This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Acclaimed Court Decision On Aboriginal Title: Unprecedented Force On Canadian Politics, Law And Society

1776 words - 7 pages

"The ultimate measure of a man is not where he stands in the moment of comfort and convenience but where he stands at times ofchallenge and controversy"Martin Luther King (1963)In 1997 the Supreme Court Decision concerning Delgamuukw vs. British Columbia has influenced how Canada defined 'Aboriginal title' with content that hold legal precedence as it pertains to land issues raised and how the Court to apply and adapt the principles to 'aboriginal title' as 'distinct species' of constitutional Aboriginal rights. Understanding the challenges of Aboriginal people in Canada provides the opportunity to appreciate the history that has influenced Canadian law, politics and societal views of recognizing the rights of the 'original peoples' of the land. As described by Thomas Hobbes, the working in any political system depends largely on how all other, social and economic institutions which have shaped or might shape the people with whom and by whom the political system must operate. Prior Delgamuukw, Canada applied the Proclamation, otherwise known as the 'magna carta of Indian rights', in order to determine 'Aboriginal rights' 'treaty rights' or 'aboriginal title'.The Royal Proclamation 1763 is a timepiece which signifies the nature of relationship building between the 'original peoples' and Crown, unfortunately Canada's principles have continually been reconstructed to meet the societal needs as it relates to the social demands of accessing resources for economic benefits. As stated in the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples Report, Canadian government gradually accepted the idea of shared sovereignty, but loath the idea of handing over full reign of powers to genuinely support self-governing nations or the resources to make self-government a success " (1993). It is evident that after 200 years of contact, the paternalistic attitudes perpetuate the institutions of government. As a result, the issue of Delgamuukw, the province of British Columbia was exercising jurisdiction with the intent to extinguish 'Aboriginal title' and "aboriginal rights' based on the principles of terminology and interpretation.Wendy Moss describes contemporary land claims fundamentally have two elements, legal and factual. Comprehensive claims, should have legal element is that the claim outlines that unextinguished aboriginal title by demonstrating that that the territory in question is not covered by a treaty or a claim agreement that aboriginal title has not been extinguished by the Crown. The factual element must demonstrate traditional and, under current policy, continuing use and occupancy of the claimed territory by the claimant group since 'time immoral'.Canadian government issues of legitimacy pertaining Aboriginal people and their right to self-govern has been scrutinized by the state as it is seen to had often gone un-noticed or unaccredited. By far any decision on Aboriginal rights have undergone the judicial process and if successful would gain Supreme Court...

Find Another Essay On Acclaimed Court Decision on Aboriginal Title: Unprecedented Force on Canadian Politics, Law and Society

The Effects of French-English Relations on Canadian Politics

1042 words - 4 pages Throughout the years the French, although a minority, have had a profound impact on Canadian politics and the law through their relationship with English Canadians. This will be evident after examining these four definitive events in Canadian history: conscription in World War One, the Parti Québécois, the Manitoba School Question, and the language law that made it compulsory for all English schools to teach French.The Conscription

Do Politics have an Influence on the Supreme Court?

1915 words - 8 pages following along with things, because I truly believe that if it wasn’t proven right in the Constitution, then these who disagree with the Affordable Care Act would easily say, solely based on personal opinion, but that’s just not how things are ran in the courts. Immigration and the opinions the people vary throughout the country, but the decision goes to the Supreme Court on what to do about immigration and the law(s) the topic may come with

European Court of Justice decision on Marshall case

755 words - 4 pages Following the argument, which a directive may not rely in an action against an individual, it should be noted that according to Article 189 of the EEC Treaty, the obligatory structure of a directive that includes the ground for the probability of relying on the directive before municipal court, exists only in alliance to ‘each member state to which it is addressed’. Directive on its own may not be able to establish obligations on an individual

A Canadian Catastrophe: The Effect of Residential Schools on Aboriginal Parenting

1537 words - 7 pages diagnostic criteria for PTSD (Corrado and Cohen 2003). These high rates of PTSD, directly attributed to the trauma experienced within residential schools, provide strong evidence for a link between PTSD and the Canadian residential school system. The prevalence of PTSD has a direct impact on the absence of effective parenting skills in the Aboriginal community, as it often influences behaviors such as alcohol abuse and spousal abuse, which in

Aboriginal Women And The Canadian Justice Sysem

2597 words - 11 pages women: race, poverty, and disability. Feminist Issues: Race, Class, and Sexuality. 32 ? 66.Elizabeth Fry Society of Saskatchewan. 1992. Aboriginal Women in the Criminal Justice System, in Western Juical Education Centre on Racial, Ethnic, and Cultural Equity. Saskatoon:WJEC in: Henry, F., C.Tator, W.Mattis and T.Rees. 1995. The Colour of Democracy: Racism in Canadian Society. Harcourt & Brace; Toronto. 355 pp.Green, J. 2001. Canaries in the

Aboriginal history - on Keith Windschuttle's black and white fallacy

1122 words - 4 pages sources, and condemns others for using opposing sources, such as aboriginal oral history. 'Orthodox' historians argue that Windschuttle's method has given him a deliberate one sided view on the issue and Ryan has labelled him as an "opportunist" and a "propagandist", with his own "political agenda about the past"In the article given, Dennet states that "Windschuttle simply accepts a European perspective published in [the 1800's]" p13, and that this

The Effects of Entertaining Politics on American Society

2278 words - 9 pages read the news, however, does that mean they should? People will listen to those who hold great influence over a large number of the community around them. The negative outlook that the Daily Show and the Colbert Report has on political officials, opinions, and events can lead to a future with little participation in politics from the younger generation, as they age into a time where political involvement is critical for the democratic society

Government Law and Politics

1492 words - 6 pages as life and liberty. Neither government, nor law, nor elected officials can interfere with these privileges. Some of the rights retained by individuals are described in the Bill of Rights, which limits the powers of Congress. Other types of law include Common law. This consists of the customary practices created by past judicial decisions. After a court makes a decision, that decision becomes an example of what can be applied to similar cases

Politics and Criminal Law

1540 words - 6 pages Most Americans believe that criminal law drives criminal punishment. However, due to their lack of knowledge about the criminal system, they are wrong. At least according to a Harvard Law School Professor, William J. Stuntz. In his essay, The Pathological Politics of Criminal Law, he focuses on how criminal codes are misleading and filled with overlapping crimes. The rules are simply too broad, which often makes them morally wrong and socially

Morality, Law, and Politics

2128 words - 9 pages I can imagine a perfect world. A world where morality is of upmost importance in our dealings with each other, where morals are critically examined, and debated with reason as well as passion. This world would be a pinnacle of human achievement. A pinnacle that we are nowhere near. Why is this? Well, in today's society, morals are often associated with obeying the law, and since laws are legislated by politicians, they are subject to politics

Politics and Law

593 words - 3 pages unwillingness of law enforcement bodies to undertake criminal procedures and hold political parties criminally liable. There is some paradox in such state of affairs, because political parties have the highest responsibilities when governing state administrations, however, they bare very little responsibility when they abuse the given powers. The reason for this is that classical criminal law rejects the possibility of holding collectives

Similar Essays

Canadian Politics Aboriginal Politics In Canada

2856 words - 11 pages claims of the Aboriginal people. It was very evident with the occurrence of the Meech Lake Accord in 1987 that the Canadian political agenda did not seem to think that aboriginal rights were of any importance to Canadian society. The Meech Lake Accord's primary focus was on Quebec sovereignty and it completely ignored and failed to address any aboriginal interests. "It is not like the Aboriginal people did not make any proposals for changes in the

The Myriad Dynamics Of State Policies Shaping Canadian Aboriginal Society

1769 words - 8 pages knowledge of these issues do not often reach the national level as Eurocentric views on the issues segregate them to the margins of society. Canada has developed through policies and social constructions that have influenced Canadian lives in an uncountable number of ways. Thematically, Aboriginal issues have been at the center of that nation, from early contact to present day. Neoliberal ideals have continued to shape what are considered to be

How Issues Such As Immigration, Abortion, Specifically The Supreme Court Decision Of Roe V. Wade, And Flag Burning Have Divided American Society And How Decisions Or Comprimises Have Been Reached

682 words - 3 pages In recent years, there have been many issues that have divided American society. Opposing sides have presented strong arguments to support what they believe in, and attempts have been made to come to a solution or compromise for the decision. Such issues include immigration, abortion, specifically the Supreme Court decision of Roe v. Wade, and flag burning.From 1967-1990, American immigration underwent dramatic changes. The Immigration Act of

Solving Foreclosure On An Unprecedented Scale

2005 words - 8 pages We are not in a crisis. Foreclosure is business as usual. The only difference in the Great Recession of the Early 21st Century is its occurrence on such an unprecedented scale, thanks to the invisible hand of the unregulated market attempting to correct itself. Congress has attempted to show some compassion with moratorium legislation, too little too late. But this is politics as usual: put out the fires that little Wall Street starts, but