This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

America’s Failing Public Schools: Charter Schools Are Not The Solution

1955 words - 8 pages

America’s Failing Public Schools: Charter Schools Are Not the Solution

It was with wild fanfare that the state’s Republican legislature and Republican Governor enacted their reforms for the state’s public school system. Among the panaceas was charter schools, a ‘90s education fad that gives individual parents the right to send their children to state-approved public charter schools at public expense. Politicians reasoned that less-bureaucratic charter schools would teach students better than traditional public schools because charter schools wouldn’t be subject to the same mandates that the state had heaped upon public schools. Furthermore, traditional schools would be forced to compete with charter schools as they lured thousands of students and millions of dollars away from traditional public schools. Competition from charter schools would then lead to all-around better schools in the state as traditional public schools improved themselves to remain competitive with the cutting-edge charter schools.

The charter school program aimed to allocate educational resources via market mechanism by shifting towards freedom of contract. However, the plan unfairly mixes individual decision making with the expenditure of public tax dollars. Moreover, the competition through which legislators sought to improve education throughout state schools has failed to materialize as students enrolled in Michigan charter schools remain a drop in the bucket.

In this paper, I will show how the charter school movement represents a limited shift towards freedom of contract and explain why this shift is unfair to the taxpayers of the state of Michigan. Further, I will argue that the market mechanism has not yet become a factor in public education in Michigan but that it can be a method for allocating educational resources. Finally, I will offer my solution for improving state schools, which attempts to create strong individual citizens and to remain accountable to the taxpayers of Michigan.

Charter schools are aimed at giving parents and educators greater freedom to design an educational program aimed at increasing student achievement, accounting for greater freedom of contract between not only parent and school but also school and state.

There are a number of ways that charter schools give parents greater individual control over their childrens’ education. No longer is a child bound to attend a particular school based on the geographical location of his or her home. Parents have the freedom to select a charter school that they feel would best suit the needs of their children1. Parents also have a greater say in the affairs of charter schools compared to public schools. In many instances, parents serve on the “board of education” governing the charter school, a board whose context is determined by a school’s charter and not state law. This contrasts with the traditional public school board that is limited to seven members elected from the...

Find Another Essay On America’s Failing Public Schools: Charter Schools Are Not the Solution

The Asinine Argument between Charter Schools and Public Schools

1481 words - 6 pages pressing debate: Are charter schools truly superior to public schools? Well, not all charter schools serve students better than public schools because of the end-results of studies comparing the test grades between charter and public schools, the growing number of charter schools being run by for-profit educational management organizations (EMOs), the scandal involving test scores with a charter school, and the stereotype of how a typical person

Charter Schools Essay

1449 words - 6 pages Charter schools are an alternative to public schools. Whether this alternative is a better solution to the public schools is the argument. Public schools can be just as creative as charter schools. Public schools are funded by our tax dollars, which ultimately the United States Government decides where those funds go. Education should be the last thing to be cut in the budget, but unfortunately, we the people do not have a choice other than the

Charter Schools

2788 words - 11 pages programs charters offer are attractive to parents and therefore increases neighboring public schools competitive spirit to improve in an effort to keep its students.School systems begin to see charters as an addition to the district's school inventory to be used as research and development sites and develop a sense of esprit de corps.Once a charter is opened, many school districts view it as an island all to itself and are often not included in

Why Charter Schools Are Important to Education

1952 words - 8 pages Why Charter Schools Are Important to Education Charter schools are public schools, but can be a better option than traditional public schools for some students. By definition, a charter school is a publicly funded and privately run school under the charter of an educational authority. (2-4) A charter school is held to a different set of standards than most traditional public schools. This can often work towards their advantage because it allows

Charter Schools in Washington DC: A Reasonable Solution?

2471 words - 10 pages Are They a Reasonable Solution for Washington D.C.’s Public Schools? The nation’s capital has a problematic history with public school education. Washington D.C. public schools have been consistently ranked as having the “lowest graduation rate” in the United States for years (Brown). To address this problem, the District has started making critical reforms. Due to Washington D.C.’s long-term negligence of public education, charter schools

Public Schools & Private Schools

460 words - 2 pages Most people think private schools are far superior to public schools, but that may not be so.I have a different viewpoint in the direction of Public Schools. I consider Public school education is just as high-quality as Private Schools. I experienced that the students are better-rounded, both scholastically and worldly, when in public schools. As a public school graduate, I feel that I have been exposed to all types of diversity and situations

What are Charter Schools and why are they so unique?

631 words - 3 pages unsuccessful or displeased in regular school settings seem generally satisfied with the charter school experience.Funding is also a common question. Charter schools are public schools that do not charge tuition. Most charters are created by groups of parents, teachers, and community leaders, and most evolved from former existing public schools. Much like district public schools, they are funded according to attendance (Edexcellence). But many

A Unique Approach: Education in Public and Charter Schools

968 words - 4 pages educational decisions, like choice of curriculum. A distinguishing element of charter schools is their freedom from the rules and regulations of government, which inhibit the choices of their public school counterparts. Still, this freedom is not without stipulations, charter schools must demonstrate student achievement on state assessments and are accountable for meeting state graduation standards. (WestEd, 2010) Charter schools are independent of

Policies Toward LGBT Students in America’s Public Schools

2217 words - 9 pages previous year, 31.2% had been physically harassed and 16.8% had been physically assaulted” (Kosciw et al. 2012). When LGBT students do not have equal treatment in public schools, it reinforces to other students that they are different. As a result other, students think it is acceptable to bully them. With the lack of policies protecting these students against discrimination, bullying and harassment is more likely to take place. Also, without this

Public Schools

766 words - 3 pages have long maintained that governments are not as knowledgeable about individual school environments as those who and they have to manage many schools, whereas the owners of a specific private subsidized school would be well informed about the school's circumstances and can concentrate on that school alone. They say that the governments role should become that of regulator, not schoolmaster, and that since the private schools do not face the

Public Schools

734 words - 3 pages attend schools in Costa Rica. I liked the article because it showed truthfulness to it. I have seen many of the factors that affect why some students cannot attend private of even public schools. Nothing really surprised me about this article, because for the most part I have "been there and done that," but what I did find interesting is that Costa Rica is rated as one if not the most literate Latin American country. I was not aware of this

Similar Essays

Vouchers Are Not The Solution For Improving Public Schools

1762 words - 7 pages , represents tinkering on the fringe of reform, offering no resolution to the central question, how do we improve education for all of America’s public schoolchildren?” Voucher supporters make several arguments not supported by research in support of their stance. Supporters argue that vouchers provide a solution for the nations failing public schools, they help children that use them, and that vouchers create motivation for public schools to

Public Schools Are The Problem, Private Schools Are The Solution

1060 words - 4 pages schooling over public because public schools are not meeting their children’s academic, individual, and special education needs.      First, parents expect that their children will know how to read, write, and acquire basic math skills by the time they graduate. However, public schools throughout the United States are failing to teach these basic academic skills. The French Commission for American Education reported that: "If there be a nation

America’s Children Deserve Charter Schools Essay

2587 words - 10 pages they are properly used to the best interest of the students and the school. The only issue is that because there are not very many charters available, enrollment opportunities are limited. Expansion of successful charter schools is needed so that more children can take advantage of what charter schools have to offer. There are many causes that led public education to this point. Failing schools did not happen overnight. It is the accumulation of

Charter Schools Vs. Public Schools Essay

1566 words - 7 pages high school drop outs and teen pregnancies, and a record of students failing all five parts of the Ohio graduation test. This can happen anywhere and at any school, but happens more often at public schools . Therefore schools are the best alternative for children’s educational needs. Cleveland has many different charter schools to choose from, and one of those types is called breakthrough schools. Breakthrough schools are one of Cleveland’s