This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Aligning It With Business Strategy Essay

1157 words - 5 pages

Is it smart for companies to invest heavily in information technology (IT)? Numerous studies indicate that excessive IT spending will usually reduce company profits and slow productivity. According to an article in the MIT Sloan Management Review, “Avoiding the Alignment Trap in Information Technology,” IT can become a huge bottleneck to growth in companies if they focus on the wrong remedies for their IT problems (Shpilberg, Berez, Puryear, & Shah, 2007). The article first focuses on Charles Schwab and its IT struggles during the early 2000’s. Then, it presents a study on 504 companies, and IT’s effect on their revenue growth. Lastly, it covers the steps to ensure success in IT’s effectiveness.
Charles Schwab is a Fortune 500 Company that manages nearly $2 trillion in assets for a wide range of clients (Hoovers, Inc., 2014). The mega-broker has obviously done something right. However, as Charles Schwab grew, it’s not surprising that its IT problems grew as well. Charles Schwab approached the situation by spending loads of money on new IT projects rather than fixing the existing systems or starting fresh altogether. Eventually, the company found itself smothered in an over-complicated system that was eating 18% of revenue annually (Shpilberg et al., 2007). “IT’s effort to satisfy its various (and sometimes conflicting) business constituencies created a set of Byzantine, overlapping systems that might satisfy individual units for a while but did not advance the company’s business as a whole (Shpilberg et al., 2007, p. 52).”
The article refers to Charles Schwab’s problem as the “Alignment Trap,” and 11% of the 504 surveyed companies were struggling with it. Despite the group spending 13% above average on IT, their revenue growth was 14% below average over a 3-year period (Shpilberg et al., 2007). The idea is that aligning a poorly performing IT system to business objectives won’t provide any benefit because the system is poorly performing. In addition, aligning each department to a different system or standard doesn’t work because a company needs all departments functioning at the same pace and every department must rely on each other.
The largest group (about 75% of surveyed companies) spent the average amount on IT, but growth was slightly below average (Shpilberg et al., 2007). Companies in the “The Maintenance Zone” have IT systems that are less aligned to business objectives and are, as a result, less effective as a whole. The authors state that the group treats IT more like plumbing, “bumping along” until something bad happens. However, since the group’s deviation of IT spending and revenue growth from the average is minimal, the article doesn’t put much focus on the “The Maintenance Zone.”
The next group, experiencing “Well-Oiled IT,” were more focused on execution and effectiveness at getting IT projects up and running (on a budget). They spent 15% below average on IT, yet revenue growth was 11% above average (Shpilberg et al.,...

Find Another Essay On Aligning IT with Business Strategy

Critically Discuss The Various Existing Models Linking Organizational/ Business Strategy With Hrm Strategy

1913 words - 8 pages ). From a theoretical position, the wide range of models and lists of best practices creates a problem. Widely acknowledged illegal practices and certain generic practices aside, it is the unique context of each business that matters when developing a HR strategy. In addition, the intentions of best practice should benefit both shareholders and workers. But as with most models of best practice, there is little reference to the role of unions or the

Delivering Business Value with IT at Hefty Hardware

1052 words - 5 pages , 10(2), 19–32. Murby, L., Gould, S., (2005). Effective Performance Management with the Balanced Scorecard. Technical Report, CIMA, London. Smith, H. A., McKeen J. D. (2012). Delivering Business Value with IT at Hefty Hardware. IT Strategy: Issues and Practices(2nd ed.) Pearson Prentice Hall: Upper Saddle River, NJ. Vielhaber, M. E., & Waltman, J. L. (2008). Changing Uses of Technology. Journal of Business Communication, 45(3), 308–330. Works Cited

Improving business with IT Metrics - Wilmington University - Assignment

643 words - 3 pages customer's shopping experience. The Runa acquisition is expected to lead to more dynamic pricing for shoppers. If small business customers are happy with the setup and see that they will find what they need with ease and at the correct price, then this acquisition could pay off in a big way down the road. Amazon offers over 1 million office products, and it ranks No. 11 globally and No. 5 in the United States. This kind of exposure is massive and a

How did HP define its business strategy with CEO Mr. Hurd?

701 words - 3 pages Mr. Hurd used a Lower Level Strategy and is a firm believer that the beauty is in the details, and began his reign as the CEO of HP by redefining the company's corporate strategy; from high-level futuristic planning to a strategy process that moves seamlessly with operations. He says, "If strategy isn't clearly driving ground-level operations, my argument is that you don't have a strategy."Mr. Hurd started to utilize a tactic that would measure

A successful Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system implementation requires integration of technology with business strategy and assessing the impact of the system on all aspects of the business;

9755 words - 39 pages technology in up dating the software of ERP systems had deep impact on the business strategy. The Information Technology is revolutionizing the means, in which we exist and labor. It is altering all aspects of our life and way of life. The digital revolution has given mankind the capability to treat information with mathematical accuracy, to send out it at very high precision and to control it at will. These capabilities are bringing into being a

Investigate that "Game theory is grounded in well established theory, but it is too hard to use in developing and implementing international business strategy"

2620 words - 10 pages strategy can be implemented by game theory.ConclusionIndeed, game theory has some difficulties to be understood. However, in this paper, by discussing and analyzing how game theory helps develop and implement international business strategy with cases, it is apparently wrong that game theory is too hard to use. Maybe, the models of game theory will become more complicated in future, but the way for game theory to deal with the problems is constant.

Recommend and justify a promotional strategy for Bethan to use when starting her business if it were to open in your area

2269 words - 10 pages Promotion is one part of the marketing mix along with place, product and price. Promotion is very important in the marketing mix because if you don’t promote your promote your product then no-one will know about the product or it will rarely be seen. Promoting in the wrong place is also a big risk. All the marketing mix is very important as choosing one wrong factor of the marketing mix could impact greatly on a business especially if it is

What is the purpose of a business plan and why is it an essential first step for a start-up firm? This essay also addresses commom problems with small businesses

804 words - 3 pages business plan can help to move you by breaking down a seemingly impracticable task into smaller, less upsetting tasks. Once you have your business going, a business plan can be very useful to help keep you on track and focusing on the goals you have set. With all the hard work and continuous effort it is very easy to lose sight of your objectives and goals. A business plan also serves to help others to understand your vision, including prospective

An investigation into the impact IT has had on the modern world with particular reference to business and social problems

3375 words - 14 pages very useful indeed. This information is used to build customer profiles.It is very important that the data is accurate at the point of collection so bar code readers are a favourite choice for supermarkets with only one error in every one hundred thousand entries. Bar code scanners are also very cheap. The only real disadvantage of using this method is that if the bar code is crumpled it is very hard for the scanner to read it. This does not happen

Explain briefly with examples on the three theories in motivation and how it applies to business organisation today

1274 words - 5 pages of work in line with their motivational impact to both the mangers and employees. We can apply this need within the organization for instance Provide lunch breaks, rest breaks, and wages that are sufficient to purchase the essentials of life.Secondly; the safety need that will employ the security one gets from the job, for all possible safety issues be it physical or emotional harm. For example provide a safe working environment, freedom from

Explain briefly with examples on the three theories in motivation and how it applies to business organisation today

1274 words - 5 pages of work in line with their motivational impact to both the mangers and employees. We can apply this need within the organization for instance Provide lunch breaks, rest breaks, and wages that are sufficient to purchase the essentials of life.Secondly; the safety need that will employ the security one gets from the job, for all possible safety issues be it physical or emotional harm. For example provide a safe working environment, freedom from

Similar Essays

The Importance Of Aligning It Strategy And An Organization's Business Strategy: A Case Study Of Metalco

1558 words - 6 pages participation of senior executives and business managers in decisions relating to investments in IT. The role of IT in strategic business planning resulted in being a business strategy enabler and driver. Skills along with scope and architecture show that Metalco has established enterprise standards. In terms of innovation, Metalco is committed to becoming the most innovative, high-quality and profitable producer of specialty metal products in the

It Strategy Vs Business Strategy Essay

988 words - 4 pages In most organizations IT expenditure is considered as one of the larger if not the largest contributor to capital investment and expenditure. Technology has a significant effect on the business landscape of most organizations and the market place they operate in. The goal of IT as such should be directed toward the alignment of IT strategy with an organization's overall business strategy (Mulcay, 2001). It is argued though that the inability to

Business And It Strategy Essay

2115 words - 8 pages Two organizations that show the importance of aligning a company’s business strategy with their IT strategy are Cirque du Soleil and Major League Baseball. Both of these organizations rely on digital technology to make it easier to provide to their customers better entertainment through collaboration. Cirque du Soleil, which was founded in 1984, has met a large amount of success in its short 30 years of operation. This Canadian multinational

Implementation Of It Strategy In Business

937 words - 4 pages help the company to make the people see the product and services by the company provided and it may help the company to growth the business as well. In addition, through advertising in search engines and social networking also, consumer is easy to have the information about Faiza products and services provided and the spreading of information will be more quickly and fast from before. From this strategy also, Faiza company will define their market