About Ethics Essay

8550 words - 34 pages

WHY ETHICS MATTERS:
A DEFENSE OF ETHICS IN BUSINESS ORGANIZATIONS
Manuel Velasquez
Abstract: I argue that Plato was right in claiming that justice is more profitable,
more rational, and more intrinsically valuable than injustice, and
that this is particularly true for business organizations. The research on
prisoners' dilemmas and social dilemmas shows that ethical behavior is
more profitable and more rational than unethical behavior in terms of
both the negative sanctions on unethical behavior when interactions
with stakeholders are iterated, and the positive rewards of habitually
ethical behavior when stakeholders can identify those who are predisposed
to be ethical. In addition, the psychological research on justice
shows that justice is intrinsically valued, both from an outcome and from
a process perspective, and so crucial for business organizations, particularly
in terms of organizational effectiveness.
In an article in the Harvard Business Review Amar Bhide and Howard H.
Stevenson write that "Treachery, we found, can pay," and "There is no
compelling economic reason to tell the truth or keep one's word."^ Bhide and
Stevenson are not the first to suggest that unethical behavior may be more
profitable than ethical behavior. Over two thousand years ago, exactly the
same claim was made by Thrasymachus, a character in Plato's Republic who
concluded that while justice is for the simpleton, injustice is for the wise:
[Socrates:] Well, then, Thrasymachus... suppose you begin at the
beginning and answer me. You say that being perfectly
unjust is more profitable than being perfectly just?
[Thrasymachus:]Yes, that is what I say, and I have given you my reasons...
I affirm injustice to be profitable and justice not...
[Socrates:] And would you call justice a vice?
[Thrasymachus:] No, I would rather say it is a sublime simplicity.
[Socrates:] Then would you call injustice malignity?
[Thrasymachus:]No; I would rather say discretion.
[Socrates:] And do the unjust appear to you to be wise and good?
[Thrasyniachus:jYes.^
As readers of Plato's Republic know, Plato's aim in the Republic is to show
that Thrasymachus is wrong, that injustice is neither more profitable nor more
rational than injustice.
In their article, however, Bhide and Stevenson are on the side of Thrasymachus.
They assert that their claims are based on the empirical data provided
©1996 Business Ethics Quarterly, Volume 6, Issue 2. ISSN 1052-150X. 0201-0222.
202 BUSINESS ETHICS QUARTERLY
by "extensive interviews." It is unclear just what this data is supposed to be,

since they do not bother to provide it in their article. Perhaps they think that the
readers of the Harvard Business Review might not be up to plowing through
tables of numbers and statistics. Instead, what they provide are anecdotes and
snippets of conversations taken, apparently, from their interviews with a variety
of business people. These business people describe incidents where dishonesty
or broken promises paid off...

Find Another Essay On about ethics

This is about progressive refom in the 1800's thru 1900's. It includes topic about politial , social and economic reforms like child labor, and work ethics

1092 words - 4 pages immigrants entering America, looking for jobs and a better life wound up working in factories amongst horrible working conditions, long hours, and low pay. These dirty little secrets about immigrant life were exposed by a muckraker, Upton Sinclair, in his novel " The Jungle", published in 1906. The book did have a powerful impact on the public, they were more concerned with the consumer questions the book raised rather then the exploitation of the lower

This is an essay I wrote for a porfessional ethics class about home schooling and its effects on childrens social behavior

661 words - 3 pages children. As a recent research study, done by Dr. Brian Ray, shows: "On average, home schooler's outperformed their public school peers on standard achievement tests by 30 to 37 percentile points across the board on all subjects."("Home Schooling Achievement," pars. 1). To say the least, this is incredible data. As for college enrollment of home schooled children, it rates about the same as public schools, however, (as expected) home schooled children

Professional Ethics and Values

1302 words - 5 pages and play a vital role in our lives. But what do values and ethics exactly mean? The following material defines each of them.Definition of Ethics and ValuesWe all know the golden rule, which is: "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." Ethics help people think about what is right and wrong. Everybody starts learning ethics at a very young age for example, at home, in kindergarten, later in school or/and church and so on. The

Ethics Code of Conduct in a Company

939 words - 4 pages program, attendees shall sign a statement confirming they have completed the training and have their personnel files updated. The ethics training program shall be reviewed on a periodic basis to ensure it remains fresh, accurate, and meaningful in service to all elected and appointed officials, employees and volunteers of Company X. Policy Assistance Questions about the Ethics Policy, or other ethical concerns, can be addressed to the Human Resources

The Development Of Ethical Behavior

1098 words - 5 pages True Diversity: Ethics Development, Understanding, and ApplicationWoody Allen was quoted as saying, "Good people seem to sleep better at night, but bad people appear to enjoy their waking hours more." How does this statement affect you? Do you sleep well at night? Ethics have a being on almost everything we do and think of doing. What is ethics? And how do they come about?Ethics refers to the study and development of one's ethical standards

Personal Ethics

848 words - 3 pages she are concerned about his or her relationships and personal reputations. As we go through this paper, we will focus on answering what are ethics, what are your ethics, where do your ethics come from, and how do you manifest your ethics? What are ethics? Let us start off with the definition of ethics. Ethics can be defined with more than one meaning. In philosophy, ethics is the study and evaluation of human conduct in the light of moral

changing ethics

993 words - 4 pages CHANGING ETHICSPersonal ethics is an individual's belief about morality or conscience .It defines one's stand on what is right or wrong.This branch of ethics gradually develops since childhood and tend to emulate the things which are set as an moral value to us by our parents or guardians in the family. It can heavily be influenced from any major incident in our life.Personal ethics refers to the ethics that a person identifies with in respect

ethics

767 words - 4 pages a business to have ethics is because if they on’t have ethics the customers wouldn’t like to go to the business.Ethics apply for customers,schools,and stores.Ethics apply on customers because if the customers didn’t have any good thing about them.For an example if an employee is working in an office and the employee has ethics they would be asking their boss if they need anything or want them to do something.Ethics apply to school because if a

Ethics in the Workplace

885 words - 4 pages An Ethics Toolkit for ManagersEthics in business is a concept that has come to mean various things to various people, but it is generally based on the principle of doing what is right in the workplace. Business ethics is about prioritizing moral values for the workplace and ensuring behaviors are aligned with those values. Many view business ethics as value management. Leaders and managers can use ethics as a tool to ensure morality at times of

Business Ethics

2216 words - 9 pages sounds simple, it is easier said than done! There will always be a conflict of interest between various groups of people. Any decisions made by businesses need to be made with an informed awareness of the specific situation and then act according to some sort of system of principals which is Business Ethics. In my report I will talk about business ethics, provide the benefits of ethics and the implications of ethics to a company's stakeholders.What

Alahmad and Murphy on Business Ethics

1049 words - 4 pages work. Finally, he mentioned that he did not conduct an extensive review of the literary works at best his writings should be used as subjective information only. Murphy wrote about responsibility being at the atomic structure level as it relates to ethics. Murphy did an examination on some 2008 articles that were presented at a Notre Dame Ethical Dimension of Research Conference and how the responsibility was the crux of all the articles. In

Similar Essays

In This Paper There Are Five Questions Asked And Answered About The Stanford Experiment Conducted In 1971. The Questions Are About The Ethics Of The Experiment

2135 words - 9 pages Discuss the ethics of the Stanford Prison Experiment. In your answer, be sure to touch on the parts of the experiment that may be considered unethical, why the study was conducted the way it was and what was done to protect the subjects, and whether you feel that under the current ethical guidelines this study could be conducted today.Ethics is thought of as a moral principle, or what should be right. The experiment that took place in the summer

This Is A Critique Of A Speech Given By Spiro Agnew In Des Moines About Journalism Ethics

589 words - 2 pages . Without backing the President is just a fool in an oval office. Agnew's mistake in his Des Moines speech was addressing his concerns as accusations, Instead of focusing on the positive things American media could do to support the President, he focuses on past transgressions.Agnew does not want censorship, he is adamant about that, he just wants to censor that which doesn't portray the Nixon administration positively. Following these standards

An Essay About Ethics Of Cloning

821 words - 3 pages CLONINGWe are living in the era of technology, due to this, science is improving very fast. Science has a lot of branches and most of them are affected by this technology. Genetic engineering is one of them. It is very popular nowadays. The main aim of it is to make better animal and plant species for the benefits of human being and to cure illness genetically. Cloning is the one of the ways that brings genetic engineering to its aim. Cloning

This Essay Is About The Role Of Ethics And Social Responsibility In Management

1122 words - 4 pages Principles of ManagementDec. 15, 2001A Role of Ethics and Social Responsibilities in Management.Ethics can be defined as a process of evaluating actions according to moral principal of values (A.Alhemoud). Throughout the centuries people were trying to choose between profit and moral. Perhaps, some of them obtain both, but every time it could have roused ethical issues. Those issues concern fairness, justice, rightness or wrongness; as a result