The Advantages Of Closed Adoption Over Open Adoption

1226 words - 5 pages

“I want to be like my adoptive mother, but my birth mother says I’m like her. I don’t know what to do or who I am. My whole life is messed up. It’s not my fault. It can’t be fixed,” said a girl adopted into an open adoption (Byrd). An open adoption is a process in which the birth parents and the adoptive parents know each other and are involved in the adopted child’s life. A closed adoption is when there is no contact at all and no identifying information is given between birth and adoptive parents (Byrd). While both are common to today’s society, closed adoptions allow opportunities for the adoptive parents to raise their kids without the interference of birth parents (Bender).
Studies have shown that in an open adoption, the adopted child may have a hard time bonding with their adoptive parents because of the involvement of the birth parents (Byrd). The interference of the birth parents causes the adoptive parents have a constant reminder that they are not the biological parents and therefore are kind of “afraid” to get too close to their children because of the fear of losing them. This may cause the child to be confused and this failure to bond may cause them to have a hard time making and keeping social relationships (Bender) (Byrd).
Closed adoptions can provide a better life for a child. The birth parents of the child may have a bad background, unsteady income, substance abuse, emotional or intellectual problems, or some other issue that may cause them to be unable to provide proper care for the child. A closed adoption would give the child a more stable family and life without any hassle from the unsteady birth parents (“Open”).
Different families may have different beliefs and values. A child involved in an open adoption may become confused because they are being “parented” by two separate families. He or she may be encouraged to do something by adoptive parents, but then told something completely opposite by the birth parents. He or she may feel obligated to listen to both sets of parents and will not know what to do. This could cause the child to reject both sets of parents’ wishes and beliefs, which could cause depression and anxiety in the child because of the lack of parental conformity (Byrd).
Because open adoption allows visitation to birth parents, it is greatly similar to foster care instead of adoption. The adoptive parents really do not get the full effect of parenting because of the involvement of the birth parents (Byrd). This can also threaten the security of the adoptive parents because they do not feel like the permanent parents because of the fear of losing their child to the biological parents (“Open”).
Closed adoptions allow birth parents privacy and to remain unidentified. Closed adoptions can also help birth parents with the grieving process because closed adoptions provide a sense of closure and the ability to move on with their lives. They get a new beginning (“Open”). In an open adoption,...

Find Another Essay On The Advantages of Closed Adoption Over Open Adoption

Adoption over Abortion Essay

1210 words - 5 pages Outline Persuade others to choose Adoption over Abortion • It's more humane: 1. Suction abortion- they stick a vacuum inside the womans vagina and suck out random pieces of the baby. The baby is torn apart by the force of the suction in the vacuum.2. Partial birth abortion- they pull the baby out till the head is the only thing remaining inside

It's Time for Open Adoption Essay

1115 words - 4 pages research, can one conclude that while handling an adoption, a process known as open adoption is the most beneficial for everyone alike. There are essentially two ways to adopt a child; one technique, known as an open adoption and one known as closed. Throughout the first quarter of the century, the latter of the two methods, also known as confidential adoption, was mainly used (Melina). This was an attempt to protect the birth mothers, as

The Advantages of Proprietary Products Over Open Source Products

1498 words - 6 pages 1. There are several advantages to proprietary products over open source products: better quality control issues in creating products; a firmer control over the licensing, either the technology the product is based on or what material (music in this case) can be used with the proprietary device; the potential to build brand loyalty (for example Sony memory cards only work in their products, if you’ve already bought these cards you could be more

Why Open Adoption Is Better For You

1903 words - 8 pages start over. Everything comes down to the parents decision whether they want to stay in touch with their child and adoptive family or if they do not. They will make their decision on how their life is going. If they do not have enough money to take care of a baby but want to be apart of their life they will want to choose open adoption. That will give them the opportunity to be there for their child since they are not able to actually have him

Open Adoption Benefits Every Party Involved

1435 words - 6 pages wanting to give a child a better life than the one that they would have if they were to stay with their birth families. While there are money troubles, corruption, and unethical actions taking place, adoptive families are not to blame. A lot of overseas adoptions may be unethical and corrupt, but not every single adoption is. Open adoptions are "where both parties agree before hand to share contact informations; and after and adopted child

Open Adoption Records Do Not Decrease Adoption Rates or Increase Abortion Rates

1796 words - 7 pages provided for judicial supervision over adoption, and by 1929 all states had enacted some form of adoption legislation. Virtually all statutes emphasized the best interests of the child as the basis for adoption.” (Sokoloff 1993) In a Golden Gate University Law Review article, Jason Kuhns (1994) says Minnesota introduced secrecy with the passing of the “nation’s first sealed records law closing adoption files from inspection by adult adoptees, their

The Process of Adoption

1473 words - 6 pages they may determine what they can afford and what is right for them. Open adoption, like international adoption, has lots of additional expenses too. In the article "Open Adoption Facts" the writer says one concern of open adoption is that it is too expensive, but in fact adoption tax credit is up to $13,170. The parents may pay around $20,000 to $25,000 for counseling and contact between the birth parents and adoptive parents. Once the child is

Analyzing the Topic of Adoption

1711 words - 7 pages some of the psychological issues that may come out of adoption. A Brief Explanation of the Types of Adoptions There are countless possible adoption scenarios and stories. Some that I will be mentioning include international, domestic, open, confidential, orphanage care and foster (state) systems. Each type of adoption impacts the amount of potential psychological issues. Not all adoption scenarios will trigger the same issues later on, and the

The High Price of Adoption

1629 words - 7 pages Parents have the tendency to overlook how lucky they are to have had the ability to create their own children. Many do not recognize what a true blessing it is to have kids, and that others are not fortunate enough to experience that miracle. Ten percent of couples endure infertility (Advantages) so they must consider other options. A very popular choice is adoption. It is not only a good alternative for the couple, but also for the child

The Psychological Effects of Adoption

2544 words - 10 pages absolute joy that parents experience when adopting a child and effectively helps children better understand their family dynamics. Adoptive families are unique in that they choose their children, creating a loving foundation for a nurturing home. Although a “chosen family” would appear to be perfect and without flaw, adoption brings with it psychological affects touching every member of the “adoption triad,” the adoptee, adoptive parents, and

The Effects of Adoption on a Family

1258 words - 5 pages an immature nation and adopt to secure their future is an inspiring image within itself for the birth parents. (Oak) Some authors like Brenda Romanchik have described effective ways to deal with adoption that may comfort the birth parents during times of discomfort. In finding support through understanding counselors, gatherings of people dealing with the same issues, and friends that are open to listen with positive feedback on the condition

Similar Essays

Open Adoption Vs. Closed Adoption Why Closed Adoption Is Better...

1280 words - 5 pages Open-ended versus close-ended adoptions ignites passionate pleas from both biological and adoptive parents. Adoptive parents tend to want a closed and confidential adoption because they want to be known as the only parents that the child knows instead of having the confusion of two sets of parents. As adoptive parents, the right is theirs to wholly embrace and accept the child as their own without having to deal with the complications or

Advantages Of International Adoption Essay

1651 words - 7 pages having to spend tens of thousands of dollars. The outcome from fertilization treatments varies from couple to couple. Furthermore, a sergeant mother can sometimes cost more than an adoption. Having another woman carry your baby is stressful, you don’t know the life they live behind closed doors, or what they are putting into their body, and it is hard to determine if your baby is out of harm’s way. There is always that chance your eggs may not be the

Open Or Closed Adoption: What Is Your Choice?

1782 words - 7 pages The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Adoption defines adoption as the transfer of parental rights and obligations from one family to another. The adoptive parents assume all responsibilities of raising the child legally and financially, therefore severing all ties to the biological parents. The difference between a closed adoption and open adoption is when birthparents and the adoptive parents know nothing of each other. Records are usually sealed

International Adoption And Open Adoption Essay

1466 words - 6 pages from Haiti. A selfless act like adoption turned into a controversy over human rights and caused many to voice concerns about adopting internationally. (Seabrook) In the aftermath of the Haiti earthquake the media began to talk openly about the issue of international adoption, advocates against it became more public with their views. Annette R. Appell who argues for open adoption and disapproves of international adoptions in her article "The