This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Acceptance And Commitment Therapy Versus Cognitive Therapy For The Treatment Of Comorbid Eating Pathology

579 words - 3 pages

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy versus Cognitive Therapy for the Treatment of Comorbid Eating Pathology
Critiquing a Scientific Article

Introduction
This article aims to prove that Acceptance and Commitment is the best method for treating eating disorders. Although Cognitive Behavior Therapy has shown some promising results. It supports this claim by stating that Cognitive Therapy is an effective treatment for bulimia and was given a grade A by the National Institute for Clinical Effectiveness Guidelines. The authors are aiming to determine which is an effective method, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) or Cognitive Behavior Treatment (CBT). Although, it is a new theory it has proven very effective. Scientific studies of CBT have confirmed its effectiveness for a wide variety of mental illnesses including mood disorders, anxiety disorders, personality disorders, eating ...view middle of the document...

Then they learn to change their slanted thinking. When they think more realistically, they feel better. The emphasis is also consistently on solving problems and starting a new behavioral change.

Article Summary
This article highlights the advantages of ACT versus CBT. The results of the 55 participants in a study determining which one is more effective. Through many tests and studies it shown that ACT is more effective at reducing the eating pathology, but only for those with a more severe eating pathology. In the discussion the authors alluded to the fact that even though ACT is a more effective therapy than CBT. The reason being is that ACT deals with the core issues that are usually associated with eating pathology. ACT understands that the patient needs to learn to understand their body shape, food or weight and encourage a desire to chance their particular mindset in regards to their eating habits.

Analysis
The increasing popularity of ACT in recent years has begun to draw the attention and scrutiny of proponents of traditional of CBT many of whom have expressed skepticism about the approach. In recent articles and book chapters, some critics have argued that ACT offers relatively minor variations compared with traditional CBT, as does this article. CBT is an alternative that should be used alongside with ACT as it has equal if not the same results as CBT.

Conclusion
The article states that ACT is more effecting at treating eating disorders, but I believe that ACT and CBT can be used hand in hand in treating these disorders. ACT incorporates acceptance strategies, mindfulness techniques, and a wide range of behavioral approaches already known to be effective from CBT. ACT is similar to the CBT tradition in the sense that it focuses on the person's relationship to experiences rather than on the content of these experiences. The data on ACT and related approaches are indicating that CBT is a new model that emphasizes being open, centered, and mindful and actively pursuing values. This is what is needed to accurately solve these eating disorders.

Find Another Essay On Acceptance and Commitment Therapy versus Cognitive Therapy for the Treatment of Comorbid Eating Pathology

Comparing the efficacy of Cognitive Therapy and Antidepressant Medication in the Treatment of Depression

1746 words - 7 pages guidelines of The Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, resulting in medications becoming generally favored at the time. These results, the quality of the therapy provided as well as the conclusions drawn have, however, been questioned by contradicting research which instead argue that cognitive therapy is just as effective in the treatment of depression. Hollon et al (1992) conducted a randomized trial which displayed both treatment methods as

Cognitive Therapy Essay

805 words - 3 pages Cognitive therapy operates on the belief that the way you think affects the way you feel and behave. If a therapist challenges a client's irrational thoughts and replaces them with rational ways of thinking, the client will feel better and behave in ways that promote healthy living. In order to change unhealthy ways of thinking to healthier ones, the client must first recognize unhealthy thoughts. Homework therapy is a form of cognitive

Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy: Treatment of Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder

2056 words - 9 pages Effectiveness of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Personality Disorders. The Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 33(3), 657–685. doi:10.1016/j.psc.2010.04.007 McGinn, L. K., & Sanderson, W. C. (2001). What Allows Cognitive Behavioral Therapy to Be Brief: Overview, Efficacy, and Crucial Factors Facilitating Brief Treatment. CPSP Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 8(1), 23–37. Pretzer, J., & Hampt, S. (1994). Cognitive Behavioural Treatment of

Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy: Treatment of Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder

1527 words - 7 pages IV: Moodiness, loss of brother Axis V: 61-70, mild difficulty in social, occupational, or school functioning. BUT, the person is generally functioning pretty well and has some meaningful interpersonal relationships. Goals of Treatment Although the patient displays symptoms of Axis I disorders (depression and anxiety), she is likely to benefit from cognitive behavior therapy with a focus on restructuring her maladaptive cognitions concerning self

Cognitive Behavior Therapy For PTSD

2607 words - 10 pages cognitive therapy to reduce the psychological symptoms related to thoughts, behavioral symptoms, and emotional symptoms of PTSD (Cukor et al., 2009). Therapists and patients work on identifying and changing thoughts and behaviors that are responsible for the persistent symptoms. All patients usually complete homework assignments to be discussed during the next session. Research shows that several CBT approaches have been successful in the treatment of

The effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy

2549 words - 10 pages . Meta-analyses can give answers to these and related questions. For some researchers, the importance of meta-analyses on cognitive behavioral therapy is clear, since it can give insight in the comparison on the treatment of different disorders with cognitive behavioral therapy (Rounsaville & Caroll, 2002). For others however, the importance of meta-analyses is not so clear; they state a meta-analysis cannot tell whether one form of

Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy and the Model of Human Occupation

3613 words - 14 pages together, the Model of Human Occupation and Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy give an explanation for this view of human behavior. These frames of reference are reviewed in regards to their conceptions of behavior, dysfunction, treatment approach, and their relevance to occupational therapy.Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy and the Model of Human OccupationMan is an open system that can change and develop through interaction with the environment. Behavior is

The Clinical Application of Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy

2765 words - 11 pages ). As an expert in the treatment of PTSD, Meichenbaum has treated all age groups for trauma suffered from violence, abuse, accidents, and illness. Meichenbaum describes seven essential tasks encompassing a cognitive-behavioral therapeutic approach, which he finds crucial for a successful outcome in all forms of psychotherapy. These tasks are described sequentially and they take place over the course of therapy; being addressed as the client and

The Role and Benefits of Dance as a Therapy for the Treatment of Mental Illness

3519 words - 14 pages integration and development.Although treatment for mental health follows the same aims as those for DMP, it has generally always involved a form of talking therapy such as counselling, cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) and psychology alongside the use of medication. Generally these treatments have a positive effect on patients but they have to be willing to comply with their therapist and often medication is introduced. Unlike Chace's idea of

Insomnia and Cognitive Behavior Therapy

2574 words - 10 pages patient is instructed to remain in bed only as long as he is actually sleeping, stimulus control no activities in the bedroom except sleep and sex, and a variety of relaxation methods, particularly in the circumstance of multimodal sleep clinics (Rowe, 1995). While sleeping medication is big business, research has shown that the most successful treatment for insomnia is really cognitive behavioral therapy. This approach to psychotherapy was first

Using Music Therapy in the Treatment of Stress and Anxiety

2260 words - 9 pages desired. Using Music Therapy in place of the more aggressive treatments for treating stress and anxiety may very well be an excellent option for those seeking a natural and gentle treatment. References Anderson, C. A., Carnagey, N. L., & Eubanks, J. (2003). Exposure to violent media: the effects of songs with violent lyrics on aggressive thoughts and feelings. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84, 4, 960–971

Similar Essays

Acceptance And Commitment Therapy Essay

1218 words - 5 pages Summary Researchers such as Hayes and Strosahl (2005) defines acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) as an empirically based intervention technique from the cognitive behavior model of psychotherapy that employs mindfulness and acceptance methods mixed in various ways. Grounded within the practical concept of functional contextualism and based on the comprehensive idea of language and cognition, ACT is different from the normal or

Pathology And Therapy Essay

1636 words - 7 pages a characteristic of the disorder.ANXIETY DISORDERScaused by a combination of biological and environmental factors and may develop from a complex set of risk factors, including genetics, brain chemistry, personality, and life eventspsychotherapy, cognitive-behavioral therapy, and medication therapy are effective treatmentsGeneralized Anxiety DisorderCharacterized by excessive, unrealistic worry that lasts six months or moreOther symptoms include

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy In The Treatment Of Depression

2447 words - 10 pages Cognitive Behavioral Therapy in the Treatment of Depression Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is a method of correcting invalid thought patterns to a more positive view of the person and their place in their world. Some people do not believe that Cognitive Behavioral Therapy is a real treatment for depression, claiming it is a form of positive thinking ("The Daily Mail," 2009). On the opposite end of the spectrum, others argue that Cognitive

The Integration Of Cognitive And Behavior Therapy

1644 words - 7 pages develops and changes (Kramer 293). The term “cognitive-behavioral therapy” or CBT is a term for therapies with many similarities. CBT is not used as a cure and often times used to help with anxiety or depression the most, and may be single or in group settings. There are several approaches to this form of therapy which include, Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy, Rational Behavior Therapy, Rational Living Therapy, Cognitive Therapy, and Dialectic