This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

America’s Broken Immigration System Essay

1278 words - 5 pages

There has been lots of controversy on the issues concerning a solution to America’s broken immigration system. Democratic and republican parties can’t seem to agree with one another, leaving reform at a stand-still. Democrats are focused on giving illegal immigrants a path to citizenship while Republicans are focused on border security. The fact is both of these approaches should work in unison with each other to provide the most efficient route in fixing immigration.
Providing a path to citizenship has been labeled as granting amnesty. In 1986, President Ronald Reagan introduced an amnesty plan similar to the one being proposed as a solution for America’s current immigration problems. The 1986 bill required immigrants to prove they were not guilty of crimes, enforced stricter employment laws, and only applied to those who were here before 1982. Unfortunately, this bill failed. Fraudulent documents circulated throughout the system and nearly 90% of the 1.3 million agricultural applications were approved even though fraud had been detected in nearly one third of the applications (Swarns). Because of this failure, Republicans are reluctant to vote for amnesty today. Today’s immigration reforms however, have a much better chance than they did twenty seven years ago. Technology improvements will allow officials to more closely monitor and filter the legitimate applications. Electronic computer systems such as E-Verify will be put in place to help employers confirm legal status. E-Verify is an online program that compares mandatory I-9 work forms to the records of those that the Department of Homeland Security and Social Security have on the employees (“What is E-Verify?”). The program will provide employers with instant, secure, and accurate eligibility results, giving an advantage in countering fraudulent documents. Tougher penalties will be set for businesses that choose to hire illegal workers anyway. Fines in the new immigration bill are expected to be around $3,200 for the first offense and range all the way to $16,000 for three or more offenses (Matthews).
There is question on whether or not the immigrants will help or hurt the economy. Some say immigrants will take jobs from Americans and damper U.S. tax rolls because they aren’t as skilled or educated. The fact is immigrants actually increase “overall wages and the pool of jobs” and add to the U.S. revenue (Dwoskin). In 2006 there was a suspected “21 million immigrants, about 15 percent of the labor force, [that] h[e]ld jobs in the U.S.” However, the U.S. only had about seven million unemployed. “So the majority of immigrants can't literally have "taken" jobs; they must be doing jobs that wouldn't have existed had the immigrants not been here,” (Lowenstein). Roger Lowenstein also presents a valid and insightful point in stating that immigrants who take these jobs that “wouldn’t have existed”, relative prices could be lowered in a similar way that global trade does.
Through amnesty...

Find Another Essay On America’s Broken Immigration System

Illegal Immigration Essay

1082 words - 5 pages country’s responsibility to fix a broken immigration system, protect the people’s security and prosperity, and help our neighbors to achieve those equal opportunities they seek in the country without discrimination. Works Cited Color of Crime. 2nd ed. Virginia: n.p., 2005. Race, Crime, and Justice in America. New Century Foundation, 2005. Web. 27 Feb. 2014. D' Amato, Alfonse M., comp. "Illegal Aliens." Report to Congressional Request

The Need for Positive Migration Policies in the United States

2245 words - 9 pages provide documentation for a legitimate job. These illegal immigrants are being taken advantage of by being forced to work backbreaking, long-hour jobs for under minimum wage. These jobs are taking money away from the government because it is not gaining tax revenue when it should be. The broken immigration system is also preventing the economy to grow. America attracts people from all over the world. People that are looking to start businesses

Why Half of the US and President Obama are in Favor of Immigration Reform

2537 words - 11 pages There are two sides in the debate about immigration. The opposing side argues that there are more negative than positive consequences to immigration reform. They believe that creating a gateway for illegal immigrants to gain citizenship will encourage more illegal immigration and reward those who have broken the law. They also argue that more immigrants will result in less resources and jobs for American citizens. Meanwhile, those who support

A Hole in the Immigration Ship

2296 words - 10 pages , immigrants with degrees in STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) fields should be able to receive an expedited green card because they help boost the economy. Overall the American immigration system hurts the economy because the country is not bringing is highly skilled workers; instead they are bringing in under skilled and high-risk immigrants. The only way that the economy can be boosted is if American politicians put their

Immigration Law: Outlining Immigration Reform Principles

600 words - 3 pages strategy can possibly be now. The focus is currently on Republicans because they have 233 of the 435 voting seats in the House of Representatives. Which means they have a majority vote on federal legislation. On January 28th, 2013, 8 bi-partisan Senators proposed an immigration reform including changes on the business immigration system, work visas for low-skilled applicants, an extended employment verification system and a citizenship path for

Media’s Power On Urban Movements

1949 words - 8 pages social movement development there are four main stages, coalescence, bureaucra¬tization, and decline (Christiansen, 2009). Though the future of the immigrant-rights movement is uncertain, this movement in currently located within the bureaucra-tization and decline stage. At a stand still within our political system President Obama has heavily advocated for this issue saying its time to fix our “broken immigration system” and mentioning, “we’ve

Immigration in USA

1675 words - 7 pages . Since 1900 to 1921, Congress created the "quota system," which gave authorization for a specified number of individuals of all ethnic groups in immigration like most Asian nations (Wellman, Cole). The government has also put provisions designed to encourage migration of certain kinds of workers who have lost the skills from the current population. In 1924, as the fears of the immigrants fleeing from border increased, Congress set up the first

stopping deportation

808 words - 4 pages concerned about deportation; it’s separating and has separated thousands and thousands of families. The immigration reform was on Obama’s agenda before he even was elected president to the United States. “During his presidential campaign in 2008 he spoke to Latino voters about the importance of fixing America’s broken immigration system”. When Obama was installed in the Whitehouse his plan was to begin the reform during his first year as the

The Cost of Illegal Imigration

1984 words - 8 pages immigration. Illegal immigrants have caused a struggle politically, in the government and have affected you even in your own schools and work. We must rectify the immigration system to help our predicament because the effects of illegal immigration may surprise you. One of the largest disadvantages of allowing illegal immigrants in our country is the cost. They take great sums of money away from taxpayers and our government, though such things as

Illegal Immigration and Equal Rights

1657 words - 7 pages them because they contrast the immigrant’s struggles with those of early equal rights movements. The simple fact that the immigration system in this country is broken comes as no surprise to Americans. America admits more legal immigrants than any other country in the world; (Johnson Mac 1) however proponents of the immigration bill would argue that illegal immigration exists due to the limits placed on legal immigration. Anti-Immigration

Should Immigration Be Limited?

819 words - 3 pages million residents who find comfort in the freedoms of America. America is a land of immigrants, also referred to as the “melting pot of the world.” However, the possibility that America’s kettle is over-flowing concerns its citizens and some politicians.      Ideas for capping immigration have been voiced in the past, but have not been heard. While some will argue legal immigration should have no restrictions, most Americans

Similar Essays

Immigration Reforms Essay

1759 words - 8 pages the US it does allow your entire work history even if they were illegal to be counted toward Social Security benefits. They feel that we pass strict laws to change this and not allow work done illegally from counting towards future benefits. For Immigration Reforms They feel that we need to fix immediately America’s broken immigration system, this would grow our economy and allow illegals and their children the chance to earn their citizenship

The U.S. Needs Comprehensive Immigration Reform

2942 words - 12 pages for the past three decades. The faces of this broken immigration system are the estimated eleven million of undocumented families, including two million children, who are living an American lifestyle as they work, live and study in American soil (Garcia, 2013). Although undocumented individuals have adopted American values as their own, they are forced to remain under the shadows. In hiding, immigrants are not capable of benefitting neither the

The Truth Behind America’s Anti Immigration Ideology

898 words - 4 pages exciting process of immigration (Van Dijk 1-2). Politics and laws are physical impediments that stand in the way of immigration in America and are a result of the ideologies of racism and nativism. The U.S. has a broken immigration system with confusing and easily-manipulated laws and politicians are too focused on their own agendas to fix these laws. With America’s immigration laws where they are at now, employers are able to use and manipulate

The Ideologies Of Racism And Nativism

1937 words - 8 pages nativism. The U.S. has a broken immigration system with confusing and easily manipulated laws, and politicians are too focused on their own agendas to fix these laws. In the state America’s immigration laws are at now, employers are able to use and cheat the system to their own advantage. Eleven million immigrants have been able to sneak past the borders and live undocumented lives here in the U.S., many of which came in search of low-paying jobs