Advancing The Argument, Analyzing Modes Of Persuasion In Edward I. Koch’s 1985 Essay “Death And Justice”

1211 words - 5 pages

What does rhetoric have to do with capital punishment? Plenty actually if you want to advance an argument as well as Edward I. Koch has in his compelling essay in support of the death penalty. Koch is introduced by the editors of the book containing his essay as “The feisty, opinionated mayor of New York City…” (handout). The editors continue describing Koch’s character and abilities as they point out that he is politician with a law degree and experience as a lawyer. More specifically that he was a leader for the Democratic Party and then a congressman (handout). Koch was still mayor of New York City in 1985 when he wrote “Death and Justice”. “[The] essay, was first published in the New Republic…” (handout) a liberal American magazine. The readers of the New Republic are primarily democrats and can therefore be assumed in general to be against capital punishment. This situation has Koch in the precarious position of arguing his point contrary to the consensus of his constituents. In spite of this daunting scenario Koch is compelled to produce his essay because he wants to make in clear to his constituents that, even in light of the recently publicized statements by convicted killers that capital punishment is wrong, he [Koch] still supports the death penalty. Koch has opened his introduction with specific and graphic testimony about the statements made by the killers Messrs. Willie and Shaw. I believe that Koch has done a good job of advancing his argument through the use of the modes of persuasion which I will now demonstrate by analyzing his use of ethos, logos and pathos in his writing.
Koch has gained his audience’s attention and now he moves to earn their confidence through his use of ethos in paragraph four. He wants his audience to agree with him or at least give his position serious consideration. To achieve this goal, he presents the history of his public service and political experience, as well as his certainty in his position for capital punishment:
During my 22 years in public service, I have heard the pros and cons of capital punishment expressed with special intensity. As a district leader, councilman, congressman, and mayor, I have represented constituencies generally thought of as liberal. Because I support the death penalty for heinous crimes of murder, I have sometimes been the subject of emotional and outraged attacks by voters who find my position reprehensible or worse. I have listened to their ideas. I have weighed their objections carefully. I still support the death penalty. The reasons I maintained my position can be best understood by examining the arguments most frequently heard in opposition (320).
Koch’s language is appropriate for his audience and subject. Furthermore his credentials are powerful and even distinctive in that he has had the opportunity to evaluate the issue with “special intensity”. He is presenting himself as restrained, sincere and fair minded as he speaks in the first person to inform his...

Find Another Essay On Advancing the Argument, Analyzing Modes of Persuasion in Edward I. Koch’s 1985 Essay “Death and Justice”

Argument Essay in favor of abolishing the death penalty with lists "Reasons For Abolishing the Death Penalty"

4046 words - 16 pages Reasons for Abolishing the Death Penalty by Nanette FlemingThere are many things that I don't agree with in today's society, but out of all the wrong doings that take place, I believe the death penalty is the worst of them all. I am strongly against the death penalty because it violates God's rules, costs the tax payers too much money, prisoners could be wrongly convicted, and it is cruel and unusual punishment.The first reason why I do not

Barthes' argument in The Death of the Author

2177 words - 9 pages The Function of Subject as Signified Barthes’ argument in The Death of the Author, as it is clarified by the structuralist approach of Ferdinand de Saussure and the manifestations of his linguistic system adapted by Jacques Lacan and Jacques Derrida, is composed of an ultimate dismissal of the signification of a text in favor of the ratification of the function of the subject. Once this function is ascertained, Barthes shifts his impetus

The Effectiveness of Irish Catholic and Nationalist Leaders in Advancing Their Cause in the Years 1801 and On

2541 words - 10 pages The Effectiveness of Irish Catholic and Nationalist Leaders in Advancing Their Cause in the Years 1801 and On The Act Of Union in 1800 meant there was no longer any Irish institution capable of advancing either an Irish nationalist or catholic cause. As a result the advancement of those causes depended on influencing the British Government directly. The catholic cause initially focused on securing emancipation for the

The Complementarity of Scientific and Religious Modes of Understanding Reality

3174 words - 13 pages Scientific and religious approaches to comprehending reality are deeply complementary. I do not use the word ‘deeply’ for emphasis alone: the qualities that science and religion hold in common are anything but obvious. Viewed on the surface, science and religion often appear to be at odds. Details and dogmas frequently conflict, and misperceptions originating on either side can lead to rejection of the unfamiliar system. At the lofty level of

Was force more important than persuasion in Mussolini's consolidation of power between 1924 and 1929? (In which I argue the other side)

1942 words - 8 pages . Therefore, although Mussolini used both force and persuasion, in the consolidation of power force was the more important factor. The type of force most associated with the Fascist regime is squadristi violence, but force is also synonymous with the removal of choice; for example, through censorship and the banning of political parties of the opposition.The most immediately threatening institutions over which Mussolini needed to assert his control

The Characteristics of Bipolar Disorder and Modes of Treatment

986 words - 4 pages Bipolar disorder (manic-depression) is a neurological disorder influencing mood. Without treatment, people afflicted by this disorder demonstrate extreme emotional fluctuations throughout their lives. Yet despite (or perhaps as a result of) the unusual intensity of the bipolar emotional roller coaster, many people with this disorder have been widely regarded as leaders and high achievers in a variety of fields of endeavor. A closer look at

This essay compares the common theme of death in two poems by Emily Dickinson, the poems are "I hear a fly buzz when i died" and "because i could not stop for death"

606 words - 2 pages Emily Dickinson AnalysisAmerican Poetry is famous throughout the world and one of the most famous and well known American poets is Emily Dickinson. Dickinson deals with many themes and tones in her poetry however; one of the most dealt with themes is death. In "Because I Could Not Stop For Death" and "I Heard a Fly Buzz - When I Died" Emily Dickinson shows that death is not always as bad as it is portrayed and at times it can actually be a

The Use of Persuasion in Jewelry Departments

1775 words - 7 pages . Furthermore, they were very well kempt. Their hair was combed and they instantly smelled of cologne. One had a nicely trimmed goatee while the other lacked facial hair. I was impressed. The That’s-Not-All technique is a method of persuasion which initially disguises itself as the Door-in-the-Face technique. In both approaches, a retailer begins by recommending a costly product. The difference lies, however, in the motivation. Individuals who rely on the

Essay analyzing The Masque of the Red Death by Edgar Allen Poe

648 words - 3 pages In The Masque of the Red Death by Edgar Allen Poe there are three important symbols that relate to ordinary life in many ways. The seven chambers in which the masque was held all represent seven different things. The ebony clock in the black chamber also represents an important thing, and the same goes for the Red Death itself. The Prince Prospero was the ruler of a kingdom, and a disease known as the Red Death plagued this kingdom. To

Advancing the Individual's Knowledge of the Holocaust

2383 words - 10 pages By comparing, analyzing and questioning the validity of Maus I and II, Night, Night and Fog, nonfictional historical accounts and a poem, called Already Embraced by the Arm of Heavenly Solace, found in Europe in the Contemporary World, Schindler’s List and the Return to Auschwitz we may determine to what degree these sources serve to advance humanity’s understanding of the holocaust. The holocaust can be explained as the historical event in

Advancing Technology and the Nurse's Role

977 words - 4 pages level look at how technology and the computer impact the nurse, the benefits associated with advancing technology, and some responsibilities the nurse has in today’s increasingly technological arena. Hebda and Czar (2009) note “The way that nurses and other healthcare providers work is changing for many reasons. There is a shift away from tasks to knowledge work and the demand for best practices. This change in clinical thinking is likely to

Similar Essays

Critical Analysis Of Edward Koch's Essay, "Death And Justice: How Capital Punishment Affirms Life"

962 words - 4 pages In Edward I. Koch's essay, "Death and Justice: How Capital Punishment Affirms Life", readers view the opinions Koch has toward the death penalty in today's world. Koch reviews a variety of excuses to abolish the death penalty. He argues the importance of the death penalty, as well as, argues excuses of the death penalty opponents. He argues the ethics and politics towards the importance and support of the death penalty. In the following essay

Overpopulation And Its Modes Of Persuasion; A Rhetorical Analysis

1404 words - 6 pages procession of sentiment-stirring images arouses from the most-likely western audience an obligation to act against the presented injustices. The accompanying information, such as the argument presented in flash animation is presented in an intellectually congruent manner consistent with Logos. Each of these three modes of persuasion plays an integral part in a rhetorical balancing act and work in harmonious conjunction to sway an audience. Aristotle

Analyzing The Structure Of An Argument

1094 words - 4 pages Islam vs. the WestCOMU1010 Essay 1In a secular society, clashes of religious tensions are inevitable. The most extreme example of this is when Eastern and Islamic culture directly conflicts with Western culture, the latter of which Australia has largely adopted. On the 9th of April, I attended a public talk on 'Islam versus the West' in relation to marriage and the treatment of women, given by a Muslim speaker called Mutahajid. This event was

Justice In Book I Of The Republic

883 words - 4 pages than the just man is, and because of that, justice is a vice while injustice is a virtue. Thrasymachus uses the example of private business to show how an unjust man would gain more than a just man would because the just man would pay his taxes fully and would not try to take advantage of others. Therefore, Thrasymachus’ viewpoint in Book I of the Republic is that one’s life can be better if he is unjust because he will have the ability to take