This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Adoption Options In Louisiana For Same Sex Couples Are Extremely Limited

3168 words - 13 pages

The Louisiana courts have remained conveniently silent regarding de facto, or psychological, parentage in their legislation and case law. In Gill v. Bennet, a grandmother appealed a lower court ruling, claiming she was the “psychological parent” of her grandchild because of a guardianship order from an Indiana court. The court noted there are no cases or statutes expressly addressing de facto parents in Louisiana. There have been custody and visitation cases regarding claims of “psychological parent” by grandparents, which resulted in the development of La. Civ. Code Art. 136 and La.R.S. 1344. The court proceeded to address her appeal as a grandparent, or third party seeking custody from a natural parent. The court upheld the trial courts ruling awarding joint custody to the parents of the child, naming the father domiciliary parent, declining to acknowledge the grandmother as a de facto parent, but awarding her visitation under La. Civ. Code Art. 136 because “extraordinary circumstances” existed.
Adoption
Adoption options in Louisiana for same-sex couples are extremely limited. The Louisiana code provides, “A single person, eighteen years or older, or a married couple jointly may petition to adopt a child through an agency.” This means that gay and lesbian couples may adopt individually. The code explicitly states that for a couple to adopt they must be married. Gay and lesbian couples cannot legally marry in Louisiana, as it is strongly against public policy. Therefore, they cannot jointly adopt a child legally.
Second parent adoption is an important tool utilized by same-sex couples in an effort to protect their parental rights in states where same sex marriage is not recognized. Although gay and lesbian parents can have their names placed on their children’s birth certificates in states that acknowledge same sex marriage, couples are still uncertain of the law outside of those jurisdictions. In states that do not acknowledge second parent adoption, courts decide custody and visitation cases arising from dissolution of a same sex relationship on a case-by-case basis.
Louisiana’s law regarding second parent adoption is not inclusive of gay and lesbian parents. Louisiana allows second parent adoption where the party seeking to adopt is married to the legal parent of the child, thus meeting the qualification of a stepparent. The limitation in this statute is that the party seeking to adopt must be married to the legal parent of the child. Consequently, same-sex marriage violates Louisiana’s public policy.
Louisiana’s public policy has not completely jeopardized the welfare of children raised is same-sex parentage. Louisiana has partially recognized a second parent adoption legally entered in California. Palazzo v. Mire, is a case relating to custody and visitation case stemming from a twenty-four year long lesbian relationship, where the couple decided to parent a child through artificial insemination. After the child...

Find Another Essay On Adoption Options in Louisiana for Same-Sex Couples are Extremely Limited

same-sex adoption Essay

1640 words - 7 pages reeled them in emotionally within the first paragraph. To the homosexual couples who already have a hard enough time being openly gay and may very well be excellent parents to a child in need, it’s heartbreaking because there may be a chance that they will not ever be allowed to legally adopt. In situations like this, they are left to feel as if the decision makers in the adoption process would send these children to just any single heterosexual

Discrimination Against Same Sex Couples Essay

650 words - 3 pages Denying same-sex couples the right to marry causes gay and lesbian families to appeal as second class citizens and sends the message that it is acceptable to discriminate against them. For the longest time civil rights has been a battle of right and wrong, affecting the lives of many people around the world. Discrimination against gays denies them their civil rights with regards to their social roles in marriage work, and everyday life. As of

Should Marriage for Same Sex Couples be Legal in United States?

1201 words - 5 pages want to be in caring, stable relationships, and they want to start a family with someone. I think their argument can be considered to be a flaw for the simple reason that they are not able to come up with convincing reasons as how same-sex marriage will not just be for their benefit, but it impact on children and marriage in the society as a whole. If legal rights to same-sex marriage is granted to gays and lesbians it would weaken the

Same Rights to Same Sex Couples

1340 words - 5 pages religions are against same sex marriage, same sex marriage guarantees equality and freedom. Gay marriage would make it easier for same-sex couples to adopt, providing stable homes for children who would otherwise be left in foster care. Making gay marriage legal in America will be the only way one could believe America is really the land of free. Many Americans don't have the right to get married because of who they fall in love with, and even if

Same Sex Parenting and Adoption

1919 words - 8 pages is a lot of hostility in the community against same sex couples. There are several arguments against same sex adoption that currently surround this topic. Some of these include that same sex parents can have a detrimental effect on the upbringing of a child. For instance, many people believe that lesbian parents who raise a daughter may influence her into becoming a lesbian herself. Similarly, many others believe that it is “unnatural” and

child raising amound same sex couples

953 words - 4 pages Adam Liptak, a journalist for the New York Times, explained in Utah, in Opposing Gay Marriage, Find Three Arguments are Better than One why a heterosexual relationship is better for raising children in. The Utah law that would have allowed same sex couples to marry was recently shot down. Liptak goes on to explain why he agrees with the bill not being passed. The article states that this was important in “holding up and encouraging man-woman

Expanding Marriage to Same-Sex Couples

2751 words - 11 pages same sex marriage, then scientific studies can be adequately done to determine if there are differences between heterosexual marriages and homosexual marriages. This, however, is impossible as we are limited by the structural limitations and prejudicial views against homosexuality. Nevertheless, allowing same sex couples to marriage will actually help children. There are a lot of children in adoption agencies due to abandonment, deaths, and

Same Sex Adoption Should be Legally Allowed

747 words - 3 pages effect the couples attempting to adopt, but it also effects the children waiting to be adopted. Americans have selfish views on adoption, they think not of the children, but of themselves. The adoption laws preventing same sex couples from adopting is unfair to both the couples wishing to adopt and the children wishing to be adopted. In Tania S’ gay adoption article she states, “Adoption is not about finding children for families, it’s about

The Unfair Treatment of Same Sex Couples in the United States

1092 words - 5 pages passed the state legislature in Arizona shows how the power of states to discriminate is too much. If the Arizona governor did not veto the bill, the state of Arizona would have been able to discriminate against its citizens. Gay rights supporters argue, substantial economic benefits attend marriage—benefits that are denied same-sex couples who cannot legally wed. (Scheb) The federal government takes a similar position. Last year, the Supreme Court

Argues in favor of the right to marry for same sex couples or homosexuals based on the fourteenth amendment and precedents set in past supreme court cases

3941 words - 16 pages that the equal protection clause will someday prevail. Denying the right to marriage for same-sex couples discriminates based on sexual orientation and sex violating the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment. From numerous experiments carried out, statistics have proven that children who grow up under the love of two same-sex parents are as healthy and well brought up as other children. Not only that, couples of the same-sex are as

Should Same-Sex Couples Be Allowed to Adopt?

1178 words - 5 pages (Forman 6)? That is a lot of children, but imagines if it was legal for homosexuals to adopt everywhere. By allowing same-sex couples to adopt would be allowing children who really need homes more options. Recent studies proved that children who are raised in a homosexual family are not very different from the children who are raised by heterosexual parents (Meezan 102). Same-sex adoption should not be controversial. Children are the future. Again

Similar Essays

Same Sex Couples, Adoption And Parenting

1229 words - 5 pages children, unable to feed themselves, left to starve because there is no one to feed them. In Romania and Turkey we found teens who weighed less than 30 pounds.” It is depressed and overwhelming to know that while you disapprove same sex couples adoption, thousands of innocent kids aspire to be loved and protected without stereotypes. Defenseless children, newborn and teenagers are living today in the market. They wake up every day hoping for

Are Same Sex Couples Really Welcome In The Church?

956 words - 4 pages the world who have lost their way to the church and to show them love and compassion, then the church is failing miserably. Holding signs and yelling into bullhorns to tell people that they are sinners that need Jesus is only going to turn them away from the church, and it is going to make them feel persecuted and unwanted. Begging for congressmen to deny same-sex couples the same rights that opposite-sex couples will do nothing but cause their

Equal Rights For Same Sex Couples Essay

2080 words - 8 pages Statistics”). Even though a same-sex couple may be married under state law, the Federal Government bans gay marriage, while consequently banning homosexual couples from adopting millions of children in the United States who do not have a home, parents, or food in their stomachs. In fact, there are more than 1.8 million children in the United States of America who need to be adopted (“Adoption Statistics”). It is not right that the government deprives

Same Sex Adoption Essay

950 words - 4 pages . Today, three states expressly restrict gay adoption, 12 allow same-sex couples to adopt. Which leaves 35 states where gay couples aren’t sure how likely an adoption petition will pass (Ruggeri). For over 30 years Florida has been very outspoken about their views on gay, especially ever since Anita Bryant was campaigning against gay and lesbian rights in 1977. Florida courts argue that “children are better off raised in a two parent heterosexual