This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Advocates For A New Social Order: Dickens, Marx, And The Trade Union In Hard Times

2651 words - 11 pages

Advocates for a New Social Order: Dickens, Marx, and the Trade Union in Hard Times

For over a century, Charles Dickens has been praised as being the working man's advocate, and the lower classes have played a major role in peopling his vast world of characters. Always, the reader is left with a sense of sympathy and pity for these characters as Dickens' journalistic descriptions of their plight are often dramatic, stirring, and pathetic. Although he renders the living conditions of the poor in such a way that no reader can escape feeling sympathy for such characters, Dickens never once offers a solution to such distress. In Hard Times we find a man who suffers not only the degradations of the industrial city, but also the ostracism of his own kind when he refuses to join the ranks of a budding trade union. Dickens has often been deemed a reformer by many modern critics. However, if he truly sought reform for the treatment of the lower classes in Victorian England, why, then, does he refuse Stephen Blackpool a chance to take a part in that reform? Like Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, Dickens realized and reported upon the conditions of the working classes, but he chose to offer a more spiritual form of aid rather than to suggest a complete political reformation.

Dickens published his views on labor issues in several of his journals, and he spoke on the subject frequently as well. Although he was moved by the plight of the workers, he could not understand why they would become violent at times. Peter Ackroyd cites a letter to Angela Burdett-Coutts, describing Dickens’ views on trade union violence. The reason for such violence, Dickens contends in the letter, is that the lower classes were being brainwashed and swindled by what he terms "designing persons who have. . . immeshed the workmen in a system of tyranny and oppression" (690). In other words, trade union "agitators" incited strikes and riots among a typically orderly, peaceful and honest group of people. Dickens never referred to these organizers as anything but "agitators,” and he thought them to be nothing but rabblerousers concerned only with lining their own pockets.

Perhaps because of his journalistic training, Dickens was able to present characters from the lower classes in a believable and heart-rending fashion, but he never truly understood them. It is true that he spent several months as a child working in a bootblacking (shoe polish) factory while his father was incarcerated for debt, but he was soon returned to his middle class household and was able to continue his education. Dickens then worked his way up to becoming a parliamentary reporter, and he was later able to write for a living. His being a self-made man is perhaps the key to understanding his view on the lower classes. If he was content with his hard-earned position in the social order, why should they not be as well? This was the typical bourgeois attitude of the time.

In The Grudrisse of...

Find Another Essay On Advocates for a New Social Order: Dickens, Marx, and the Trade Union in Hard Times

Charles Dickens' Hard Times Essay

3666 words - 15 pages Charles Dickens' Hard Times Many characters in the novel are victims of hard times as a result of many factors. These include the lack of money, the education system, the industrialisation in the area and the social injustices of the Victorian era. The novel is divided into three books: sowing, reaping and garnering. The names of these books have biblical references. ‘Ae ye sow, so shall ye reap’ New Testament This means that

Charles Dickens: Hard Times Essay

3038 words - 12 pages Charles Dickens: Hard Times Hard Times is a powerful use of satire. The satire is aimed at the Victorian school system and some values of the Victorian period. The novel presents us a fictional town called ‘Coketown’. It introduces us to a man called Thomas Gradgrind, a satirical character with the basis of a Victorian school master. Dickens wrote this novel to attack the Victorian school system because he did not

Charles Dickens' Hard Times

1900 words - 8 pages Charles Dickens' Hard Times The book "Hard Times" was written in 1854. It was written in weekly instalments in a magazine called Household Words. This is like a normal soap but was weekly. The magazine was owned by Charles Dickens as he was a journalist. The book was written at the time of the Industrial Revolution. This was when factories were being built near major towns and cities such as Manchester, Liverpool and Birmingham. The

Charles Dickens' Hard Times

1103 words - 4 pages ” approach to governance but one more in touch with the realities and complexities of being human. Works Cited Dickens, Charles. Hard Times. Ed. Fred Kaplan and Sylvére Monod. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc, 2001. Nussbaum, Martha C. “The Literary Imagination in Public Life.” Hard Times. Ed. Fred Kaplan and Sylvére Monod. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc, 2001. 429-439.

Charles Dickens' Hard Times - 851 words

851 words - 3 pages Charles Dickens' Hard Times The death of God for many in the Victorian era due to scientific discoveries carried with it the implication that life is nothing more than a kind of utilitarian existence that should be lived according to logic and facts, not intuition or feeling – that without God to impose meaning on life, life is meaningless. Charles Dickens, in Hard Times, parodies this way of thought by pushing its ideologies and

Hard Times/Charles Dickens

688 words - 3 pages      The novel Hard Times by Charles Dickens offers a glimpse into the life and times during the industrial revolution in England during the nineteenth century. Dickens offers a wide range of characters from the upper class factory owner to the lowest class factory workers. He creates characters in this range of social classes and crafts this story that intertwines each person and their transformations throughout the

Charles Dickens' Hard Times: A Look At Then And Now

1832 words - 7 pages this upper class behavior and his novel Hard Times portrays the lower class struggle honestly just how it was in the Victorian era. Sadly, these class structures have not changed for the better.The repression of the female gender in Dickens' Hard Times is also highly relatable to the people of today. Louisa Gradgrind is a girl who constantly has a man in her way telling her how to live her life. Her father Thomas Gradgrind only tells her to be

Dickens' Hard Times as a Critique of the Educational System

2270 words - 9 pages Dickens' Hard Times as a Critique of the Educational System            Industrialization made Victorian England a brave new world.  A world bereft of justice, humanity and emotion.  In Hard Times, Dickens critiques this world in several ways; it's pollution problems, factory accidents, divorce laws, utilitarian ideals, and educational system.  The goal of this essay is to focus strictly on Dickens critique of the educational system which

Hard Times-Charles Dickens

1403 words - 6 pages Hard Times-Charles Dickens In “Hard Times” there is a teacher called Mr Gradgrind, Mr Gradgrind set up a school As a charity. Although this makes him sound like a kind man he is quite the opposite. He is very harsh and cruel man. I know this because of how he treats one of the members of his school. Her name is Sissy Jupe. One day Mr Gradgrind said “girl number 20, who is that girl. Sissy stood up and said “me sir”. Mr Gradgrind asked her

Dickens' Attitude Toward Education in Hard Times

1302 words - 5 pages down so that they can not have independent thought, he is like how a machine grinds. The direct speech in the text is mostly Gradgrind with a little from M'Choakumchild. The narrative is Dickens and it is through this that his opinion is shown and put forth. The effect on the reader from this is that they know what he is thinking at all times. In Hard Times Dickens attitude and what he is saying is displayed. There is

Dickens' Attitudes Toward Education in Hard Times

1469 words - 6 pages Dickens' Attitudes Toward Education in Hard Times Throughout the novel "Hard Times", Dickens satirically attacks the state of education of the 1800's. It written in 1854 which was close to the time of the national education act (which ensured all children went to school) was introduced. These schools however, were fully focused on the teaching of facts. Dickens disliked this type of teaching and expressed these views

Similar Essays

Industrialization And Utilitarianism In Dickens' Hard Times

1649 words - 7 pages my purpose, and what I have seen has disgusted and astonished me beyond all measure. I mean to strike the heaviest blow in my power for these unfortunate creatures....' The blow was a long time in getting delivered...; it came finally in the publication of Hard Times" (Marcus 30). In a way, Dickens took it upon himself to do much as Sinclair did with The Jungle; he wrote the book to expose the evils that existed and were going on in order to

Utilitarianism In Dickens' "Hard Times" Essay

1387 words - 6 pages Dickens’ presence through the characters. He was against the lack of imagination because of the factual ideologies. In every single human being, imagination is a part of life. In short, it can easily be claimed that Dickens felt strongly about the subjects discussed in ‘Hard Times’. He was a strong believer in equality and small leader for the poor people in England. He makes revenge by making the utilitarianism looking unreasonable in ‘Hard Times

Social Classes Of Industrial England In Charles Dickens' Hard Times

527 words - 2 pages Social Classes of Industrial England in Charles Dickens' Hard Times In his novel, Hard Times, Charles Dickens used his characters to describe the caste system that had been shaped by industrial England. By looking at three main characters, Stephen Blackpool, Mr. Josiah Bounderby, and Mr. Thomas Gradgrind, one can see the different classes that were industrial England. Stephen Blackpool represented the most abundant and least represented

Charles Dickens: Hard Times Essay

2075 words - 8 pages essentially a didactic satire upon the Victorian social, industrial and educational systems, like Charles Kingsley and Elizabeth Gaskell before him Charles Dickens ponders the "condition of England". Unlike some of his contemporaries Dickens never directly criticises mill-owners, so as to keep his middle-class audience, and this is sometimes highlighted as a limitation of Hard Times. Dickens chooses to take the easy route, by bowing to the pressure