahern PAGE 5 Michael AhernProfessor CastlemanENG 102, Essay 231 October 2014Gun Control in America: The Problem Lies in EnforcementIn the past generation, gun violence in the U.S. has produced a high volume of citizen casualties, prompting the need for a reassessment of gun control. Finding a solution has been no easy task. With the constant development of new firearms, such as assault rifles, semi-automatic handguns and machine guns, the need

Analysis of Argument: Gun Control in America

695 words - 3 pages Aroung the time of John F. Kennedy’s assassination, the controversial and widely argued issue of gun control sparked and set fire across America. In the past decade however, it has become one of the hottest topics in the nation. Due to many recent shootings, including the well known Sandy Hook Elementary school, Columbine High School, Aurora movie theater, and Virginia Tech, together totaling 87 deaths, many people are beginning to push for

Gun Control in America: a new approach at an issue that is becomming an epidemic. Possible solutions and the costs of those solutions

703 words - 3 pages . It is a phenomena that is beyond our control ? and can be frightening to those whom are not prepared.II.Prevention ? is a human's only hope for combating a potential storm?.. the storm that I refer to today is gun violence. Like a natural disaster ? the temperament of a criminal offender is beyond our control.III.The prevention method can be applied to this issue as well, in the reduction of the availability of guns, the adoption of a

Gun Control in America Today

4369 words - 17 pages the years. The Americans that favor strict gun control have come to the conclusion that this amendment guarantees the right of the states to own firearms. They believe the forefathers of the Constitution wanted to guarantee every state the right to keep and bear firearms, in order to defend against the federal government, should it try to possess too much power. The “well regulated militia,” they say, refers to state troops using state-supplied

Gun Control Right In America

892 words - 4 pages others argue that it would. The Second Amendment, the Columbine shooting, and self defense are all prime examples of why qualified Americans should be able to possess a firearm. The Second Amendment to the US Constitution, the right to bear arms, is one that every US citizen has the right to and it should not be taken away due to present gun control issues. The gun debate in the United States widely revolves around the Second Amendment

America Needs A Better System of Gun Control

1997 words - 8 pages United States, in actuality, owns more than a quarter of the world's registered firearms. The reason why our nation is allowed to bear a large quantity of firearms is due to the Second Amendment of our constitution, which specifically states, "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." (U.S. Const. am. 2) Because of how vague this amendment is when

Similar Essays

A Well Regulated Militia Essay

1137 words - 5 pages , another debate is about whether or not guns can be carried throughout the United States. The Second Amendment of the United States was written by our founding Fathers stating that it was necessary to have the security of a free state, the right of the people and bear arms, and these rights should not be imposed. In ‘A Well Regulated Militia’ by Saul Cornell, I will explain the different views of gun ownership in early America, which rebellions

Gun Control In America Essay 1758 Words

1758 words - 7 pages amendment, which states "a well-regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." Note that the founding fathers made this the second right out of ten. Which means that it most of been of great important to them. It is argued that the right to bear arms is conditional upon the need to have armed citizens as part of the national defense. Therefore, if the

Gun Control In America Essay 1883 Words

1883 words - 8 pages , tracing its origins through modern political policy and then evaluate each justly. I will then suggest a possible courses of action to help eliminate the problems today=s society faces involving gun violence. It=s time for this country to take a serious step to ensure the safety of its people. AA well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right to bear arms, shall not be infringed.@ This sentence from the second

Gun Control In America Essay

1534 words - 6 pages to the public? Or not accessible enough? Presented here are some facts taken from some pro-gun and pro-control web sites, and the web sites addresses themselves. The Second Amendment A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of the Free State, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Though there seems to be no definitive survey, most random surveys show most Americans believe some type of gun