Achilles' Shield Essay

1074 words - 4 pages

As long as there is thought there will always be debate as to the relevance and applications of any figure that has potential symbolism deeper than its appearance. We see it with the Bible, with its accompanying fundamentalism, literalism, interpretationalism, and its downright detractors. Attention given to an object for such a prolonged time is bound to foster battleground for linguists, philosophers, and literary scholars. Additionally, we see it with the Shield of Achilles in Homer's The Iliad. The Shield is a literary figure of beauty which the world has enjoyed, despised, and revered for several millennia. Its lengthy and detailed description forces any reader to, if not look past it for higher meaning, at least imagine and stare at it for a significant amount of time.

There are conflicting explanations as to the importance of the passages describing the images on the Shield. They range from it being an afterthought by the Poet to the revelation of God as interpreted by Homer. There are many differing ideas as to the significance and the use of the figure by Homer, but the beauty of his work is that it doesn't really answer itself. Homer doesn't give the key to his secret closet in his work; he leaves it to the interpretation of others.

That is the beauty of literature, there is no right or wrong answer. What the creator meant it to be is only a shadow of what it is, as a branch of a tree can become a home to chittering fowl. And so it is with the Shield of Achilles.

One of the more interesting, in my opinion, of the ideas, concerning the Shield, is the interpretation of Hugh Nibley in his book Abraham in Egypt. He discusses at length, in the volume, the manner in which God reveals His knowledge and specifically to His repeated use of visual aids to form man's idea of heaven. He draws comparisons of the Shield to Facsimile 2 in the Book of Abraham. He compares the physical description, with the circular depiction of the cosmos and geologic structure of the earth, and the significance of the two images, in the depiction of the God(s) interaction with man. Nibley quotes Justin Martyr when he said that "Homer became acquainted with Moses' cosmic teachings while he was visiting Egypt... impressed by what he [Moses] had written about the origin of the cosmos, he depicted it in the Shield of Achilles." (Nibley, pg. 46) This interpretation causes there to be a more eternal implication in the tone of the Shield, instead of merely a work of beauty, it is a work of Divine Beauty, wherein a revelation of the world as it really is, is incorporated into the description.

There is, also, a thought wherein the importance of the Shield's image is merely a meandering act of poetic prowess by Homer. That the Poet's stream of thought brought it about, as much of an aesthetic wonder as a relief from the intensity of the battle scenes. This mode of thought was described by Oliver Taplin in his essay The Shield of...

Find Another Essay On Achilles' Shield

adasdsa Essay

1491 words - 6 pages certain of this, he does not even guard himself against Achilles’ spear throws. These are exemplified by the following, “This helmet with chestnut horsehair plumes and the shield you can see on my left arm offer me no protection at all. I wear them purely for show - just as Mars the war god is dressed for show. (OM 12.89)” It appears that stupide could be involved as well as Cycnus forgets that Achilles is much stronger and can still harm him by

Achilles and the Trojan War Essay

1090 words - 5 pages Achaean warrior. He turns and runs around Troy’s walls in hopes of escaping, but he is unable to outrun the “swiftest warrior” Achilles. When Hector finally musters up his courage to fight, Athena tricks him into believing that he has a chance. As Hector watches his spear fall uselessly off of Achilles’ shield, his hopes are crushed. Achilles, with all his battle prowess slays Hector and in his anger and desire to seek revenge, mutilates Hector’s

Pride Fueled Rage: Achilles

1817 words - 7 pages war is to seek vengeance for his best friend. He is not returning because he wants to be a hero and wants to save his people, rather with the thirst for blood—Hector’s blood. In The Death of Hector, Book 22, Achilles has no fear as he approaches Hector. “…Achilles exploded forward, fury / Incarnate behind the curve of his shield,” the rage is driving him and will not cease until he has taken life from the one who killed his love, Patroclus

Iliad Study Questions

2128 words - 9 pages Romeo Ardimento 9745 7U Mr. Gern AP English The Iliad, Homer Review Questions 48) Three of the gift-offerings Agamemnon will make to the implacable Achilles are seven tripods never touched by fire, ten bars of gold, and twenty burnished cauldrons. He makes rather diverse and interesting offerings. The return of Briseus' daughter is perhaps the most significant. 49) Odysseus presents Agamemnon’s offer to Achilles, but Achilles immediately

Iliad Overview

1569 words - 6 pages more. But after they each realize that their ancestors were allies, they decided to put down their weapons and continue their ancestors’ wishes. This reveals that although warriors can battle, they will also dwell a existence a peace and friendship. The shield wherein Thetis convinces Hephaestus to create for Achilles is a superb occasion of the finest way Homer tries to convey to the reader that there's battle and peace. The shield had two cities

Achilles Vs Odysseus

3891 words - 16 pages uncontrollably filled with delight (Iliad, 16. 141-142). Similarly, Achilles' shield-which symbolizes war and peace-connects his actions on the battlefield with the immortal while his physical body in indelibly linked to death. His horses, as well, were a gift to his father from Poseidon and outmatch all other potential heroes' mounts. Achilles is uniquely positioned to achieve great deeds because of his relationship with the gods. So, this characterization

Details of Homeric Poems, and stories.

1667 words - 7 pages years before his time. Homer was able to recall palaces and locations, which were destroyed. He has mentioned the Mycenaean warfare and that bronze weapons were used. He also was familiar with the use of chariots. Homer's knowledge of the chariot's use not too clear, but he describes them as a ferry to taxi the gods and heroes around. He describes this in the Iliad. Homer also was familiar with Mycenaean art. He mentions of the shield of Achilles in

The Odyssey and the Iliad

1191 words - 5 pages mighty hand.      The story of The Iliad, deals with two armies, the Achaeans and the Trojans. In the war, the Achaians are trying to sack the city of Troy. The Trojans, the defenders of the city, are led by the powerful warriors Hector and Paris, while the Achaeans are led by Agamemnon, Achilles, Odysseus and several other powerful men. The story concludes with the Achaeans on the verge of sacking Troy because their

The Power of Friendship

1023 words - 5 pages the world. The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Iliad, by Homer, both exemplify some of the lessons a companion teaches the hero. Both epics portray a hero’s need for a motivational friend or ally to help stand against overwhelming odds, and complete their journey. Without Enkidu many of Gilgamesh’s conquest could not have been possible or would have been left incomplete, and if Patroclus had not fought in Achilles place the Trojan’s would have lost the

Idealism in Auden’s O who can ever gaze his fill, Out on the lawn I lie in bed (A Summer Night 193

2145 words - 9 pages Idealism in Auden’s O who can ever gaze his fill, Out on the lawn I lie in bed (A Summer Night 1933), and The Shield of Achilles W.H. Auden’s poems are celebrated for their intelligence, detachedness, and musicality. Often, idealism is associated with romanticism and the excessively personal, because it is an attempt at envisioning the world as it ought to be and not as it is. However, Auden successfully blends idealism into

Hector - Point of View

1737 words - 7 pages mighty Achilles, his armor, shield, greaves, helmet and even the way he moved was similar to Achilles. The fight ended all too quickly. I cut across his neck and thought that I had eliminated Achilles. The boy's dying cries were horrible, he died too young, and he wasn't ready for war. It was not honorable for me to kill him. The death of Patroclus, Achilles' cousin, meant that he would seek me out for revenge, with the powers of the gods, my

Similar Essays

The Shield Of Achilles. From The Illiad.

769 words - 3 pages Frosh Level Essay NoneThe Shield of Achilles:The shield of Achilles plays a major part in the Iliad. It portrays the story of the Achaeans and their fight against the Trojans in a microcosm of the larger story. Forged by the god, Hephaestus, who was a crippled smith, it depicts the two cities and the happenings within, as well as Agamemnon's kingly estate. To gain insight into the details and intricacies of the shield, one must look at the

"Achilles' Shield Essay" Is An Analysis Of The Shield Described In Book 18 In The Iliad, By Homer.

581 words - 2 pages Achilles' Shield EssayIn Book 18 in The Iliad Achilles receives new armor. Among the new items is a shield, made by Hephaistos. This shield held everything valued in Greek life. The center of five concentric circles was the Earth. Surrounding that were stars, the sun, and the moon. After that, there was a ring of two cities, one of peace and one of war. The next circle has in it the agricultural aspects of Greek life, plowing and harvest. On the

Achilles: The Tragic Hero Essay

1129 words - 5 pages . This shows a dramatic reversal in Achilles character as his desire to defend his loved ones overcomes his pride from defying Agamemnon. In honor of Patroclus, Achilles comes out from the Achaean ships and seeks help from his mother and the gods to forge new armor for Achilles to fight with against the Trojans. Hephesteus creates an incredible shield for Achilles that cannot be matched by any set of armor. Once Achilles obtains this shield, he

The Iliad: Achilles' Rage Essay

1516 words - 6 pages ' dead body. This action inspires Achilles to seek Thetis' help again. She has Hephaestus make new armor for Achilles. The new armor is magnificent. It is "a great and massive shield, blazoning well-wrought emblems all across its surface" (173). Thetis and other gods encourage Achilles to fight now. Apollo taunts Achilles while Hector holds fast outside the city gates. It is King Priam who first sees Achilles coming and is filled with fear