A White Lie In The Heart Of Darkness

1381 words - 6 pages

A White Lie in the Heart of Darkness

“He cried in a whisper at some image, at some vision, – he cried out twice, a cry that was no more than a breath – ‘The horror! The horror!’” (Conrad, Heart of Darkness, pg112)1. After returning to Brussels, Marlow pays a visit to Kurtz’ intended and brings these final words of Kurtz with him. When asked to reveal Kurtz’ last declaration, Marlow offers this: “‘The last word he pronounced was – your name.’” (Heart, pg123). He lies.

In this situation, with the possibility existing of inflicting severe emotional damage on an already grieving soul, should Marlow have lied? Of course, the answer is neither simple nor short, and depends heavily on who is asked. The most relevant perspective naturally comes from Marlow himself. Marlow makes his feelings about lying clear early in his adventure. “You know I hate, detest, and can’t bear a lie, not because I am straighter than the rest of us, but simply because it appals me. There is a taint of death, a flavour of mortality in lies, – which is exactly what I hate and detest in the world – what I want to forget. It makes me miserable and sick…” (Heart, pp49-50). Marlow doesn’t hold much back here. He believes that lies are what is wrong with the world. That said, it seems that a third-person Marlow would severely disapprove of his actions, and would believe that he should have told the truth. This becomes even more evident after a glance at Marlow’s reaction after he does lie. “It seemed to me that the house would collapse before I could escape, that the heavens would fall upon my head.” (Heart, pg123). Marlow obviously sees his actions as in err, and is waiting for his punishment from above.

If this were all, the answer to the original question from Marlow’s perspective would be rather simple. However, there is another element that must be examined. Marlow’s original statement about lies included one very peculiar statement. He yields the fact that his distain for lies is, “not because I am straighter than the rest of us…” (Heart, pg49). Despite his extremely harsh words, Marlow actually admits to committing the very offense he speaks of. In addition, his reaction later after lying also includes the feeling that, “my heart stood still, stopped dead short by an exulting terrible cry, by the cry of inconceivable triumph and of unspeakable pain.” (Heart, pg123). The “terrible cry…of unspeakable pain” is obviously his distain for his actions, but what about the “inconceivable triumph”? The “triumph” here is successfully avoiding having to tell Kurtz’ intended the truth, because it “would have been too dark.” (Heart, pg123). It seems Marlow is a bit of a hypocrite. He hates lies, yet admits to lying, and also recognizes the triumph when he does. This new revelation, however, does not actually change the fact that Marlow would believe that he shouldn’t have lied; it simply means that that belief wouldn’t...

Find Another Essay On A White Lie in the Heart of Darkness

Colonialism and Imperialism - The White Male and the Other in Heart of Darkness

1073 words - 4 pages The European, White Male vs. the Other in Heart of Darkness      The novella Heart of Darkness has, since it's publication in 1899, caused much controversy and invited much criticism. While some have hailed it's author, Joseph Conrad as producing a work ahead of it's time in it's treatment and criticism of colonialist practices in the Congo, others, most notably Chinua Achebe, have criticized it for it's racist and sexist construction of

A Journey into the Soul in Heart of Darkness

1618 words - 6 pages A Journey into the Soul in Heart of Darkness         A picture is an abstract idea, brought into context to form something concrete.  They are made up and created to give off some sort of feeling or mood, that one can relate too.  The atmosphere helps determine what kind of mood the picture will take.  Any author, of either a painting or piece of literature will set the mood by

"Heart of Darkness": The Darkness.

1381 words - 6 pages city are blind and ignorant too darkness. Marlow even tells a lie to Kurtz Intended, which was to try and protect her from the darkness, but Marlow would have never told a lie if he hadn't felt the darkness in Africa.The darkness takes over a man's soul and savages him. There are ways of delaying the darkness from getting you, but you can never stop it; and there is no cure for it, and no one is safe from it. The darkness powered man's greed and

A Journey into Darkness in Heart of Darkness

1542 words - 6 pages , though he was appalled by his lie as bringing with it a betrayal of truth which was essentially a kind of death.        In "Heart of Darkness" the sense of human waste that pervaded the story was best unfolded in the ivory itself.  It was an object for the rich - in decorations, for piano keys and billiard balls - hardly a necessary item for survival, or even for comfortable living.  In a way, it was evil, a

The Other in The Heart of Darkness

2506 words - 10 pages Author's Last Name PAGE 1 [The Author's Name][The Professor's Name][The Course Title][Date]The Presence of "The Other" in Heart of Darkness and UlyssesThe Africans in the Heart of DarknessIt is an imbedded story of an adventurous Englishman who undertakes a journey into the primitive Congan jungle in order to rescue a strangely successful Ivory merchant, Kurtz, from the dangers posed by the unknown African people, the greed of his Belgian

The White Lie

1103 words - 4 pages The White Lie People are always talking about the white lie and how this kind of lying doesn't hurt other people. Other people feel that any lie is one that should not be made. No matter what individuals have to say about lies, Socrates feels that it is necessary to create a noble lie so that his vision of the just state, or kallipolis, can be created. The Myth of the Metals, Socrates myth, in no way contradicts his definition of justice

Colonialism In Heart Of Darkness

1418 words - 6 pages attitudes towards colonialism and those, less civilized, races. "In Heart of Darkness "¦ the natives portrayed are not reduced by Kurtz or other whites any less than they are reduced by the author to a state we vulgarly call aboriginal" (Murfin 128). Despite the difficulties of representation, Heart of Darkness can be read as a critique of colonialism, a comment on the "vilest scramble for loot that ever disfigured the history of human

Color as a Tool of Symbolism in Heart of Darkness

765 words - 3 pages Color is used very effectively as a tool of symbolism in Heart of Darkness. Colors, especially black and white, are used to symbolize evil (black) and good (white). Other colors are also used, although less often than black and white. Throughout the story, people are thought to have white souls or black souls depending on their innate "goodness" or "badness" or the role they are fulfilling at the time. The color of a person's soul is often

A Comparison of the Power of Will in Heart of Darkness and Apocalypse Now

1925 words - 8 pages The Power of Will in Heart of Darkness and Apocalypse Now        The story of Heart of Darkness was adapted to film after many failed attempts. (Hearts of Darkness, Coppala E.). Finally, director Francis Coppala collaborated with his friend John Milius on writing a screen play for Conrad's masterpiece. The two came up with Apocalypse Now, utilizing a more modern setting than the original story which was based in imperialistic Europe. The

Prejudice in Heart of Darkness: Racism is a Relative Term

1043 words - 4 pages makes it, in many ways, easy to see racist statements in the text and this is why it is also easy to classify the text as a racist text. Nevertheless, a text does not need to be racist just because some of the characters in the text are. Heart of Darkness is an example of a text with many racist statements without being racist itself. Moreover, why is that one might wonder? Mostly because there are also many antiracist parts in the book. I have

Charlie Marlow as a Narrator in Heart of Darkness

559 words - 2 pages Some of the things you have discovered about Charlie Marlow as a Narrator in Heart of Darkness. In Heart of Darkness, the main story teller is Charlie Marlow. Based on a boat waiting for the turn of the tide on the river Thames, he tells his crew of his journey into the African Congo. In the opening pages Marlow is described as looking like some kind of idol; "he had the pose of a Buddha preaching" this relates to his somewhat

Similar Essays

Lieshod Marlow’s Lie In Joseph Conrad's Heart Of Darkness

620 words - 2 pages Marlow’s Lie in Heart of Darkness     Throughout the Heart of Darkness scenes, we get several glimpses of Marlow's particular attitudes towards women, that they are creatures that live "in a world of their own, and that there had never been anything like it, and never can be" (Longman, p. 2199). Women are able to create and see the beauty in life, something that is harder for men to do, roughened by hard work and misfortunes. Marlow also

The White Collars In Joseph Conrad's Heart Of Darkness

701 words - 3 pages The White Collars in Heart of Darkness In Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness, Charles Marlow relates to his listeners aboard the Nellie the story of his service with a European company operating in the African Congo. Arriving in this European country to interview for employment, Marlow recalls, "I arrived in a city that always makes me think of a white sepulchre. Prejudice no doubt" (73). But whose prejudice is he speaking of: his or that

Opposition Of Black And White In Heart Of Darkness

1237 words - 5 pages   light in the European society, and the true heart of darkness which is present within all of humanity. From the start of Marlow’s journey into the African Congo it is apparent that he is a product of the colonialist European society, which is where the first oppositions of black and white evolve. Marlow understands the premise behind colonialism, but is unprepared for the savagery and the wilderness of the heart of darkness. This is most

Blackhod Black Vs. White In Joseph Conrad's Heart Of Darkness

1681 words - 7 pages Black vs. White in Heart of Darkness        The warm glow of civilization comforts and protects us all, but is there something more?  Is the heart of darkness lurking just below the surface, accessible to all but revealed to few?  In Heart of Darkness, Joseph Conrad provides the reader with the image of black vs. white in an attempt to convey the idea of an ever-present heart of darkness.    Although the main plot of Conrad's tale