This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Affirmative Action Is Discrimination In A New Form

1793 words - 7 pages

Affirmative Action - Discrimination in a New Form

The roots of affirmative action can be traced back to the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act where legislation redefined public and private behavior. The act states that to discriminate in private is legal, but anything regarding business or public discrimination is illegal ("Affirmative" 13). There are two instances when opposing affirmative action might seem the wrong thing to do. Even these two cases don't justify the use of affirmative action. First is the nobility of the cause to help others. Second, affirmative action was a great starter for equality in the work place. The most prominant variable in deciding affirmative action as right or wrong, is whether or not society is going to treat people as groups or individuals. Affirmative action is a question of morals. The simplicity to form two morals that are both correct but conflicting is the reason for the division of our nation on affirmative action.


Affirmative action is very noble when looking at who benefits from the outcome. Take a closer look at affirmative action. The people that are involved and the damage it takes on our society surfaces many doubts. Taking a closer look also stirs up a question of nobility that needs to be answered before making a decision on affirmative action. Does affirmative action simply change who is discriminated against and makes it legal for the new discriminators?


Coming from my point of view, the view of a white male, this is a serious question. One example of this came to my attention from Dave Shiflett who once worked at Rocky Mountain News wrote "Rocky Mountain Hire". In this article he tells about a new hiring strategy used at the Denver news paper Rocky Mountain News. A memo was sent out stating, "The job reviews of supervisors and others involved in hiring should address race and sex. Each review should have a hiring goal of at least half of our hires being women and at least half non-white" (Shiflett 45). Lets put this strategy to work. We have ten positions to fill, these positions can be filled following the above guidelines by hiring five black women. It can also be met by hiring five white women and five non-white men. Obviously to meet this goal successfully would mean to not hire a white male (Shiflett 45). I strongly disagree with my white fore fathers and society today who both address race and sex when hiring. Using a persons skin color in hiring is discrimination no matter how society looks at it.


At St. Bonaventure University the potential for reverse discrimination became a reality. In May 1994, 22 faculty members were fired, all were male. The president of the university was very blunt about his motive, to protect the small number of women on the university staff (Magner 18). This was purely a discussion based on gender not qualification. No matter how efficient these men were some were fired for not being part of a certain minority. Gary A....

Find Another Essay On Affirmative Action is Discrimination in a New Form

Affirmative Action Is Positive Discrimination Essay

663 words - 3 pages does have its flaws and has often been debated over, including rulings by the Supreme Court. One positive thing about Affirmative Action is that the people who are discriminated and qualify for it can get the boost they need to succeed. This “boost” may come in the form of unemployment at a certain establishment, or admission to a university that may not have otherwise been possible. Here, Affirmative Action grants all people the right to succeed

Affirmative Action is Reverse Discrimination Essay

2420 words - 10 pages Affirmative Action is Reverse Discrimination Even though slavery has not been a part of America for over a century now, racial discrimination still exists in various parts of our culture. A controversial policy known as affirmative action was introduced in the 1960's to try and promote racial equality in society. Affirmative action is supposed to give minorities an equal chance in life by requiring minority employment, promotions, college

Affirmative Action is NOT Reverse Discrimination

2075 words - 8 pages Affirmative action is not the source of discrimination, but the vehicle for removing the effects of discrimination. The Labor Department report found less than 100 reverse discrimination cases among more than 3,000 discrimination opinions by the U.S. District Court and the Court of Appeal between 1990 and 1994. Discrimination was established in only six cases. The report found that, “Many of the cases were the result of a disappointed

Affirmative Action is Not Reverse Discrimination

1298 words - 5 pages Affirmative Action is Not Reverse Discrimination Affirmative Action is not meant to help blacks because of the color of their skin, but because they deserve compensation for past and continuing injustices. Opponents may criticize the wisdom of how this compensation is meted out, but they cannot question the principle of compensatory damages, which enjoys a long tradition in our society. To many opponents of affirmative action, a color

Discrimination and Affirmative Action

3024 words - 12 pages and a government contract of over $50,000, the burden to prove that there is or was no discrimination against disabled veterans and that they have actively engaged in the recruitment of disabled veterans lies with the employer in the form of a written Affirmative Action Plan ( is also important to note that individuals with disabilities, veterans or not, are also protected from discrimination

Affirmative Action Promotes Discrimination in America

1927 words - 8 pages and freedoms they are able to possess by living in this great land. Although initiated to continue this reputation, affirmative action raises more problems than it mends. A key reason for having affirmative action in our country today is to aid those who are at a financial disadvantage. However, that is not always the case when it comes to actually dispersing the money, because it is often only assumed that certain minorities fall into

Reverse Discrimination and Affirmative Action

542 words - 2 pages minorities live in substandard areas and are subject to bad leaning environments, there fore are exempt form the rules that bound the rest of us."All men are created equal" was engorged in the early years of this country, slavery and women's suffrage being two prime examples. We live in a time where society likes to think that discrimination is a thing of the past. However critics of affirmative action say that this is not the case, they propose that

Affirmative Action: A Road to Discrimination and Prejudice

2257 words - 9 pages Department to handle it (Lemann, 1995, p.144). This ruling allowed affirmative action to be monitored by a larger and more permanent staff than an ever changing White House staff could have provided. It is interesting that this original form of affirmative action called for in Executive Order 11246 did not call for affirmative action to be used to combat gender discrimination, only to combat racial discrimination, the gender issue would be put in

Affirmative Action, the New Segregation

2274 words - 9 pages “advantage” because there is more of a priority in reaching the African-American quota than any other (Nieli). Surprisingly, not every ethnicity has a quota that needs to be reached by colleges and universities. Most often Caucasian and Asian applicants are left out of affirmative action plans when it comes to scholarships and admission opportunities (Nieli; Sander). Usually the feeling of being left out leaves most with a feeling of unfairness

Affirmative Action in Medical Schools is a Must

806 words - 3 pages Affirmative Action in Medical Schools is a Must Medical education is among the most rapidly changing fields of higher education today. However, in spite of the continuing progress in medical education, the field has remained relatively slow to respond to the demands of what is an increasingly multicultural society. Affirmative action has been a controversial issue at all levels and in all fields of education. I believe that in medical

Affirmative Action is Ineffective

4217 words - 17 pages workplace(Stewart,1) It was a much different time than now discrimination and racism was much more prominent in society back then but rest assured the tag team has never completely left America it has only abated itself. The same problem of inequality in the workplace from back then is the same problem we are facing today over 60 years and Affirmative Action is still empty handed. We are still facing the problems of the past today and in some cases

Similar Essays

Affirmative Action Is Discrimination Essay

1071 words - 4 pages ;    In addition to that, people say affirmative action is ok because it cures past discrimination (Keyes 1996, 1).  Discrimination wasn't ok when blacks were the ones getting the short end of the stick.  Therefore it's not ok when whites are discriminated against (DeWit 1996, 1).  Two wrongs don't make a right.  Therefore, affirmative action doesn't make discrimination ok just because it's against blacks instead

Legalized Discrimination In America This Paper Is About How Affirmative Action Is A Form Of Legalized Discrimination Towards Whites In The United States

1067 words - 4 pages ). Affirmative action is a form of legalized discrimination and should be abolished.For years minority groups have fought for their civil rights in the United States. African Americans, Native Americans, women and the disabled have won numerous civil rights cases in the United States Supreme Court. Their success has brought forth a movement of affirmative action. "Affirmative action we tentatively define as a program for giving preference to

Affirmative Action Is Reverse Discrimination Essay

2770 words - 11 pages goal or purpose could lead to the conclusion that reverse discrimination is wrong. Form this viewpoint, affirmative action is not reverse discrimination.Counter argument: Although the goal of affirmative action is right, the way to go about it is wrong as it has sacrificed someone's rights to achieve the goal. Under the right purpose (correct discrimination), for example, in a recruitment process, the means to achieve this goal might cause the

Affirmative Action Is Racial Discrimination Essay

2776 words - 11 pages California Board of Reagents with a 10-15 vote. in Michigan, the state legislature is conducting hearings on the "fairness" of affirmative action. David Jaye, a Republican member of the Michigan State legislature, said affirmative action creates economic imbalances within the system. Affirmative action policies are means for reverse discrimination against the non-minority population and should be repealed by the United States government. The phrase