Abortion Did Not Lower Crime Rate

1032 words - 5 pages

Ever since Freakonomics was published, and sold, which it sold very well to be honest, there has been many debates about one theory that Steven D. Levitt used to explain why the crime rate dropped in the 1990’s. That theory is that the Supreme Court case of Roe V Wade, which legalized abortion in all fifty states. Steven Levitt stated in Freakonomics that the legalization of abortion had the biggest percentage of why the crime rate went down. Yet, I would like to question this theory myself.
One big controversy that I have with this theory is that Mr. Levitt did not put in to factor the crack issues that were occurring during the time. The 1990’s was the biggest boom for the crack ...view middle of the document...

Many would ask, “How or why is this possibly an error?”. Allow me to give a brief reason why. Let’s say one is combining the most dangerous state to live in, homicides wise, and the safest state. What would occur when one combines these two states? Most likely the crime rate for the state with the highest homicides will decrease, but what about the safest state? It would increase, thus creating two states that look somewhat safe, but in reality one is dangerous and the other one is the safest place to ever be in.
Now that I had the chance to let out my frustration of this error, or at least the tip of the iceberg of it, let us continue. To correct this error the obvious answer would be to use a per capita formula, which creates various different age groups, rather than a complete whole for all arrests. Instead of doing a nationwide accumulation Levitt should have done a research that would have been conducted per state. This is very beneficial because one is not mixing states that had a low homicide rate with states that did have a high homicide rate, thus a clearer image of the emphasize that abortion had on crime rate in the 1990’s could have been made (http://www.bostonfed.org/economic/wp/wp2005/wp0515.pdf).
So why did the genius Steven Levitt not think of this possible solution? His and John Donohue answer was “because of the absence of reliable measures of state population by single year of age”, but if one were to truly looked into it one can easily find these “absence” reliable measures; especially since the Census Bureau has been constructing them for every year since 1980 (http://www.bostonfed.org/economic/wp/wp2005/wp0515.pdf).
If one was to be a diehard, word by word, Freakonomics freak I would be dodging flying projectiles right about now. Yet, before these projectiles are thrown, or even possibly fired, there is proof that even Steven D. Levitt agrees that he did do a mathematical error while conducting the theory.
Steven D. Levitt wrote...

Find Another Essay On Abortion did not lower crime rate

Exploring the Abortion Issue Essay

3867 words - 15 pages (“Induced Abortion”). Therefore, the U.S.’s abortion rate is lower than the worldwide rate despite its generally liberal restrictions for abortion. A 1998 poll showed that 56% of Americans believed that abortion was wrong, 36% did not believe it was wrong, and 8% were unsure (Shaw). However, in 1998 CBS poll 69% of Americans were opposed to making all abortions illegal, and 25% favored making all abortions illegal (Shaw). The results of

Abortion in the United States Essay

1937 words - 8 pages , 84,610 women obtained abortions in Texas, producing a rate of 16.5 abortions per 1,000 women of reproductive age. Some of these women were from other states, and some Texas residents had abortions in other states, so this rate may not reflect the abortion rate of state residents. The rate decreased 4% since 2005, when it was 17.3 abortions per 1,000 women 15-44. Abortions in Texas represent 7% of all abortions in the United States.”(Jones, Zolna


864 words - 3 pages is a welcome and necessary procedure, and proves to be morally acceptable in many instances. Although many in opposition claim that women are using abortion as a method of birth control, they are clearly wrong as current statistics show:Teenagers' abortion rate in 2000 was 24.0 per 1,000 women aged 15-19--some 3% lower than the 1999 rate of 24.7 per 1,000. From 1986 to 2000, the abortion rate dropped by 43%; during the same period, the proportion


4197 words - 17 pages mentioned. On this question, it has been observed that there have been fluctuations in opinions. In 1998, 56 percent thought abortion was “wrong” compared with 36 percent who did not (Shaw). The public also has been divided on whether abortion constitutes murder (Gillespie). Groups such as adoption agencies, churches, the Catholic Church in particular, and some women strongly believe that abortion is a form of murder. Therefore, their stance

A Case For Pro-Choice

2350 words - 10 pages that are after 12 weeks. Yet, this law was ruled to be unconstitutional because it is not until about 22 weeks that the fetus has the capability to survive outside the womb of the mother. Even though there are states in favor or the fetus’ rights, many states believe the rule of “born alive.” This basically meaning, that in order for abortion to be considered a crime, the fetus has to have taken independent breathes from the mother. These legal

Abortion is Every Woman's Right

994 words - 4 pages child as well as the woman about to have a baby, apart from being a moral crime in itself” (D‘Silva). D’Silva expressed how humans have no right to restrict the life of a baby, and that abortion was once considered a sin. Also, D’Silva boldly stated that an abortion can psychologically ruin the mother, as well as the family. The article also listed many health risks that are associated with abortion. For example, an abortion may damage the

The Abortion Issue

4889 words - 20 pages reducing the need for abortion. Pro-life advocates suggest that students be taught the practice of abstinence. As recently as twenty-five years ago, sex education policy did not explicitly support either side of the debate. According to research conducted by Douglas Kirby and Peter Scales in the late nineteen-seventies and early nineteen-eighties, “States in general weakly support sex education, and only three states, Maryland, Kentucky, and New

Abortion in Texas

3402 words - 14 pages countries began to occur in the later 1960's. English Law Henry Bracton, (1216-1272) "the Father of Common Law," apparently regarded abortion (at least after 5 or six weeks) as homicide and it seems that at early Common Law abortion was a felony, and, therefore, a hanging offense. Later commentators, Coke and Blackstone, held expressly that abortion after quickening was not the crime of murder, but a separate crime (a "grave misprision"). It is

Should Women Have the Right to Abortion?

1262 words - 5 pages and women are complete human beings, motherhood is just an option not an obligation. Those who think women should not have the right to terminate their pregnancy consider abortion to be murder and unsafe to women. According to CNS news, the meta-analysis conducted by Chinese researchers found that the risk for breast cancer increased by 44 percent after an abortion and this rate grew significantly with subsequent abortions (CNS News 2013). This


2382 words - 10 pages citizens even though some religions believe that abortion is a sin and a crime, the ACLU is often at odds with religion. By religious leaders banning abortion such as the view of the Vatican, this benefits the unborn. Therefore the American Civil Liberties Union believes that religious teachings frequently disobey the first amendment, since not all religions feel that way. Not even the medical community can make up their mind. For example, Donald A

Abortions Pros and Cons

1184 words - 5 pages small children we were taught values that are based on the bible such as that famous phrase “Thou shall not kill”. This phrase relates to this topic because an abortion is the murder of a human being.      A 52% of women getting abortions performed on them are younger than 25 years old and 19% are teenagers. The abortion rate is highest for those women aged 18 to 19 (56 per 1,000 in 1992 pregnancy centers.org).the reasons for this alarming rate

Similar Essays

Abortion Did Not Reduce The Crime Rate

2010 words - 8 pages because of Roe v. Wade, legalized abortion had an impact on crime (Levitt & Dubner, 2009). The authors point to the early 1990’s, that just as the first cohort of children born after Roe v. Wade were becoming teenagers, the years which were detrimental for young men to become involved in criminal activity, the crime rate started to drop (Levitt & Dubner, 2009). According to them, what that cohort was missing were the criminals that had not been

The Legalization Of Abortion And Crime

2409 words - 10 pages that police and the justice system are not against any race/minority. The crime rate statistics for minorities are quite revealing to how abortion lead to the decrease of these crimes. The black community are seven times more likely than any other race to commit murder and are eight times more likely to commit some kind of robbery. Also the best indicator of the crime levels in your community is the percentage of the population being black and

Legalized Abortion Essay

957 words - 4 pages abortion. Legalized abortion appears to be the reason for crime rates dropping 50 percent within the states. Crime rates began to drop a few years after abortion was first legalized in 1970. The few states that have passed legalized abortion first experienced the dropping in crime rates before the rest of the world. States that hold higher abortion rates in the 80’s hold lower crime rates in the 90’s (Donohue & Levitt, Doc 2). If

Abortion Rights Or Wrongs? Essay

3916 words - 16 pages actually died and lackof baptismal name were the reasons why abortionwas not a crime. (Terkel, 16)In 1670 an English Judge, Sir Matthew Hale, rules that if a woman died as a result of an abortion, the abortionist was guilty of murder. If she did not die, the abortion was legal. "In 1803, the first restrictive abortion statute was passed in England, called the Lord Ellenborough Act, it made it a crime to have an abortion after quickening, which is the