This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Agency Discretion Essay

1213 words - 5 pages

When an agency can choose between two or more alternatives that mean the agency has discretion. Arbitrariness can be cause by too much discretion; therefore it is best it is best if it is not too broad. On the other hand inflexible public administration can lead to too little discretion and this is just as bad. As it stands now the agencies are given too much discretion and are not being monitored enough. The framers protected civil rights through the federal constitution, stated constitutions and statutory law because they were concerned about the excessive and unchecked discretion which eventually led to arbitrary decision making. Americans show a cautious distrust if not anxiety of discretion. These rights act as restrictions on the discretion of lawmakers and law enforcers.
Discretion does have its advantages. Philip Howard puts forward as an argument that discretion is an essential and inevitable element of public administration. According to Howard discretion is needed to make certain that benevolence is in the manner of governing. He suggest that in an effort to attain conformity with the rules or fairness, more than is normal limited the discretion of public officials in some principle of action adopted by government areas.
A sentence expressed to illicit information as to whether discretion can successfully determine the behavior of. An example is police departments have been successful in decreasing the amount of deaths that occur from high speed police chases and the use of deadly force by setting up policies to control the chases and the deadly force. In other instances being able to control discretion has been proven burdensome. Sometimes the cure is worse than the symptom: that is the dominance may have not planned and have the opposite of the desired effect. Howard reveals that today there are so many workplace safety rules that inspectors have to decide upon the rules to enforce. The actual intention of generating so many rules was to put a cap on the power of the inspectors. One study predicted that 80 percent of the thousands of rules made known by the Occupational Safety and Health Administrations rules go unenforced. Therefore have not enough rules and also having too many rules leave inspectors with compelling discretion.
This problem would not be happening if an agency had the wherewithal to enforce all its rules. This compromise has its complications also. Firstly it is expensive. We may want to be able to spend money so that our nuclear plants are safe but may not want to have to be strict when it comes to our building codes when we are constructing swimming pools. Howard makes a point that when rules are put into place they cannot see every likelihood. Then naturally the rule making can lead to unfairness. One of the examples is enforcing rules when the purpose of the rule is not fulfilled. The other problem is not acting when required because the drafters of the rules did not anticipate the...

Find Another Essay On Agency Discretion

The CIA Essay

967 words - 4 pages The Central Intelligence Agency has remained on the front lines of American foreign policy for more than 50 years. The CIA's mission is to provide accurate and timely intelligence to the President and other leaders to prevent terrorism as well as to protect national security. Over the past few years the CIA has received some negative attention for both September 11th and the war in Iraq. While its failures are harshly criticized, many of the

History of Criminal Justice Essay

1514 words - 6 pages criminal procedure, and department and agency rules and regulations. The Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, for example, govern the procedure in all criminal proceedings in courts of the United States. (Houghton; Mifflin; Harcourt, 2013) The workings of the criminal justice system have four major characteristics, (1) discretion, (2) resource dependence (3) sequential task, and (4) filtering.DiscretionAll levels of the justice filtering reflect a high

The Separation of Powers Doctrine

1605 words - 6 pages legislative authorization of agency action be accompanied by “intelligible principle” and legislative “standards” adequate to convey to the agency its lawful role and to appropriately confine the agency’s discretion “within banks that keep it from over flowing” (Krauss, 1991). According to Driesen (2002) allowing either an agency or a court to construe a statute that creates grave constitutional doubts under the non-delegation doctrine is problematic

corporate finance and literature review - corp2017 - research paper

1079 words - 5 pages corporations assure themselves of getting a return on their investment FRC 2012 · relationship between different parties · respective responsibilities · means of regulation Theoretical frameworks for understanding corporate governance · agency theory · stewardship theory · stakeholder theory · transaction cost theory Agency theory = restrain self interested agents · capital requirements lead to large firms · separation of ownership and control

Police and Racial Profiling

2178 words - 9 pages The term “racial profiling” is used by agencies of law enforcement to describe an individual’s race or ethnicity as a factor in articulating reasonable suspicion to stop, question, or arrest an individual (Racial Profiling 2001: 1). Police officers have the discretion to make decisions regarding whom they stop. However, if any law enforcement employee profiles potential suspects based on their race or ethnicity they violate the

Both sides of juvenile justice

3334 words - 13 pages , see --· Law Enforcement Entry into the systemView flowchart detailThe justice system does not respond to most crime because so much crime is not discovered or reported to the police. Law enforcement agencies learn about crime from the reports of victims or other citizens, from discovery by a police officer in the field, from informants, or from investigative and intelligence work.Once a law enforcement agency has established that a crime

Anaysis of Articles Regarding Public Policy, Legislation and Politics

807 words - 4 pages Article Summary American (and other Western) democratic political theory: Legitimizes decisions made through elective and legislative processes. Places a high value on participation and representation. Fears the “king” or, in modern terms, authoritarianism. Rejects transfer of decisions (often called “discretion” in public administration literature) to administrators.  Basic Issue, Part 1  Are the servants of the public to decide their own

Flexibility at Workplaces

692 words - 3 pages opportunities to spend time with friends and families. Substitute teacher that work through an agency is an interesting concept to consider. In situations such as this, teachers tend to feel lack of control over their work due to teaching schedules laid down before hand, where their duties only consisted of covering for others. This results to a great dissatisfaction, and a lack of discretion. Another disadvantage is the forming a bond with the pupils

Business Plan for MILO into the Irish market - Dublin Business School, and Year 1 - the launch of MILO into the Irish market

992 words - 4 pages Sources · Course Reading List · DBS Library - www. · Internet · Wikipedia is NOT an academic source · Google Scholar retrieves information of a more scholarly nature · Company and advertising agency websites · External Sources - access through DBS library website · GAAP · Irish Times · · Warc (World Advertising Research Centre) · Possible Advert Sources Online ·  · ·

Why Do Managers Prefer to Pay Dividend in Cash?

2436 words - 10 pages discretion.” Moreover, in Pakistan like developing countries, the governments would also improve their own welfare at the expense of outside shareholders. This problem is labeled as “the agency problem of state ruler discretion”. Pinkowitz, Stulz, and Williamson (2006) argue that in countries where investors are poorly protected the value of cash within firms is lower for minority investors. Further they conclude that in developing countries

Extended Responces

830 words - 4 pages Independent Agencies, for example, the CIA’s function is Gathering Intelligence. (B) The government grants the bureaucracy discretion to make policy because it lacks expertise, which leads Congress to usually only set general guidelines when it passes a law. This is also due to the tendency of problems to be clear-cut but solutions are more ambiguous, yet congress is under pressure to act. The bureaucracy is also given the power to implement rules and

Similar Essays

Challenges Of Formal And Informal Law

804 words - 3 pages hearing and deciding controversies; (2) rulemaking, the procedures for developing and amending regulatory rules; (3) discretion of administrative agencies, defined in the statute that creates an agency and reviewing courts must defer to the statute; and (4) judicial review, establishes the standards that courts must apply when reviewing agency actions (Harrington, 2009). Administrative law governs the government, and the Administrative Law Judges

Who Guards The Guardians? Judicial Control Of Administration

2827 words - 11 pages . The trouble seemed to be that when a government agency regulates a particular industry, over the time the agency tends to see the world more and more the way the industry sees it. It begins to regulate in the interest of the regulated. So perhaps it was wrong to allow the technocrats in the agencies wide discretion. They might be captured and use their discretion to serve the regulated industry rather than the public.Closely akin to capture

The Pros And Cons Of Contracting Out In The Public Sector

2472 words - 10 pages only there temporarily—that they are only there to do their job. Once the job is done they move on to another job. (Lyons 154) High turnover is also caused by the ability of the contracted company to fire and hire as they see appropriate. Many contracted companies are private companies, which have more discretion involving hiring and firing of employees. If Contractor Leaves, Knowledge Leaves Contractors bring to the agency their own

Law Enforcement Code Of Ethics Essay

494 words - 2 pages source of solicitation and acceptance of gratuities (pp. 141-142). In addition, a precinct with a value system empathizing crime control may allocate resources differently from one with a value system promoting community-oriented policing (p. 139). In fact, officers within these two precincts would be rewarded differently, and the formal culture of the agency would encourage different behavior patterns (Thomson and Wadsworth, 2005, p. 140).According