Let Gays Marry And Leave Marriage Alone

1323 words - 5 pages

I will summarize some of the key points from the essay, Let Gays Marry, by Andrew Sullivan, and the essay, Leave Marriage Alone, by William Bennett. Some of these main points are taken from mutual beliefs of both authors and others are derived from the opposing opinions of the two.

The first summary of Andrew Sullivan’s essay is a reflection of Andrew Sullivan’s stance of the issue. The original essay was in favor of allowing same sex marriage in America. My summary will dictate some of the arguments that I found to be the most persuasive and important to Sullivan’s case. The second summary is of Bennett’s essay, Leave Marriage Alone. I will, again, try to point out the most influential pieces of argument in the essay. Finally, I hope to synthesize these two essays, and expose some of the similarities and arguments between the two. In the synthesis, I hope to provide an incite into some of the basic ideals presented from both sides of the issue.

Andrew Sullivan states his thesis in the first paragraph of his essay entitled, Let Gays Marry. “They are citizens, entitled, like everyone else, to equal protection -no special rights, but simple equality”(25). Sullivan is referring to a supreme court declaration, stating that homosexuals are no longer separate from the general public in America. The decision states that gay and lesbian couples have the same rights as every other American citizen.

With the new openness to the gay and lesbian lifestyle, there is no longer a need for homosexuals to feel like a separate entity from society. Based on this idea, advocates of gay and lesbian marriage are campaigning towards the right of same sex unions, recognized by law. Andrew Sullivan argues that many homosexuals feel very fortunate to find the someone that they can spend the rest of their life with. He continues to argue that marriage is a normal and natural step that two people may wish to take during their lives(25). As a basis for these arguments, Sullivan believes that marriage is an important key to the progression of homosexual equality in America.

Sullivan is aware of certain churches and religious affiliates that would be in opposition to the marrying of gay couples. Sullivan explains that homosexuals pushing for the permission of gay marriage do not intend to change the doctrines or traditions of any church. The movement’s actual desire is the fundamental right to marriage.
Sullivan reiterates the hopes of the gay community by expressing their longing for recognition before the law as a married couple. Gays are essentially making the simple request that they be given the same marriage license as any other couple in America who wishes to be married.

Advocates of homosexual marriage say they are aiming to strengthen and become a part of the institution. Bennett disagrees and implores that if they were allowed to follow through, and be accepted as an active part of the institution of marriage, they would...

Find Another Essay On Let Gays Marry and Leave Marriage Alone

Marriage is a Sacred Union between Man and Woman

1161 words - 5 pages people of America now and in the future. Works Cited Bayles, Fred, and Andrea Stone. “Gay-marriages foes try to stop ‘activist courts.’” USA Today 25 Feb. 2004: 06a. Bennett, William. “Leave Marriage Alone.” Newsweek 3 June 1996: 27. Breslau, Karen, Brad Stone, Debra Rosenberg and Tamara Lipper. “Outlaw Vows.” Newsweek 1 Mar. 2004: 40. “Broken marriages, not gay nuptials, pose risk to kids.” USA Today 23 Feb. 2004: 18a

Rights for Homosexuals Essay

805 words - 3 pages Rights for Homosexuals Gay marriage is a hotly debated issue in today's society. Andrew Sullivan and William Bennett offer opposing views in the June 3, 1996 edition of Newsweek. Sullivan's article, “Let Gays Marry,” offers several arguments supporting the issues of same sex marriage. Bennett counters in his article, “Leave Marriage Alone,” that same sex marriages would be damaging to the sanctity of marriage. Each author presents

Equal Rights for ALL Americans

2490 words - 10 pages Marriage has always been a sacred agreement between a man and woman. However, as times have changed, our ideas involving marriage are forced to change with the times. Our country has developed throughout the years to enforce the belief that all Americans should be granted equal rights no matter what their skin color or cultural background. Granting gays the right to marry would simply be giving all people equal rights in the issue of

Same-Sex Marriage

2329 words - 9 pages difficult. Society really cannot accuse gays of being promiscuous if the law does not permit them to access the institution of marriage. Allowing gays to marry would discourage promiscuity in the homosexual population and bring stability to same-sex relationships. Through marriage, gays can "reclaim the legitimacy of [their] relationship[s] and demonstrate to other gay and lesbian couples that lasting homosexual love is

Definition of Marriage Essay

792 words - 3 pages this, he does mention other types of marriages such as polygamy and family marriage. If these styles of marriages were accepted in the culture in the US, he would accept them. He argues we should not change this culture because of the tradition of marriage. Works cited Bennett William. “Leave Marriage Alone”. Constructing Others Constructing Ourselves. Ed. Sybille Gruber et al. Kendall/Hunt, 2002

same sex marriage

1233 words - 5 pages get denied the rights to marry even if they are great citizens. This discrimination must stop because, just like heterosexual couples, Gays and lesbians are law abiding citizens that should have the same rights.One common problem that gay and lesbian couples have are that they don't have the right to marry their partners and once their partner passes away they can't claim their social security. The Human Rights Campaign, which work to achieve equal

Gay Marriage Rights

1025 words - 4 pages gay marriage is often referred to as the "slippery slope." Some people actually believe that if gays are allowed to marry it will completely destroy the sanctity of marriage, resulting in people insisting that they be allowed to marry animals, trees, or inanimate objects. This is just a scare tactic to intimidate people into thinking the worst. The reality is that gays are allowed to marry in other countries and have been able to for years and

Gay Marriage and the Government

1678 words - 7 pages an issue that occasionally arose in a few states to a national and even worldwide controversy. Moreover, the battle over whether or not gay and lesbians should be allowed to wed shows no signs of abating. In the last year alone, three states have banned same-sex marriage and four states have legalized the practice. Recently, both sides in the debate have scored important victories. In April 2009, Iowa’s Supreme Court ruled that the states

Same-Sex Marriage

1456 words - 6 pages with their homosexuality because of the criticism and other negative aspects that come along with it. Allowing gays to marry will provide some comfort to gay people because they will be more accepted in society. The U.S. Constitution is made to supposedly protect human rights, making gay marriage illegal does not protect gay rights. It violates the rights of same-sex couples by not giving them equality of marriage. Gays cannot be stopped from

Gay Marriages

946 words - 4 pages been recently ridiculedwithin each of our individual 50 states about whether they are capable of rearing children,whether they can marry, make love, so on. Let's go on the flip side to further display howthis type of discrimination hits many. Let say they took this law and said they no longerwill allow overweight people to marry. That rewriting the Constitution states there is aweight limit. If anyone weighs more than 225 lbs. They cannot marry

Human Sexuality : A Taste of Variety

922 words - 4 pages If two people love one another why should homosexuals be denied the right of being together on paper? ?I am not gay but I respect the rights of gays and lesbians. It?s not their fault if God made them born like that.? -By. King Norodom Shanouk of Cambodia. Many critics hold opposing views, arguing that same sex marriages harm no one and that to deny homosexuals the right to marry is unconstitutional. People who are and aren?t gay can understand

Similar Essays

Comparing William Bennett's Leave Marriage Alone And Andrew Sullivan's Let Gays Marry

1561 words - 6 pages , I feel it is not a dangerous problem for us. If they love each other, let them marry and they will solve that problem by themselves. Who knows after gay law is passed, no one want to marry with same sex person any more. So just let it is solve by itself. Sources Cited William Bennett, Leave Marriage Alone Andrew Sullivan, Let Gays Marry An Exchange on Same-Sex Marriage - William Bennett and Andrew Sullivan http://faculty.mc3.edu/barmstro/sullivan.html

Relationships And Marriage Don't Marry!

1584 words - 6 pages Don't Marry! "Marriage is quite likely the one most damaging force our species have ever invented, up to and including war." Harold Christensen, author of Marriage Analysis, is not the only person who believes marriage is in many ways "hogwash." To borrow a phrase from the 1980's, young women simply have to "say no to marriage." Not only is it unnecessary, but a bad habit as well. We young women who are now at the age for which

Who Should Be The Determining Factor?

997 words - 4 pages in these two arguments. There were a lot of aspects, both these writers took and recollected on different scenarios. In the beginning half of the paper there is a summary of both stories, “Let Gays Marry” and “Leave Marriage Alone.” Basically in “Let Gays Marry,” it discusses how gays feel towards the society and how they don’t want to be second- class citizens. Also, it explains you cannot choose to black, white, gay, etc... In “Leave Marriage

Gay And Lesbian Marriage Essay

569 words - 2 pages Gay and Lesbian Marriage Andrew Sullivan and William Bennett argue profusely on the subject that is in almost every American’s mind, whether or not to civically let gays marry. Between Sullivan’s article “Let Gays Marry” and Bennett’s article, “Leave marriage alone, they pretty much sum up both sides of the argument. Andrew Sullivan, the editor of The New Republic and author of Virtually Normal: An argument about