America Does Not Need Gun Control

1318 words - 5 pages - by admonishsickle ✓ Expert Reviewed

Gun control is often considered as an effective means of protecting ordinary citizens. We all want to feel safe, and it's easy to ascribe notions of safety to the idea of gun control. Unfortunately, feeling safe and actually being safe can be very different things. Gun control sounds wonderful in theory: no guns means no shootings. If only it were that simple. When one considers some of the worst shootings and gun-related crimes in recent history, it's peculiar to realize how often these occurred in places where guns were illegal to carry or even own. It's downright disturbing to realize that, in some cases, the only armed person in sight was the one planning a crime. A sign that says 'no guns' might as well say 'no resistance'. What safer environment could exist—for a criminal? It is my intention, throughout this paper, to discuss the disadvantages and incongruities of gun control policies, and to highlight and provide argument for the positive benefits of gun ownership.
The major problem with gun control laws is that it is likely only the law-abiding will obey them. In the midst of planning or perpetrating a crime, is it plausible that criminals stop and wonder whether their firearm is duly registered with the state, or even legal in their local ordinance? Seems kind of silly. In the meantime, some conscientious citizens have turned in their firearms while others no longer carry them out of the house, or carry their handguns about in a locked case in their car (where they are about as useful a means for defense as butter for cutting granite). Clearly, the law is only a restriction upon those who obey it.
Another problem is deciding whether or not gun control laws are even, well, lawful. This is not as cut and dried as it may seem because it is not enough to be able to pass a law or ordinance, a law must be able to stand up to scrutiny as 'constitutional'. The recent decision in McDonald v. Chicago says that “the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment incorporates the Second Amendment right recognized in Heller.” (slip op., 44) The result of this decision is that Chicago residents are recognized as fully within their rights to keep guns for home defense, and laws that are essentially a ban in their effect are actually unconstitutional.
Maybe you're thinking that, if anyone was in a situation that would necessitate a gun, surely it is a matter for the police? While the police do serve a useful function and are essential in the due process of law, they are not wholly effective at crime-prevention. In fact, according to the Supreme Court, “nothing in the language of the Due Process Clause itself requires the State to protect the life, liberty, and property of its citizens against invasion by private actors.” (DeShaney v. Winnebago Cty. Soc. Servs. Dept. 195). Is protection a goal of the police force? Probably. Nonetheless, it is not a requirement; there is still an expectation for citizens to be responsible for their own...

Find Another Essay On America Does Not Need Gun Control

America Needs Gun Education, Not Gun Control Laws

2287 words - 9 pages mass extermination of Jews began. By the time Germany was stopped millions of innocent men, women, and children were killed. If these people had not been disarmed by the government, they would have had the means to protect themselves. Even with history example of the negative effects of gun control educating the people of need for gun ownership faces many challenges. Many in the news media seem to support and agree with the gun control measures...

A Need for Gun Control but Not the Governments Form

862 words - 3 pages , many people would prefer a gun to defend themselves than whatever is closest, like an umbrella. People do not fully understand guns, or what gun control actually is; therefore people have to understand or society could be in trouble. Guns should be controlled but not to the extent that the government wants to. Guns kill people along with many other things but the real things that need controlled are people. Crime is already high enough in this...

Gun Control: There is no need for anymore Gun Control. Does Gun Control prevent crimes?Did Gun Control ever prevent crime?

809 words - 3 pages clearly shows no connection between the sell of firearms increase and a increase in murder rate. The murder rate also dropped 20 percent from 24,526 to 19,654 from 1993 to1996, there was an additional nine percent drop in 1997. As reported in the May 25, 1998, edition of U.S. News & World Report. As you can see the murder rate decrease trend does not end in 1963.The truth is most gun laws don't work. Again in David B. Kopel's words...

Gun Control in America

1071 words - 4 pages were first time offenders and claim they were in situations that got "out of control." So, this indicates that many gun violence situations are not necessarily with intent. Unfortunately a lot of the gun crimes committed with intent leave no survivor to question. Only recently, in the Aurora, CO move theatre shooting was the perpetrator, James Holmes, left alive and many hope to better understand the mind of mad man. However, with so few subjects...

Commonsense Control, Not Gun Control

1281 words - 5 pages want. They want a ban on all firearms. But that is not the solution, the solution is the education of every person that purchases a firearm and required trigger locks, and stricter compliance by judges to the sentences mandated for crimes involving firearms.The 'most recent attempt at federal gun legislation was the Gun Control Act of 1968...

The 2nd Amendment Does Not allow Gun Control

3696 words - 15 pages . "Banning Assault Weapons Will Not Reduce Gun Violence." Opposing Viewpoints: Gun Control. Ed. Tamara L. Roleff. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 1997. Opposing Viewpoints Resource Center. Gale. Pierce College. 4 Jun. 2010. “The Constitution, Bill of Rights, and Firearms Ownership in America.” Second Amendment/Right to Arms. NRA Institute for Legislative Action. NRA. 2009. Web. 10 Jun. 2010 United States. National Archives and Records Admin. Bill of Rights. Washington: 1 1791. Web. 10 Jun. 2010....

America Needs Gun Control

1319 words - 5 pages gun-control advocates are liberals. “According to a 2009 survey by Republican pollster Frank Luntz, 69% of NRA members and 85% of gun owners support background checks at gun shows” (Altman, “Why Obama's Silence on Gun Control Pleases No One” ) “In one year on average, almost 100,000 people in America are shot or killed with a gun” ( “Protect Children, Not Guns 2009”). Hysterical gun owners oppose any gun control and often think that the...

Gun Control in America

1534 words - 6 pages Gun Control in America The American Constitution and the Bill of Rights are amazing documents in their wording. Its writers showed astonishing foresight in some ways, and understanding that they could not accurately predict the future in others. These documents grant specific and vague powers to different departments of the Federal Government. The wording allows for changes to be made in its content and interpretation. One example of all...

Gun Control in America

1883 words - 8 pages Gun Control in America Firearms are so pervasive in this country that sometimes we forget the price we pay for an all-too-easy access to guns. According to the Centers for Disease Control, 10,744 Americans were murdered with firearms in 1996. However, only 174 of these homicides were justifiable. In 1995 alone, 35,957 Americans were killed with firearms, in homicides, suicides and accidents. In comparison, 33,651 Americans were killed...

Gun Control in America

1301 words - 5 pages activity. Guns are not the reason for the violent crimes. The crimes are caused by the typical person with a violent past with them. Most people would agree that the firearms they have are used either for recreational activities or home protection in times of need. So they believe that without firearms, they are defenseless. Most will also tell anybody that the weapons aren't the ones causing the harm. Gun violence statistics show that he US has...

Gun Control in America - 1248 words

1248 words - 5 pages federal “assault weapon” ban was banished in 2004, murder rates fell by 10%. Studies for Congress, the Congressional Research Service, the Library for Congress, the National Institutes of Justice, the National Academy of Sciences, and the Center for Disease Control and Prevention have not found evidence that gun control laws reduce crime (Ownership at All Time High, 1). In Florida, over a 15-year period with concealed weapon laws, homicide rates fell...

Similar Essays

America Does NOT Need Gun Control

2516 words - 10 pages , despite the claims of gun control activists, gun control does not reduce crime, it only leaves law abiding citizens increasingly vulnerable to violent crime.      One common claim of gun control advocates is that gun control in foreign countries, notably Great Britain, is responsible for their lower crime rates. They present statistics showing that Britain has lower murder rates than America, but skip some other interesting information...

America Needs Criminal Control, Not Gun Control

1935 words - 8 pages criminals with extensive criminal backgrounds to return to live among society. While a case can easily be made to improve/enforce existing gun control laws, it is key to point out that criminals are criminals due to the fact that they do not follow laws, whereas law-abiding citizens do. There is no reason why a law-abiding citizen should be forced to accept a system that would allow someone convicted of murder the chance to get out of prison after...

Gun Control Does Not Reduce Crime

1248 words - 5 pages guns. Deaths from X are sure to be higher in states with more X. On the other hand it is no secret that the upper New England states have both some of the laxist gun laws and lowest crime rates out of any states in the Union. It is important to remember the old adage: "Correlation does not imply causation". If it turned out that states with less gun laws tended to have less crime it wouldn't necessarily mean that the lack of gun laws caused...

We Need Gun Control Essay

1505 words - 6 pages We Need Gun Control   Baton Rouge, Lousiana--October 17, 1992--8:30 P.M....A Japanese exchange student, Yoshihiro Hattori, was searching for a party he had been invited to. Thinking he had found the house in which the social would take place, Yoshihiro knocked on the door. Not knowing that they had the wrong house Yoshihiro and his companion startled the proprietor. After having the front door shut in their face the two boys began walking...