This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Alternatives For Animal Dissection Essay

1118 words - 4 pages

One of the breadth requirements for every student in college is to take a biological or life science course. When it comes to Biology, Anatomy, and few other sciences, one needs to learn about the body parts and the functions. Books explain all the information, but hands on learning is better so animal specimen are used for dissections and experiments. But is this the only way to learn about the body?
There are students that find it disturbing when they look at a dead corpse or are against using animals. With the technology we have now, there are 3-D virtual programs as well as models that can take the place of the specimens. The University of California, Riverside should replace traditional animal dissection and experimentation with alternatives for the biological and life science courses. Not only alternatives make good replacements, but it will be for a good cause, cheaper, and can improve student's learning than dissection.
By replacing traditional dissections with alternatives, lives of animals would be saved. According to National Anti-Vivisection Society's Jodie Wiederkehr, "biology is the 'study of life' not death"(132,Fleischmann). They would no longer have to suffer and be killed. They would be in pain and distress (Balcombe). There are some people that don't follow the ethics on treating animals. Using animals for dissections can have a great risk of them being extinct. Dissection for a course that no one is studying in the biological and life science is causing unneeded deaths of animals.
Animal dissection is expensive and time consuming, especially that it can only be used once and then must be properly thrown away. The price range depends on the animal that is used with the addition of the equipments. Frogs cost between fifteen to nineteen dollars, cats around forty-three to one hundred and five dollars, and the fetal pig approximately sixteen to twenty-seven dollars. Then one must multiply it with the number of students and the supplies must be bought every year. With the alternatives, it will be cheaper and can be reused over. A program would cost around nine hundred dollars, but it is a lifetime license. It can be bought only once and there's no need to buy another one. Also unlike dissecting the animal once and then disposing it, even clay models can be reused.
Clay models provides a "constructive process" that can be helpful for students to "develop surgical and tissue-handling skills", which can't be presented in dissection (68, DeHoff Clark). Dissection only contain a destructive process, that it destroys the structures inside the specimen when trying to get deeper into it. Students can also repeat the process when using the alternatives since it won't get destroyed. According to Dr. Jonathon Balcombe, who has a PhD in ethology and three biology degrees, in his article, "Dissection: The Scientific Case for Alternatives", he claims that dissection is "weak in concept learning and problem solving". Students would just...

Find Another Essay On Alternatives for Animal Dissection

Animal testing: Inevitability of animal testing

1161 words - 5 pages What is an animal tested product? Is it a medicine? Or is it a cosmetic?Some people might think animal tested products as complicated stuffs. In fact, animal tested products are easily found around our lives. As animal testing is available in many uses, it has a long history and has been controversial for many years. Those who insist on abolition of experiments for animals argue that alternatives for animal testing exist. In addition, the

Animal Testing Position Paper

1063 words - 4 pages in the past why continue doing the same tests. Due to the protests of The Center for Alternatives to Animal Testing in 1981, Avon and Revlon have stopped using animals in their research (Comptons, CD). Experiments and research on animals such as the LD50 test and cosmetic tests are cruel and inhumane towards animals. They believe that animals have rights and they are just as important to society as humans are, therefore if humans are not used

Animal Testing Should Be Outlawed

1198 words - 5 pages in their time as test subjects, they are either put to death or sent to a habitat. These animals sent to the habitats are left with severe psychological issues and are not healthy animals anymore (“Animal Research”). Experimentation on animals is unethical. Animal testing is unethical and should be outlawed. Live animals are not necessary for testing because there are many alternatives such as computer software, robots, human tissue cultures, and

Animal Rights

1220 words - 5 pages in scientific experimentation. In today’s society groups such as People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) have continued these traditional fights as well as adding new agendas. These new agendas include hunting and fishing, and dissection of animals in science classes. This paper will discuss the pros and cons of animal experimentation and research, animals in the classroom, animal organizations and hunting. Along with these topics my

Taking a Stand Against Animal Testing

1865 words - 7 pages /animals-used-for-experimentation/classroom-dissection/ Animals in Research and Testing | Animal Use in Research. (n.d.). Animals in Research and Testing | Animal Use in Research. Retrieved from Testing Alternatives. (n.d.). - The American Anti-Vivisection Society (AAVS). Retrieved from Testing_Alternatives.htm#.U127yhyR1w0 Stachura, S. (2008). Drug safety: an argument to ban animal testing. Journal Of Nursing Law, 12(4), 147-156.

Animal Testing: A True Ethical Dilemma

1704 words - 7 pages organism. In this case the animal is not operated on but rather tested in a natural living state such as exposing the animal to a toxin or chemical and documenting the side effects. The other is vivisection and can be closely related to dissection or surgical experiments on the living. It is an operation on a living animal for testing rather than healing purposes. This word is usually associated with negative perceptions such as torture, pain

Testing One Two Three

772 words - 4 pages are considered unreliable (Animal Liberation Humane Education, 2014). The standard testing of medical devices and new medications calls for the exploitation of animals from blinding them to vivisection (dissection of an animal while alive and awake). The assumption that all recently discovered medications must be tested for safety in animal studies ahead of being authorized for human testing is based on the hypothesis that an animal’s response to

Animal Experimentation: The Price of Being Beautiful and Healthy

2378 words - 10 pages animals constitute cruel and inhumane. For instance, the barbaric testing of animals in the medical and cosmetic industry causes the unnecessary suffering and death of millions of animals every year. The harsh horror inflicted upon laboratory animals may be easily avoided and replaced with more effective, moral alternatives. In early 500 B.C., scientists such as Herophilus, Aristotle, and Erasistratus first utilized animal testing and began

The Controversy Over Animal Testing

2148 words - 9 pages testing is rooted from natural curiosity. How the insides of a living organism operate and look is an interesting idea. Because of the fact that dissection of humans was illegal by the Roman Church, animals were the second best option for knowledge of living organisms. (Animal Testing) The debate surrounding the idea of animal testing is a very heated one. There are many alternating opinions to why it is just or not. Animal testing was started in

"Alternatives To Animail Experiments

2038 words - 8 pages creatures in the room that first day of dissection, did not look like the cute little kitten I remembered from my childhood. The concept of alternatives covers more than the replacement of animal use. In addition there are two other categories, reduction and refinement alternatives. . The Three Rs provide a strategy for a rational and stepwise approach to minimizing animal use and the suffering caused by this use, without compromising the quality

Medical Schools and Animal Experimentation

2027 words - 8 pages Issues." PETA. N.p., 2014. Web. 19 Apr. 2014. . Cohn, Meredith. "Alternatives to animal testing gaining ground." The Baltimore Sun [Baltimore] 26 Aug. 2010: 1-2. Print. "Cosmetics and Household-Product Animal Testing | Animals Used for Experimentation | The Issues." PETA. N.p., 2014. Web. 19 Apr. 2014.

Similar Essays

The Ethics Of Animal Testing For Vaccine Development And Potential Alternatives

2451 words - 10 pages potential alternatives to animal testing, and the search for such alternatives is of ethical importance. Historically, the use of animals for experimental purposes dates back to early Greek physician-scientists. Aristotle and Galen both conducted experiments on animals in an effort to contribute to our understanding of science and medicine.1 Claude Bernard later established animal experimentation as part of the scientific method. Known as the

Dissection Of Cats Essay

543 words - 3 pages alternatives to it. There are many other ways to work around the actual dissection of the animal. The National Vivesection Society ( as well as many other companies sell life-size models and CD-ROMs that are available for almost any animal species (sharks, rats, starfish, even insects). Not all students have issues with dissection. " I don't mind dissecting animals as long as it's the best way to learn about the human body," says

Animal Testing Essay

843 words - 4 pages tool in human medicine for decades. (AAVS) Conversely, nine out of ten drugs that appear promising in animal studies go on to fail in human clinical trials. (News and Events) Ending the use of animals in science has emerged throughout the decade making animal test subjects pointless. Through these specific type of alternatives dissection of animals is not necessary as well as vivisection which is the dissection of animal while it is still alive

Defying Your Elders Essay

1571 words - 7 pages evolutions has a direct meaning to how the animal is meant to function, which his dissections of muscles could help prove. The use of dissection gave him the opportunity to use his writings as learning materials for all medical writers and physicians for the 10 or so centuries until the time of Vesalius. The final most important figure to the idea of the anatomical-morphological body and dissection was Andreas Vesalius. His published work