This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Altruism Vs The Selfish Gene Essay

1574 words - 6 pages

Would you give a penny to the needy? How about a kidney? A heart?
The thought of spring break brings up images of partying in warm weather, drunken one-night stands, and the raging hangovers that follow; yet for Rachel Garneau, a junior at Notre-Dame, it represented an pseudo-holiday opportunity for giving, and give she did. This twenty year old gave up a kidney for a complete stranger. There was an air of psychosis to her as she walked right into the University Of Chicago’s Bernard Mitchell Hospital, calm as ever; her demeanor quite indifferent, her nonchalance quite unnerving. Funny how we find this act of complete altruism ‘weird’; because it is weird, all that we know from evolution, Darwinism, basic human tendencies, and even the insightful field of behavioral economics contradicts what Rachel Garneau chose to do at 5:45 a.m. on a Tuesday: she gave till it hurt, and then some more.
Economics, a field based on profit and gain, when taken into context of human choices and decisions, leads to a deeper understanding of the motivation behind our actions. The fundamental theory behind welfare Economics is: “Assume all individuals are selfish price takers. Then a competitive equilibrium is Pareto optimal (Feldman 1987, IV, 890)”. The amalgamation of the life’s work of Adam Smith was proving that humans are selfish and that we will, when it comes down to it, succeed for our own profit. So how would he explain a concept so selfless as altruism? How would he go about making sense of Rachel Garneau’s actions?
Surprisingly, it is a culmination of pure science and theories of economics that helps us unravels the mysteries of this very ‘God-like’ selflessness. Research in modern cognitive neuroscience has led to a new theory on altruism. We think of giving as a choice, as a conscious decision we make out of the ‘goodness of our hearts’; but what if there is more, what if our very evolution has primed us in ways that lead to not individual gain but social cooperation? Studies conducted on the early developmental egalitarianism and parochialism in children show that other-regarding factors are, to some extend, exist as inherent tendencies in all humans: when allowed to choose between how candy is distributed among an anonymous partner and themselves, the children chose to be heavily selfless in their distribution. As Fehr et al. come to this startling conclusion in their paper “Egalitarianism in young children”, we see how proper upbringing and cultural norms are not solely responsible for our altruistic nature. We have evolved to take others into consideration in our choices; we have evolved a ‘heart’.
The innateness of these ‘selfless’ tendencies is exemplified by the close study of our primitive ancestors. Frans de Waal, professor of psychology at Emory University, studied the habit of the greater apes. In his work “Homo homini lupus? Morality, the Social Instincts, and our Fellow Primates”, deWaal talks about the surprising altruism we see in...

Find Another Essay On Altruism VS The Selfish Gene

Altruism: Selfless or Selfish? Essay

1611 words - 6 pages Altruism: Selfless or Selfish? "We are all here on earth to help others. What I can't figure out is what the others are here for." --W. H. Auden (1) Whether we are here to help others is a question I've often asked myself, and a question I will not be able to answer while I am still here on earth. Perhaps before I even consider that question, however, I should wonder whether we even can be here to help others: is selflessness really

Nature vs. Nurture Essay

2511 words - 10 pages , "We have the power to defy the selfish genes of our birth and, if necessary, the selfish memes of our indoctrination. We can even discuss ways of deliberately cultivating and nurturing pure, disinterested altruism — something that has no place in nature, something that has never existed before in the whole history of the world. We are built as gene machines and cultured as meme machines, but we have the power to turn against our creators. We

Altruism: The Illusion of Self-Interest

1156 words - 5 pages after it is over, it will always turn into a reciprocal altruism action. Many would argue that moral would influence in it as well as the opposite of altruism, ethics. Another two different main points which have to respect this altruism theory is the universal egoism and the moral. Although altruism and egoism are completely opposites, there is a connection between so-called selfish behavior and altruistic acts. The moral action is based largely

The Causes of Altruism

1148 words - 5 pages How do humans actually behave when faced with the decision to help others? The innate desire that compels humans to help is called altruism by psychologists. Through this feeling, humans transform from a selfish jerk to a more compassionate and caring person. Some psychologists believe that this feeling stems from nature itself. Despite the fact that some altruistic acts originate from the pressures of society, altruism predominantly

Metaphor, Sociobiology, and Nature vs. Nurture: The Biological Battle of the Century

2375 words - 10 pages Wright, his ally, is "unusually well positioned to deal with the issue of sociobiology" (147)—he is contributing editor at Time, The New Republic, and Slate magazines. And my does he pack a mean punch! Round 1: The sociobiologists move in quickly with their own metaphor! I haven’t seen strategy like this since Dawkin’s Selfish Gene metaphor! Wright begins to pit metaphor against metaphor in this astonishing fight! And what is their

Biology and Altruism

931 words - 4 pages as "I see you eagle, but it's pointless for you to try and catch me."Altruism deals with one species opposing selfish acts to better ones around them. I think this is very valuable but hard to place among evolutionary theory. Evolution theory basically states that "individuals" constantly work to survive and throughout hundreds of years of passing on the best traits in order to help the species be best adapted to that environment. One might think

Analysis of Real Altruism

1726 words - 7 pages itself and the ideas of that person can be considered altruistic. But when the goal is to receive self-benefit from helping another person, this behavior would be considered selfish. They designed experiments to try figure out the real idea behind an action to help someone and to test the empathy-altruism idea against all opposite theories. Their results suggested that the empathy-altruism ideas was a valid and could be researched. But their study

Is it possible to identify some property or a set of properties that necessarily, all and only humans have? Is this what we mean when we speak of

1258 words - 6 pages human, it is exactly (and no more than) that the human being shares in the gene pool of Homo sapiens sapiens.” Though an essential trait of being human is sharing in the common gene pool of Homo sapiens sapiens, this does not quite correlate with what we mean when we speak of ‘human nature’ in casual conversation. Human nature is often heard of in phrases such as “it is in human nature to be selfish” and “humans are curious by nature.” When

The Smartest Guys or the Biggest A-Holes in the Room?

1626 words - 7 pages like hyenas for our next prey to apply our awesome selfishness on and further our genes. Cowardice to the highest level, that is what Skilling and the culture of Enron represented. When attempting to account for his actions and the way he conditioned the culture in Enron, he stated that his favorite book the “Selfish Gene” informed his approach. Wait, I thought Harvard graduates could read…because if that’s the case, how did he miss pages over

Good vs. Evil By JumboMoos An analysis using "A seperate peace" and "East of Eden"

850 words - 3 pages . The paragon for all best friends. Forgiving. Almost so forgiving as to be naïve. Almost perfect.Gene is everything we are. Every single person in this world is Gene. Sarcastic to hide our weakness, plotting, and untruthful, even to ourselves. Doing things for the wrong reasons.Is man inherently evil? As a child we knew as much of this Gene character as I do now. Brooding in my subconscious, selfish, and, yes, evil. Just the little things

Analysis of Altruism And Egoism in Ayn Rand's The Fountainhead

1484 words - 6 pages development. There are four characters in particular who distinctly exhibit the attributes of altruistic and egoistic individuals: Catherine Halsey, Peter Keating, and Ellsworth Toohey possess altruistic qualities; whereas, Howard Roark is explicitly egoistic. By definition, altruism is "the principle or practice of unselfish concern for or devotion to the welfare of others". Through vigorous analysis, however, I have established it to be a

Similar Essays

The Selfish Gene By R Ichard Dawkins. Chapter By Chapter Overview Of The Book

3727 words - 15 pages altruism, because we are born selfish. Let us understand what our own selfish genes are up to, because we may then at least have a chance to upset their designs, something that no other species has ever aspired to do.I shall argue that the fundamental unit of selection, and therefore of self-interest, is not the species, nor the group, nor even, strictly, the individual. It is the gene, the unit of heredity.Chapter 2 - The replicatorsWas there to

Altruism Vs Seclusion, A Sociological Approach To The Psychology Of Interaction

1126 words - 5 pages to be a basic form of altruism. I also believe the positive forms of the social interactions point towards altruism, while the negative forms signify seclusive tendency. The primary research consisted of non-intrusive, observations of students and faculty on or around campuses in the Albuquerque area. The analysis of the secondary data yielded that Americans, on average, believe their positive characteristics were high while their negative ones

Strong Individualism Vs. Strong Government This Essay Is About Wither Or Not Society Should Embrace Altruism And Whether Its The Governments Place To Do So Or The Individuals

1499 words - 6 pages their country they should not be done. By Mussolini’s reasoning the government should be first and foremost in a person’s life and individualistic thoughts and actions are just selfish acts towards the progress of one’s society.Also in support of a strong government over individualism is Thomas Hobbes. Hobbes believes a strong government is essential to keeping peace in society as without a strong government intact he believes

Altruism Essay

1000 words - 4 pages ] The presence of altruistic genes in humans today resulted from the selfish notion of gene inheritance. After all, genes are selfish and a person is simply the gene’s method of survival. [12] Reciprocal altruism, primitive passive sympathy and altruistic behaviour through social norms are acts which largely benefit the individual and can hardly be seen as a selfless act. In conclusion, altruism should not be defined as an act carried out by an individual in order to benefit another individual rather, it should be defined as an act carried out by an individual, regardless of motive to benefit another. [13]