Actions In Negligence: Case Study

936 words - 4 pages

Through the introduction of the Civil Liability Act the NSW government’s extensive Tort Law reform in 2002 saw changes to the degree at which the courts might apply certain principles to cases of negligence. The CLA has improved to make more predictable the finding of a duty of care with these statutory guidelines. The moral and equitable extent to which this new regime is an improvement however is arguable, as the general principles of the Duty of Care have become somewhat restrictive and difficult for plaintiffs to succeed.

The law of Torts began prior to the era of Industrialisation, where duty for action was minimal due to the majority of claims being for only “intentional” wrongs. Following the Industrialization tasks and jobs become more distinct and citizens began to depend and become more inter-reliant on one another. As articulated by Abel ‘as the focus of tort law has shifted from intentional wrongs among intimates to unintentional injuries among strangers, its moral tone has changed as well’

The CLA with its more rigid control mechanisms to determining a duty of care has no improved to enact a much more probable approach towards bringing about actions in negligence. The specific preconditioned measures listed the CLA include those rejected by the High Court previously in Tame/Annetts , two of which are that a person of ‘normal fortitude’ could have foreseeably suffered the psychiatric harm and that the plaintiff must have had ‘direct perception’ of the incident at the scene or been a ‘close member of the family of the victim’ . In Castel’s case, having successfully passed one of the preconditions for recovery, it was found rather efficiently and predictably that TopClub should owe him a duty of care.

The requirement that the suffered psychiatric harm must have been a ‘recognized psychiatric illness’ is one precondition to recovery that may significantly alter the likelihood of an outcome. The distinction between ‘mere mental distress’ and ‘psychiatric illness’ however can cause confusion as Gummow and Kirby JJ describe in their judgment that it is one that ‘advances in the capacity of medicine objectively to distinguish the genuine from the spurious’. Had post-traumatic stress syndrome not been ‘recognized’ prior to Mandanarra’s case she may not have been able to claim damages. Although modern courts often refer to psychiatrists ‘opinions towards the definition of’ psychiatric illness’, there is often uncertainty as to how plaintiffs should proof the precise reasonableness of the defendants. .

Looking at an example from the scenario, when proving a duty of care, unless the plaintiff is a close member of the family, they would had to have been in proximity and have witnessed the killing, injury or put into peril of the victim. This has improved to narrow the...

Find Another Essay On Actions in Negligence: Case Study

effective leadership in case study

1250 words - 5 pages Introduction Having an effective leadership approach in an organization supports a productive and successful business. In this case, an organization called Valena Scientific Corporation (VSC) failed to have effective leadership. VSC attempted to development leadership; but failed initially. This occurred once VSC decided to create a research program for their scientists; this program split nine individuals into three groups. Once the groups

A Case Study in Technical Communications

730 words - 3 pages -Lee.pdf Piotrowski, S. J. (2008). Freedom of Information: A Duty of Public Agencies. In M. Lee (Ed.), Government Public Relations (pp. 309-314). Boca Raton, FL: Auerbach Publications. PlainLlanguage.gov. (n.d.). Retrieved March 8, 2014, from http://www.plainlanguage.gov/ Williams, M. F., & James, D. D. (2009). Embracing new policies, technologies, and community partnerships: A case study of the City of Houston’s Bureau of Air Quality Control [PDF]. Technical Communication Quarterly, 8(1), 82-98. http://dx.doi.org/10.10.1080/10572250802437515

Case Study: Hygienist in the Middle Evaluated

733 words - 3 pages In this particular case study, many ethical dilemmas exist. The hygienist feels, very strongly, that the patient has moderate periodontal disease. With the probing depths, and state of the tissue, it is quite possible that the patient has type 2 periodontitis. However, the dentist feels differently. This brings into play the opposing professional autonomy of the dental hygienist and the dentist. If the hygienist was to do as the dentist

IT Governance in Airline Industry Case Study

1548 words - 6 pages Contents A description of the organisation and the market in which it operates 3 A description of the IT governance used 3 A summary of the case study 4 A critical analysis of the impact of the IT governance on the organisation 5 References 8 A description of the organisation and the market in which it operates Airline and travel industry profitability has been strapped by a series of events starting with a recession in business

Tobacco Ads in India: Ethics Case Study

1190 words - 5 pages Tobacco is used around the world, and its negative health effects are also public knowledge. Since everyone knows that tobacco can seriously harm people who use it, many countries face the ethical dilemma of allowing this harmful substance to be sold, regulated, and smoked. The case study “Ban on Tobacco Ads by the Government of India” addresses some of the effects of an advertising ban on tobacco in India, as well as the conflict of interest

Pharmacology: A Case Study In Polypharmacy

2436 words - 10 pages discuss this case study in terms of the problematic nature of this patient's pharmacological management.Your answer should include a discussion of the problems of polypharmacy as it is related to this case study and the assessment/management and educational strategies which could have been implemented to improve the outcome of Mrs A.IntroductionIn analyzing the case study of Mrs A, a number of factors come into play. The patient has recently been

Case Study on Being Bilingual in America

3037 words - 12 pages Case Study on Being Bilingual in America The participant was my daughter, Amy. As soon as she arrived in Hawaii, USA, from Mainland China in July 1998, I began observing how she reacted to the new environment and how she adjusted to it. Over a five-month period (July-November, 1998) I kept a journal of what she did (about 35,000 words either in English or in Chinese), sometimes on the spot and sometimes upon recollection, and tape-recorded

Emily: A Case Study in Adolescent Development

3141 words - 13 pages Emily: A Case Study in Adolescent DevelopmentAbstractThis case study details the developmental milestones of an adolescent girl named Emily. Emily is 12 years old and lives with her mother who is a single parent. According to many theorists and researches, because she is being raised by a single mother, Emily is an at-risk adolescent who may have trouble properly hitting developmental milestones along with her peers. After observing Emily in her

Case Study in a Correctional Facility

2467 words - 10 pages This case study focuses on a scenario describing the experience of Leon Smith, a fictional rookie correctional officer (CO) in a large jail in a Midwestern industrial city. Smith observed that the inmates in the jail were always talking about their criminal successes, and that many of them seemed eager (in a surreptitious way) to share intelligence information with CO’s. Rookie Smith was excited by the possibility of collecting

Case Study 1: Costco Wholesale in 2012

1389 words - 6 pages becoming a member to shop at their stores. For Costco’s basic membership, known as a Business membership, a price increase had to occur to outweigh price increases from their suppliers. This led to the Costco Business membership annual fee being set at $55. When looking into the case study assembled by Thompson, Peteraf, Gamble, and Strickland (2014) they point out that Sam’s Club is able to offer similar benefits to its members. Like Costco, Sam’s Club

The IMAX in 1990-2007 Case Study

2980 words - 12 pages IntroductionIMAX is the film format and projection standards created by IMAX Corporation. This essay provides an insight into the status quo of IMAX, and engages in 3 questions.Before deep analysis, there are two primary question needs to be solved. First one is which strategy level is based within the essay. It can be seen that, the case is more focus on the corporate level strategy. The evidence is that the case has talked about

Similar Essays

Case Study 4 D's Of Negligence

639 words - 3 pages negligence is duty. The dentist owed a duty of care to every one of his patients. Duty of care is a legal obligation a health care worker, in this case, the dentist, owes to their patient and, at times, non-patients. If actions or omissions within the scope of an orthodontist or dentist’s job could possibly cause harm to the patient, the patient is owed a duty of care. It can be proven the dentist has established a relationship with each of the

Using The Case Study Provided, Develop A Treatment Plan For This Client. Justify Your Assessment And Proposed Actions In Terms Of The Relationship Models And Concepts In The Module

3532 words - 13 pages time to come to the surface because initially the couple will be working to cope with the practical changes to their lives, once they have been dealt with, the deeper emotional and physical issues will rise. Case Study Six years ago Mr G was diagnosed with a progressive neurological condition that has affected his mobility seriously. The condition will get worse but no time limit can be given to its progression. He is now in a wheelchair most

Ethics In Workplace Case Study

2630 words - 11 pages and newspaper interviews, which allowed the company to remain a trusted corporation in the public's eyes. This helped keep the door open for the corporation to heal once this incident had been corrected.Ethical Issues InvolvedThere are two main ethical issues involved with the Johnson and Johnson case study. The first ethical issue was responsibility. Johnson and Johnson accepted responsibility for the Tylenol poisonings and took the blame for

Case Study: Google In China

906 words - 4 pages Case Study: Google in China152Case Study: Google in China When Larry Page and Sergy Brin first launched the Internet search engine, Google; they did so with one goal in mind, to provide people searching the internet for information with the fastest, most reliable search engine. Because of their creativity and innovation, Google is one of the largest and most profitable Internet search engines available. With more than 150 domains worldwide