This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Alias Grace: Innocent Or Guilty? Essay

1101 words - 4 pages

Innocent or Guilty?

     Grace Marks, the main character in Alias Grace by Margaret Atwood, is undoubtedly guilty. The evidence against her is way too much to consider innocence. Feeling sympathy towards Grace seems easy, especially since she tries to make it out to seem that she is the victim, but when looking at the facts only, it is obvious that the evidence all points against her. She has motives, Grace has left evidence, and her stories are not consistent with each other. The evidence, as well as the motives signify her guilt, not her being a victim of an unfair system.
     Grace’s motives seem to be fairly simple, as they are based mostly on a love interest of Mr. Kinnear. Mr. Kinnear’s love interest is Nancy Montgomery, who Grace absolutely despises. This hatred has more to do than the fact that Nancy involved herself with Thomas Kinnear, but also because Grace considers her to have multiple personalities, signified by her alias Mary Whitney, and she hates that she is not blessed with the same social standing and wealth that Nancy Montgomery has reached. It is not just a crush for Grace, especially since there are signals that Mr. Kinnear has interest in Grace as well. The easiest solution for her to obtain his love would be to kill Nancy. Kinnear’s interest in Grace is shown when he takes time out of his day to make small talk with Grace. The best signal of Mr. Kinnear’s interest in Grace, however, would be when he asked her to go out on her birthday. Mr. Kinnear’s sly flirting, however, only increases Grace’s desire to be with him, and this will lead to his eventual death. The feelings are not one sided, as they are reciprocated by Grace based on her going out of her way to do things, for example delivering coffee to Mr. Kinnear, that make Nancy angry. Due to the time period, the idea of a mistress, and being born by anyone other than one’s wife is extremely unacceptable, and when Grace finds out Nancy is pregnant, she has another motive for killing her. A marriage between Nancy and Mr. Kinnear would appear imminent if she were to have his baby. Grace will not allow this to happen, and therefore she puts an end to any chance of it occurring by murdering Nancy and Mr. Kinnear.
     In addition to having motives, Grace has done a poor job of covering up the murder, and can be considered guilty solely based on logical reasoning. Her love for Mr. Kinnear was clearly expressed in the text, but she acted completely unemotional after he was killed. It is thought that if her love was real, and she did not commit the murder, that Grace Marks would be a wreck after such a tragic event. Instead she acts calm and collected, and she even goes as far as wearing Nancy’s clothes and even taking her money, both being blatant signs of disrespect. Even more blatant would be the fact that Nancy was strangled, and Grace’s handkerchief was the “weapon.” Also, Grace had little or no...

Find Another Essay On Alias Grace: Innocent or Guilty?

Innocent or Guilty: The O.J. Simpson Trials

1560 words - 6 pages requirements and examined the evidence equally. How then can we determine if this man was guilty, he was acquitted by a criminal jury and convicted by a civil jury? Is this man innocent or guilty? This is a perfect example of when the law does not do its job. A guilty man is set free and to this day no one has been charged with the deaths of Nicole Brown or Ron Goldman in criminal court, is this justice? O.J. Simpson was charged with the same crime

Guilty or innocent? The story of Ethyl and Julius Rosenberg all about j & e Rosenberg

714 words - 3 pages Guilty or innocent? The story of Ethyl and Julius RosenbergIt was shortly after World War Two, and the nation was going through another Red Scare. Being a suspected communist made one as guilty as being a serial murderer in America. Communist North Korea and China had recently invaded South Korea, and the USSR had recently discovered the secret to atomic weapons. When Russia detonated its first atom bomb, Americans were infuriated. They wanted

Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace

1178 words - 5 pages Thomas and Nancy. This is not surprising because in Victorian society sex was as unacceptable and shocking as murder. There is a connection between sex and guilt that runs throughout the novel. Some people believe that if Grace were McDermott’s lover, she is automatically guilty of murder, while if she is a virgin she must be innocent. Though sex means guilt in some people’s minds, to Grace sex means danger and death. She tells Jordan of her

Atwood's Framing of the Story in "Alias Grace"

1768 words - 7 pages One of the main themes of the postmodern movement includes the idea that history is only what one makes of it. In other words, to the postmodern philosopher history is only a story humans frame and create about their past (Bruzina). Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace is an excellent exploration of this postmodern idea. Through use of postmodern writing styles and techniques, Atwood explores how the framing of a story influences its meaning. By mixing


3365 words - 14 pages the detail about Grace's chores might help define Simon's character, as the reader compares Grace's ability to handle the house with Simon's complete inability to clean up after himself, cook a meal, or even shop at the market, once his landlady loses her own maid.Why do you think the book is called Alias Grace? Izabela thought the title was particularly suitable. We talked about how the title has a literal meaning, in that the "real

Discuss the ways in which two writers you have studied enhance their stories through the exploration and inclusion of lies, deception and betrayal

926 words - 4 pages innocent or guilty, which leaves the reader with many unanswered questions. These questions arise from the fact that the reader is not one hundred percent aware that Grace Marks is telling the truth. At the trial Grace betrays McDermott. She mentions that he forced her to accomplice her in the murder. This saves her own skin, but results in the hanging of McDermott. Just as Angela lie or betrayal to Santiago was fatal for him, Grace's lying in court

Alias Grace Literary Essay: The Consequence of Childhood

1748 words - 7 pages Childhood is often perceived as a period of innocence and purity. However, it is also the period of time where a person’s fundamental character is established, which can be easily affected by the conditions of the child’s environment. Alias Grace, a novel by Margaret Atwood, contains many themes centered on the concept of childhood and the influence of a person’s past. The book features a famous convicted murderess, Grace Marks, and a doctor

Case Study: The Mind of Alias Grace

1086 words - 4 pages In Alias Grace by Margaret Atwood, Doctor Simon Jordan is a psychologist that is analyzing and talking to convict Grace Marks with the ultimate goal of unlocking the truth behind the murder case of Thomas Kinnear and Nancy Montgomery. Parts of Grace’s memory are missing completely, and through constant discussions with Doctor Jordan about her dreams and memories from the past, Doctor Jordan is trying to find a way around the memory blocks while

Alias Grace: Margaret Atwood's Work of Historical Fiction

647 words - 3 pages In ‘Alias Grace’, one of her most satisfying novels till date, Canadian author Margaret Atwood takes us back into the mid-1800s in the life and mind of Grace Marks, who was notoriously convicted for the murder of her employer, Thomas Kinnear and his house-keeper Nancy Montgomery. Reading Susanna Moodie’s account of the story, Atwood became interested and dug deeper into the story only to find several discrepancies in Moodie’s version of the

The Physicists

804 words - 3 pages during a short period of time and because he can’t speak to or take away the murderer . He is also expressing the wish of the public prosecutor that the sanatorium has to be taken over by male nurses because of the two murders by the two physicists. During the course of the play the personal and physical change is perceptible. Both the main characters and the environment are changing. For an example in act two, Herbert Georg Beutler alias Sir

What evidence is there to suggest that the conspiracy theorists might be right about the death of Martin Luther king

3634 words - 15 pages essay will concentrate on the main conspiracy theories surrounding King's death and will endeavor to establish whether or not the evidence suggested by such theorists could possibly be right, regarding the 'most unresolved murder in modern American history'.If Ray was innocent then why did he plead guilty and effectively waiver any rights he had to a trial? Ray had numerous lawyers throughout the thirty years of his sentence, but it is with his

Similar Essays

Guilty Or Innocent? Essay

747 words - 3 pages If a mother left her six month old child alone at home, alone for seven days, would you say she is guilty or innocent of second degree murder? A woman named Mary Barnett left her six month old child at home for a week while she traveled to San Francisco to visit her fiancé. While left unattended, the child died of dehydration. Mary Barnett is being charged with second degree murder. During her trial, the jury heard from numerous witnesses, some

Lady Macbeth: Guilty Or Innocent? Essay

1285 words - 5 pages In William Shakespeare's play Macbeth; one of the leading roles is Lady Macbeth. Lady Macbeth is the wife of Macbeth, a warrior and cousin of King Duncan. As the play progresses and the plot thickens, Lady Macbeth changes. Her actions change, her words change, her personality changes, and her motivations change. Now the real question is; is Lady Macbeth guilty or innocent?Upon Lady Macbeth's first appearance in the play she is very affectionate

Is Socrates Innocent Or Guilty? Essay

1942 words - 8 pages Is Socrates Innocent or Guilty? Living in a democracy, everyone is exposed through television and other various forms of media everyday to numerous trials by jury. Usually they are rarely given a second thought, but every once in a while along comes a specific trial which captures the attention of the entire country. This goes the same for trials throughout centuries in our past. Although they did not have the same forms of media as in

The Apology Of Socrates: Guilty Or Innocent?

954 words - 4 pages The Apology of Socrates: Guilty or Innocent?    In any case of law, when considering truth and justice, one must first look at the validity of the court and the system itself.  In Socrates' case, the situation is no different.  One may be said to be guilty or innocent of any crime, but guilt or innocence is only as valid as the court it is subjected to.  Therefore, in considering whether Socrates is guilty or not, it must be kept in mind