Abortion: Is It Possible To Be Both Pro Life And Pro Choice? Carl Sagan And Ann Druyan

1032 words - 4 pages

In this paper, I will investigate the right to life for embryo based on Carl Sagan and Ann Druyan’s article “Abortion: Is it Possible to be both “Pro-life” and “Pro-Choice”?” My conclusion is an embryo is a potential person thus it has the right to life. Sagan and Druyan argue that embryo does not have human characteristics; therefore it is acceptable to abort it. I will show that embryo is at least a potential person, so it has the right to life.
First, I want to convince embryo may not be a person. If “person” here, means biologically a member of human beings, then after 14 days when primitive streak or after 16 days when gastrulation (Damschen, Gómez-Lobo and Schönecker), an embryo is certainly a person, because at this point, the process of individualization is irreversible. At this time, the embryo can be determined as an individual human being. From this I believe that an embryo is a person in biological meaning after 14 or 16 days. However, the definition of “person” given by Boethius is “naturæ rationalis individua substantia” (Boethius 74). What it means is that if someone who does not have rational yet or permanently loses it, it is uncertain that is the one a person. Form Boethius’s view, I argue that embryo may not be a person. It may be a potential person. On the other hand, if “person” means a person who has personhood, the problem is another matter. Mary Anne Warren suggests the concept of personhood (Warren):
1) Consciousness (of objects and events external and/or internal to the being), and in particular the capacity to feel pain;
2) Reasoning (the developed capacity to solve new and relatively complex problems);
3) Self-motivated activity (activity which is relatively independent of either genetic or direct external control);
4) The capacity to communicate, by whatever means, messages of an indefinite variety of types, that is, not just with an indefinite number of possible contents, but on indefinitely many possible topics;
5) The presence of self-concepts, and self-awareness, either individual or racial, or both.
So far I assert that an individual who has personhood may not be a human beings or a human being may not have personhood, the individual could be another species, or even beyond existence. This means some human beings in biological definition are not essentially a person. For example, hydatidiform mole, anencephalic, Siamese twins, even fetus-in-fetu, or some fetuses develop to a certain stage but discontinue, and even some patient in brain-dead state(unlike vegetative), all of them can be known biologically as human beings, but they would not be considered as a person since they do not have rational.
Notably, even in today’s general understanding, avoid using substance or essence of rationality to talk about the person, instead with the way does the object have rational function, to determine whether it has the personhood. However the concept of personhood, in fact, is inseparable from the meaning of some kind of...

Find Another Essay On Abortion: Is it Possible to be both Pro-life and Pro-Choice? Carl Sagan and Ann Druyan

Abortion: Pro-life vs. pro-choice Essay

1278 words - 5 pages daypro-lifers, and pro-choicers will be able to merge and find a commonground on the issue. That day is probably not in the near future, butI know it will come. It will always be highly debatable because it isa moral issue, with so many things tied into it, and so many argumentsto be made. Until that common ground on abortion is found I willcontinue to stand up for the pro-choice cause.Source Page1. www.prolifeactivists.org2. Mathewes, Frederica. First national conference of the commongroundnetwork for life and choice. Madison, Wi. June. 1986.3. www.prochoiceaction.org

Abortion: Pro-Life Or Pro Choice. Essay

1019 words - 4 pages an infant, child or adult. In cases where the baby s life is threatened due to unwanted or unplanned pregnancies, alternative solutions to abortion such as adoption and family parenting should be considered. The protection of all innocent human beings should be honoured as a courageous life choice to be supported by our society. Pro-lifers sees life from the starts with conception view , therefore when abortion occurs in a case of rape and incest

Abortion: Pro-Life vs. Pro-Choice

783 words - 3 pages life, and don't end up making it. I am not saying that choosing abortion over having a child is the right thing to do, I solely believe that the people who choose abortion, choose it for what they believe to be the right reasons. They know that they cannot, either emotionally, mentally, or financially support the child the way it is should be supported.My final argument is that of biblical passages. Often, Christian or Catholic pro-lifers make

Pro-Life: Abortion is Unethical and Immoral

2023 words - 8 pages personal choice and right to decide whether she has an abortion, after all, it involves her body, health and future. These enthusiast believe that in most, if not all situations, abortion should be legal. For instance, when a woman or an unborn child’s life is in danger and if the fetus has an acute congenital disorder or birth defects they consider abortion necessary. They believe that abortion is justifiable in the case of rape, incest and in

Abortion and Pregnancy: Pro Life

1474 words - 6 pages child, one half say they do not want to be a single parent or are having problems with their husband or partner, and three fourths of women said, having a baby would interfere with work, school, or other responsibilities (“Facts About Abortion: U.S. Abortion Statistics.”). None of these statistics should be acceptable reasons for a woman to kill a life growing inside of her. Although abortion has been made legal, it is still a highly debated

This essay is about abortion. It uses many quotes from doctors and scientists arguing pro-choice.

1894 words - 8 pages result of a discussion about abortion. When forming an opinion about abortion one needs to consider every possible proof that medical science supplies. Since medical science has proven that the fetus is not human through many statements, then "There is nothing wrong in taking control over one's reproductive life" (Welton in Cozic & Tipp, 1991, p.127). Practicing abortion is a freedom of choice and that is the most important human right. Abortion is not a murder. A murder would be killing a born, unwanted child when a woman was forced to bear it.

Abortion: Pro-Choice is the Wrong Choice

828 words - 3 pages experience psychological damage due to aborting the child, and the woman is ending a human life. The first reason abortions should not be allowed is because the woman could get breast cancer after having the abortion. According to Hern (2006) “In medical practice, there are few surgical procedures given so little attention and so underrated in its potential hazards as abortion ,and it is a commonly held view that complications are inevitable” (pg

Pro choice vs pro life

1176 words - 5 pages effect on the American culture in the twentieth and the twenty-first centuries. Ultimately, Page comes to the conclusion that “abortion isn’t the keystone issue anymore. It’s birth control and, more to the point, Americans’ sex lives”(3) that the pro-lifers are going after. Page’s book effectively illustrates the challenges between the pro-life movement and the pro-choice movement and their impacts that have shaped America to be the way it is

Pro Life or Pro Choice

1585 words - 6 pages choice on whether or not she wants to carry a pregnancy to term. So many questions are raised when it comes to this matter. Is having an abortion is right or wrong? To me abortion is every women's right. Pro-life will argue statement such as abortion is murder, if a woman is willing to have sex, she's knowingly taking the risk of getting pregnant, and should be responsible for her actions, adoption is a viable alternative to abortion, and rape

Pro-Choice Abortion

1402 words - 6 pages abortions. Roe vs. Wade is considered today, to be an avant-garde decision, exemplifying ?judicial activism?. One important topic debated by many pro-choice and pro-lifers, is: at what point does a fetus become human? This is one of the determining factors of the controversy surrounding abortion. Pro-life activists claim that life begins at conception, stressing the idea that a human embryo is self-developing. And since it cannot become anything

Abortion: Pro-choice

510 words - 2 pages procedure unless keeping the baby presents a medical risk to the mother. Even in these situations abortions are very risky after sixteen weeks. The moral question has always been whether or not it should be a woman’s decision to get an abortion. The other side of that question is whether the government should have control over a woman’s body and forbid her to get an abortion. Both the pro-life and the pro-choice supporters on this issue are

Similar Essays

This Is A Discursive Essay On Abortion, Describing The Views Of Both Pro Choice And Pro Life Groups.

799 words - 3 pages the foetus is living, it has rights and therefore abortion qualifies as a killing. They say that if the woman did not want to have a child, she should not have had unprotected sex and so it is her own fault and she must bear the brunt of it. If your mother had decided to abort, you would not be here now.But pro-choice groups say that just because the woman got pregnant by mistake or without realising the consequences does not mean that she should

The Point Of Views Of Abortion Both Pro Life And Pro Choice.

1610 words - 6 pages for abortion).Pro-life supporters believe that abortion should be illegal. To them abortion is a crime because you kill the fetus, which in their eyes it is a future living human. Christians are a majority of the pro-life supporters. Their point of view is that in God's eyes, a fetus is a living child. Pro-choice supporters believe that abortion should be legal, because it is their choice and no one else's choice. America's given freedom makes them

Abortion A View From The Pro Choice And Pro Life

1765 words - 7 pages ground. It must be noted that neither the pro-choice or pro-life arguments are homogenous; neither side can agree fully when a woman should have access to an abortion. When it comes to my opinion as to whether abortion is right or wrong, I often find myself fluctuating between both sides of the issues. I agree that abortion is wrong after the 20th week when the neural structure starts to develop and the fetus can start to feel pain. I do not see

Abortion Should Abortion Be Acceptable? Discussion Of Both Sides Of The Issue: Pro Life Or Pro Choice?

878 words - 4 pages One of the most controversial questions of all time is abortion. Is it morally acceptable to have an abortion? There are two main views on abortion, "pro-life" and "pro-choice". Someone who is "pro-life" believes that from the time of conception, the fetus is alive. They believe that the fetus deserves to live, and to kill it would be murder. Someone who is pro-choice believes that the decision to abort a pregnancy is that of the mother, and no