This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Abraham Trial Essay

1039 words - 4 pages

The trial that Carol Delaney witnessed has brought about a new light on the interpretation of law and religion. This trial has a basis on not only murder of one's child, but on a possible link to the "Tempting Of Abraham" in the book of Genesis. This trial compares the separation between the evil deed committed and the religious motivation to do so. It raises the question, how can a secular legal system deal with this case? To understand the jury's decision, one must recognize the crime and its purpose.In the first phase of the trial, the defendant and prosecutor were trying to decide the severity of the crime. They were hung between a decision of either first-degree murder or manslaughter. The grand jury decided that the death penalty was not a factor in this trial. Therefore, the terms for the defendant were either a hefty jail sentence or plausible case to plea insanity. The defense chose the latter, so that they might contend with the possibility of not having to serve in prison and being released every six months. The idea behind why they chose to enter a plea of not guilty is to defend Cristos Valenti's beliefs and to prove them to the court, along with a lighter sentence. Their argument was centered around his following the word and orders of God. Even though in a moral and legal sense he understood his actions to be wrong, he still could not fathom disobeying God's calling. The problem is that the court will not follow a religious notion, as this trial is a direct correlation with the story of Abraham and Isaac. Nearing the end of the discussion, the jury decided on a verdict of first-degree murder. This shocked the defense, because it was clearly a case of manslaughter on the basis of no inclusive malice. Personally, I believe that the decision on first-degree murder does not relate to this trial. As we know, Valenti was only answering the word of God and following his orders. As shown by the testimonials of his children "he was a good father, was always there, did a lot of family things, was not strict and didn't hit them" (Delaney 55) he knew the repercussions of his actions and would never have done such a thing. The fact that there was no malicious intent should point directly to manslaughter. Since they cannot change what the jury's verdict was, they decided to plead insanity.Throughout the trial, the defense of Valenti was based on his mental state at the time of the murder. It was difficult to see him as insane, because he functioned normally in everyday life. "The psychiatrist said he suffered from religious delusion"(Delaney 57), since he clearly believed that God had told him to commit this act. The trial complicated itself even more when they introduced the fact that he killed his daughter and not his son, as Abraham did. Not to mention that Abraham did not actually kill his son, because God stayed his hand. The question was raised as to why Valenti did not stay his hand, which was...

Find Another Essay On Abraham Trial

Abraham and Isaac: Was God’s Command Moral?

1968 words - 8 pages “Abraham…Take your son Isaac, your only one, whom you love, and go to the land of Moriah. There you shall offer him up as a holocaust on a height that I will point out to you.” Genesis 22:2 Thus, Abraham, with perfect faith and trust in the Lord, sets out the next follow the commandment of God. This is the beginning of one of the most intriguing and horrific stories in the Old Testament. A man willing to kill his only son because he

Abraham Lincoln Essay

2331 words - 10 pages Abraham Lincoln How well do we know all the little details of Abraham Lincoln’s life? Abe had a lot of things in his life that we don’t know about or focus on. Either we don’t see it as something important or we don’t know a lot about it. Something we don’t focus on is that a lot of mourning time happened in Lincoln’s life as a child and teen. During his early politics, he let some things from his childhood and teen years shape the way he acted

How Great is "The Great Emancipator"?

753 words - 4 pages Great Emancipator”. Works Cited Bio. "Abraham Lincoln - The Emancipation Proclamation." YouTube. YouTube, 14 Nov. 2012. Web. 22 May 2014. . Foner, Eric. The Fiery Trial: Abraham Lincoln and American Slavery. New York: W. W. Norton, 2010. Print. US National Park Service. "Lincoln on Slavery." National Parks Service. U.S. Department of the Interior, 07 May 2014. Web. 22 May 2014. .

Theodor Herzl vs Rabbi Abraham Isaac Hacohen Kook

1135 words - 5 pages 1894, Captain Alfred Dreyfus was accused of treason just because he was Jewish. This was a big court case so Theodor Herzl was sent to Paris to cover the case for the Neue Freie Presse. While there, he and the other newspaper correspondents realized how unfair the case was. It was clear that Dreyfus was not guilty and that he was put on trial due to anti- Semitism. Before the Dreyfus Affair, Herzl was a secular Jew who did not strongly identify

Analyzing Chasing Lincoln's Killer by James L. Swanson

1105 words - 4 pages Trent Sawicki Samuelson Honors Civics and Economics 20 March 2014 Book Assignment 1: Chasing Lincoln’s Killer The book Chasing Lincoln’s Killer is about the world famous story of assassinating President Abraham Lincoln. This book takes the reader into the lives and minds of the four main conspirators responsible for the assassination of Abraham Lincoln and the attempted assassination of the Vice President, Andrew Johnson , and the Secretary of

The Assassination of President Lincoln

1676 words - 7 pages Networks Television, n.d. Web. 06 Dec. 2013. "Lincoln Papers: Lincoln Assassination: Introduction." Lincoln Papers: Lincoln Assassination: Introduction. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Jan. 2014. “ O' Reilly, Bill. Lincoln's Last Days. N.p.: n.p., n.d. Print. "Facts about Abraham Lincoln." Facts about Abraham Lincoln. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Jan. 2014. "The Trial of the Lincoln Assassination Conspirators." The Trial of the Lincoln Assassination Conspirators. N.p

The Meaning of Faith

1833 words - 7 pages greater than the tragic hero, "not by being exempted in any way from distress and the agony and the paradox, but became greater by means of these"(Kirkegaard, p.65). Abraham is not going through a "spiritual trial" (Kirkegaard, p.56) but he is being tested. His test is the temptation by the ethical. If he could express himself and his dilemma, he would find himself in a spiritual trial and in the universal. Abraham makes the movement of faith by

American Civil War

1249 words - 5 pages The Civil War was the worst war in American history. More Americans died in this war than World War 1 and 2. The events that lead up to the Civil War show that it was a conflict that was going to arise no matter what happened. Abraham Lincoln was vital to the outcome of the Civil War. Lincoln was born in 1809. Lincoln’s whole family were opposed to slavery considering it cruel and evil. Lincoln’s mother died when he was young. Even

Mary Surratt and the Death Penalty

3346 words - 13 pages “She kept the nest that hatched the rotten egg.” President Johnson was referring to Mary Surratt when he declared this. Who is Mary Surratt? Not many people would be able to answer this question however, many people would be able to explain who John Wilkes Booth was if they were asked. He was the man who assassinated Abraham Lincoln. Well, Mary Surratt was a middle-aged woman during the civil war, and was wrongly accused of assisting in the plot

Mary Surratt: An American Secret

1984 words - 8 pages , and then acquitted of all charges in his role in the assassination of Abraham Lincoln. In John Surratt’s trial, the legitimacy of two of the main witness testimonies against himself and his mother, including that of her tenant Mr. Lloyd, came into question. Later on, memoirs, diaries, autobiographies, and the like that emerged all seem to show Mary Surratt’s innocence in the crimes she was accused of committing. It is likely that the reaction to

The Injustice of Slavery

425 words - 2 pages country, we brought them here. We are the ones to blame. Yet, they have to pay. If you were a black man and had a trial with a white jury, you will probably be guilty. If you are a black man, many white people will try to steer clear of you, or look at you in a funny way. How did slaves actually become free, you might be asking yourself. It all began with a man named Abraham Lincoln, he wanted to set slaves free. But the southern

Similar Essays

Kierkegaard And Abraham: A Literary Tool And Belief In The Ideal Christian Existentialist

1690 words - 7 pages allegiance. Kierkegaard argues that Abraham’s very actions of not showing remorse or hesitation up until the last seconds of his trip up the mountain with Isaac are proof of his perfection as a knight of faith. Kierkengaard describes his views of Abraham’s actions when he states, “Not so with Abraham. For him a harder trial was reserved; along with the knife the fate of Isaac was put into Abraham’s own hand. And as he stood there, the old man with

A Call To The Task: The Attunement Of Fear And Trembling

1767 words - 7 pages In the “Attunement” of Soren Kierkegaard’s Fear and Trembling, the author produces four beautiful variations on God’s temptation of Abraham in Genesis 22. In each, Abraham fails at his test in some way; even though in each he offers his son, he misses the full movements of philosophy and faith that the true Abraham completed. Each is closed by a brief image of a child being weaned, presumably a metaphor of the past story. Characteristically

Assassinating Lincoln Essay

1647 words - 7 pages Abraham Lincoln, one of the most recognizable presidents, was widely known for abolishing slavery and ending the civil war, but what is unknown is the true story behind his assassination. History books teach that Lincoln was assassinated by John Wilkes Booth, but it was who hired Booth that is the true mystery. Booth, along with multiple other co-conspirators was highly successful in assassinating the sixteenth president, but he had received

Comparison Between Merchant Of Venice And The Bible

2041 words - 8 pages Hagar, the first son of Abraham) were the Arabs. It seems, then, that this reference is actually incorrect, since it is very likely that Launcelot is Venetian just like the rest of the characters. This assumption is probably justified, because as we see in the trial scene, the "Turks and Tartars" (Muslims and Mongols) were seen as even "worse" than Jews, indicating that it is unlikely that Launcelot's presence would have been much tolerated in