This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Adults And Children As Learners Essay

2194 words - 9 pages

Adults and Children as Learners

Teaching adults should be different if adults learn differently than children do. Theories or perspectives on adult learning, such as andragogy, make a number of assertions about the characteristics of adults as learners: adults need learning to be meaningful; they are autonomous, independent, and self-directed; prior experiences are a rich learning resource; their readiness to learn is associated with a transition point or a need to perform a task; their orientation is centered on problems, not content; they are intrinsically motivated; their participation in learning is voluntary (Draper 1998; Sipe 2001; Tice 1997; Titmus 1999). For some, "the major difference between adults and younger learners is the wealth of their experience" (Taylor, Marienau, and Fiddler 2000, p. 7). For others, the capacity for critical thinking or transformative learning is what distinguishes adults (Vaske 2001). In contrast, pedagogy assumes that the child learner is a dependent personality, has limited experience, is ready to learn based on age level, is oriented to learning a particular subject matter, and is motivated by external rewards and punishment (Guffey and Rampp 1997; Sipe 2001).

If there are indeed "distinctive characteristics of adults, on which claims for the uniqueness and coherence of adult education are based, then one might expect them to be taken into account in all organized education for adults" (Titmus 1999, p. 347). However, each of these characteristics is contested. Courtney et al. (1999) assert that "characteristics of adult learners" refers to a small number of identified factors with little empirical evidence to support them. Andragogy has been criticized for characterizing adults as we expect them to be rather than as they really are (Sipe 2001). Both andragogical and pedagogical models assume a "generic" adult and child learner (Tice 1997).

Some question the extent to which these assumptions are characteristic of adults only, pointing out that some adults are highly dependent, some children independent; some adults are externally motivated, some children intrinsically; adults' life experience can be barriers to learning; some children's experiences can be qualitatively rich (Merriam 2001; Vaske 2001). The emphasis on autonomy and self-direction is criticized for ignoring context. Adults in higher education can be marginalized and deprived of voice and power (Sissel, Hansman, and Kasworm 2001). Power differences based on race, gender, class, sexual orientation, and disability can limit adults' autonomy and ability to be self-directed (Johnson-Bailey and Cervero 1997; Leach 2001; Sheared and Sissel 2001). Lifelong learning can be coercive and mandatory, contradicting the assumption that adult participation is voluntary (Leach 2001). Adults do not automatically become self-directed upon achieving adulthood. Some are not psychologically equipped for it and need a great deal of help to direct their...

Find Another Essay On Adults and Children as Learners


1002 words - 5 pages Diabetes has become one of the top killers in America, not only in adults, but children as well. Diabetes has been claimed to be one of the top 5 killers in the USA, ranking in at number 4. There are approximately 200 million people with diabetes, which is about 8.3% of our population. More and more children in the USA are resulting with type 1 diabetes. Diabetes is defined as having too much glucose (sugar) in your blood stream. Genetics and

Grieving for Children and Adults Essay

2315 words - 10 pages children is slightly different from adults grieving. “Remember, any child old enough to love is old enough to mourn…with our love and attention, they will learn to understand their loss and grow to be emotionally healthy children, adolescents, and adults” (Dr. Wolfelt, qtd. In Michaelson 48). During this time, it is important for adults to help children understand and handle the situation in a more mature manner. Kids, especially younger ones

ADHD in adults and children

1946 words - 8 pages Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is the most frequently diagnosed neurobehavioral disorder in children and young adults (Schilling, Walsh & Yun, 2011). Though there is a breadth of research on the topic, the fact that individuals with ADHD have to overcome many difficulties throughout their life, like failing to inhibit inappropriate actions that can otherwise lead to antisocial behavior, severe injuries and in many cases end with

Outgrowing the Pain: A Book For and About Adults Abused as Children

1851 words - 7 pages In the book, Outgrowing the Pain: A Book For and About Adults Abused as Children, Dr. Eliana Gil discusses the causes and effects of traumatic experiences adults abused as children have undergone during their childhood. Throughout the book, Dr. Gil introduces various types of abuse within the family such as emotional, physical, and sexual abuse. Furthermore, Dr. Gil explains how to guide these once mistreated adults to understand and cope with

How Divorce Affects Children and Adults

1585 words - 7 pages those of intact families. Divorce is unhealthy it can change your personality, point of view on things, capability of doing anything, and finance problems. I know adults can’t always get along but they should try to think of their children first before they make this decision. Think of how bad they would feel on a holiday only seeing one parent, and now think how lonely that adult would feel. It’s unfair for one of the parents to feel like this and a child shouldn’t feel bad either. Instead of getting a divorce adults should go into counselling and see if they can save themselves from physical and mental damage as well as their children.

Gender Dysphoria In Children, Adolescents and Adults

2317 words - 10 pages Gender Dysphoria in children, adolescents and adults I. What is Gender Dysphoria? It is important to understand the difference between gender and sex. The English language defines “sex” by using the anatomy that an individual is born with. In other words, the reproductive organs that makes someone female or male. “Sex” also includes the chromosomes that someone obtains to make them male or female, the different gonads, sex hormones and the

Is vaccinating the public for diseases (such as influenza (in adults) and measles (in children)) harmful to their health?

997 words - 4 pages In a survey conducted recently (2010) amongst parents of children about the overall balance of the possible risks and benefits of required vaccinations for their infants and children, about two-thirds of the parents (67%) replied that benefits outweigh risks, 23% indicated that the risks and benefits are equally balanced, and the remaining 10% reported that the risks outweigh benefits. (Health Policy Survey 2010) “A vaccine is a biological

Bipolar disorder in children and adults and treatment

894 words - 4 pages Bipolar disorder is more common than thought. It is being more diagnoised in younger ages than adults. There are a few causes and triggers of biplolar disorder. There are numerous signs and symptoms of mania and depression. Bipolar disorder in children and adults differ in a few ways. Three differents types of treatments are avilable. There is also a few places to go for help. Bipolar disorder can be can lead to serious issues if left

Savant Autism and Asperger’s Syndrome in Children and Adults

1765 words - 7 pages parents to bring in videotapes of the child at home. Photo albums and other records may help in identifying time sequences.” (Polsdofer, “Diagnosis of Autism”). This is why in the first 36 months of life, children are screened and go for routine well visits, to make sure they are hitting all of the typical milestones. Even though they may appear to be fine as a child, the symptoms of their condition may not come until later in life. In many

Assessing Personality Using Body Odor: Differences Between Children and Adults

1295 words - 5 pages highest congruence for neuroticism in both children and young adult raters, thus showing children and adults assessing neuroticism by smelling body odor. The young adults also received highest for assessing dominance. With the exception of dominance in the young adult raters, the ratings of the other personality traits such as openness, agreeableness, extraversion, and conscientiousness were not consistent. Both study groups were analyzed first

Fish Oil Is Beneficial For Children And Adults

760 words - 3 pages for children and adults who suffer from health conditions as well as those that retain good health. Healthful properties extend well beyond advertisements geared toward the masses. The omega-3 fatty acids, popularly referred to as fish oil, are considered unsaturated fats. Science differentiates between unsaturated and saturated fats quite clearly. One fact that separates the two is the temperature at which melting occurs. Saturated fats melt

Similar Essays

Should Children Be Tried As Adults

684 words - 3 pages because we’ve known since a young age that violence is horrible. Depending on the age of the child, teens who commit violent crimes should be tried as adults. People may argue that our brains may still be developing but at the age of 6 months children are able to make moral judgements. Teens often know the difference between what is right and wrong, but base their decisions on enjoyment. Many of the kids who are often convicted of crimes have

Children Being Tried As Adults? Think Again

1090 words - 5 pages If children are too young to vote, drink alcohol, drive, and go watch rated R movies, why should they be tried as adults? It has always been an issue if whether an adolescent, under the age of eighteen, convicted of violent crimes should be tried as an adult or not. There are children as young as eleven years old that are being sent to adult prisons (Krikorian 2003). In such cases the jury does not take into consideration the fact that they are

Should Children Be Tried As Adults?

2898 words - 12 pages Kindaya Baker Professor Shelichach Should Children Be Tried As Adults? Would it be ok telling a twelve year old kid that has committed a crime, that he or she is sentenced to doing life in prison? Would it be ok to sentence a child to the death penalty, throwing a child's life away by ending it in prison? There are many different perspectives people have on children committing crimes and how they should be dealt with. Some people would say

Tbi's In Adults And Children Essay

743 words - 3 pages Traumatic brain injuries have become an epidemic, affecting both children and adults. The effects of these brain injuries are severe however; they do differ in severity from youth to adult age in areas such as: cognitive and speech function, physical ability, fatigue, and headaches. America has been recognizing the severity of these injuries and sports and medicine have increased funding to prevent them. In order to properly decide what