This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

America's Tax System: Flat Or Fair?

877 words - 4 pages

America’s Tax System, Flat or Fair?

“No taxation without representation!” A fair tax system was what the American colonists were looking for and one that many say we are still trying to achieve. Today, while we are all represented in government and are all required to pay taxes, some still perceive the system of taxation as unfair, allowing for specialized interests, loopholes, as well as more/less taxation based on income. Should the American tax system remain the same, where individuals’ income is taxed based on how much one makes with loopholes and deductions? Should we consider a system that would eliminate progressive income taxes, taxing everyone at an equal rate through the Flat Rate Tax or should taxes be collected through national consumption of retail goods and the Fair Tax System?
Our current system of taxation is a varied rate percentage based on different income brackets. Many say that it violates our constitutional rights through unequal taxation. Multiple deductions, loopholes, special rates, and a complex system of regulations all characterize our Federal Income Tax System, prompting many to question why it is still being used (Peters, 2013). The current system although bringing in over $3 trillion, taxes income multiple times, and includes the taxing of estate, labor, savings, and investments (National Priorities Project, 2013). The system itself is complex with over 20,000 pages of regulations, requiring a massive filing system, which is set up and maintained by an even larger IRS, requiring over $225 billion in compliance costs (Hall, 2001). One can be hard pressed to find an advantage in the current system, other than the fact that it provides the government with an enormous amount of funds, and it has been road-tested.
While there are advantages and disadvantages associated with each of the new tax proposals, I believe that the Flat Rate Tax System would be the most fair. Taxing everyone’s income as a flat rate treats everyone equally, no matter what income bracket you are in. Since the flat rate percentage, usually around 17% is assessed on one’s income, it is still progressive, so the rich would pay more as a dollar amount and the poor would pay less (in dollars), but nevertheless an equal percentage (Hall, 2001). The Fair Tax System, although taxing everyone equally through the purchasing of retail products, places more of a burden on the lower income class, as they are the ones who spend more freely. Even if the Fair Tax would rebate or eliminate taxing of those below the poverty line, the question of equal taxation arises again as these individuals would not be...

Find Another Essay On America's Tax System: Flat or Fair?

The United States Should Not Impose a Flat Tax

1569 words - 7 pages A flat tax is a system in which a person’s income is not a factor and a single rate is set for all taxpayers. This kind of tax includes no deductions or exemptions. The United State’s current, progressive tax is very different from a flat tax, the most noticeable reason being that a progressive tax takes different percents of income depending on what income bracket a person falls into (Investopedia). During 2010 in the United States

Progressive Taxation System vs. Flat Taxation System

1076 words - 5 pages The United States’ economy, as everyone knows, is not in its best shape. One way the government gains money is by imposing taxes on people. There are many taxes that are placed on different items that the public needs or already has. The United States uses a taxation system which is criticized by many people due to not fully understanding the system. The system used is called progressive tax. However, many people believe the system of flat tax

The Variable Rate Income Tax: Flat Tax

2192 words - 9 pages government-funded programs. Questions Still Remain After reading this article, I had questions Iron did not answer. In the article, Iron mentions a 20 percent flat tax rate. He then states that this tax rate would led to a $200,000 tax cut for the 1% of Americans who are currently in the upper class (Irons). One I had before reading the article was why isn’t there a fair tax rate that is proportional to one’s income without deductions or

Progressive Taxation Better for Fairness

2274 words - 10 pages , one of them is the faire distribution. The fair distribution of the income tax burden has long been a central issue in policy making (Diamond & Saez, 2011, p.1). A large number of academic literature has developed two types of income tax theory to cast light on the problems of fair distribution—— progressive tax system and flat tax system. A flat tax (short for flat tax rate) is a tax system with a constant marginal rate, usually applied to

A Flattened Income Tax

2874 words - 11 pages falls (Merino 40). In general, when one brings in an income of $16,000 or less, he no longer has to pay taxes (Duby 1). The progressive tax is just one of many ways the government can collect income taxes. Another way of collecting income taxes is by using a flat rate. Americans should implement a flat tax on incomes because the tax system would be simpler, fairer, and promote work and education. A flat tax is a tax in which the rate of taxation

Comparing and Contrasting United States and International Tax Systems

1040 words - 4 pages citizens. A marginal tax system, which the United States uses, places taxpayers into brackets by income. The percentage of income taxed raises in each bracket.The way a government taxes its people is often definitive of the way that government operates. Many people feel very strongly that one system or another is the ethical or fair way to collect taxes. Each system certainly presents fairness in at least some way. At the same time, every tax

Flat Tax

2979 words - 12 pages even the people at the IRS whose job it is to provide answers to taxpayer questions don't always understand the tax code. In 1993, for example, the IRS provided confused taxpayers with 8.5 million incorrect or incomplete answers” (Armey). The flat tax replaces the current income tax code, with its maze of exemptions, loopholes, and targeted breaks, with a system so simple Americans could file their taxes on a postcard-size form. The Tax

flat tax bill

588 words - 2 pages single tax rate as low as possible. The 12. cost of using the current tax system totals about $200 billion annually, 13. or $700 for every man, woman, and child in America. A flat tax would 14. reduce those totals by 94% , saving taxpayers more than $100 15. BILLION in compliance costs each year. Even with the reduced tax 16. rate, it is still possible to provide revenue to cover the cost of 17. government. America has the right to demand

Tax Reformation Common Ground

1549 words - 7 pages agency alone costs the taxpayers eleven million dollars. With less of a hassle filing taxes there would not be the need for such a big government agency. Since a flat tax is neither parties optimal solution, neither party has chosen to adopt it, but it is a fair compromise and has been discussed. It would seem based on revenue comparison that a flat tax would be more beneficial. But many people are still very skeptical as to whether or not a flat

United States Tax Policy

2474 words - 10 pages , the same dollar amount. This may seem fair, but in actuality, it requires lower-income individuals to pay a much larger portion of their income. For example, a $500 licensing fee is 10% of a $5,000 income, where it is only 1% of a $50,000 income. A proportional or flat tax requires every taxpayer to pay the same fixed rate. If a 10% state sales tax was passed, low, middle, and high-income taxpayers would all pay 10% on purchases. Like a

The Flat Tax

914 words - 4 pages tax system would be beneficial to all concerned and will ease the growing separation between the wealthy and poor as the capacity of the average citizen to save resources should be greatly increased, which will in turn generate capital for investment into the economy. If a flat tax system were realized, it would prove to be a constructive benefit to the United States taxpayer. The burden would be fair, transparent, and easily adaptable. America should explore the consumption tax.

Similar Essays

Flat Tax System Essay

2264 words - 9 pages The current tax system is extremely complicated and punishes those who are successful by taxing people more than the average citizens. If flat tax were to be in the United States it would create fairness within the economy and be less complicated. Flat tax would not punish people for having higher income; instead flat tax would create equality to all tax payers. The taxpayers would not be complaining to the neighbors or their close relatives

The Canadian Governing System Is Not Fair Or Democratic

1391 words - 6 pages , even more radical law or tax in the future. Brian Mulroney is a walking example of how the power should be balanced in government. A head of State in a democratic nation should not have too much power, and Canada is no exception. A way to restrict his power is to take a page from the American governing system, where the branches of government are organized in a way so that no branch, including the President’s, holds more power than another. The

Flat Tax Essay

2183 words - 9 pages The current tax system is extremely complicated and punishes those who are successful by taxing people more than the average citizens. If flat tax were to be in the United States it would create fairness within the economy and be less complicated. Flat tax would not punish people for having higher income; instead flat tax would create equality to all tax payers. The taxpayers would not be complaining to the neighbors or their close relatives

The Flat Tax Essay

992 words - 4 pages The flat tax structure applies an “average tax rate [that] is the same at all income levels [with] everyone pay[ing] the same percentage of their income in taxes” (Gwartney, Stroup, Sobel, & Macpherson, 2013, p. 84). The theory behind the flat tax system stems from the fundamental concept of supply-side fiscal policy that states, “Lower tax rates increase the incentive of people to work, supply resources, and use them more efficiently and