This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Active Euthanasia: Physician Assisted Suicide Is Wrong

2047 words - 8 pages

Active Euthanasia: Physician Assisted Suicide is Wrong

The issue at hand is whether physician-assisted suicide should be legalized for patients who are terminally ill and/or enduring prolonged suffering. In this debate, the choice of terms is central. The most common term, euthanasia, comes from the Greek words meaning "good death." Sidney Hook calls it "voluntary euthanasia," and Daniel C. Maguire calls it "death by choice," but John Leo calls it "cozy little homicides." Eileen Doyle points out the dangers of a popular term, "quality-of-life." The choice of terms may serve to conceal, or to enhance, the basic fact that euthanasia ends a human life. Different authors choose different terms, depending on which side of the issue they are defending.
Maguire argues by defining his terms. After explaining on page 447 how difficult it is to decide "to impose death," he says on page 448 that it is a moral argument, not a legal argument. In the final sentence of the fifth paragraph, he contends that "morality and legality are not identical." His transition, the first sentence of the sixth paragraph, invites the reader to "face up to the objection." The objection, according to the fourth paragraph, is "that there is no moral way in which death could be imposed on a person who is incapable of consent because of youth or irreversible loss of consciousness." The fifth paragraph begins by admitting the truth of this objection. These transitions tie together an argument that seems to agree with the objection, while defining the terms of the argument. When all the terms have been defined, however, the objection is rejected. He argues that, in some cases, it would be "morally good . . . to terminate a life" (p. 448). The terminology here is neutral; we are not talking about a good death, or a bad death, but simply an end to life. It is not murder, and it is not suicide. It is not emotionally loaded at all. In real life, however, the question of euthanasia is, and should be, filled with emotion.
Maguire acknowledges the argument that acceptance of the practice of euthanasia could lead society down the path toward the "mass murder of physically and mentally defective persons" (p. 449). He argues, however, that the specific case under examination is "drastic," and our behavior in a "drastic" case cannot be generalized to our behavior in normal situations. In fact, if we keep that particular defective child alive, then we are defining our terms wrongly. We are committing the "error of interpreting the sanctity of life in merely physical terms" (p. 449). First, he uses the example of a fetus, which is not yet a person, but which is capable of becoming a person. This image is followed by a transition, at the end of the tenth paragraph, to his next idea, which is that life might sometimes "be terminated when other sacred values outweigh its claims to life in a conflict situation" (p. 449). Maguire's idea of the correct definition of...

Find Another Essay On Active Euthanasia: Physician Assisted Suicide is Wrong

Are Physician-Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia Ethical?

1751 words - 7 pages .  In all of the passive euthanasia cases, the patient's life could be extended;it is mercy that demands that he or she be allowed to die.         The second component of the mercy principle may also demand the easing of pain by means more direct than mere allowing to die; it may require killing. This usually is called "active euthanasia.  In passive euthanasia, treatment is withheld that could support failing bodily

Physician Assisted Suicide is Murder Essay

1076 words - 4 pages quarter of cases, physicians regretted performing euthanasia after the incident and in half of those cases physicians experienced emotional distress’ (Jama 898). After the act of assisted suicide is carried out, there is no room for regret. The patients life has already been ended at the hands of a physician who may not have been sure they were doing the right thing. ‘Not only were there types and levels of stress varied for each decision maker but

Physician assisted suicide: Whose Choice Is It?

1292 words - 5 pages (do not resuscitate) order is given. These actions are usuallyspelled out in a patient's living will or requested by family members if the patient is in avegetative state. A living will expresses your wishes regarding medical care in the eventyou become unable to express them yourself.Another type of euthanasia is called active euthanasia. Active euthanasia occurs whena patient's life is ended by their own actions. Physician assisted suicide is a

Moral and Ethics: Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide

2469 words - 10 pages Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide are actions that hit at the core of what it means to be human - the moral and ethical actions that make us who we are, or who we ought to be. Euthanasia, a subject that is so well known in the twenty-first century, is subject to many discussions about ethical permissibility which date back to as far as ancient Greece and Rome , where euthanasia was practiced rather frequently. It was not until the

Euthanasia, Physician-assisted Suicide and Our Aged and Frail Population

1315 words - 5 pages Euthanasia, Physician-assisted Suicide and Our Aged and Frail Population Is the attitude of  Americans toward the old and frail evolving into the attitude indicated in the following episode? In Indiana, a nurse suspected of killing as many as 100 people is on trial, charged in the deaths of seven elderly patients. Orville Lynn Majors Jr., 38, began serving as a licensed practical nurse in a Clinton, Indiana hospital in 1993; months later

The Case for Euthanasia, Should Physician-Assisted Suicide be Legalized?

1534 words - 6 pages euthanasia, there has been no Supreme Court ruling determining whether the right to die, as understood in passive euthanasia cases, can be bound over to active euthanasia. The decision is thus left to the individual states. Currently, thirty-one states have criminalized explicitly the act of assisted suicide . Physician-assisted suicide is generally recognized as illegal under the parameters of homicide, however it is very difficult to meet all of

Euthanasia Essay - The Immorality of Physician Assisted Suicide

1121 words - 4 pages Euthanasia: the intentional killing by act or omission of a dependent human being for his or her alleged benefit, a highly controversial subject.  Assisted suicide: Someone provides an individual with the information, guidance, and means to take his or her own life. When a doctor helps another person to kill themselves it is called "physician assisted suicide" ( 1).  This widely debated topic of assisted suicide is immoral and

Euthanasia/Physician Assisted Suicide Should Not be Legalized

1510 words - 6 pages forget how euthanasia murdered that beloved man, my grandfather. Euthanasia/Physician assisted suicide should not be legalized in the United States. The definition of murder is “killing intentionally and with premeditation”, how is euthanasia any different? (Miller) Not only is it morally wrong, but logically and ethically as well. Human life is not anyone’s to take and destroying it is devaluing a gift given to us. “Suicide is the 11th leading

The Difference Between Physician Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia

870 words - 3 pages controversial article. The authors define the difference between physician assisted suicide and euthanasia. This source contains different viewpoints, written by various authors that contain information about both sides of the issue. They explain the certain factors to why patients may ask for assistance in their suicide. Their goal in the article, is to explain to the physician’s about the certain steps and protocols that are needed

Physician-Assisted Suicide Essay - Euthanasia Should Not be Legalized

846 words - 3 pages assisted suicide, whatever you want to call it, it should not be legalized.      People should live their lives for as long as long as it is worth living.  As long as someone can still have experiences and communicate with others, they should go on living. Someone may have six months to live and decides to end their life rematurely, saying that they are going to die anyway, why bother with waiting.  It is the same with

Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide: Nice Words for Murder

2074 words - 8 pages Increasingly, in the courts and the media and in conversation, we are hearing about euthanasia and the so-called "right to die." It's time we all are fully informed about what is going on, and what the appropriate response should be. Euthanasia is not a future problem. It is a present problem. It is happening now and becoming increasingly accepted. And we are asleep, not realizing that the road we are on will lead to the massive elimination

Similar Essays

Physician Assisted Suicide And Voluntary Active Euthanasia: A Closer Look

2456 words - 10 pages Physician Assisted Suicide and Voluntary Active Euthanasia: A Closer LookThesisIn this essay, I will first argue that physician assisted suicide (PAS) is morally easier to defend than voluntary active euthanasia (VAE), maintaining the view that the patient must take full responsibility for his/her actions if he/she has the capacity to do so. I will also show that there is little difference (although there is one) between PAS and VAE, and how the

Physician Assisted Suicide And Euthanasia Essay

799 words - 4 pages Physician Assisted Suicide (PAS) and euthanasia raise ethical questions about the medicalisation of death (J Hardwig, 2006; Kavanaugh, 2000) and whether it is worse to kill a patient, or to let them die through omission of treatment (Kavanaugh, 2000). All have the same outcome – the death of the patient – the ethical dilemma arise when considering how the patient’s death occurred (Rachels, 1975). Allowing a patient to die from the cessation of

Physician Assisted Suicide And Euthanasia Are Murder

1924 words - 8 pages euthanasia, is where a doctor or another person does nothing to prevent death, therefore allowing the person to die. Passive euthanasia is not always wrong. It is allowing a person's body to take a natural course of death. Active euthanasia, or positive euthanasia, is when a doctor or another person takes direct action to cause death. (Grolier, 98) Active euthanasia is extremely wrong. It is murder and should not be allowed.   Assisted suicide

Physician Assisted Suicide Is Murder Essay

3578 words - 14 pages a world where killing another person is criminalized, how unethical that the norm that killing is wrong now is defended more heartily than its opposite. Works Cited Ardelt, Monika. "Physician-Assisted Death." University of Florida, 2003. Web. 10 Feb. 2014. Benjamin, Harry. "Euthanasia -- Pro and Con." Euthanasia -- Pro and Con. The Nation, 12 Oct. 2009. Web. 24 Feb. 2014. Deakins, Marlene. "Legalizing Assisted Suicide