This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Alternative Methods To Prison Sentencing In Britain

1946 words - 8 pages

More and more people in Britain are being sentenced to jail time: this
is a fact. In 2004, there are currently over eighty thousand inmates.[1]
(Peter Reydt, 2004 / Scottish Executive, 2003) Crime is on the
increase but our prisons are already overcrowded. Consequently, new
prisons will be required to accommodate prisoners. Where will the
money come from to pay for the construction of new prisons? Will they
have a sufficient rehabilitation programs in place? The prison
system is obviously failing because it is not acting as a deterrent.
Clearly we should now be examining why the system is failing and
possible alternatives to prison. What should these alternatives be?
Would they work and would they be seen as a suitable punishment?

First of all, I'd like to look at why the prison service is failing.
Ten years ago, Britain's prison population was actually on the decline
(Casciani, 2002)[2]. This was due to the government at the time
implementing more community based punishments over the use of prison
sentencing. However, not all of the Home Secretaries of the time -
Kenneth Baker and Kenneth Clarke - agreed with this policy and soon
changed their minds and began to follow up on the 'rhetoric of being
'tough' on crime'[3](Cascianni, 2002) by asking the courts to sentence
more people to prison.

Due to these sterner policies being put in place, the government
figures in 1999 actually showed that there were now more than twenty
four thousand people being sent to prison than there were ten years
previous.(Cascianni, 2002)[4] This was despite no change in the amount
of adults being convicted of offenses. The government's 2001 Halliday
Report, which was put in place to investigate prison sentencing,
concluded that the toughening up of sentencing did not mean that there
were more serious crimes being committed. Consequently, all this
'toughening up' on crime just seemed to be adding more and more
numbers to the prison population. Jack Straw, the Home Secretary of
the time, wanted to increase the use of electronic tagging to try and
help ease the numbers entering prison but, on the other hand, he
wanted to toughen up sentencing for offenders he described as "the
worst anti-social crimes such as burglary"[5](Cascianni, 2002). This
appears that Jack Straw was trying to decrease the prison population
but at the same time increase it - a rather contradictory message.
Since David Blunkett's hard line speeches in 2002, the Howard League
for Penal Reform who have been monitoring the prison numbers since
2001, noticed that the actual number of people being sent to prison
had been constant until he started making tough speeches about crime
and punishment. Since then, up to 500 more people per week have been
sentenced to prison - a huge number and a huge burden on the prison


Find Another Essay On Alternative Methods to Prison Sentencing in Britain

Community Corrections: Is it really a sensible alternative to prison?

1542 words - 6 pages It is only in the last 30 years that community corrections have become a substantial part of the correctional system. Beginning in the 1950s, national attention was focused on the development of alternative, community-based correctional services. In the early stages of the community corrections movement, local institutions, residential centers, group homes and specialized probation services were promoted as alternatives to incarceration. In

Exploring Alternative Methods of Discipline to Creative a Positive Learning Environment

613 words - 2 pages Alternative Methods In academic institutions several challenges exist in regards to discipline Today’s teachers and students have been exposed to increasingly violent and hostile environments. In the circumstance that a student is endangering another person, punishment should be swift and intolerant. However there are instances that require a different penalty level that are balanced in relation to the offense. There is a

The methods used by Great Britain to control the land and inhabitants of the United States and India differ vastly

1583 words - 6 pages natural, that enabled Britain to fuel its industries and fund its military. Although these countries were once the property of the same nation, and came under British rule during the 1600's, the methods use by Great Britain to control the land and inhabitants of these countries differ vastly.The United States began to be colonized in the 1600's with the Jamestown settlement. At first the settlement got off to a slow start, and it wasn't until the

Why did Britain not go to war in March 1938?

1982 words - 8 pages Why did Britain not go to war in March 1938Many historians have traced the causes of World War II to problems left unsolved by World War I (1914-1918). World War I and the treaties that ended it also created new political and economic problems. Forceful leaders in several countries took advantage of these problems to seize power. The desire of dictators in Germany, Italy, and Japan to conquer additional territory brought them into conflict with

Capital punishment needs to be abolished for it is manifestly unjust and there is disparity in sentencing

917 words - 4 pages capital punishment.There are many innocent lives on death row. David Jones stated. " Nationally, since 1973, more than 100 people have been exonerated of the crime that landed them on death row." A typical case of Washington, who was mentally retarded, confessed to killing a neighbor. He also confessed to other crimes he could not possibly have committed. After nine years in prison on death row, he was released after having a DNA test, which

Year 9 Commerce had an assignment to do during a period of six weeks. Students chose 4 alternative methods of investing $10, 000 they had inherited

1436 words - 6 pages Investment decisionsYear 9 Commerce had an assignment to do during a period of six weeks. Students chose 4 alternative methods of investing $10, 000 they had inherited. The students had to keep track of the performance of the invested choices on a weekly basis for six weeks. Students would have to research and collect information about shares, interest rates and etc. Students must hand in a written report including illustrations and calculations

Differences in Policing Methods: Correction Variations from State to State

3449 words - 14 pages Parole Survey to come up with an overall layout of how the four different forms of corrections (probation, jail, prison, parole) have increased over the decades. Each category has been broken down by year to show what changes have been made, but at the same time for you and myself, I will give you the overall changes from 1980 to the current period of available data. "In 1980 there were 1,842,100 in the correctional system. Now through 2004 that

Methods to Improve Sleep and Rest in the Hospital

1092 words - 4 pages The founders of nursing acknowledged the need for sleep and rest to aid the body in healing, but with 60% of patients requesting a sedative, this shows the hospital environment is not one that promotes sleep and rest. There is renewed interest in exploring the best nonpharmacological methods of helping achieve sleep and rest while in the hospital to promote healing (Robinson, Weitzel, & Henderson, 2005). Evidence-Based Practice As nurses

Crucial Methods In Order to Achieve Successful Teaching

1113 words - 4 pages The purpose of this paper is to review three peer review articles on excellence in teaching a first grade class and or an elementary level class. In order to be successful in a classroom a teacher must be up to date with the latest methods for enhancing their lessons and abilities for students to learn. It is important for teachers to have supportive interactions with their students in order for the student’s achievements to be successful. It is

To what extent does social class continue to affect voting behaviour in Britain?

3507 words - 14 pages interests of our class, then we are likely to vote Labour in the general election. Since the 1970s, explanations of deviant voting have been more than ever called for. Voters are no longer so tied to the two-party model of part competition. The level of partisanship (voters who are loyal to a particular party) declined dramatically.Before starting to discuss the extent to which social class continues to affect voting behaviour in Britain, I will

Identify And Evaluate The Roles Of The Prosecution And Defense In A Criminal Trial. Identify & Discuss The Sentencing Powers, Available To A Judge In A Specific Criminal Case

1693 words - 7 pages ; as a result, he spent nearly thirty years in prison for a crime he did not commit (BBC: 19/03/2009). However, if a defendant admits guilt then the defense's role will be to seek a lenient sentence based on that omission.There are many stages of a criminal trial and at each one the CPS conceivably carries the majority of the burden. During the first pre-trial hearing at Magistrates Court, the CPS must demonstrate that there is a prima facie case

Similar Essays

Probation: A Sentencing Alternative To Incarceration

936 words - 4 pages . There are specific tasks included in probation that must be completed to stay out of jail. This is not an option that is given to all offenders but it is one of the most common types of correctional supervision used. With the different levels of crime, probation is a sentencing option that should be used to keep prison population in control. The main purpose of probation is as a tool for rehabilitation. Usually confused with parole, probation is

The Disparity In Sentencing Amongst Minorities In Prison

1148 words - 5 pages THE DISPARITY IN SENTENCING AMONGST MINORITY PRISONERS Although some say the disparity of minority to white prison sentences are due to repeat offenses by second and third time offenders, the disparity in the population between black and white Americans in the U.S. doesn't support the fact there are more blacks than whites in American prisons. The make- up of judges, juries and law enforcement officials in the judicial system are a factor

The Disparity In Sentencing Amongst Minorities In Prison

1906 words - 8 pages is due to the societal issues such as racial discrimination, racial inequality of lawmakers in the court system, and presumptive sentencing guidelines. Racism in American society plays a part in the manner in which the judicial system operates. The American prison population is larger than at any time in the history of the penal system in the world.” Nearly half of the more than two million Americans behind bars are African Americans. These

Is Drug Treatment A Viable Alternative To Prison Time?

1265 words - 5 pages against the prisons. With the prisons and county jails facing major overcrowding issues and drug treatment programs being a viable alternative to prison time, more states need to be implementing drug / treatment programs. Treatment / Drug Courts are specialized courts to help stop drug, alcohol, and related criminal activity (U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration,2011). These courts closely monitor the participants in the treatment programs and if