This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Account For The Different Interpretations And Perspectives Of The Battle Of Salamis As Described By Herodotus, Aeschylus And Plutarch

1177 words - 5 pages

Herodotus, Aeschylus and Plutarch are all directed by the views of the society of their time. While the three classical writers have similarities, they came from different periods in history. They have gathered evidence or information from varying sources, focused on different aspects, and used different text types to tell the tale. These factors have influenced their thinking, and accounts for their differences in perception and interpretation of the Battle of Salamis.All writers are affected by who they are, where they are from and their topic of interest. Herodotus was no exception. Herodotus based his work on solid research and travelled widely, interviewed hundreds of people and tried to have two or three versions of events - e.g. "Such is the Athenian account of how the battle started" (The Histories, Herodotus, 8, 85-92) - both the Persian version and the Greek. He was not perfect, however: there were mistakes, and he was affected by his context.Herodotus was of Greek origin, writing around 50 years after the Battle of Salamis in 480 BC, so he was not an eyewitness, although some of his information may have come from primary sources. Herodotus gave a detailed account of the Battle, and describes little incidents that contributed to the final triumph. However, although he mentions strengths in both armies, one cannot miss the pro-Athenian bias, e.g. "These two officers (Persians), as I say, had some success; but the greater part of the Persian fleet suffered severely in the battle..."Like other Greeks of his time, he believed that arrogance would result in punishment from the gods, and he used this to explain the Greek victory. While he did not give all the credit to the gods, he did not completely remove their influence - rather, individual's actions and not the gods, directly determine events (Herodotus, Information on the Classical Authors Source booklet).Herodotus' research was thorough, and while he's Atheno-centric, he strived to get the Persian view, and he knew their culture well. He provided several versions of events for the readers to decide for themselves, and he put in a huge effort to find the truth. However, his Greek ties, and his hate for tyranny as a result of personal experiences, influence his interpretation of the Battle of Salamis, for he saw Xerxes as a tyrant. While he was a historian trying to present facts, it was intended also as a "memory of the past conflict between Greece and Asia" and should tell a story, which makes his histories not entirely accurate.While Herodotus was a historian, Aeschylus was both a playwright and a soldier in the Battle of Marathon, and at least a witness in the Battle of Salamis (Biography of Aeschylus, Information on the Classical Authors Source booklet), making his experiences a primary account. Although The Persians is a play and meant to entertain an audience, there is a level of accuracy in the descriptions, for he might've written it based on his experiences as a soldier. Also,...

Find Another Essay On Account for the different interpretations and perspectives of the Battle of Salamis as described by Herodotus, Aeschylus and Plutarch

Different Interpretations of the Relationship Between Kate and Petruchio in The Taming of the Shrew

2783 words - 11 pages . In the wedding itself Petruchio acts as an even bigger shrew than Katherina. He asks for wine in the middle of his wedding ceremony, swears during the vows and knocks over the priest as he bends down to pick up his book. All these things are only described by the servants and so cannot be seen on stage but depending on how the servants describe it, different audiences can either recognise it as an important part of the

The Agamemnon of Aeschylus Essay

2327 words - 9 pages accepted the gift of prophecy from him but then refused to lie with him. He punished her by causing her prophecies never to be believed. This now occurs as the Choros refused to believe that Agamemnon is threatened. Suddenly she tears off her priestess' garland and throws down the sceptre. She prophesies that she and Agamemnon will be avenged by a son come to kill his mother. Ceasing to be sorry for herself she prays Apollo for a quick, painless death

Analysis of “Herodotus’ Scythian Narrative, Sima Qian’s Account of the Xiongnu, Tacitus’ Germania”

1047 words - 5 pages ). This can also be observed in Sima Qian’s Account of the Xiongnu which shows how primitive they were when it is said that sons whose father has passed away will marry their stepmothers and brothers of diseased brothers will marry their widow (Xiongnu 130). These works of about people who were considered as different give us and understanding of how they were looked down upon by others which came from an established society. Although there were

The Different Perspectives of Deviance

1095 words - 5 pages everyday items that others depend on in their everyday lives. Second is the working class, is the individual that work for the capitalist and have very little power if any at all. They try to hold onto their positions as long as possible without being fired by the ones in power. For these people it is hard to make any huge impact on the way they live, because of the lack of power which they do not have. The ones with power only keep people that

The Battle Of Gettysburg - A Fictional Account

1404 words - 6 pages the eastern hills as we lay claim to the final trench. Having secured the location, we transferred to a Virginian company to aid them in defending against an expected confederate charge. We had a quick breakfast of hardtack, a hard biscuit made only of flour and water. The stuff lasted absolutely forever. So did the taste, unfortunately. Reports and rumors flew in from every direction. Spotters estimated about 15,000 rebels preparing for battle. I

Compare the perspectives of E.M. Forster and H.V. Morton as revealed in the account of their travels in "The Hill of Devi"and "In the Footsteps of the Master" respectively

2398 words - 10 pages different people have different preferences. While E.M. Forster usually tends to look upon circumstances negatively, H.V. Morton looks on the brighter side of matters, accepting everything he sees with sheer delight. Both methods can be extremely effective as one perspective stimulates laughter, whilst the other creates a sense of yearning to be alongside the author whilst on his travels.An important element of both books involved looking out for and

How to Account for the Success of Romeo and Juliet by Baz Luhrmann

3575 words - 14 pages How to Account for the Success of Romeo and Juliet by Baz Luhrmann “The play re-worked for MTV.” This is just one of the many ways Baz Luhrmann’s Romeo and Juliet has been described after the director dramatically changed the way the world sees Shakespeare. The controversial film shows us just how important Shakespeare still is no matter how you try to change it. The classic, original play will always be present in some

Account for the military defeat and collapse of Nazism

1344 words - 5 pages Account for the military defeat and collapse of Nazism.The collapse of Nanism was highly unexpected by the German people especially with the initial euphoria that was associated with Blitzkrieg. Because of Germany's rapid penetration and defeat of the Polish in 1939, Germany reached an all time combined euphoria and it could be assessed that at this time Hitler reached his Zenith of popularity. Because of this popularity Hitler experienced he

Account for the breakdown of the family as an institution

1486 words - 6 pages Account for the breakdown of the family as an institution.The family is a set of parents and children or of relations living together or not. It is a race or group of people from a common stock. The family is the oldest institution devised by man. It is a legal social and moral institution because it perpetuates throughout generations. It existed from time immemorial. With time, it is a concept but its structure has changed. There has been a

Different Interpretations of William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

4121 words - 16 pages Mercutio takes off the nurse’s head-dress, he means no harm and wraps himself in it taunting her and singing songs as he goes. “An old hare hoar, And an old hare hoar, Is very good meat in lent? But a hare that is hoar Is to much for a score, When it hoars ere it be spent.” The Zeffirrelli film has a different interpretation of Mercutio to the later Luhrmann film. He is

Account for the responses of the European democracies to the military aggression by Italy and Germany during the 1930s

1839 words - 7 pages Hitler and Mussolini would turn out to be costly moves that were fortunately corrected by the strength of the United States and its Allies in time. This was definitely a tough predicament for Europe to be in. In the aftermath of World War I, literally tens of millions were mortally wounded and missing, there were devastating effects on morale and view towards war, which would make most any weakened society apprehensive about having to go there

Similar Essays

The Battle Of Salamis Essay

1016 words - 4 pages , the Persian losses at Artemision, Thermopylai, the Euboian Hollows, elsewhere throughout central Greece and Attica, and especially at Salamis, had overtaxed Xerxes' military forces."In addition to these, before leaving for Asia, Xerxes left Mardonius and a small force to control the conquered areas of Greece. Mardonius recaptured Athens, but the Greek city-states united to fight him at the battle of Plataea. Persians were defeated again by the

Analyzing The Battle Of Salamis Essay

1568 words - 6 pages an account of the battle from the Greek historian Herodotus, the Athenians are described as bringing “a hundred and eighty ships (to the battle), a greater number than that furnished by any other people” (Herodotus 1). Rather than sending a small fleet of ships, the Athenians sent their entire navy to help the Greeks defeat the Persians, sending a message that they were determined to help and save the whole country of Greece. Leadership may be a

The Validity Of Plutarch Essay

3232 words - 13 pages Plato), Plutarch used their systems to take his knack for observing the behavior of men and formulating the proper way to live. His essays, On Being Aware of Moral Progress, On Listening, and How to Distinguish a Flatterer from a Friend, came at a time when the city-states of Greece were in moral as well as material turmoil, and he was providing the way out. Regardless of the topic, Plutarch's goal in each essay is the same; becoming a virtuous

Julius Caesar, By William Shakespeare And The Life Of Caesar, By Plutarch

1065 words - 4 pages No matter how hard one tries to avoid being manipulated, it is impossible to avoid all sources such as documents, leaders and friends. Manipulation, the ability to alter the position or influence a person, occurs everywhere one goes. Throughout Julius Caesar by Shakespeare and The Life of Caesar by Plutarch, the theme of manipulation was revealed through countless instances showing both its sources and effects. Several of the characters in both