American Civil Liberties Are Not Violated By The Patriot Act

2131 words - 9 pages

American Civil Liberties are NOT Violated by the Patriot Act

As we face the threat of terrorism, how do we protect ourselves without hurting our freedoms? Today, terrorism is a major threat to our homeland security and has become increasingly more prevalent and difficult to monitor with the public's accessibility to communication and information through today's technology. Terrorists are now able to communicate more freely with recent technological advances. In an effort to combat this new threat, the government passed the Patriot Act, which was created to relieve some of the difficulties of monitoring communications and activities of the public so the government can easily detect terrorist activity. In response to the Patriot Act, many argue that this law takes away our civil liberties as Americans. Others believe we must lose some of our liberties to gain protection. This essay offers a critical analysis of the arguments for and against the U.S. Patriot Act. The result will be a conclusion affirming the validity of the U.S. Patriot Act due to the fact that our civil liberties are not violated to the extent argued by the opposition.

The U.S. Patriot Act was a bill adopted under the Bush administration that purportedly affords the government the tools required to surveil, investigate, and share information pertaining to national security without major judicial constraints. This allows the government, for instance, to monitor Internet usage and provides effective communication between different agencies of federal authorities (Olsen, 2001). Assistant Attorney General Michael Chertoff, while discussing the Patriot Act and its role in improving communication within the agencies said,

"...we have got to be able to exchange information and bring together all of the knowledge in the U.S. government, and we can't afford to have people lose their lives because part of the information is in one department and part is in another department and they are not talking to each other" (Frank, 2002, p. 1505).

The Patriot Act expands the "pen register" statute to include electronic communications and Internet usage, which was previously limited to tracing of telephone numbers called by suspect criminals (Olsen, 2001). In addition, this act allows the government to obtain warrants to examine what people read in libraries and bookstores from records on what a person checks out or buys. Moreover, the law allows the government to detain or deport suspects of terrorism as well as monitor financial transcripts and electronic records. Recently, the federal court ruled to expand the use of wiretaps and other surveillance techniques in tracking suspected terrorists under the Patriot Act. The main part of the ruling is removing previously existing legal barriers between the FBI and the Justice Department investigators, prosecutors and law enforcement personnel (Fox, November 2002).

Those opposed to...

Find Another Essay On American Civil Liberties are NOT Violated by the Patriot Act

The U.S. Patriot Act and the Risk of Losing Our Civil Liberties

1841 words - 8 pages ("Issues in terrorism and homeland security: Selections from CQ researcher", 2010, p. 322). The thing that has people questioning this title would have to be the commandeering can be under a vial of secrecy. After vigilant thoughtfulness of each argument, it is obvious that many of the apprehensions of the resistance of the U.S. Patriot Act do not hold up when studied and addressed. Our civil liberties are not intruded upon because there are

The USA PATRIOT Act of 2001: Need for National Security vs. Protection of Civil Liberties

1436 words - 6 pages responsibility first and foremost to protect its citizens from enemies foreign and domestic. However, for every proponent there is an equally passionate opponent who partially believe not only does the Act impede on civil liberties and individual rights but was an opportunistic ploy to grant excess power to the government in the wake of September 11th empathy. USA PATRIOT is what is referred to as a “backronym”, or a title from which is construed

The Not So Patriot Act

1780 words - 7 pages people to be secure in their persons, houses, paper, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized”. (United States Constitution - Bill of Rights, 1789) In order to rewrite this section of the Patriot Act, the Fourth Amendment must be

Was Lincoln’s actions in which violated civil liberties and abused the presidential power justified?

2287 words - 9 pages violation of civil liberties. He violated the first amendment right, freedom of press The U.S. Constitution grants these individual rights to citizens to guarantee and preserve freedom. By arresting, imprisoning and disallowing further publishing, Lincoln took away that first amendment right, which was a power as president he did not hold, overstepping his power as president and violating civil liberties. This was however, justified because the two

American Civil Liberties: Do Americans Have Enough Protections for Civil Liberties, or Not?

1742 words - 7 pages American Civil Liberties: Do Americans have enough protections for Civil Liberties, or not?   In a world where terrorism, war, and economic instability are ever looming threats it’s not a wonder why the limits on the freedom of the individual can come into question. This is especially true when the country where these limits are brought into question is one of the world’s leading powers in: democracy, economics, social welfare, military

The Patriot Act is Not so Patriotic

832 words - 3 pages immigration authorities in arresting and deporting immigrants suspected of terrorist acts. Under the Patriot Act, American law enforcement personnel have far more authority than is constitutional. This act should be repealed and should not be enforced.The Patriot Act has many loop holes and is open for interpretation for the government to use to its liking. The act states that anyone can be accused of terrorism by:"Guilt by association, association as

The War on Terrorism Has Not Compromised Civil Liberties

676 words - 3 pages The War on Terrorism Has Not Compromised Civil Liberties In the wake of 9/11, the United States of America began to fight a war on terrorism.  Many in this country would say we actually started a war against ourselves.  One argument is the war on terrorism has begun to erode our civil liberties.  Have our civil liberties really been abused or have they been slightly altered by the Patriot Act to protect all Americans best interests?  To

American civil liberties are defined as civil rights designed with the purpose of limiting government intervention in citizen’s affairs (Civil Lib

1113 words - 5 pages thought in order to help the CIA’s job of interrogating potential terrorists easier. After the World Trade Center attacks, the government violated citizen’s civil liberties by enacting unnecessary policies, treating civilians incorrectly, and utilizing cruel interrogation tactics. Civil liberties are guaranteed to American citizens in the Bill of Rights and since terrorism has become a threat, those rights have been left behind. Now, it is

In accordance with your own research what key reasons for Britain's defeat in the "American War of Independence" are not explained by the movie "The Patriot?" Explain citing examples

539 words - 2 pages ’s victory, as they helped the Americans win during the Naval Battle.In conclusion, “The Patriot” failed to raise and highlight the impact the costly debt British were faced with and the reasons why the British were in debt and had to impose taxes. The movie did not highlight the British soldiers having limited communications with each other, as well as disregard the importance of American colonist’s foreign aid. These are the key factors that did not inform the viewer all the aspects to the reasons why the British were defeated by the Americans.Bibliography:

Civil Liberties: 1. What are the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments? - Politics - Assignment

602 words - 3 pages and order? In other words, to what extent is it possible to protect individual rights and maintain civil order at the same time? I do not think there is a tradeoff between civil liberties and law and other, but it is possible if the government treats the crime stricter and if the government gives the right rights for their citizens. In other words, it is possible to protect individual rights and maintain civil order at the same time as long as there are no citizens violate the laws.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU)

713 words - 3 pages Where do you go if someone is threatening your personal rights? Do yougo to the police, or maybe to the government? What if the police andgovernment are the parties threatening your rights? All you have to do is justcall the ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union). Sounds like a commercialdoesn't it. The ACLU blankets the United States with its legal protection. It isinvolved in so many aspects of the fight for civil liberties that it is difficult

Similar Essays

Civil Liberties Versus The Usa Patriot Act

1882 words - 8 pages . "Fortress America." The New York Times 23 Feb 2003.Edgar, Timothy. "Interested Persons Memo: Section-by-Section Analysis of Justice Department draft "Domestic Security Enhancement Act of 2003," also known as "PATRIOT Act II"." 14 Feb. 2003. American Civil Liberties Union. ACLU. 20 Nov. 2004 .Eisendrath, Craig, and Melvin Goodman. Bush League Diplomacy: how the Neoconservatives are putting the world at risk. Amherst NY: Promethesus Books, 2004.Lithwick

The Patriot Act Vs Civil Liberties

1191 words - 5 pages facing death? “The importance of safety continues to be paramount.” Lee, M.Dilascio, Tracey M.3). The patriot act allows officers to search suspect’s property without their consent. Searches without the need for consent allow officers to find anything ill legal that the suspect may hide later. Criminals may use civil liberties as an excuse to get searched or caught by police. It is better being certainly sure then not. The patriot act is

Patriot Act Violates Civil Liberties Essay

1834 words - 7 pages course of their investigation. Equally disturbing are the necessities of the USA PATRIOT Act that greatly weaken the requirement that investigators show probable cause for many types of searches. Former laws governing electronic communications provided for a lower standard than probable cause to put a trace on telephone calls, allowing investigators to determine who a suspect is calling, but not to survey the conversations themselves. Under the

Legality Of The Patriot Act A Theft Of Civil Liberties Or The Protection Of American Life

4600 words - 18 pages attend. It also violates the 1st Amendment by prohibiting those who have been searched by the FBI to disclose the contents of the search, even if it poses no risk to national security (Unpatriotic Acts).With the controversy surrounding the Patriot Act, it is not surprising that powerful positions on both sides of the topic have formed. The American Civil Liberties Union or ACLU has taken an important interest in the topic. The ACLU is one of the