Aboriginal Self Government In Canada Essay

978 words - 4 pages

The question that is brought up is not that of sex, but it is that of aboriginals in Canada. The question that is asked is should there be an aboriginal self-government? If the government were to go ahead and give the natives there own government they would be losing money and would most likely have angry taxpayers after their asses for the rest of there sorry political lives. The government would also have to deal with a swarm of Quebecans that would be harassing them because of their decision to give the natives their own government, because of their 1995 appeal to separate from Canada. The Quebecans would believe that if the natives get what they want, they should also get what they want.

That would mean that Quebec would separate from Canada and create their own nation. However, if the government refrained from processing the natives request of obtaining a self-government, the government would be saving a lot of money and would also be treating everyone in Canada as equals and not just giving what they want because they have different color skin or different ethnic origins. Issues brought up on creating an aboriginal self-government are very important in the future of the Canadian government. I feel that if the government created self-government for the natives, the government would be spending too much money. The decision would cause the natives to become way too greedy. And also that there is probably a little racism going on amongst the government.To carry on, giving the natives their own self-government has a worthy advantage.

That advantage being that when the government eventually processes the native's request of self-government, they will once and for all have the natives off their back. At least they'll think that they will. Either way the government will have to put up with the whining of the disrupted natives. There is still a pretty good chance that the natives will leave the government alone for a while.

After the years of complaining and fighting, the natives got what they want. Hopefully they'll be happy with what the government gave them and not fight for any more rights, because they have enough already.As mentioned in the first paragraph, giving the natives their own government would cause the government of Canada to lose a lot of money that can be used for other useful needs, such as spending the money on something more useful, such as education, which there isn't enough spent on. Maybe the government could even think about putting some more money into health care and give the less-fortunate people a chance to receive medical help when needed instead of them not wanting to go a physician because of the amount of money needed to attend one. The Canadian government is always complaining about how they're in debt and can't afford to accomplish certain goals they promised to achieve. Well I don't see them...

Find Another Essay On Aboriginal Self-Government in Canada

Aboriginal People Face Discrimination in Canada

1567 words - 7 pages were responsible to help teach aboriginal children in Canada English and really bring them away from the aboriginal culture. Also there was so much discrimination against Aboriginals; many times Canadians would say the phrase “Kill the Indians” which showed how much hatred was shown to Aboriginals. The Canadian government funded all the expenses for residential schools, which wasn’t a whole lot of money because the schools were already in terrible

Minority Government in Canada Essay

850 words - 3 pages , thus giving way for another election in September of 1926. (http://www.liberal.ca)The shortest minority government that Canada has seen was John Diefenbaker's Progressive conservatives; only staying in power for a little under 6 months in 1957! (http://www.mapleleafweb.com, C) This, however, was the first time in 22 years that the Liberal's were not in power. Diefenbaker's campaign strategy was quite different then what people were used to

Government Cutbacks in Canada

613 words - 2 pages . People would be dyingon route to the hospital, because they were too far away fromthe hospital.Looking further and going more in depth, governmentcutbacks are creating a problem with unemployment. We areletting young teachers go by the dozen, as well as nurses,government workers, the list goes on and on. Well qualifiedand educated people are deciding that they should find workelsewhere, and they choose to leave Canada. In the cashstrapped society

Reinventing Government in Canada

1929 words - 8 pages actor is to serve the needs of the customer first. The traditional form of government is completely opposite from this. Bureaucracies believed that “their” interests and needs in self- preservation and self-advancement were the first and it was their duty to decide how to deal with the needs of the citizens. This approach is turned on its head, with all government organizations viewing citizens as customers, and believes that serving the needs

Canada and Their Government´s Intervention in the Entertainment Industry

1243 words - 5 pages Many people argue whether not Canada has any culture at all, and why American culture seems to have such a big influence on Canadian music, art and television. Over the years the Canadian government has tried to protect and develop talent in Canada. Once British traditions started to fade away, the influence on Canada from America became stronger. If Canada was to become a strong independent country they needed their own identity. The government

The Pros and Cons of Privatizing Government Services in Canada

2955 words - 12 pages Municipal control or an alternative delivery method? This is the question that has intrigued all levels of local government and created intense debates between taxpayers across municipalities. The services that municipalities provide are often vital to the existence of a local area. The issues of accountability, cost savings, quality of service and democracy often arise when choosing the best options to deliver services to a municipal area. In

‘A comparative analysis of the effect of settler colonialism on Aboriginal women and children in Canada and New Zealand.’

2108 words - 9 pages The ongoing targeting of Aboriginal Children and Women is a significant impediment to Indigenous development in Canada and the wider world. In this essay I will critically interpret government-led development initiatives in Canada with a comparative analysis of New Zealand. I will address development interventions throughout Canada’s history with a focus on Indigenous women and children with specific reference to Indigenous womens maternities

A Chronology of Treaty Negotiations in Canada with emphasis in British Columbia

1330 words - 5 pages , and that their title had never been extinguished (Ministry of Aboriginal Affairs).1973 - The court case, coined the 'Calder case,' was resolved with the government of Canada further considering the topic of native self-government (Ministry of Aboriginal Affairs).In 1974 - Canada began official negotiations with the Nisga'a Tribal Council (Ministry of Aboriginal Affairs).1976 - The federal government adopts a "comprehensive land claims policy


1803 words - 7 pages , Canada’s First Nations’ plight can be improved through self-governance. According to Pocklington, “For several years, Canadian aboriginal leaders have been demanding the recognition of a right of Native self-determination and thereby, for the aboriginal collectivities that choose it a right of self-government” (102). Aboriginal self-governance is a controversial issue in Canada. Before researching the issue I believed that self-governance would deter

Acclaimed Court Decision on Aboriginal Title: Unprecedented Force on Canadian Politics, Law and Society

1776 words - 7 pages have continually been reconstructed to meet the societal needs as it relates to the social demands of accessing resources for economic benefits. As stated in the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples Report, Canadian government gradually accepted the idea of shared sovereignty, but loath the idea of handing over full reign of powers to genuinely support self-governing nations or the resources to make self-government a success " (1993). It is

A Need for Change

2116 words - 9 pages announced on the Day of Action event in Ottawa that she was going to start a hunger strike ("Timeline," 2013). Chief Theresa Spence began her hunger strike in protest to what she felt was abuse to her Aboriginal community as well as the Aboriginal communities across Canada. Within her statement she stated that the Canadian government is “violating the right of Indigenous peoples to be self-determining and continues to ignore our constitutionally

Similar Essays

Aboriginal Self Government Essay

2361 words - 9 pages When we talk about Aboriginal self-government, we are talking about something that is very complex and not well understood. Aboriginal self-government was even the subject of a legal challenge in the case of the landmark treaty that was signed by the Provincial Government of British Columbia, the Federal Government of Canada, and the Nisga'a First Nation. It is clear that this is a complex matter, and that there is a need to understand what it

Analysis Of Aboriginal Self Government Through Constitutional Design By Christopher Alcantara And Greg Whitfield

794 words - 4 pages In “Aboriginal Self Government through Constitutional Design: A Survey of Fourteen Aboriginal Constitutions in Canada” Christopher Alcantara and Greg Whitfield explore the dynamics of modern Aboriginal constitutions, as they analyze 14 Aboriginal constitutions and their comparative design and political nature to that of non-Aboriginal ones. Longstanding Indigenous traditions, and the unique development of their beliefs and practices are often

Canadian Politics Aboriginal Politics In Canada

2856 words - 11 pages Aboriginal organizations as advocates of Aboriginal rights in the constitutional context contributed to more overt centralization in management of the Canada-Aboriginal relationship within the federal government."(Abele, p.265)"The early seventies saw aboriginal peoples increasingly emphasizing land claims, treaty rights and self-government which were all oriented towards sovereignty and away from the notions of equal judicial status which the Charter

Discrimination Against Aboriginal Women In Canada

725 words - 3 pages subordinated and ignored by the government system of Canada. Thus today, aboriginal women experiences double jeopardy as they belong to more than one disadvantaged group i.e. being women and belonging to aboriginal group. In contemporary world, there are not much of a difference between Aboriginal people and the other minority groups as they face the similar challenges such as gender discrimination, victimization, and experiences injustice