This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

According To Socrates, Should You Obey An Unjust Law?

685 words - 3 pages

Q: “According to Socrates, should you obey an unjust law?”

Convicted For Living?

Do we have an obligation to obey any law, no matter how unjust or evil, provided only that it is in fact a valid rule of the legal system in which we happen to be physically located? In the following composition, I am going to examine the answer to this question in accordance to what Socrates believes. The best way to understand this almost “WWSD” (What Would Socrates Do) approach is by looking at Socrates' actions in the three Platonic dialogues we have read. These dialogues bring forth three possible bases for why Socrates believes one should obey the law. First, that there is a distinction between the the “justness” of a law and how that law is applied. Second, that if one willingly accepts living in a society, it is implied that he is also accepting the rules that that society abides to. And third, that even if the law in question is unjust or applied unjustly, it would impious to correct this injustice by not adhering to it; an unjust action in itself.

In the Apology we find out that Socrates is being indicted by Meletus on the grounds that he is corrupting Athens' youth with his teachings. Socrates was tried before a judge and jury panel of 500 or 501 members, found guilty, and sentenced to death. At no point during the proceedings did Socrates deny that corrupting the youth was a criminal act punishable by death. Socrates in fact believes that it is noble to prosecute those who corrupt the minds of the youth. Moreover, in the Euthyphro Dialogue, Socrates even praises Meletus saying that, “He [Meletus] is the only one who begins at the right point in his political reforms; for his first care is to make the young men as good as possible” (2). Therefore while Socrates may not have necessarily agreed with the verdict of his trial, he did agree with the essence and/or idea of what the law that he “broke” was founded on.

Socrates was accused of corrupting the...

Find Another Essay On According to Socrates, Should you Obey an Unjust Law?

What Does Unjust Mean to You

1606 words - 7 pages treated in the same situation.” When you apply the rule you’d have to imagine yourself on the receiving end of the action. If you act a way towards someone and are unwilling to be treated that way under the same circumstance than you violate this rule, thus making it an unjust action. That includes having that other person’s likes and dislikes in mind. Of course I do believe there are levels to it, a murder isn’t on par with stealing your

Is there a moral obligation to obey the law?

2788 words - 11 pages an obligation because of the bad consequences to society if people did not obey. Hobbes states that a law is to be obeyed; even it is unjust because the alternative is a 'state of nature'. What he means is that if people do not use a system of guidance, a fixed set of rules, there will be chaos and anarchy, just like there will be crashes in a country without a traffic code. It is 'moral' to want to avoid this situation of chaos. Also, people not

Moral Law According To Kant

553 words - 2 pages Moral Law According To Kant      Immanuel Kant was a deontologist from Germany in the eithteenth century. He believed that the only test of whether a decision is right or wrong is whether it could be applied to everyone. Would it be all right for everyone to do what you are doing? If not, your decision is wrong. It would be wrong, for example, to make a promise with the intention of breaking it because if everyone did that, no one would

What according to Socrates is a just city

1337 words - 5 pages According to Socrates a just city where most of the population is virtuous, because a just city is based on the virtues of wisdom, moderation, and courage. The reason the city came into existence was for justice, not pleasure and happiness. Wisdom and good judgment are based upon knowledge. Also, Socrates examines the effect of wealth on craftsmen, and states that if a potter gets rich, he will not be concerned for his craft and will become lazy

"THE BEARD." Shaving according to Jewish law

1025 words - 4 pages those that do not resemble a razor) or through depilatories (hair removal through medicine). This is due to the law of Payos Hazakain, "Neither shall you mar the corners of your beard."B. Those who remove their beards transgress the Torah law of, "A man shall not wear the garment of a woman." Some authorities hold that this brings with it a punishment of Malkos (lashing). This reason applies even to those who cut their beard with a scissors.C

Courage, Virtue, and the Immortality of the Soul: According to Socrates

2174 words - 9 pages Charmides, 199D)? The simple answer to this question is no. The definition that was suggested by Socrates for the definition of courage has become the definition of virtue. “Then the thing you are now talking about, Nicias, would seem not be a part of virtue but rather virtue entire” (Laches and Charmides, 199E). To summarize, for a person to be virtuous, he or she must have knowledge of all goods and evils, according to the definition put forth

Ethics According to Natural Law - Aquinas's and Augustine's Views

1139 words - 5 pages both dynamics and content to exist. An act must be the function of both the intelligence and the will. Intelligence requires acts to be true and the will demands that the act be good. The total good of man is tended toward by the will. Truth is the end of the intellect and love is the end of the will. Natural Law is the divine order by which all rational beings are on a course to achieve their potential.Acts are viewed as good if they conform to

Antigone, Tragedy and Law versus Desire according to Lacant

549 words - 2 pages the agony, the heartbreaking agonies of our lives.' 'I am no-one, nothing'.Lacant's ReadingThe play is about law versus desire. Antigone's desire, according to Lacant, 'visibly eminates from the eyes of this admirable girl'.When Antigone makes the decision to bury her brother she steps outside Lacant's symbolic order of the law and into the law of her own desire.Lacant says of Antigone that she is 'a noble embodiment to the natural laws of desire

Puppy Love: Things You Should Consider Before Bringing an Animal to Your Home

925 words - 4 pages When thinking about purchasing a puppy, it is something that you should definitely take some time to consider. Bringing in a new animal is a very huge commitment. You are choosing to care and give love unconditionally to that animal. Although you get to go out on your own and see the world, the animals don’t get that option, so you are their world. Getting a puppy is beneficial but also costly and difficult at times. Before purchasing an

Why you should go to Brazil!

1330 words - 5 pages Topic: Brazil: Country of MysterySpecific Purpose: To persuade my audience that they should plan a trip to Brazil.Thematic Statement: Brazils wonder and exotic attributes alone are reason enough for all of you to come visit this land of beauty.IntroductionI. Have you ever wanted to go surfing on white sand beaches where the people are beautiful and everything is cheap. Have you ever wanted to see the diversity and wonder of the Amazon mixed in

Persuasive Speech: You Should Travel to Nepal

779 words - 4 pages Persuasive Speech Good Afternoon everyone; My presentation topic today is: why you should travel Nepal? Let's begins with Bob Seger's legendary song: "Kathmandu" I think I'm goin' to Katmandu, That's really really where I'm going to If I ever get out of here That's what I'm gonna do Kkkkkk, Katmandu I think it's really where I'm going to If I ever get out of here I'm goin to Katmandu...... Capital city of Nepal,Kathmandu is as beautiful

Similar Essays

Sartre's Existentialism. How Should An Existentialist Live According To Sartre? To What Extent Do You Agree?

910 words - 4 pages Sartre's existentialism is a humanistic philosophy that attempts to explain man's freedom and how he should live with the knowledge that this freedom exists. It is based upon the idea that "existence precedes essence", Sartre explains this by saying "it means, first of all, man exists, turns up, appears on the scene, and only afterwards, defines himself." In the text "Free will, self construction and Anguish", Sartre defends a number of claims

Should You Follow The Law Even If It Harms Someone?

1437 words - 6 pages Case study 3 - An ethical surveyShould you follow the law even if it harms someone?'Ethics, ethical behaviour and taking personal responsibility for choices are important in professional life and management today.'(Bucaro 2006) This case study mainly talks about professional ethics, the concept of teleopathy, breach of confidentiality, whistleblowing and public and private morality. Here Citizen's gas company is involved in a fraud of putting a

"Do You Think There Are Any Authors Or Books Not Listed In The `chicago Canon` That Should Definitely Not Have Been Omitted? Discuss" Socrates

562 words - 2 pages -development rather than the pursuit of material wealth. If one knows what is good, there is a clear path to become content.In 399 BC Socrates was accused of introducing new gods and misleading youth. He was found guilty and convicted to death. According to Xenophon and Plato (his student who wrote “Dialogues” and is the main source of information about Socrates), Socrates had an opportunity to escape, as his followers were able to bribe the

Our Duty To Obey The Law

1038 words - 5 pages ), 1986, pp. 190-191. and Stephen Grant Should we ever disobey the law) Lastly and appropriately so according to me is the fear of sanctions that in a way force people to obey laws in order to avoid the possible negative consequences of disobedience. The strength of this factor is proportionate to the severity of the imposed sanctions.( china law review) When should we obey the law? The question of when the duty to obey the law exists is one